Wala sanang pilitan no? As they say most Filipinos can sing. The question is what do you have that is unique? Ano pagkakaiba nyo sa ibang singers? Kasi s totoo lang kahit charm wala but you girls have good harmony naman but it’s not distinct. Very forgettable ba. Nothing special. You’re only known because of your name but majority of people are not really interested. Real talk yan cos you girls need a humble pie.
Hmmmm pano gagawin natin? Eh one of those lang kayo among the oceans of talents here. Besides, di rin naman unique yung offer nyo.. sorry but thats reality. Maybe its best if you pursue individual crafts or try another field perhaps.
mahusay mga yan kasi pati si Simon napabilib. Hindi lang sila pumatok as a girl group kasi hindi sila market ng maayos at hindi ayusin ang packaging sa kanila
Sa true lang medyo yumabang kasi sila nung nakatapak sa ibang bansa at umingay panandalian ang pangalan nila. Eh they're just trying to replicate Aegis.
Eh kasi aminin natin di sila masyado kagandahan. Alam naman yun ibang fans sa mukha nagbabase hindi sa talent. Kung pretty sila maraming boys ang magiging fan nila.
Ummm.. meron kasi tayong tinatawag na x-factor / karisma sa tao. Masakit man tanggapin, wala po kayo non. Kahit super talented ng isang tao if di sya makaconnect sa audience, wala talagang mangyayari.
True. Madami naman talagang singer na kahit super galing, wala talagang “it factor” kaya di na sumikat sa mainstream. Pero yumaman naman sa pag shoshow sa mga bar, cruise, and hotels. So hanapin na lang ung tamang lugar kung saan kayo maapreciate.
Nope birit is fine , pero need tlaga ng mass appeal, patok na song, un mga issues n relevant, of course fan base , yan ang mga kelangan para ka sumikat
Patok kasi ngayon kpop style. Aside from singing, you have to dance and most importantly, connect with your fans. Look at Ben&Ben and SB19, may fandom names pa nga sila. Even pa light stick during concerts. Brand merch are very popular, too. Di lang cd albums binebenta. May pa hoodies, tumbler, tote bag, etc.
Hindi na pwede marunong ka lang kumanta these days. You have to create or produce your own style songs (like JK Labajo), figure out your branding, and establish your image. Di lang puro cover songs.
Sorry for saying this but hindi talaga ganun ka impact yung mga performances nila. For me lang naman. Tried to watch them a lot pero waley talaga for me
12:34 medyo disagree ako dito. In PH we have many successful female singers who dont have slim model looks. Matino ang styling yes, pero hi di naman artista levels ang fez
CHARISMA ang wala sa inyo girls. Wala na kaming masabi sa husay nyo sa pagkanta pero dapat may appeal din kayo. May mayabang vibes pa kayo. Grabe support ng mga pinoy sa inyo sa journey nyo sa Britain’s Got Talent kaso kahit si Simon, eventually nagsawa rin sa inyo.
Talented sila pero parang hindi nahawakan ng may malakas na kapit sa industry. Lacks promotion and lacks presence in the right places. Even great products need some push with good publicity and promotion.
Oo nga, sometimes what people call "charm" is actually professional marketing. Example na lang si Liza Soberano. I'm not bashing her ha, but for better or worse her image completely changed nung hindi na siya hawak ng ABS
It could be magaling pero walang charm sa tao. Wag magtampo, it means you might need to try other things..malay nyo naman you can make it kung individually instead as a group. Kung di patok sa mga tao maybe need ng change sa concepts. You need charm. Di lang sa sa pagiging magaling. Like Ann Curtis, di sya singer pero may charm sya sa tao. Dont give up, we have our own season.
lack of humility kasi.. kahit pa nung Xfactor stint nil, sila lng ata ang kaisa isang ng audition na bago kumanta sumigaw ng Xfactoooor na parang sarili nilang concert..
I watched and liked them during tehir Xfactor days, but after that nung puro covers nalang sila, nakakasawa na. Their diction pati nila while singing, hindi na nag improve. And sorry, hindi sila full package.
This isn't your time sorry tama sila di na uso biritan. Very 90s pa yan patok, bakit? Kasi ang dami ng ganun. Halos magkakatunog na nga. Accept the fact that people also evolve. Sawa na siguro kami sa biritan kasi kung ganun lang din ang dami ng choices.
Hindi naman kasi sila magaling sa totoo lang. If you really listen to them, they're below mediocre singers individually. Tapos ang nipis pa ng harmony nila and super tryint hard sa appearance nila.
153am, you said it yourself, SB19 & Ben&Ben have THEIR hit song/s. They can make their own music. This girl group just cover songs, and to be frank, their cover are not the best.
