Nagkapera lang dahil sa YouTube. Nag artista man siya pero wala naman pumapansin. Dami kasi jeje tambay sa YouTube. Kahit walang katuturan pinapanood. Mababaw ang kilite nila don.
Lets be honest of this most you tubers content are trash. Ginagaya at inuulit lang nila content ng iba sasabihin pa nila most requested. Trying to start a new trend to si donnalyn if this didnt backfire at her gagawin din to nina zeinab and gelai andres and so with the others.
I warched it because of all these comments. I did not see it in a negative way. Mapagmahal na ate si Donnalyn. Mababait mga kapatid nya. May lesson silang ntutunan. Masasaya yung other family. Ng enjoy sila at very thankful. Hindi daw nila makakalimutan yung experience na yon. I dont see anything wrong tbh.
Saw this too and di ko din inattempt panoorin. Title pa lang parang alam mo na may mali. She could’ve thought of a better challenge for her content. Yung hindi insensitive.
Actually classmates napanood ko siya. Tingin ko naman ay may consent nung pther family tapos in a way she used it to teach her sibling nga a lesson of how life is different kasi ‘yung kapatid ni D lagi nakukuha lahat ng gusto and they take it for granted. I don’t think she wanted to harm or insult anyone sa bideo na to.
Ako rin hindi pinanood, alam ko naman na walang katuturan yan eh. Ang favorite kong panoorin ay kay Basel aka The Hungry Syrian dahil sa pagtulong nya.
3:17 So ginamit niya yung "poor" family? Hindi ba niya pwedeng turuan ang kapatid niya nang wala nang swap swap at mag outreach program na lang? Oh wait, hindi pala yun interesting for youtube content..
Agree with this. My family was once 'rich' and lost everything and became poor. The one who was most affected? My siblings who was around 6-7 years old. Before andami pwede kainin after nun naghirap, wala na. Tipid sa pagkain. Di maiintindihan ng bata kung bakit nanyari ang ganito
Unless Donalyn's family counts as genuinely well off, I would call HER not-so-wealthy and the other fam, something else, but definitely NOT label it the way she has. What a nincompoop.
i feel you 1:36 kami din ganyan bigla kasi pinauwi tatay ko from saudi kaya from may kaya biglang hirap. dumating kami s punto na tirang ulam ng kamag anak namin mga inuulam namin na minsan 3 araw na pala sa ref nila. pero syempre pasalamat pa rin kami kay Lord kahit paano meron.
Hindi rin naman siguro 1:06. Although I do not agree sa format ni Donnalyn dito sa vlog nya but letting the less fortunate experience some luxuries in life for a day or two isn’t bad. I’ve seen this in other shows. And masaya naman sila after. You know, the less fortunate will always cherish whatever blessings they enjoyed even just for a day or two. Iba naman kasi yung from rich to nothing na case. Syempre, nasanay sa marangyang buhay. Mafifeel talaga ang malaking adjustment. Just saying.
Ang ironic lang kase donnalyn didn't really came from a rich family, she's just an ordinary poor girl from novaliches na nakilala kase puro labas makinis na kilikili ang picture nya before sa fb. Her mom also used to work abroad para lang may mapakain sa kanila. And now, she thinks so highly of herself?!?! Nakalimot kana yata girl. Im sure wala pang isang dekadang mayaman ka
137 oh hi Donnalyn, pero di pa rin yan sapat na dahilan para umasta kang ganyan at gawing content ang ganitong challenge. Hiya hiya din minsan sa mga totoong mayaman.
don’t use these people to teach a lesson,for u to do to this only means your parents didn’t raise you well.real rich people di gaya sayo girl.hope u get banned & no ads na.feeling rich ka lng & user pa.
1:08 mema ka, di mo pinanood ang video. Parents didn't raide you well, masyado lang judgemental ng dahil lang sa isang video na di naman talaga nakaka offend. Masaya pa nga ung pamilyang pinagswapan dahil first time daw nila maexperience as a family ang makapag hotel at kumain sa mamahaling restaurant. Walang kinalaman ang pagpapalaki ng magulang nya sa latest video nya.
Ano ang intensyon ng pagagawa ng ganitong videos? When a lot of the Filipino families are impovrished.As if hindi natin alam sa kamalayan natin yan.Sa ibang bansa,tulad ng UK,it is rare to be poor.Kumakain pa ang poor.Pero iba ang sa Pilipinas.So stop showing these swaps because it is insensitive.
Totoo. Iba yung ikaw ang magbibigay mismo, iba yung appreciation kesa dun sa mag swap kayo knowing na ilang oras lang yun at uuwi ka na comfortable life
Napaka cheap and insensitive ng content. To think na may isa pa siyang issue about dun sa lola kalurkey basta mema vlog lang. All for the view ang peg teh? Think before you click naman next time
This is soo true! Bobong content.May ganitong show sa Europe pero tinutulungan yung mga mahigirap.Yung bida palaging ultra rich nakiki tira kasama ng magihirap.Kumbaga immersion pero hindi ganyan.
agree with this, nag outreach kami sa isang isla, japorms ung mga nakatira, rebonded at may color ang pa ang hair. kahit sabihing less fortunate, they still find ways to cope up with uso. ang gaganda din nila. kayumanggi tapos ung face maganda
Papano yung totoong mayayaman,kilala naman natin kung sino sila.Wala silang vlog for security reasons.Kasi kung wealthy na yang Donnalyn,napaka baba naman ng standards ng mga Rich sa Pilipinas.
