Yung concept borrowed from the mv of michael jackson’s smooth criminal. Walang originality. Hindi pa bagay sa kanta ni sarah na duyan which is a love song. Grabe!
Clearly inspired by Michael Jackson + old school Janet Jackson (music videos nya na dancing amongst friends) + Gene Kelly Singin' In The Rain + Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse in "The Bandwagon" (1953).
Yung part na short hair and naka black short dress si Sarah? Very Cyd Charisse.
Now let's stop saying Sarah is not original by copying MJ's Smooth Criminal, because MJ copied The Bandwagon. Watch it on Youtube.
Maganda yung sayaw at medyo bolder si Sarah, but its so Michael Jackson, particularly yung Smooth Operator. She couod have thought of a more original concept na babagay sa song niya.
1:46 At least bagay naman. Ito ang weird na ganun ang kanta tapos ganun ang sayaw. It's not to say naman na di magaling si SG. Pero gahd...di bagay talaga.
1:46, FYI not a copy but a tribute to Fred Astaires musical number in the movie The Band Wagon with Cyd Charisse. Ilang beses kong napanood yan as a fan.of old MGM musicals.
There's nothing wrong naman kung yung mv is MJ inspired marami talaga gumagaya kau MJ Pero sana nag live sya hindi lip sync comeback performance nya tapos lip sync
Idol nya kasi si Michael Jackson hehe. When she was younger she used to dress up and imitate MJ talaga. Ganda ng song in all fairness, iba talaga si SG although medyo nadismaua ko at nabudol ako ng ASAP, kala ko live.. Hmppp
Ano ba yan comeback pero yung performance di live tapos di bagay sa song yung concept. and please retire that MJ concept na ang dami mo na nagawa ganyan
Di ko na siya gusto. Wala na un youth niya at masyado na siyang maarte na magperform live. Halatang nagpapataas ng premium. Kung ayaw. Di wag. Dami pwede kumanta at magperform LOL
Matagal na ko di nanonood ng ASAP. papanoorin ko sana nung linggo dahil sa pagbabalik ni Sarah pero nung napanood ko sa TV Patrol ay music video lang naman pala, akala ko live mismo sa studio ang performance nya.
8:48 anong klaseng comeback yan eh sya performer, mga classmates dito hindi. Sya ang dapat mag level up ng performance no, wag masyadong tard na butthurt
Sorry may talent si SG talaga. Pero Ang baduy ng concept nitong Duyan obvious na copycat Kay MJ. Yung moves Hindi Bagay sa mga lyrics ng kanta. Basta Hindi siya maganda. See for yourself...
yung lyrics niya Pilipinong-Pilipino pero yung MV Western. Parang hindi siya nag-mix well para sa akin. Tas yung costume pang 90s. Ok pa yung Kilometro kesa dito
Yung concept borrowed from the mv of michael jackson’s smooth criminal. Walang originality. Hindi pa bagay sa kanta ni sarah na duyan which is a love song. Grabe!
ReplyDeleteInspiration nga nya si MJ, diba???
DeleteActually ang nakikita ko mala Janet Jackson yung dance moves
DeleteHindi bagay un Smooth Criminal Concept ni MJ sa Duyan. Tsk
Delete12:56 mv is mj inspired
DeleteDance moves is janet inspired
Kahit nga yung Tala MV niya ay hawig ng Together Again ni Janet Jackson pero ang mga fans todo puri na original daw LOL
DeleteAgree. Duyan pero ni isang duyan wala ako nakita sa mv. Sana man lang kahit hinele nalang sya sa choreo para masabing dinuyan sya.
DeleteDi ko maintindihan yung theme ng performance but it's nice to see her perform again
ReplyDeleteClearly inspired by Michael Jackson + old school Janet Jackson (music videos nya na dancing amongst friends) + Gene Kelly Singin' In The Rain + Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse in "The Bandwagon" (1953).
DeleteYung part na short hair and naka black short dress si Sarah? Very Cyd Charisse.
Now let's stop saying Sarah is not original by copying MJ's Smooth Criminal, because MJ copied The Bandwagon. Watch it on Youtube.
Kahit kopya un kay MJ eh bagay naman. Whether kopya or original sana tiningnan naman kung bagay o hindi
Delete💯 1:11. I see some cabaret, Fosse, and Chicago (the musical) influences also.
Delete1.46 you cannot blame ppl from expecting highly because it's THE Sarah Geronimo.
Deletedapat masaya nalang kayo para sa kapwa natin. comment kayo. dnaman nyo kaya nyan. puriin ang kapwa Pilipino. wag crab mentality.
DeleteParang smooth criminal ni MJ
ReplyDeleteWelcome back,SG!!! 🥹🦋
ReplyDeleteMaganda yung sayaw at medyo bolder si Sarah, but its so Michael Jackson, particularly yung Smooth Operator. She couod have thought of a more original concept na babagay sa song niya.