You have to know and understand your audience. Kung target market ay mga pinoy, your group is not that extraordinary - and as a lot have put it, kulang sa x-factor. Siguro sa ibang bansa, unique and east asian all-girl group. Continue trying on the other side of the pond.
Sorry girls pero ang patok ngayon yung mga legit musicians na nagco-compose ng sariling kanta. Hindi lang enough yung maganda ang boses at bumibirit. Tingnan nyo pattern ng mga sikat sa OPM for the past 5 years, mga singer-songwriters and performers in one. At infairness ang gaganda ng mga kanta sa local music scene ngayon.
Cover artists kasi kayo paano kayo sisikat at ma recall ng mga tao kung wala kayong sariling mga kanta. Hanap kayo ng mga producers and songwriters. Wag isisi sa pinoy audience failure ng group nyo if di naman talaga kayo nag try na gumawa ng sariling songs niyo.
They don't have original material that people can sink their teeth into. I think they're trying too hard to be like an American African girl group pero dito naman sila nagmamarket. Even in the US (and UK) that kind of girl group is practically dead. They have the talent yes pero they're not optimizing their talents to make them marketable. Ung looks naman, other less attractive talents have had some success locally so it's really a problem of having original material and marketing.
-May sinulat na ba silang kanta o puro covers lang? -Mga pinoy di na gaano nabibilib sa mga biritera, gusto na ngayon yung ikaw mismo sumulat ng song -JK Labajo, Moira Dela Torre, OPM Bands -Baguhin nila styling nila, magkakamukha na nga sila, pati sa damit at buhok same same padin. Boring
Nagrereklamo sila, sila daw nagluluto and nagbubuhat, neng look at Liza sya din lahat when she move to the US... anong akala ng mga to porket nakapg xfactor UK sila hindi na sila pwede maging independent. Nakakaloka kau.
Ang tanong paano ka mag sa shine? E dami nga magaling
Hit songs ayan kasi jan ka ma alala Can you write songs? If not can you perform like sarah g? Hirap din na walang songwriter gagawa song for you mahal ata bayad jan
Sa totoo lang Bihira lang mga singers na sikat pa for 10 years. Kaya nga sa ibang bansa singer dati actor na ngayon. Kasi kahit matanda ka na basta kaya mo pwede ka pa rin magartista.
Hindi talàga sila sisikat kung puro covers lang gagawin nila. They have sing original songs, mas okay kung sila ang magsulat ng kanta. Look at SB19, Ben&Ben, Moira, JK Labajo.tumatatak talaga ang mga gawa. Hindi na uso ang puro birthday, nakakasawa at masakit na sa tenga after a while. Panghuli, hindi mo mapipilit na gustuhin kayo ng tao.
No original songs (puro cover) No distinction (iisa ang tunog ng boses) No harmony (lahat puro birit, walang low notes) No impact (wala kayong appeal, mga teh)
Sino bang hindi maririndi sa kanila na puro sigawan lang naman ginagawa? Naalala ko pa nung nakipag sabayan sila kay Dessa sa ASAP, juskooo nilamon lang sila ni Dessa ng buong buo.
Nag-umpisa nga sina Lani Misalucha, Jaya, Katrina Velarde at Vice Ganda etc. na hindi pa ganun kagandahan pero kinagat agad ng masa. Sa right management lang yan na ipopromote kayo ng bonggang bongga.
They need to show their own style at dapat may sikat na original song, for example the likes of Ben&ben, Sb19, Moira, Juan Karlos, Zack , Adie and Arthur Nery.
Pinakamalaking factor siguro yung wala silang sariling sound. Yung ibang singer kasi alam mong sila yung kumakanta kahit nkapikit. Madami din namang singer na di kagandahan pero sumisikat tsaka nagkakaalbum…
Magaling sila kaso chaka ng datingan. Need nila e reinvent yung style nila. Tayo kase mga pinoy ina idolize naten yung mga mas maganda sa aten. Pero kung mas chaka pa datingan kesa sa aten, di naten papansinin
they should also consider a life outside the entertainment industry & have a fallback like maybe face the reality of just working a corporate job because time is so fleeting. one day they will wake up, tapos na ang kanilang "15 minutes of fame" & they're old na chasing fame. even Jake Zyrus(the former Charice) can't break into the Hollywood industry again. ganon kabilis makalimot or magsawa ang mga tao.
As someone who doesnt know them, i think they need to rebrand or restyle at least. My first thought after a few seconds of watching is they look like bubble head dolls na maraming abubot. Makalat sila tingnan kaya nobody stands out. Hindi ko sila ihahire for entertainment. Dapat stand out isa isa like with black pink, we know one girl is not the same as the other. Their hair and makeup do nothing for their faces, their clothes do nothing for their body type. They would really benefit from a short hairstyle that shows off the jaw to balance their round and heavy cheek areas. Makeup that makes their skin and hair look healthy, natural eyeshadow and lip shades. I think the sosy rich auntie look will work for them as a group. Sleek clothes, healthy skin, hair color for pinoy skin tone. Like Lani Misalucha x4.