Tinanggal yan for the same reason,insensitive.Meron binago ang concept.ginawang yung mayamang bata na spoiled brat ilalagay sa mahirap to teach them a lesson.Pero walang swap.
Kasi ang concept ng Rich=Poor swap ay palabas sa UK.Kung saan ang poor sa UK ay hindi karamihan,ang poor ng UK ay middle class pang matuturing dito,kumakain,may maayos na bahay,may sasakyan.Yan ang poor.Pero Pilipinas ito,ang mahirap isang kahig isang tuka.Kaya hindi dapat yang ganyan pausuhin sa Pilipinas.
Sayo na nanggaling, TV PRODUCTION. It means pinagisipan, and for sure consultation with psychologist, sociologists etc. lalo na sa post prod.
Ang alam kong shows na ganto Foreign: simple life (parus hilton and nicole ricci) - they didnt have to change clothes na pangmahirap. Local - dayoff (carmina villaroel) PBB- probably sa a few challenges in the entire run of PBB.
hindi po pa-woke. The production value was sensitive and really had values.
This one nakapagenglish lang and kumita ng pera, feeling mayaman na. WEALTHY talaga?
Ano ba ang circle na ginagalawan nya. Unless she’s rubbling elbows with the ayala’s pangilinans and alike she’s just an ordinary girl.
girl,sana sinama mo na lng sila sa evacuation centers na ipamigay mga donations ng fans mo para maturuan ng lesson kc poor parenting yata sainyo & di aware sa currents events family mo.
Tama ka naman sa suggestion mo. But for you to say na poor parenting sa kanila dahil lang sa isang video is being judgemental na. Hindi mo sila kasama 24/7 so wala kang right sabihin yan.
Meron naman lalo na yungvmga nagtuturo ng skills.Like make up tutorial,nagluluto na vlog,etc.yan ang may content at may pakinabang sa tao.But there are vlogs too focused on the personal life.Nakaka irita.Yung iba naman majologs at palamura.
Not exactly pinoy but pusong pinoy. Basel "The hungry Syrian wonderer". I can say that he is one of the genuine, down to earth and humble impluencer that I've known. His videos are all worth it to watch, bonus pa yung cuties niyang mga puspin.
kwento ng mga anak ng tycoons ,they spent their summer doing odd jobs in their business kaya di spolled,they know how hard it is to earn money.kala mo mga rich eh na tunay.
The moment I saw that video on my suggested vids on Youtube alam kong it’s a problematic vlog and magiging issue. Eto talagang mga vloggers na to kung anu anong basura nilalagay sa social media
mganda mga feedback sa YT kaya these comments in other socmed platforms e walang bearing. Kung magkaron man ng impact itong nega comments e pagkakakitaan lang ulit yan ni Donalyn; malamang gagawa sya ng reaction video sa hate comments.
still think it was distasteful kahit ano pang realization inspiration kuno ang gusto nyang ishare. unang kita ko palang im like WhY?? for the content?? hay nako people today talaga
pinanood ko yung video at tingin ko, kahit maganda intensyon ni donalyn na matuto mga kapatid nya, I don’t think matatandaan naman nila un lalo na nung bunso nila. Simpleng life lesson lang din naman ang narealize nila kaya parang di na need ng over night life swap.
Yes kasi if I’m not mistaken ‘yung dad niya nasa US military yata. Eh malaki bigayan doon alam naman natin. Plus you can see sa ibang vlog niya na maayos sila.
4:18 just like many of the FP readers here,walang sense na sabihing mayaman sila Donalyn.May kaya siguro because dad earns in dollars but not rich.Otherwise,they are not working for US navy.Ang dami kong kamag anak sa US na nasa Navy,comfortable because of the benefits but not rich.Normal lang ang buhay sa US.
What’s more scary are those praises from YT! Most of the commenters says na napakagandang vlog etc. Haaay people wake up! Teaching your siblings a lesson for a day? Maybe they’ll feel bless but then again after a week or so they would probably forgot it too! And yes, yung tinatawag niyang “poor” family. Once they’re back on reality, there might be a negative impact with them too! This content vlog is totally trash! š”
Ang totoong mayayaman don't consider themselves wealthy. They are more likely to say that they're living comfortably. So this donnalyn girl basically has money but never wealthy... Or perhaps, a social climber
Itong Donalyn ay sabihin na natin middle class ganyan hindi mahirap pero hindi mayaman.Malamang mas mayaman pa mga readers nitong FP.May mga artista na umunlad dahil sa kanilang career pero galing sa hirap.
Pakisearch please :Rich House Poor House Naka season 4 na po ang reality series na to. Para maging open minded lang ang lahat. I'm just saying, we tend to overly sugarcoat reality. Kaya hirap tayong umasenso dahil wagas and inappropriately sensitive. You will never know na it will spark inspriration in both sides. I am just a fan of the reality series so seeing like this isn't surprising anymore.
Girl,we are aware of that.Paki research din kung ano ang level ng mahirap sa UK kumpara mo sa Poverty level sa atin,mayaman pang matuturing yung mga mahihirap sa Rich house,Poor house mo.Mahihirap sa first world countries,matuturing mo ng middle class sa Pilipinas.
