Matanda na siya for Ibarra role. Kung babasahin ang book, Crisostomo was around early 20s. Dennis Trillo was also old for the role buti nlng may pagka baby face siya at magaling sa acting kaya nairaos niya.
Piolo was never a good actor, iisa lang lagi portrayal niya. Hindi nakakadala acting. Ang nagdala sa kanila noon sa Starting Over ay yung nagsulat ng dialogue na yun nila ni Toni.
Hindi ok na ggawa din sila ng ganyan alam nman nilang kakatapos lang ng MCAI. Di malayong ipagkumpara ng mga tao ang akting ng mga gumanap sa MCAI at jan sa series or movie na Ibarra na yan. 🙄🙄
Dennis Trillo and Julie Ann San Jose are the best actor and actress who have played the characters of Ibarra and Maria Clara, ever. These two have big shoes to fill in.
8:19 Kalma ka lang. There are no shoes that they need to fill in. Ibarra is a musical restaging of Kanser, a straight play that drew references from Jose Rizal’s Noli Me Tangere.
8:19 I've never seen maria clara at ibarra, so I'm asking out of curiosity. Does MCAI really have a better cast than the miniseries from 1992? Cause that series has a superb cast.
8:19 Baks, I watched Joel Torre as Crisostomo Ibarra in an old Noli series sa youtube. Magaling si Dennis pero iba pa rin ang atake ni Joel Torre pati na rin si Daniel Fernando as Elias. Magagaling sila. Eddie Romero ba naman ang direktor.
10:44 i watched both. MCAI cast was decent, the every actor in main cast was allowed to shine and they did! the miniseries had great cast too but it was boring bordering documentary. MCAI was a combination of great cast, great director and writers, superb cinematography, beautiful costumes, great lighting, perfect musical scoring which made it so successful— the cast was icing on the cake.
Not everyone watches free tv, pwede ba. May ibang audience ang theater. Maka none other than. Wala kayong paki kung may ibang gustong magportray. In the first place, hindi naman talaga kayo ang audience
kaloka mga nega rito. matagal na pong pinapalabas sa mga entablado ang Noli at El Fili, pwede ba? wag epal. porke nakapanood kayo sa TV nang libre, andami nang sabe. malamang wala lang kasi kayong pambayad ng ticket kaya masyado kayong salty.
Nanunuod ako ng stageplay, Ante. Hindi naman sikat na artista ang gumaganap sa El Fili at Noli dati. So why now after ng success ng MCAI biglang may paganito. Timely kasi kakatapos lang ng very successful TV series, lakas maka-bandwagon.
kung totoo ito...for me, sana hwag nalang ituloy. sa ngayon kasi yung hype ng pag ganap ni dennis at julie ang nakatatak sa isipan ko o natin at sa lahat ng nag mahal sa MCaI...maybe sa 2024 baka pwede na..lol! eh kc di ba,ang galing naman talaga ni dennis,julie and the rest of the cast dun sa series..#mcisepanx
Hindi sa GMA, kung hindi sa mga nakakaraming nanonood nito all over the world. Kakatapos lang din kasi ng MCAI. Of course, maikokompara talaga ang performance nila kina Dennis and Julie na syang tunay na nagmarka.
10:57 I'm sure na yung viewers ng MCAI eh hindi manonood sa teatro kaya walang chance to compare. If MCAI actors and actresses can stage a musical and still make a mark, then yung talaga ang nakakabilib.
Mga ka-FP na masyadong bilib at baliw sa serye na pinanood niyo na feeling niyo eh wala ng karapatan yung iba na i-retell yung storya, MUSICAL yan. Opera singer si ate mong Myramae.
Di po tard yan! Nag worry lang ang mga tao since bago palang na tapos ang MCAI tapos heto may another version na musical, Baka Di tauhin dahil nakita na nila ang MCAI. Kung maka tard ka agar ang mga to. Di ba pweding worried lang sa musical nilang Di mag click. May gulay!
10:59 Worried ka pang nalalaman dyan. Iba ang audience ng teatro sa audience ng teleserye. Sigurado ako na hindi talaga mag-click sa inyo yang musical. Okay lang kasi hindi naman kayo kawalan.
Tigil ka nga dyan @10:59. Anong hindi tauhin na pinagsasabi mo? Halatang hanggang TV ka lang. Maraming theater goers ateng. At hindi mga kagaya mo ang ineexpect nila na manood. Mga kagaya nila Lea Salonga, Audie Gemora, Ryan Cayabyab ang manonood niyan. May vegetable!