12:19 yung suggestion mo na dapat parang Black Pink, mas lalong walang identity kasi kung anu yung uso dun nalang kakapit s uso. Take the P-Pop di ba sunod din s KPop why need to brand the same ? Gaya gaya puto maya. May Talent Pero wlang uniqueness, one time thing. One viral or trending videos can’t make you a star ( yan ang nasa ulo ng mga Badfluencers at tiktokers at kahit ng mga new talents ngayon). Di dahil walang support, baguhin nyo ang style nyo
Imagine if KFC laments na napapagod na sila doing business here kasi si Jollibee parin mahal ng pinoy. ahahahaha! They sounds like that.. You are a product, you are offering your music/entertainment, the public does not owe you attention or loyalty. If di nila bet product mo, di sila bibili. Maybe reinvent or improve your product. If you want to get pinoy love, maraming talented performers and songwriters na pinoy, collaborate with them. Naghanap pa kayo sa labas tapos sasabihin ang mahal mahal. Pinoys love people who support locals.
Right management and right composers lang ang kailangan nyo na kailangan pumatok sa masa. Kahit sana na naging one hit wonder na lang kayo pero wala akong alam na kanta nyo na napasikat. Tinalo pa kayo nina Yeng Constantino, Moira Dela Torre at KZ Tandingan na ilang years pa lang sa industry.
Colonial mentality. Basta local acts, ang daming puna, ang daming negative comments. Pero kapag foreign acts, asahan mo, hahanapan ng maganda kahit tipikal lang naman. Ipagtatanggol pa sa bashers. Ew!
1243, I watched their pandemic concert with SB19. They can’t level with SB19 at all. As a Filipino, you should know by now the pool of talents we have in singing, so expect really high standards when it comes to singing. Just because you can hit high notes doesn’t cut it.
Tigilan mo kaka-colonial mentality, kasi sinuportahan naman sila dati. Sila mismo kasi sumira sa momentum nila...nag-sign sa Star Records, pangit naman nung Unleash the Diva na Kanta. Tapos puro cover songs at lack of proper image training pa
Ang gagaling magbigay ng suggestions ng mga tao rito. Kapag sinunod naman nila, hindi rin naman susuporta! Hahanapan pa rin ng mali! Kadiring pinoy mentality.
Remember nung nagsisimula pa lang sina Jaya, Jona, Lani Misalucha and even Regine Velasquez hindi rin naman ganun kagandahan pero nabigyan sila ng right management at magagandang kanta na until now ay tumatak talaga sa masa. Na kahit nakapikit ka alam na alam mo na sila ang kumakanta.
In this industry, it’s not enough that you can sing and belt songs. Mas nagtatagal yung may originality, someone who writes their own music. Otherwise, you’re just a copycat of more famous singers.
Sino patok ngaun, ung mga singer songwriters and performers ung may mga sariling kanta n pasok s panlasang pinoy - sb19, ben&Ben, zach, jk, adie, moira, Arthur nery.
pansin ko lang ha sa lahat kasi ng sinalihang contest ng 4th impact palaging may background story na panv maala ala mo kaya. Tama na yan mga teh, move on sa past and concentrate on marketing your talent and not your personal drama.
kulang sa face value, yes magagaling kumanta pero dapat iretoke, wag nyo na gayahin ang kpop stars dahil matatanda na kayo para sa kpop, ibahin ang style.
Imagine from The Cercados to Cercados Sisters to 4th Power to 4th Impact wala pa ring nangyari sa career nila na 2008 pa pala nag-umpisa sa music industry. Ibig sabihin wala talaga silang IT FACTOR.
Yes, kulang nga ng support here sa Philippines. But don't give up, look at SB19 now, their hardwork, passion and perseverance and of course a solid fan base. Just because kpop ang uso ngayon, doesn't mean they have to imitate kpop group. Style nila pwedeng katulad ng girl groups like Little Mix or Fifth Harmony, halimaw ang vocals.
walang ganda period. Alam mo naman sa pinas kahit super talented kapa, kung hindi ka mestiza, matangkad, sexy, buti kung pansinin ka, wag na magtaka mga ate gurl.
I was actually surprised when I saw their group name labeled as “Ppop Idol Group” and not just a regular OPM group. I don’t think they had the same rigorous training as other idol groups. Those trainings also include personality development trainings and other stuff that makes an idol group… an “IDOL” group, y’know?