Ang reality series po may mga psychiatrist etc na nag debrief sa mga sumasali para maitindihan nila ang purpose ng mga social experiment/reality shows kaya don ang difference. Well researchwd din at na mo monitor especially in more developed countries
Her way of teaching is not age-appropriate, especially to the 2 brothers she compromised for the sake of fame. I just wonder why did the parents agree to the idea? It's abuse!
Senior Chief Petty Officer sa US Navy si fathership richy rich nga sila kse $$$$$. Nevertheless nakakanega nga ung video. On a positive note, nag-enjoy cla lola and family.
Day,kahit magtrabaho pa yan 24 oras ha hindi pa rin considered as rich o alta sa lipunan.May kaya lang.Yung rich may mga sariling negosyo,may ari ng isang damakmak na properties,nakatira sa mga alta na subdivision not working for anybody.
Title pa lang hindi ko na kinaya, but I tried, pero 1min pa lang cringe na ko sa accen TV ni girl, so yes, lame content, fake content, for the sake of content. Vloggers nowadays, memapost na lang.
Even when you grow up having money and privileg, there are others better off that you consider "wealthy", ie. $ billionaires. IMO, even if you're comfortable and all, unless you can afford a private jet to traipse around the world (although not necessarily purchase one), you're not really wealthy enough to say you're wealthy. Also, regardless of wealth, you can't put a price tag on class and decency. Who makes content like that?? Look around. Also, put those kids in schools where they have immersion programs. Why do you need to monetize it that way? Oh right..because you need the money. Which means no, you're not really wealthy.
pinanuod ko ito kasi lagi nasa suggested video pero kalmado ko namang pinanuod, nega na pala yung mga comments sa twitter. pero kasi parang same ito dun sa napapanuod ko sa gmanews tv yung parang show ni janine gutierrez tapos parang tinitreat nila yung mahirap o ngtatrabaho tapos yung host naman yong gumagawa naman ng trabaho nung mahirap. parang ganun ngkapalit lang.
hindi ko ngustuhan itong donna dun sa lola ng youtuber issue kasi grabe makareact. pero dito i dont get the point kung bakit nabash yung video nya. i think thats the reality kasi ung mga batang kasama nya pinapakita na ayaw dun sa lugar. pero atleast naexperience nila tumira dun.
Mali kasi diyan yung pagkumpara sa mayaman vs mahirap.Sa ibang reality shows walang comparison dahil nga sa sensitive ang topic.Kung sila Donalyn lang ang nagpunta sa mahihirap mas ok pa sana.
mukha lang siyang mayaman! tingnan mo parents niya mukhag so-so lang! bwisit ako sa wealthy vs poor family niya. i-hire ko nga yan buong family niya to work for me and malaman niya ano ang totoong wealthy!
uu napanood ko yun parang cla nancy castiliogne at paolo contis yun at c Claire dela fuente..nakiswap cla...infairness I like that episode naclose ni Claire yung mga mahihirap na kaswap nya then cla nancy nagpapaligo dun sa mga anak ng mga mahihirap.
Nakakatakot ang comments sa youtube mga bes. Mabibilang mo lang ang mga gumagamit ng utak. Grabe mga fantards ngayon kahit maling mali yung content todo praise pa rin. Smh
Hay mako problema talaga ng filipinos is always trying to find the good in everything. Sometimes it's good sure but seriously?? Poverty is a systemic problem. It should NEVER be romanticized.
And myghad, people who brag about their wealth are sooo cheap š¤®
The issues are 1. This is exploitation. Yung gagamitin mo ang mahirap to garner views. 2. This is technically a social expirement. Usually if ang tv shows gumagawa nito meron silang psyhologist to debrief the minors of both families. Kasi we don’t know this might have a negative effect, especially to the minors of the poor family. They might begin to ask why they live with such limited means, possible pa na mag grow ng resentment towards their parents kaya kailan talaga ma brief. In short kahit maganda pa ang intention nya kulang ng pre caution kasi napaka sensitive ng topic na to.
I watched the video, honestly it's not that bad - the title is soo wrong though, i wouldn't call her wealthy. Also, the only thing that bothered me was why she was hiding her face, she's not that popular. I only know her because of Nadine. She's pretty though. Next time, better title, and don't assume everyone knows you.
“Family Swap” no need for wealthy family poor family on the title because that’s a very sensitive issue. But on her side it’s a more “intriguing” title na mas maraming gusto e watch. Freedom of expression for her hence freedom of speech din para sa mga di sang ayon
Gaano ba kayaman ang pamilya ni Donnalyn?
ReplyDeleteWealthy daw sila according to herself.
DeleteNagkapera lang dahil sa YouTube. Nag artista man siya pero wala naman pumapansin. Dami kasi jeje tambay sa YouTube. Kahit walang katuturan pinapanood. Mababaw ang kilite nila don.
DeleteHindi naman mafefeel ng mahirap un kung one day lang o kahit pa one week. Gawin niyang one year para feel talaga
DeleteMga gabartolome siguro kadami bakz.
DeleteThinking of the same thing. Yung totoong mayayaman sa Pinas ay humble
DeleteBaka feeling mayaman. Pero sure may kaya naman sila.
DeleteHindi lahat ng pinapakita sa YouTube ay totoo,marami ay peke.Maski mga bahay malay nyo kung umuupa.
DeleteLets be honest of this most you tubers content are trash. Ginagaya at inuulit lang nila content ng iba sasabihin pa nila most requested. Trying to start a new trend to si donnalyn if this didnt backfire at her gagawin din to nina zeinab and gelai andres and so with the others.