ReplyDeleteSmooth operator. Smoooth operatoooor. 😂♪♫
DeleteMJ Music video smooth criminal is also a copy FYI
Delete1:46 At least bagay naman. Ito ang weird na ganun ang kanta tapos ganun ang sayaw. It's not to say naman na di magaling si SG. Pero gahd...di bagay talaga.
Delete1:46, FYI not a copy but a tribute to Fred Astaires musical number in the movie The Band Wagon with Cyd Charisse. Ilang beses kong napanood yan as a fan.of old MGM musicals.
DeleteI stand corrected, Smooth Criminal. Ala Fred Astaire. ~ 12:07
DeleteThere's nothing wrong naman kung yung mv is MJ inspired marami talaga gumagaya kau MJ
ReplyDeletePero sana nag live sya hindi lip sync comeback performance nya tapos lip sync
Music video nga di ba teh. Pano maglive
Delete1:50 akala naman LIVE PERFORMANCE yun pala Music video ang binigay marami ang na budol No!
DeleteIdol nya kasi si Michael Jackson hehe. When she was younger she used to dress up and imitate MJ talaga. Ganda ng song in all fairness, iba talaga si SG although medyo nadismaua ko at nabudol ako ng ASAP, kala ko live.. Hmppp
ReplyDeleteIdol din pala niya si MJ. Gusto ko ding maging superstar like her 🤠kaso waley sa dancing lol
DeletePara saan ang mic?
ReplyDeleteObvious ba?
DeleteAno ba yan comeback pero yung performance di live tapos di bagay sa song yung concept. and please retire that MJ concept na ang dami mo na nagawa ganyan
ReplyDeleteThis is her comeback? She can do better than this.
ReplyDeleteWala talaga siyang originality at personality
ReplyDeleteHmm I love this song pero the choreography and the concept, though inspired by MJ's Smooth Operator, I find distracting. Sana iba nalang.
ReplyDeleteAng dami nyo naman po reklamo,, sige nga, kayo magperform.
ReplyDelete1:36 nabudol ang lahat kaya sorry ka na lang kung maraming asar
DeleteKaya d sumisikat ang Pinoy singers internationally kasi walang originality.
ReplyDeleteKPop is also Western inspired. They hire choreographers from US pa nga
Delete10:24 yeah I know pero naging brand na din talaga ang Kpop, I don't know how they did it pero it worked for them. Sana tayo din sumikat soon.
DeleteWalang kupas
ReplyDeleteNabudol kayo, mv lang pala yung asap comeback LOL
ReplyDeleteDi ko na siya gusto. Wala na un youth niya at masyado na siyang maarte na magperform live. Halatang nagpapataas ng premium. Kung ayaw. Di wag. Dami pwede kumanta at magperform LOL
ReplyDeleteBakit di sya makapag perform ng live?
ReplyDeleteDi bagay yung song sa dance steps nya
ReplyDeleteWala pa rin tatalo kay ate ghorl. Galing!
ReplyDeleteMatagal na ko di nanonood ng ASAP. papanoorin ko sana nung linggo dahil sa pagbabalik ni Sarah pero nung napanood ko sa TV Patrol ay music video lang naman pala, akala ko live mismo sa studio ang performance nya.
ReplyDeleteNagkamali pa ko nung una, kala ko last week kaya inabangan ko. Tas nitong Sunday pala — abang ulit. Tas hindi naman pala live on stage. Anube?
ReplyDeletePareho tayo! Yung live performance nya ang na miss ng mga tao. Yung makita siya sa studio together with the other hosts. Nabudol talaga tayo.
DeleteNot a good performance
ReplyDelete8:16 sge teh, sayo na ang entablado. Ikaw ang magsayaw. Hirap i-please.
Delete3:26 i think may k naman magcritique ang fans dahil hyped yung comeback tapos ganyan lang pala.
Delete3.26 nakaka-umay yang mga ganyang banat. parang "sige, ikaw na lang mag-presidente". di mo ba naiisip?
DeleteLalaland concept na smooth criminal. Di bagay sa kanta
ReplyDeleteKayo na po mg perform hahaaha . Basta Ilove SARAH G.
ReplyDelete8:48 anong klaseng comeback yan eh sya performer, mga classmates dito hindi. Sya ang dapat mag level up ng performance no, wag masyadong tard na butthurt
DeleteParang I’ll Never Break Your Heart ng Backstreet Boys! Same rhythm and same mv theme!
ReplyDeleteSorry may talent si SG talaga. Pero Ang baduy ng concept nitong Duyan obvious na copycat Kay MJ. Yung moves Hindi Bagay sa mga lyrics ng kanta. Basta Hindi siya maganda. See for yourself...
ReplyDeleteyung lyrics niya Pilipinong-Pilipino pero yung MV Western. Parang hindi siya nag-mix well para sa akin. Tas yung costume pang 90s. Ok pa yung Kilometro kesa dito
ReplyDelete