I understand that they’d been doing this for a long time but let’s be honest.. they’re not exceptional. Try to rewatch their viral audition on the XFactor and you’d realize they’re not that great pala.. you’d hear shouting and mumbled rapping…
Plus the fact that they don’t have their own songs… so why categorize yourselves as a “Ppop Group”? Ppop is a sub-opm genre that caters to a specific audience… and then you’re gonna go out there and offer cover songs? come on.. dont blame the filo fans… we were able to make ben&ben, moira, jk labajo & sb19 trend… give us something original and see what happens..
Just keep trying. Yung SB19, dati hindi rin sila ma-appreciate ng mga Pinoy but they never gave up. Look at them now, sikat na sila.
ReplyDeletethey need to get a good manager.
Deletethey need to be humble first.
Deletemahal pa sumingil yan
ibang iba na ang fez ng mga ito
Deletesing original music/songs...isang hit lang. then siempre para ma sustain sundan pa ng maraming hits....
DeleteWala silang X-factor, nothing special
DeleteCharisma kulang SA Kanila. Meron ba sila original song?
DeleteKahilatsa Kasi nila aegis but because may original songs Kaya tumatak plus talented composer din aegis. Just like sb19 talented song writers.
Wala sanang pilitan no? As they say most Filipinos can sing. The question is what do you have that is unique? Ano pagkakaiba nyo sa ibang singers? Kasi s totoo lang kahit charm wala but you girls have good harmony naman but it’s not distinct. Very forgettable ba. Nothing special. You’re only known because of your name but majority of people are not really interested. Real talk yan cos you girls need a humble pie.
DeleteHmmmm pano gagawin natin? Eh one of those lang kayo among the oceans of talents here. Besides, di rin naman unique yung offer nyo.. sorry but thats reality. Maybe its best if you pursue individual crafts or try another field perhaps.
ReplyDeleteGirl Group na cover singers lang naman sila.
DeleteWalang appeal. Walang original songs. Walang sariling style o identity.
DeleteWalang impact. #realtalk
mahusay mga yan kasi pati si Simon napabilib. Hindi lang sila pumatok as a girl group kasi hindi sila market ng maayos at hindi ayusin ang packaging sa kanila
DeleteSa true lang medyo yumabang kasi sila nung nakatapak sa ibang bansa at umingay panandalian ang pangalan nila. Eh they're just trying to replicate Aegis.
DeleteEh kasi aminin natin di sila masyado kagandahan. Alam naman yun ibang fans sa mukha nagbabase hindi sa talent. Kung pretty sila maraming boys ang magiging fan nila.
ReplyDeletetotoo ito. Kulang sa packaging
Deleteit’s not their faces. kulang talaga sa charisma. napakadaming famous singers dito sa atin na di naman beauty queen material.
Deletereally, they should refrain from saying sht like this. improve their image.
Sa dami ng kayang bumirit sa Pinas tapos MAGAGANDA pa, nagtataka talaga sila bat di sila pansinin?
DeleteKulang sila sa XFactor at walang nagawang original songs, unlike sa aegis regardless of their age and style sikat pa din
DeleteOverrated kasi to be honest. Puro sigaw but at the same time they mumble the words, so the music becomes unpleasant to listen to.
ReplyDeleteTHIS!
Deletejusko yung korean nga wala kayong maintindihan pero baliw na baliw kayo
DeleteI'm not a K-pop fan 7:59, pero may difference yung kanta na ang sakit sa tenga compared dun sa iba ang language.
DeleteUmmm.. meron kasi tayong tinatawag na x-factor / karisma sa tao. Masakit man tanggapin, wala po kayo non. Kahit super talented ng isang tao if di sya makaconnect sa audience, wala talagang mangyayari.
ReplyDeleteTrue. Madami naman talagang singer na kahit super galing, wala talagang “it factor” kaya di na sumikat sa mainstream. Pero yumaman naman sa pag shoshow sa mga bar, cruise, and hotels. So hanapin na lang ung tamang lugar kung saan kayo maapreciate.
Delete💯. kulang talaga sa IT factor
DeleteKakasawa na rin kasi birit birit mga ante
ReplyDeleteNope birit is fine , pero need tlaga ng mass appeal, patok na song, un mga issues n relevant, of course fan base , yan ang mga kelangan para ka sumikat
DeleteMay own song/s ba sila?
ReplyDeletePatok kasi ngayon kpop style.
Aside from singing, you have to dance and most importantly, connect with your fans. Look at Ben&Ben and SB19, may fandom names pa nga sila. Even pa light stick during concerts. Brand merch are very popular, too. Di lang cd albums binebenta. May pa hoodies, tumbler, tote bag, etc.