DeleteThe makings of a Social climber ang batang eto. May kakalagyan ka din ghorl. You can’t stay on top forever.
DeleteI warched it because of all these comments. I did not see it in a negative way. Mapagmahal na ate si Donnalyn. Mababait mga kapatid nya. May lesson silang ntutunan. Masasaya yung other family. Ng enjoy sila at very thankful. Hindi daw nila makakalimutan yung experience na yon. I dont see anything wrong tbh.
Delete6:19 Just because it appears na ok sila sa video, doesn't mean na walang psychological impact sa "poor" kids yun.
Deletesis ang totoong mayaman di nila sinasabing mayaman sila.
Deletefor the sake of "content" .
ReplyDeleteNakita ko to sa yt pero di ko pinanuod. Sa title pa lang parang nahihiya ako sa wealthy/poor chuchu. Ano ba happenings sa vid fp classmates?
ReplyDeleteSaw this too and di ko din inattempt panoorin. Title pa lang parang alam mo na may mali. She could’ve thought of a better challenge for her content. Yung hindi insensitive.
DeleteSame, mga baks. Pagkakita ko pa lang sa title alam ko na may mali at naisip ko din sigurado may aalma. At yan na nga.
DeleteActually classmates napanood ko siya. Tingin ko naman ay may consent nung pther family tapos in a way she used it to teach her sibling nga a lesson of how life is different kasi ‘yung kapatid ni D lagi nakukuha lahat ng gusto and they take it for granted. I don’t think she wanted to harm or insult anyone sa bideo na to.
DeleteAng OA LANG NG MGA NETIZENS.
same here. wla akong balak panuorin kahit pakalat kalat sa youtube. kairita ang title. wealthy talaga ang tingin sa sarili nila eeww
DeletePara siang Dayoff (work, lifeswap), pero distasteful na lantarang wealthy vs poorš¤¦♀️
DeleteSame here..
DeleteKala ko ako lang nakaramdam ng mali title pa lang kaya di pinanood.madami pala tayo.
DeleteI skipped it too when i saw it in youtube
DeleteAko rin hindi pinanood, alam ko naman na walang katuturan yan eh. Ang favorite kong panoorin ay kay Basel aka The Hungry Syrian dahil sa pagtulong nya.
Delete3:17 So ginamit niya yung "poor" family? Hindi ba niya pwedeng turuan ang kapatid niya nang wala nang swap swap at mag outreach program na lang? Oh wait, hindi pala yun interesting for youtube content..
DeletePreach 511! You have a really good point!! @317 please look at that angle
DeleteAnd the psychological impact to not-so-wealthy fam, especially the children, when they go back to their reality.
ReplyDeleteTHIS!!! How inconsiderate of Donnalyn.
DeleteAgree with this. My family was once 'rich' and lost everything and became poor. The one who was most affected? My siblings who was around 6-7 years old. Before andami pwede kainin after nun naghirap, wala na. Tipid sa pagkain. Di maiintindihan ng bata kung bakit nanyari ang ganito
DeleteI like sa not so wealthy instead of using POOR. I know yun naman talaga ang tawag, but iba pa din pag sinabing poor
DeleteTama! Ang babata pa ng mga yan for them to understand kung ano nangyayare
DeleteAgree! These so called vloggers nakalimutan na yata mag isip ng matino basta lang may content sila
DeleteGumagaya yan sa isang reality show na when rich kids gone broke sa UK.Pero iba yun kasi hindi sila swap,and ang ending nagdodonate.
DeleteUnless Donalyn's family counts as genuinely well off, I would call HER not-so-wealthy and the other fam, something else, but definitely NOT label it the way she has. What a nincompoop.
Deletei feel you 1:36 kami din ganyan bigla kasi pinauwi tatay ko from saudi
Deletekaya from may kaya biglang hirap. dumating kami s punto na tirang ulam ng kamag anak namin mga inuulam namin na minsan 3 araw na pala sa ref nila. pero syempre pasalamat pa rin kami kay Lord kahit paano meron.
Hindi rin naman siguro 1:06. Although I do not agree sa format ni Donnalyn dito sa vlog nya but letting the less fortunate experience some luxuries in life for a day or two isn’t bad. I’ve seen this in other shows. And masaya naman sila after. You know, the less fortunate will always cherish whatever blessings they enjoyed even just for a day or two. Iba naman kasi yung from rich to nothing na case. Syempre, nasanay sa marangyang buhay. Mafifeel talaga ang malaking adjustment. Just saying.
Delete2:07 and she addressed herself as wealthy as if legit alta
DeleteThe other shows you mentioned are set in the UK.Ang layo ng first world countries sa mahihirap sa Pilipinas.
DeleteAng ironic lang kase donnalyn didn't really came from a rich family, she's just an ordinary poor girl from novaliches na nakilala kase puro labas makinis na kilikili ang picture nya before sa fb. Her mom also used to work abroad para lang may mapakain sa kanila. And now, she thinks so highly of herself?!?! Nakalimot kana yata girl. Im sure wala pang isang dekadang mayaman ka
ReplyDeleteAkala ko ba sa states sya lumaki? Lagi nya sinasabi sa vlogs nya pag inaasar syang english magsalita
DeleteYeah,nahahalata naman sa kilos ni Donalyn that she wasn't born rich.Chusera.