Ang OA ng tards ng MCAI. Sa theater yan. Sobrang common na iportray sa theater ang noli at el fili. Hindi copyrighted ng MCAI ang libro ni rizal. Obvious namang hindi kayo theater goers based on your comments kaya wag masyadong affected
90s kids alam na every year may play ang florante at laura for sophomore, noli for junior and el fili for seniors required manuod kasi gagawa ka reaction paper
Rizal’s works have been staged, re-staged all the time. In fact, we saw Noli Me Tangere opera here in NYC which was also shown in the Philippines a few years ago. Also, planning for stage plays/operas/musicals take a long time. And the target audience is different for each art form. MCAI just reached a wider audience which is good for history. But it is not the ‘original’ adaptation of Noli or Fili. I’m sure ‘Ybarra’ on stage has no time-travel, as did the original book.
Naglipana avid fans ng teleserye dito ah! Hahaha Kala mo yung MCAI nila ang nagsalba sa storya nina Ibarra at Maria Clara. O eto, niresearch ko na para sa inyo bago niyo ipa trademark o kung anuman ang Noli Me: Musical premiered in 1995 1st CCP Revival 2005 2nd CCP Revival 2011 Musical to debut in Los Angeles 2014
Sorry po alam kong di lahat sasangayon at alam kong this is for Theater pero pag sinabing Crisostomo Ibarra si Dennis Trillo na ang napipicture ko in my mind gaya ng pag si Jose Rizal ay si Cesar Montano at si Papa Jesus ay si Matt Ranillo III dahil sa mga film/show nila na napanood ko
Mga walang alam sa play mga gen z yan millennials know na every year sa high school required manood ng play, florante sa 2nd year, noli sa 3rd year at el fili naman sa 4th year kasi yan ang inaaral per year may reaction paper pa after manuod ng play.
Anu nanaman yan jusme.. pauso?
ReplyDeleteStage play yan beh wag kang ano
DeleteNega mo pati ba naman trabaho may mamasasabi ka pa
DeleteBeh, tsismosa lang tayo, hindi tanga. Kelan pa naging pauso si Ibarra?
Deletefree tv lang alam mo baks? hahaha
DeleteAy, bakit?
ReplyDeleteMatanda na siya for Ibarra role. Kung babasahin ang book, Crisostomo was around early 20s. Dennis Trillo was also old for the role buti nlng may pagka baby face siya at magaling sa acting kaya nairaos niya.
ReplyDeleteHindi naman sya ganun katanda itsura. Feeling ko naman madadala nya yung 20s role
DeleteHindi bagay
ReplyDeletePiolo was never a good actor, iisa lang lagi portrayal niya. Hindi nakakadala acting. Ang nagdala sa kanila noon sa Starting Over ay yung nagsulat ng dialogue na yun nila ni Toni.
ReplyDeleteNakiuso si papa p? Pero aminin iba talaga ang dennis trillo kaya nakakainspire gawin ang ibarra.
ReplyDeleteFeel ko hindi nya mkuha kuha yung depth ng acting ni dennis trillo. Iba tlaga un
ReplyDeleteHindi talaga teh kasi musical yan. Hahaha!
DeleteHindi ok na ggawa din sila ng ganyan alam nman nilang kakatapos lang ng MCAI. Di malayong ipagkumpara ng mga tao ang akting ng mga gumanap sa MCAI at jan sa series or movie na Ibarra na yan. 🙄🙄
ReplyDeleteStage play yan. Hindi series o movie. 🙄🙄
DeleteDennis Trillo and Julie Ann San Jose are the best actor and actress who have played the characters of Ibarra and Maria Clara, ever. These two have big shoes to fill in.
ReplyDelete8:19 Kalma ka lang. There are no shoes that they need to fill in. Ibarra is a musical restaging of Kanser, a straight play that drew references from Jose Rizal’s Noli Me Tangere.
DeleteI agree. Super galing nila Dennis and Julie. MCAI the best tv series. Pato c Barbie, super galing din.
Delete@8:19 AM Oa, masyado. Hahaha.
Delete8:19 I've never seen maria clara at ibarra, so I'm asking out of curiosity. Does MCAI really have a better cast than the miniseries from 1992? Cause that series has a superb cast.