Hindi na pwede marunong ka lang kumanta these days. You have to create or produce your own style songs (like JK Labajo), figure out your branding, and establish your image. Di lang puro cover songs.
True
DeleteSorry for saying this but hindi talaga ganun ka impact yung mga performances nila. For me lang naman. Tried to watch them a lot pero waley talaga for me
ReplyDeleteSame here, they don't have charm.
DeleteWala silang IMPACT sa tao sa totoo lang.😂
ReplyDeleteBiritan na kanta kasi atake nila at hindi naman lahat bet yun epecially ang mga bagets. Ang puros cover din ginagawa nila eh
ReplyDeleteKulang kasi sil sa charisma at sa ganda, real talk, ang mga pinoy mahilig sa maganda , slim , model look more than talent
ReplyDelete12:34 medyo disagree ako dito. In PH we have many successful female singers who dont have slim model looks. Matino ang styling yes, pero hi di naman artista levels ang fez
Delete5:30 may point si 12:34. They are trying to be pop stars, and pop stars are attractive.
DeletePag naging super famous kayo sa ibang bansa yung mala charice level na fame for sure ma appreciate na kayo ng mga Pinoy 😅 ganon naman palagi dito.
ReplyDeletewag sisihin ang pinoys. hindi lang talaga charming at pangit ang pino project na image. tapos nagsasalita pa ng mga ganyan
DeleteHarsh pero wala silang Star Quality.
ReplyDeleteCHARISMA ang wala sa inyo girls. Wala na kaming masabi sa husay nyo sa pagkanta pero dapat may appeal din kayo. May mayabang vibes pa kayo. Grabe support ng mga pinoy sa inyo sa journey nyo sa Britain’s Got Talent kaso kahit si Simon, eventually nagsawa rin sa inyo.
ReplyDelete*x-factor pala
DeleteIlang beses na rin silang sinabihan sa costumes nila dati sa XFactor na wag parang uniform. Hindi sinusunod eh
Deleteactually, ang yabang ng dating. mahal pa daw sumingil yan
DeleteTalented sila pero parang hindi nahawakan ng may malakas na kapit sa industry. Lacks promotion and lacks presence in the right places. Even great products need some push with good publicity and promotion.
ReplyDeletecorrect, mali ang managers nito. Palaging mukha silang nakakaawa
DeleteOo nga, sometimes what people call "charm" is actually professional marketing. Example na lang si Liza Soberano. I'm not bashing her ha, but for better or worse her image completely changed nung hindi na siya hawak ng ABS
DeleteIf it's not working for the longest time then I think you should change something.
ReplyDeleteIt could be magaling pero walang charm sa tao. Wag magtampo, it means you might need to try other things..malay nyo naman you can make it kung individually instead as a group. Kung di patok sa mga tao maybe need ng change sa concepts. You need charm. Di lang sa sa pagiging magaling. Like Ann Curtis, di sya singer pero may charm sya sa tao. Dont give up, we have our own season.
ReplyDeletelack of humility kasi.. kahit pa nung Xfactor stint nil, sila lng ata ang kaisa isang ng audition na bago kumanta sumigaw ng Xfactoooor na parang sarili nilang concert..
ReplyDeleteAy true yan. Tapos masyado silang high and mighty di makatanggap ng criticism.
DeleteLol, maingay kayo. You guys are very 2000 and late lol
ReplyDelete😆 witty.
Deletepag girl group kasi you also have to sell sex appeal and wala sila nun sadly
ReplyDeletenakakaumay ang biritan.. naging group lang kayo na bumibirit... dami na nyan sa asap & aos
ReplyDeletesa abroad nga waley kayo pinas pa kaya.. pwede kayo pang mga fiesta o campaign rally pero di kayo yung tipong sisikat. realtalk
ReplyDeleteI watched and liked them during tehir Xfactor days, but after that nung puro covers nalang sila, nakakasawa na. Their diction pati nila while singing, hindi na nag improve. And sorry, hindi sila full package.
ReplyDeleteWala silang originality. Magaling sa harmonization at choreography pero walang dating. Di rin naman sila maganda. Daming magaling na singers.
ReplyDeleteThis isn't your time sorry tama sila di na uso biritan. Very 90s pa yan patok, bakit? Kasi ang dami ng ganun. Halos magkakatunog na nga. Accept the fact that people also evolve. Sawa na siguro kami sa biritan kasi kung ganun lang din ang dami ng choices.
ReplyDeleteHindi naman kasi sila magaling sa totoo lang. If you really listen to them, they're below mediocre singers individually. Tapos ang nipis pa ng harmony nila and super tryint hard sa appearance nila.