Deletefor sure di mo pinanood. panoorin mo wag kang judgemental. wala pa nga sya isang dekadang mayaman pero mayaman pa rin.
DeleteMay kaya siguro pero hindi naman mayaman.Most of the vloggers are not really rich as what they portray on cam
Delete137 oh hi Donnalyn, pero di pa rin yan sapat na dahilan para umasta kang ganyan at gawing content ang ganitong challenge. Hiya hiya din minsan sa mga totoong mayaman.
Deletedon’t use these people to teach a lesson,for u to do to this only means your parents didn’t raise you well.real rich people di gaya sayo girl.hope u get banned & no ads na.feeling rich ka lng & user pa.
ReplyDeletemaka-hate comment lang kht di pinanood. your parents didn’t raise you well.
Delete1:08 mema ka, di mo pinanood ang video. Parents didn't raide you well, masyado lang judgemental ng dahil lang sa isang video na di naman talaga nakaka offend. Masaya pa nga ung pamilyang pinagswapan dahil first time daw nila maexperience as a family ang makapag hotel at kumain sa mamahaling restaurant. Walang kinalaman ang pagpapalaki ng magulang nya sa latest video nya.
DeleteAno ang intensyon ng pagagawa ng ganitong videos? When a lot of the Filipino families are impovrished.As if hindi natin alam sa kamalayan natin yan.Sa ibang bansa,tulad ng UK,it is rare to be poor.Kumakain pa ang poor.Pero iba ang sa Pilipinas.So stop showing these swaps because it is insensitive.
DeleteDont have to watch it based on the title. Youre just making us watch it. Noveau Rich classless girl sya.
DeleteLol idedefend pa talaga ginawa ni Donna @1:39 š
DeleteAgree 1:39. Grabe. Dahil lang sa isang vlog, netizens are quick to judge the parents. Napakaperfect siguro nilang parents for them to say that.
Delete139 kinakampihan mo pa yung mali
DeleteEffort ha. Sana nag outreach nalang sila to teach her siblings. Kasi for them for video lang naman kung bat sila nandun
ReplyDeletekorek!pinagkakitaan pa mga mahirap na tao para pambili ng luho nila.eh sana bigay sa family lahat ng bayad ng ads sa content na yan.
DeleteTotoo. Iba yung ikaw ang magbibigay mismo, iba yung appreciation kesa dun sa mag swap kayo knowing na ilang oras lang yun at uuwi ka na comfortable life
DeleteNapaka cheap and insensitive ng content. To think na may isa pa siyang issue about dun sa lola kalurkey basta mema vlog lang. All for the view ang peg teh? Think before you click naman next time
ReplyDeleteUng mgnda ka nga pro wla ka nmn utak. Lol..
ReplyDeleteThis is soo true! Bobong content.May ganitong show sa Europe pero tinutulungan yung mga mahigirap.Yung bida palaging ultra rich nakiki tira kasama ng magihirap.Kumbaga immersion pero hindi ganyan.
DeleteShes not even pretty to begin with. Sorry not sorry
DeleteDi din sya kagandahan.
DeleteMaputi lang sya. Yun lang yon.
Deletenaging personalan na, focus on the issue
Deleteang gaganda nyo! lol!
Delete11:10 maganda naman talaga kami.
DeleteMay ma content lang kasi e.
ReplyDeleteCan't even consider her "wealthy"
ReplyDeleteIm sure there are a lot of FP readers here who are wealthier.Do not us!
DeleteStop romanticizing poverty.
ReplyDeleteI agree with
ReplyDelete"The less fortunate aren't there for you to realize how blessed you are"
girl...pinaggagagawa mo???
ReplyDeletegirl,kahit mahirap may nail polish..u don’t have to change clothes,di nman mukhang mamahalin mga suot nyong t-shirts.
ReplyDeleteagree with this, nag outreach kami sa isang isla, japorms ung mga nakatira, rebonded at may color ang pa ang hair. kahit sabihing less fortunate, they still find ways to cope up with uso. ang gaganda din nila. kayumanggi tapos ung face maganda
Deletepinanood nyo ba ang video?
ReplyDeleteWala akong pinapanood na video niya. Yuck sana mauso sa YouTube un mga conyo talaga un di kailangan ng pera pero maganda un content
Deleteoo
DeletePapano yung totoong mayayaman,kilala naman natin kung sino sila.Wala silang vlog for security reasons.Kasi kung wealthy na yang Donnalyn,napaka baba naman ng standards ng mga Rich sa Pilipinas.
DeleteKaloka
ReplyDeleteMatagal ng nagawa ang "Rich-Poor Swap" sa local TV at abroad, nauso lang ang socmed kaya maraming reaction na pa-woke ang nababasa online.
ReplyDeleteTinanggal yan for the same reason,insensitive.Meron binago ang concept.ginawang yung mayamang bata na spoiled brat ilalagay sa mahirap to teach them a lesson.Pero walang swap.
DeleteKasi ang concept ng Rich=Poor swap ay palabas sa UK.Kung saan ang poor sa UK ay hindi karamihan,ang poor ng UK ay middle class pang matuturing dito,kumakain,may maayos na bahay,may sasakyan.Yan ang poor.Pero Pilipinas ito,ang mahirap isang kahig isang tuka.Kaya hindi dapat yang ganyan pausuhin sa Pilipinas.
DeleteSayo na nanggaling, TV PRODUCTION. It means pinagisipan, and for sure consultation with psychologist, sociologists etc. lalo na sa post prod.