DeleteHands down to Dennis and Julie. Napakahusay na mga artista.
Delete8:19 Baks, I watched Joel Torre as Crisostomo Ibarra in an old Noli series sa youtube. Magaling si Dennis pero iba pa rin ang atake ni Joel Torre pati na rin si Daniel Fernando as Elias. Magagaling sila. Eddie Romero ba naman ang direktor.
Delete10:44 i watched both. MCAI cast was decent, the every actor in main cast was allowed to shine and they did! the miniseries had great cast too but it was boring bordering documentary. MCAI was a combination of great cast, great director and writers, superb cinematography, beautiful costumes, great lighting, perfect musical scoring which made it so successful— the cast was icing on the cake.
DeleteWhy?
ReplyDeleteWala na kase maisip
ReplyDeletehmm kakatapos lang ng MCAI. do they think na papatok ito? marami namang philippine literature na gawan ng films
ReplyDeleteSino nagsabi na film yan? Hahahaha
DeleteStage play kasi acheng. Hindi film
DeleteSino ba yan si ate girl?
ReplyDeleteOpera singer. Music graduate yan
DeleteThe design is very John wick. Hahahaha
ReplyDeleteNaubusan na ng idea???
ReplyDeleteFresh pa sa isip ng Tao ang MCAI, Dennis as Ibarra and Julie Ann as Maria Clara
ReplyDeleteDennis Trillo portrays it well. None other than.... ilove MCAi of GMA. It's a big hit. We cannot deny.
ReplyDeleteNot everyone watches free tv, pwede ba. May ibang audience ang theater. Maka none other than. Wala kayong paki kung may ibang gustong magportray. In the first place, hindi naman talaga kayo ang audience
DeleteMay audience din na nanonood both tv and theatre kaya wag ka!
Delete10:53 and the fact that you were so quick to bash here para maiangat ang precious mcai niyo proves hindi kayo yun.
Delete10:53 Nah, I don't think so. If ever meron man, hindi MCAI ang pinapanood nila.
Deleteang tataas ng ere nitong mga nanonood kuno ng theather at hindi ng free TV lol
Deletekaloka mga nega rito. matagal na pong pinapalabas sa mga entablado ang Noli at El Fili, pwede ba? wag epal. porke nakapanood kayo sa TV nang libre, andami nang sabe. malamang wala lang kasi kayong pambayad ng ticket kaya masyado kayong salty.
ReplyDeleteOpo mga dukha lang po kami, ayan inamin na namin 12:35
DeleteNanunuod ako ng stageplay, Ante. Hindi naman sikat na artista ang gumaganap sa El Fili at Noli dati. So why now after ng success ng MCAI biglang may paganito. Timely kasi kakatapos lang ng very successful TV series, lakas maka-bandwagon.
DeleteI hope GMA does GomBurZa.
ReplyDeletekung totoo ito...for me, sana hwag nalang ituloy. sa ngayon kasi yung hype ng pag ganap ni dennis at julie ang nakatatak sa isipan ko o natin at sa lahat ng nag mahal sa MCaI...maybe sa 2024 baka pwede na..lol! eh kc di ba,ang galing naman talaga ni dennis,julie and the rest of the cast dun sa series..#mcisepanx
ReplyDeletesi Klay lang naman ang tumatak
DeleteBakla tagal ng mga stage play hango sa mga sinulat ni rizal bakit mag aadjust ang theater para sa GMA
DeleteHindi sa GMA, kung hindi sa mga nakakaraming nanonood nito all over the world. Kakatapos lang din kasi ng MCAI. Of course, maikokompara talaga ang performance nila kina Dennis and Julie na syang tunay na nagmarka.
DeleteHype sa masang free TV lang ang alam at afford na entertainment medium, ayt! 😃😁😁😆😅
Delete10:57 I'm sure na yung viewers ng MCAI eh hindi manonood sa teatro kaya walang chance to compare. If MCAI actors and actresses can stage a musical and still make a mark, then yung talaga ang nakakabilib.
DeleteMga ka-FP na masyadong bilib at baliw sa serye na pinanood niyo na feeling niyo eh wala ng karapatan yung iba na i-retell yung storya, MUSICAL yan. Opera singer si ate mong Myramae.
ReplyDeleteHala, feeling naman tong mga fans ng MCAI! Ano, si Dennis at Julie Ann lang may karapatan sa characters ng Noli Me Tangere?