ReplyDeleteMass appeal, song na patok, gimik issues, yan ang mga req para sumikat ka d2 sa pinas, of course fan base , yan ang importante
ReplyDeleteKahit nagpailong na kayot nagpaoverhaul ng face, wala pa ring impact, puro covers lang at sigaw ng sigaw, nakakarindi.
ReplyDeleteYou need a hit song. Parang sb19-mapa, ben and ben dami rin hits
ReplyDelete153am, you said it yourself, SB19 & Ben&Ben have THEIR hit song/s. They can make their own music. This girl group just cover songs, and to be frank, their cover are not the best.
DeleteYou have to know and understand your audience. Kung target market ay mga pinoy, your group is not that extraordinary - and as a lot have put it, kulang sa x-factor. Siguro sa ibang bansa, unique and east asian all-girl group. Continue trying on the other side of the pond.
ReplyDeletemaybe need nila mag change ng management, nanjan na ung talent… may something lang talaga na missing sa kanila plus originalnsongs
ReplyDeleteMas ok kasi sila na solo.
ReplyDeletePara kasing ang yayabang nyo sa true lang
ReplyDeleteKais isipin mo magkakahawig sila. Tapos same ng boses. Ending nila mala aegis. Pero ang aegis kasi may sariling kanta.
ReplyDeleteSorry girls pero ang patok ngayon yung mga legit musicians na nagco-compose ng sariling kanta. Hindi lang enough yung maganda ang boses at bumibirit. Tingnan nyo pattern ng mga sikat sa OPM for the past 5 years, mga singer-songwriters and performers in one. At infairness ang gaganda ng mga kanta sa local music scene ngayon.
ReplyDeleteHindi rin naman kasi kayo talaga kagalingan. Sa true lang.
ReplyDeleteCover artists kasi kayo paano kayo sisikat at ma recall ng mga tao kung wala kayong sariling mga kanta. Hanap kayo ng mga producers and songwriters. Wag isisi sa pinoy audience failure ng group nyo if di naman talaga kayo nag try na gumawa ng sariling songs niyo.
ReplyDeleteThey don't have original material that people can sink their teeth into. I think they're trying too hard to be like an American African girl group pero dito naman sila nagmamarket. Even in the US (and UK) that kind of girl group is practically dead. They have the talent yes pero they're not optimizing their talents to make them marketable. Ung looks naman, other less attractive talents have had some success locally so it's really a problem of having original material and marketing.
ReplyDelete-May sinulat na ba silang kanta o puro covers lang?
ReplyDelete-Mga pinoy di na gaano nabibilib sa mga biritera, gusto na ngayon yung ikaw mismo sumulat ng song -JK Labajo, Moira Dela Torre, OPM Bands
-Baguhin nila styling nila, magkakamukha na nga sila, pati sa damit at buhok same same padin. Boring
Hanapin nyo yung pang limang impact. Kulang eh
ReplyDeleteang style niyo hindi patok sa Pilipinas pero pasok sa international community. Goodluck
ReplyDeletePuro Beyonce covers lang naman ginagawa nyo. Walang X-factor pa ang grupo. Pano kayo sisikat dito?
ReplyDeleteThey need to create an original song and nake it popular
ReplyDeleteAng tatanda na din kasi nila. Music now a days kasi wala ng biritan. Mah rebranding sila and hanapin nila niche nila.
ReplyDeleteNagrereklamo sila, sila daw nagluluto and nagbubuhat, neng look at Liza sya din lahat when she move to the US... anong akala ng mga to porket nakapg xfactor UK sila hindi na sila pwede maging independent. Nakakaloka kau.
ReplyDeleteDaming magaling na singer sa Pinas
ReplyDeleteAng tanong paano ka mag sa shine? E dami nga magaling
Hit songs ayan kasi jan ka ma alala
Can you write songs?
If not can you perform like sarah g?
Hirap din na walang songwriter gagawa song for you mahal ata bayad jan
Sa totoo lang Bihira lang mga singers na sikat pa for 10 years. Kaya nga sa ibang bansa singer dati actor na ngayon. Kasi kahit matanda ka na basta kaya mo pwede ka pa rin magartista.
ReplyDeleteHindi talàga sila sisikat kung puro covers lang gagawin nila. They have sing original songs, mas okay kung sila ang magsulat ng kanta. Look at SB19, Ben&Ben, Moira, JK Labajo.tumatatak talaga ang mga gawa. Hindi na uso ang puro birthday, nakakasawa at masakit na sa tenga after a while. Panghuli, hindi mo mapipilit na gustuhin kayo ng tao.
ReplyDeleteNo original songs (puro cover)
ReplyDeleteNo distinction (iisa ang tunog ng boses)
No harmony (lahat puro birit, walang low notes)
No impact (wala kayong appeal, mga teh)
Sino bang hindi maririndi sa kanila na puro sigawan lang naman ginagawa? Naalala ko pa nung nakipag sabayan sila kay Dessa sa ASAP, juskooo nilamon lang sila ni Dessa ng buong buo.