DeleteAng alam kong shows na ganto
Foreign: simple life (parus hilton and nicole ricci) - they didnt have to change clothes na pangmahirap.
Local - dayoff (carmina villaroel)
PBB- probably sa a few challenges in the entire run of PBB.
hindi po pa-woke. The production value was sensitive and really had values.
This one nakapagenglish lang and kumita ng pera, feeling mayaman na. WEALTHY talaga?
Ano ba ang circle na ginagalawan nya. Unless she’s rubbling elbows with the ayala’s pangilinans and alike she’s just an ordinary girl.
Nouveau rich classless girl. ✌️
Stop romanticizing poverty kasi. Di dahil ginawa ng iba, gagawin mo rin.
Delete1:26 exactly.
DeleteStop "romanticizing poverty" ka jan, nakikiuso ka din sa iba. Naoaka OA nyo eh masaya nga yung pamilyang pinagswapan nila. 8:44
Ang mahihirap sa UK ay hindi kasing hirap ng pulubi sa Pilipinas kaya hindi maganda yang ganyang palabas.
DeleteMacucurious ang mga tao, syempre manonood, at the the end of the day is Wealthy Donnalyn pa din ang winner sa views.
ReplyDeleteTawa naman ako sa wealthy
DeleteDi ko pinanood to kasi title pa lang off na
ReplyDeleteAko din
Deletegirl,sana sinama mo na lng sila sa evacuation centers na ipamigay mga donations ng fans mo para maturuan ng lesson kc poor parenting yata sainyo & di aware sa currents events family mo.
ReplyDeletetrue
DeleteCorrect.There is a more sensitive approach on this.
DeleteTama ka naman sa suggestion mo. But for you to say na poor parenting sa kanila dahil lang sa isang video is being judgemental na. Hindi mo sila kasama 24/7 so wala kang right sabihin yan.
DeleteQuestion,gaano ba kayaman sila Donalyn na yan???
ReplyDeleteAng totoong tanong, may pinoy influencer ba na hindi sabaw o cringey?
ReplyDeleteLloyd Cadena is not bad honestly and age appropriate ang mga vlogs niya
Deletemeron wag lang kasi puro jeje panoorin mo
DeleteMeron naman lalo na yungvmga nagtuturo ng skills.Like make up tutorial,nagluluto na vlog,etc.yan ang may content at may pakinabang sa tao.But there are vlogs too focused on the personal life.Nakaka irita.Yung iba naman majologs at palamura.
Delete1:49 anong age appropriate?!?
DeleteNot exactly pinoy but pusong pinoy. Basel "The hungry Syrian wonderer". I can say that he is one of the genuine, down to earth and humble impluencer that I've known. His videos are all worth it to watch, bonus pa yung cuties niyang mga puspin.
Deletekwento ng mga anak ng tycoons ,they spent their summer doing odd jobs in their business kaya di spolled,they know how hard it is to earn money.kala mo mga rich eh na tunay.
ReplyDeleteSome of the altas of Manila wouldnt even vlog because parents are too worried at baka makidnap.
DeleteThe moment I saw that video on my suggested vids on Youtube alam kong it’s a problematic vlog and magiging issue. Eto talagang mga vloggers na to kung anu anong basura nilalagay sa social media
ReplyDeletemganda mga feedback sa YT kaya these comments in other socmed platforms e walang bearing. Kung magkaron man ng impact itong nega comments e pagkakakitaan lang ulit yan ni Donalyn; malamang gagawa sya ng reaction video sa hate comments.
DeletePareho tayo. Pagkakita ko pa lang sa suggested feed ko alam ko magkakaissue to
DeleteYeah.Caption pa lang nakakairota na.Condiscending.
DeleteDinedelete daw niya yung negative comments sa YouTube kaya lahat maganda.
DeleteGaano ba kayaman itong si donnalyn..........wealthy daw sila eh
ReplyDeleteParang hindi naman kasi hindi man mag take off ang career.
DeleteBaka may kaya lang.Comfortable,but a lot of FP readers here,Im sure are richer in that sense.
Deletestill think it was distasteful kahit ano pang realization inspiration kuno ang gusto nyang ishare. unang kita ko palang im like WhY?? for the content?? hay nako people today talaga
ReplyDeleteGumagaya lang kasi siya sa show sa UK.
Deletepinanood ko yung video at tingin ko, kahit maganda intensyon ni donalyn na matuto mga kapatid nya, I don’t think matatandaan naman nila un lalo na nung bunso nila. Simpleng life lesson lang din naman ang narealize nila kaya parang di na need ng over night life swap.
ReplyDeletepinagkakitaan pa ang mahirap . k
ReplyDeleteDapat i-donate niya sa poor families yung kikitain niya sa video
ReplyDeleteCheap naman yan ever since. Lol so desperate to make a name for herself eh wala talaga
ReplyDeleteAy mayaman pala siya? hello BIR!!!
ReplyDeleteCorrect singilin ng tax yan.Kasi kumikita naman talaga ang YT vloggers from their ads and from the subscribers.
DeleteYes kasi if I’m not mistaken ‘yung dad niya nasa US military yata. Eh malaki bigayan doon alam naman natin. Plus you can see sa ibang vlog niya na maayos sila.