ReplyDeleteDi po tard yan! Nag worry lang ang mga tao since bago palang na tapos ang MCAI tapos heto may another version na musical, Baka Di tauhin dahil nakita na nila ang MCAI. Kung maka tard ka agar ang mga to. Di ba pweding worried lang sa musical nilang Di mag click. May gulay!
Delete10:59 Worried ka pang nalalaman dyan. Iba ang audience ng teatro sa audience ng teleserye. Sigurado ako na hindi talaga mag-click sa inyo yang musical. Okay lang kasi hindi naman kayo kawalan.
DeleteTigil ka nga dyan @10:59. Anong hindi tauhin na pinagsasabi mo? Halatang hanggang TV ka lang. Maraming theater goers ateng. At hindi mga kagaya mo ang ineexpect nila na manood. Mga kagaya nila Lea Salonga, Audie Gemora, Ryan Cayabyab ang manonood niyan. May vegetable!
DeleteAndaming tard dito ng MCAI. Hehe
ReplyDeleteMatagal na ngang may play pero bakit yan napili nila gawin? Kase sikat MCAI now? The design is very BANDWAGON.
ReplyDeleteMaria Clara at Ibarbie
ReplyDeleteThis is on point!
DeleteHahaha sorry pero nakakatawa ung mga tard ng mcai dito. Wala pa man sa tv, matagal ng nasa teatro ang noli at fili.
ReplyDeleteMga teh!I'm sure iba ang audience nitong musical na ito kaya iba ang expectations nila VS sa mga nakapanood ng teleserye. Jusko kayo!
ReplyDeleteMusical yan! May babayarang ticket. Iba ang taste ng mga nanonood ng musical kumpara sa mga nanonood sa free tv.
ReplyDeleteAh Noli Me Tangere Musical
ReplyDeleteAng OA ng tards ng MCAI. Sa theater yan. Sobrang common na iportray sa theater ang noli at el fili. Hindi copyrighted ng MCAI ang libro ni rizal. Obvious namang hindi kayo theater goers based on your comments kaya wag masyadong affected
ReplyDeleteAt bigla kayong naging theater goers para lang pagtanggol yang idol mo anek? HAHA
DeleteSa June pa yata yan ipapalabas as musical so ok lang
ReplyDelete90s kids alam na every year may play ang florante at laura for sophomore, noli for junior and el fili for seniors required manuod kasi gagawa ka reaction paper
ReplyDeleteRizal’s works have been staged, re-staged all the time. In fact, we saw Noli Me Tangere opera here in NYC which was also shown in the Philippines a few years ago. Also, planning for stage plays/operas/musicals take a long time. And the target audience is different for each art form. MCAI just reached a wider audience which is good for history. But it is not the ‘original’ adaptation of Noli or Fili. I’m sure ‘Ybarra’ on stage has no time-travel, as did the original book.
ReplyDeleteKung theater man, wala na bang ibang historical figures na pede iportray? Si Ibarra at MC ulit? Dami dyan, akala ko ba GOMBURZA project ni Piolo?
ReplyDeleteNaglipana avid fans ng teleserye dito ah! Hahaha Kala mo yung MCAI nila ang nagsalba sa storya nina Ibarra at Maria Clara. O eto, niresearch ko na para sa inyo bago niyo ipa trademark o kung anuman ang Noli Me:
ReplyDeleteMusical premiered in 1995
1st CCP Revival 2005
2nd CCP Revival 2011
Musical to debut in Los Angeles 2014
Sorry po alam kong di lahat sasangayon at alam kong this is for Theater pero pag sinabing Crisostomo Ibarra si Dennis Trillo na ang napipicture ko in my mind gaya ng pag si Jose Rizal ay si Cesar Montano at si Papa Jesus ay si Matt Ranillo III dahil sa mga film/show nila na napanood ko
ReplyDeleteHuwag masyadong insecure, tard. Makaasta kayo na parang bawal na may ibang gumanap ng ibarra. Hindi naman kayong rabid mcai tards audience nito 🙄
DeleteMga walang alam sa play mga gen z yan millennials know na every year sa high school required manood ng play, florante sa 2nd year, noli sa 3rd year at el fili naman sa 4th year kasi yan ang inaaral per year may reaction paper pa after manuod ng play.
ReplyDeleteNge hinde po bagay gawa nalang sila ng iba bash lang abutin nila kung ganon
ReplyDelete