ReplyDeleteNag-umpisa nga sina Lani Misalucha, Jaya, Katrina Velarde at Vice Ganda etc. na hindi pa ganun kagandahan pero kinagat agad ng masa. Sa right management lang yan na ipopromote kayo ng bonggang bongga.
ReplyDeleteNakita ko sa Spotify naka 2 palit na pala sila ng pangalan. From The Cercados to Cercado Sisters and now 4th Impact.
ReplyDeleteBawas bawasan din kasi ang pa borloloy na kasuotan. Ang sakit kaya sa mata tingnan na feeling taga Western country.
ReplyDeleteThey need to show their own style at dapat may sikat na original song, for example the likes of Ben&ben, Sb19, Moira, Juan Karlos, Zack , Adie and Arthur Nery.
ReplyDeletePinakamalaking factor siguro yung wala silang sariling sound. Yung ibang singer kasi alam mong sila yung kumakanta kahit nkapikit. Madami din namang singer na di kagandahan pero sumisikat tsaka nagkakaalbum…
ReplyDeleteMagaling sila kaso chaka ng datingan. Need nila e reinvent yung style nila. Tayo kase mga pinoy ina idolize naten yung mga mas maganda sa aten. Pero kung mas chaka pa datingan kesa sa aten, di naten papansinin
ReplyDeletethey should also consider a life outside the entertainment industry & have a fallback like maybe face the reality of just working a corporate job because time is so fleeting. one day they will wake up, tapos na ang kanilang "15 minutes of fame" & they're old na chasing fame. even Jake Zyrus(the former Charice) can't break into the Hollywood industry again. ganon kabilis makalimot or magsawa ang mga tao.
ReplyDeletesumikat kayo sa xfactor ukna hinde naman pinapanuod ng filipino so wala kayo connect sa tao sa news lang kayo nakilala
ReplyDeletepara kasi silang aegis na sumasayaw! hahahha!
ReplyDeletetriny ko talaga silang gustuhin pero waleyt talaga. over singing na may growl sa huli. birit kaumay
ReplyDeleteNagpagawa ba sila lahat ng nose? Pero hindi sila gumanda
ReplyDeleteSorry to say this, magkakamukha na nga sila tapos hindi sila ganun kagaganda. Puro birit and covers din. Predictable na palagi yung performance.
ReplyDelete11:31 yung birit na Wala s lugar
DeleteYou don’t even have original songs. You’re basically a cover band. And we have a ton of those. Every corner merong kayang kumanta.
ReplyDeleteTry kaya nila maging humble at magbagi ng inage. Yung mala-Aegis, J Bros, or mga Family Band. Trying hard kasi maging FOJ eh.
ReplyDeleteBig factor yung wala silang original songs. Harder to make an independent album kasi babayad pa sila ng royalties to do a cover
ReplyDeleteAs someone who doesnt know them, i think they need to rebrand or restyle at least. My first thought after a few seconds of watching is they look like bubble head dolls na maraming abubot. Makalat sila tingnan kaya nobody stands out. Hindi ko sila ihahire for entertainment. Dapat stand out isa isa like with black pink, we know one girl is not the same as the other. Their hair and makeup do nothing for their faces, their clothes do nothing for their body type. They would really benefit from a short hairstyle that shows off the jaw to balance their round and heavy cheek areas. Makeup that makes their skin and hair look healthy, natural eyeshadow and lip shades. I think the sosy rich auntie look will work for them as a group. Sleek clothes, healthy skin, hair color for pinoy skin tone. Like Lani Misalucha x4.
ReplyDelete12:19 yung suggestion mo na dapat parang Black Pink, mas lalong walang identity kasi kung anu yung uso dun nalang kakapit s uso. Take the P-Pop di ba sunod din s KPop why need to brand the same ? Gaya gaya puto maya. May Talent Pero wlang uniqueness, one time thing. One viral or trending videos can’t make you a star ( yan ang nasa ulo ng mga Badfluencers at tiktokers at kahit ng mga new talents ngayon). Di dahil walang support, baguhin nyo ang style nyo
DeleteImagine if KFC laments na napapagod na sila doing business here kasi si Jollibee parin mahal ng pinoy. ahahahaha! They sounds like that.. You are a product, you are offering your music/entertainment, the public does not owe you attention or loyalty. If di nila bet product mo, di sila bibili. Maybe reinvent or improve your product. If you want to get pinoy love, maraming talented performers and songwriters na pinoy, collaborate with them. Naghanap pa kayo sa labas tapos sasabihin ang mahal mahal. Pinoys love people who support locals.