Delete4:18 just like many of the FP readers here,walang sense na sabihing mayaman sila Donalyn.May kaya siguro because dad earns in dollars but not rich.Otherwise,they are not working for US navy.Ang dami kong kamag anak sa US na nasa Navy,comfortable because of the benefits but not rich.Normal lang ang buhay sa US.
Delete4:18 hindi mayaman ang nasa US military.
DeleteWhat’s more scary are those praises from YT! Most of the commenters says na napakagandang vlog etc. Haaay people wake up! Teaching your siblings a lesson for a day? Maybe they’ll feel bless but then again after a week or so they would probably forgot it too! And yes, yung tinatawag niyang “poor” family. Once they’re back on reality, there might be a negative impact with them too! This content vlog is totally trash! š”
ReplyDeleteAng totoong mayayaman don't consider themselves wealthy. They are more likely to say that they're living comfortably. So this donnalyn girl basically has money but never wealthy... Or perhaps, a social climber
ReplyDeleteYou dont see the ultra wealthy in the vlogs.Takot makidnap.
DeleteTrue, social climber lang peg. Kahit ba kaylan hindi yan siya naghirap kasi parang di nman sya mukhang mayaman talaga. Feelingera, oo.
DeleteItong Donalyn ay sabihin na natin middle class ganyan hindi mahirap pero hindi mayaman.Malamang mas mayaman pa mga readers nitong FP.May mga artista na umunlad dahil sa kanilang career pero galing sa hirap.
DeleteMeh, if she is really wealthy then she can help the poor by giving them employment, not a photo op for herself.
ReplyDeletePakisearch please :Rich House Poor House
ReplyDeleteNaka season 4 na po ang reality series na to. Para maging open minded lang ang lahat. I'm just saying, we tend to overly sugarcoat reality. Kaya hirap tayong umasenso dahil wagas and inappropriately sensitive. You will never know na it will spark inspriration in both sides. I am just a fan of the reality series so seeing like this isn't surprising anymore.
Di porket pinapalabas sa ibang bansa eh un na ang tama. Duh! Sila yata idol mo.
DeleteGirl,we are aware of that.Paki research din kung ano ang level ng mahirap sa UK kumpara mo sa Poverty level sa atin,mayaman pang matuturing yung mga mahihirap sa Rich house,Poor house mo.Mahihirap sa first world countries,matuturing mo ng middle class sa Pilipinas.
DeleteAng reality series po may mga psychiatrist etc na nag debrief sa mga sumasali para maitindihan nila ang purpose ng mga social experiment/reality shows kaya don ang difference. Well researchwd din at na mo monitor especially in more developed countries
DeleteClick bait ni lola para sa vlog niya. A shameless user and bragging of her “wealth”.
ReplyDeleteOmg, she thinks being poor is a game, lol.
ReplyDeleteIf she is wealthy why does she need to vlog to make money? Too funny.
ReplyDeleteHer way of teaching is not age-appropriate, especially to the 2 brothers she compromised for the sake of fame. I just wonder why did the parents agree to the idea? It's abuse!
ReplyDeleteBe humble huy! Ang taas ng tingin sa sarili nakakaloka. Money can't buy utak talaga
ReplyDeleteSenior Chief Petty Officer sa US Navy si fathership richy rich nga sila kse $$$$$. Nevertheless nakakanega nga ung video. On a positive note, nag-enjoy cla lola and family.
ReplyDeleteBakit baks $100k a month ba ang sweldo nyan? Lol, if hindi š¤£
DeleteDay,kahit magtrabaho pa yan 24 oras ha hindi pa rin considered as rich o alta sa lipunan.May kaya lang.Yung rich may mga sariling negosyo,may ari ng isang damakmak na properties,nakatira sa mga alta na subdivision not working for anybody.
DeleteTitle pa lang hindi ko na kinaya, but I tried, pero 1min pa lang cringe na ko sa accen TV ni girl, so yes, lame content, fake content, for the sake of content. Vloggers nowadays, memapost na lang.
ReplyDeleteDonnalyn, define wealthy please...because IMO, wealthy are the likes of the Sys, Tans, Gokongweis, Zobels, Ayalas, Etc.
ReplyDeletethey're still wealthy naman girl. not billionaire levels pero wealthy pa rin
DeletePwede ba they are not Wealthy.They don't belong to the Society Pages .
DeleteNakakakita ka ba na alta desyudad na trying hard mag artista?
DeleteLet's get real. Walang wealthy na parents na magpapangalan sa anak nila ng "Donnalyn".
ReplyDeleteHahaha
Deletehahaha chrew!
DeleteHAHAHAHAHA! This is so true!
DeleteLol. Winner ka baks. So true.
DeleteTawang tawa ako vaks!
DeleteHahahahaha
DeleteHahahahaha!!!!! OMG!!! Your comment made my day!!!! š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£
DeleteCorrect! Hindi din belong sa mga alta apelyido nila.
Deleteano bang natapos nitong si Donnalyn? major in vlogging sa youtube university? how stupid and insensitive!
ReplyDeleteEven when you grow up having money and privileg, there are others better off that you consider "wealthy", ie. $ billionaires. IMO, even if you're comfortable and all, unless you can afford a private jet to traipse around the world (although not necessarily purchase one), you're not really wealthy enough to say you're wealthy. Also, regardless of wealth, you can't put a price tag on class and decency. Who makes content like that?? Look around. Also, put those kids in schools where they have immersion programs. Why do you need to monetize it that way? Oh right..because you need the money. Which means no, you're not really wealthy.