ReplyDeleteSa cruise ship or theme parks abroad na lang sila magtrabaho/kumanta.
ReplyDeleteIt’s a good paying job 🤷🏻♂️
Right management and right composers lang ang kailangan nyo na kailangan pumatok sa masa. Kahit sana na naging one hit wonder na lang kayo pero wala akong alam na kanta nyo na napasikat. Tinalo pa kayo nina Yeng Constantino, Moira Dela Torre at KZ Tandingan na ilang years pa lang sa industry.
ReplyDeleteColonial mentality. Basta local acts, ang daming puna, ang daming negative comments. Pero kapag foreign acts, asahan mo, hahanapan ng maganda kahit tipikal lang naman. Ipagtatanggol pa sa bashers. Ew!
ReplyDelete1243, I watched their pandemic concert with SB19. They can’t level with SB19 at all. As a Filipino, you should know by now the pool of talents we have in singing, so expect really high standards when it comes to singing. Just because you can hit high notes doesn’t cut it.
DeleteTigilan mo kaka-colonial mentality, kasi sinuportahan naman sila dati. Sila mismo kasi sumira sa momentum nila...nag-sign sa Star Records, pangit naman nung Unleash the Diva na Kanta. Tapos puro cover songs at lack of proper image training pa
DeleteAng gagaling magbigay ng suggestions ng mga tao rito. Kapag sinunod naman nila, hindi rin naman susuporta! Hahanapan pa rin ng mali! Kadiring pinoy mentality.
ReplyDeleteExcuse nyo na lang na mga tamad yan. Ayaw ng feedback na matino naman
DeleteRemember nung nagsisimula pa lang sina Jaya, Jona, Lani Misalucha and even Regine Velasquez hindi rin naman ganun kagandahan pero nabigyan sila ng right management at magagandang kanta na until now ay tumatak talaga sa masa. Na kahit nakapikit ka alam na alam mo na sila ang kumakanta.
ReplyDeletePapalit palit pa sila ng pangalan. 4th Power ang gamit nila nung nag-audition sa X Factor UK.
ReplyDeleteSorry 4th Wihout an Impact
ReplyDeleteIn this industry, it’s not enough that you can sing and belt songs. Mas nagtatagal yung may originality, someone who writes their own music. Otherwise, you’re just a copycat of more famous singers.
ReplyDeleteSino patok ngaun, ung mga singer songwriters and performers ung may mga sariling kanta n pasok s panlasang pinoy - sb19, ben&Ben, zach, jk, adie, moira, Arthur nery.
ReplyDeletepansin ko lang ha sa lahat kasi ng sinalihang contest ng 4th impact palaging may background story na panv maala ala mo kaya. Tama na yan mga teh, move on sa past and concentrate on marketing your talent and not your personal drama.
ReplyDeletekulang sa face value, yes magagaling kumanta pero dapat iretoke, wag nyo na gayahin ang kpop stars dahil matatanda na kayo para sa kpop, ibahin ang style.
ReplyDeleteImagine from The Cercados to Cercados Sisters to 4th Power to 4th Impact wala pa ring nangyari sa career nila na 2008 pa pala nag-umpisa sa music industry. Ibig sabihin wala talaga silang IT FACTOR.
ReplyDeleteYes, kulang nga ng support here sa Philippines. But don't give up, look at SB19 now, their hardwork, passion and perseverance and of course a solid fan base. Just because kpop ang uso ngayon, doesn't mean they have to imitate kpop group. Style nila pwedeng katulad ng girl groups like Little Mix or Fifth Harmony, halimaw ang vocals.
ReplyDeletewalang ganda period. Alam mo naman sa pinas kahit super talented kapa, kung hindi ka mestiza, matangkad, sexy, buti kung pansinin ka, wag na magtaka mga ate gurl.
ReplyDelete4th impact didn't make an impact. 😔
ReplyDeleteI was actually surprised when I saw their group name labeled as “Ppop Idol Group” and not just a regular OPM group. I don’t think they had the same rigorous training as other idol groups. Those trainings also include personality development trainings and other stuff that makes an idol group… an “IDOL” group, y’know?
ReplyDeleteI understand that they’d been doing this for a long time but let’s be honest.. they’re not exceptional. Try to rewatch their viral audition on the XFactor and you’d realize they’re not that great pala.. you’d hear shouting and mumbled rapping…
Plus the fact that they don’t have their own songs… so why categorize yourselves as a “Ppop Group”? Ppop is a sub-opm genre that caters to a specific audience… and then you’re gonna go out there and offer cover songs? come on.. dont blame the filo fans… we were able to make ben&ben, moira, jk labajo & sb19 trend… give us something original and see what happens..