ReplyDeleteI watched the video and i dont c anything wrong with it. Maybe off lang yung title pero maganda yung content nya.
ReplyDeleteExactly. Dami kasing pawoke. Lahat nalang ng bagay may opinyon sila
DeleteSinetch itech? Grabeh ka girl...
ReplyDeletepinanuod ko ito kasi lagi nasa suggested video pero kalmado ko namang pinanuod, nega na pala yung mga comments sa twitter. pero kasi parang same ito dun sa napapanuod ko sa gmanews tv yung parang show ni janine gutierrez tapos parang tinitreat nila yung mahirap o ngtatrabaho tapos yung host naman yong gumagawa naman ng trabaho nung mahirap. parang ganun ngkapalit lang.
ReplyDeletehindi ko ngustuhan itong donna dun sa lola ng youtuber issue kasi grabe makareact. pero dito i dont get the point kung bakit nabash yung video nya. i think thats the reality kasi ung mga batang kasama nya pinapakita na ayaw dun sa lugar. pero atleast naexperience nila tumira dun.
ReplyDeleteMali kasi diyan yung pagkumpara sa mayaman vs mahirap.Sa ibang reality shows walang comparison dahil nga sa sensitive ang topic.Kung sila Donalyn lang ang nagpunta sa mahihirap mas ok pa sana.
Deletemukha lang siyang mayaman! tingnan mo parents niya mukhag so-so lang! bwisit ako sa wealthy vs poor family niya. i-hire ko nga yan buong family niya to work for me and malaman niya ano ang totoong wealthy!
ReplyDeleteMeron na gumawa nito dati sa isang episode ng Extra Challenge early 2000s. Yung family ng mayaman at mahirap nag-swap sila ng bahay for 1 week.
ReplyDeleteuu napanood ko yun parang cla nancy castiliogne at paolo contis yun at c Claire dela fuente..nakiswap cla...infairness I like that episode naclose ni Claire yung mga mahihirap na kaswap nya then cla nancy nagpapaligo dun sa mga anak ng mga mahihirap.
DeleteIgnorante.
ReplyDeleteNakakatakot ang comments sa youtube mga bes. Mabibilang mo lang ang mga gumagamit ng utak. Grabe mga fantards ngayon kahit maling mali yung content todo praise pa rin. Smh
ReplyDeleteMukhang dmo napanood ang vid. Panoorin mo muna kasi bago ka mag react.
DeleteNapanood namin ang video and we don't find it helpful.It doesnt change the reality that the poor,goes back to poverty.
DeleteThere you go @1149. 227 the epitome of “the fantard” haha
DeleteHay mako problema talaga ng filipinos is always trying to find the good in everything. Sometimes it's good sure but seriously?? Poverty is a systemic problem. It should NEVER be romanticized.
ReplyDeleteAnd myghad, people who brag about their wealth are sooo cheap š¤®
The question is, who is she??
ReplyDeleteWealthy people does not say they are wealthy :) Just saying....
ReplyDeleteAside from this inappropriate swap, I feel so unfair na sila nag-invade mismo ng bahay ng kapus-palad pero yung kaswap sa hotel pinatulog.
ReplyDeleteThe issues are
ReplyDelete1. This is exploitation. Yung gagamitin mo ang mahirap to garner views.
2. This is technically a social expirement. Usually if ang tv shows gumagawa nito meron silang psyhologist to debrief the minors of both families. Kasi we don’t know this might have a negative effect, especially to the minors of the poor family. They might begin to ask why they live with such limited means, possible pa na mag grow ng resentment towards their parents kaya kailan talaga ma brief.
In short kahit maganda pa ang intention nya kulang ng pre caution kasi napaka sensitive ng topic na to.
I watched the video, honestly it's not that bad - the title is soo wrong though, i wouldn't call her wealthy. Also, the only thing that bothered me was why she was hiding her face, she's not that popular. I only know her because of Nadine. She's pretty though. Next time, better title, and don't assume everyone knows you.
ReplyDeleteSiya yung mangiyak ngiyak sa mga bashers dahil dun sa pelikula niya eh.. Ano pa ba eexpect mo?
ReplyDeleteWait, kung hindi dapat wealthy ang ginamit nyang term, anu ba dapat?
ReplyDeleteMiddle class?
Delete“Family Swap” no need for wealthy family poor family on the title because that’s a very sensitive issue. But on her side it’s a more “intriguing” title na mas maraming gusto e watch. Freedom of expression for her hence freedom of speech din para sa mga di sang ayon
DeleteEh marami din naman ibig sabihin ang family swap hindi lng naman ibig sabihin estado ng buhay. Kaya kailangan maintindihan ng viewers o magcclick.
DeletePoint is,you dont jave to compare.Point taken lalo na sa Pilipinas kung saan ubod ng hirap ang mahihirap.
DeleteMaybe wealthy lang talaga ang ginamit nyang term kasi yung kabilang pic eh talaga naman mahirap sila tpos sila donalyn may kaya naman talaga sila.
ReplyDeleteThey are comfortable but not rich.Ang baba naman ng standards ng rich sa Pilipinas kung mayaman na yan.Nakaluwag luwag lang.
ReplyDeletepasikat. laos na kasi eh. wala naman talent
ReplyDeleteLol. If you need a click bait nonsense for your vlog to make money, then you are far from being wealthy.
ReplyDeleteHahaha.True!
Delete