Hahaha who cares if they were chosen by the franchise!? We all know that they just chose a judge who has a big fan base enough to make the show a trend. Quantity over Quality sila.
12:30 whatever it is, that is the reason why these judges were chosen. and people should respect that reason. why? because the show is not for them, obviously. it is for those who appreciate the show despite all these questions on judges' credibility. and for the network, those people are anough reason.
11:40 pinagsasabe mo, the show is for everyone kaya mo nga napapanuod on free tv its just that they are not loving the show and just giving their opinions. im sure after ng hirit ng mga yan hindi na nila yan pinanuod.
Never akong nanood ng malaman ko ang judges ng Idol. Ito namang si Joey Reyes bakit nag suggest pa ng mga pangalan sinali pa si Moriseete. Puede ba may Zsa Zsa, may Kuh Ledesma etc.
Notice ko rin mostly JaDine fans. Hurt sila for James kasi very obvious na hindi talaga siya magaling na judge, at marami talaga ang hindi convinced na tama o nararapat siyang judge sa contest na yan.
I don't get the hate but his suggestions have no ill-intent. Totoo naman need ng credibility. Butthurt lang mga tards. Aminin, flop ang Idol Ph dahil di credible ibang judges.
Also, if they are choosing someone na magiging “idol” sa singing or stage performance, they need to have industry veterans or people who have proven their star power in the industry. Sikat si James as part of a love team, not as a singer or recording artist. Nagkaroon lang ng break sa recording dahil sa love team niya, pero hindi legit na recording artist. Si Moira naman, so bland as a judge, I don’t see that she can even confidently “judge” the aspirants. Tsaka parang sobrang hilaw to be considered a judge for a contest like that. Ewan, sa YT ko na lang pinapanood ang mga excerpts dahil hindi ko rin ma stand panoorin. Disappointing ang show na yan. Sana si Regine na lang at Vice, then another industry veteran na music producer or songwriter.
Everyone has an opinion and we should learn respect each others' opinion. Kung yun ang gusto niya maging judge. Pti ako rin nman, ayaw ko n line of judges s show n yan. Pti cgurado ko nman may gusto din nman sila ilagay dyan
I think Direk Joey was just suggesting something on the show. He didn't mean to disrespect the existing judges. And yeah, you cannot blame the people, there are so many reaction papers afterwards. Sorry, I don't mean to be harsh but it will serve as a lesson as well whenever we conduct something, let's get judges that has experience and has carved their names in the stones of the showbiz.
May point naman c Direk. Kumuha ng credible na judges para mas maayos at maturuan for improvement un mapipiling contestants. Ang siste kasi kumuha ng judges based sa popularity kc nga naman business is business. Pang hatak ng viewers un mga sikat na may fan base na. Kumikitang kabuhayan nga naman🙄
I think vice was chosen because he’s a manager. So he should know pano i-market ang mga aspiring. Regine, alam naman natin lahat why she’s there. Moira and James on the other hand? I have no idea.
Some Of their songs naman talaga si from the past pa... sinulat nila ex jowa niya. Hahahaha! Please naman girl writes? Ang babaw kaya ng nga songs nila. Hinde naman sikat! Thanks sa fans nila sila lang may alam ng kanta nila
so what kung producer siya may napasikat na ba siyang ibang artist at kanta ng ibang artist? nagsisimula pa lang siya, thus no credibility kaya tigil-tigilan niyo na yang producer ek ek nyo
1:07 yang pinaglalaban niyong songs ni james puro walang sense ang lyrics not to mention flop din kahit sa youtube so wala pa ding credibility. mas sikat pa nga energy gap song niya compared her original songs
Mas Catchy pa nga yung songs nila before yung hanap hanap parapapa E at ang sarap Pakinggan basta yung una album ni James Reid bet ko yun .... Not yung careless ha! Swear mas ok pa yun. Pero now parang ayaw na niya balikan yun Pinoy songs nila ng jowa niya.. pang na ewwww na sila and they dont even sing it na!:(
Wrong k 2:57, khit ung first song that he release ay hndi rin naghit. Walang naghit ni isa s naproduce ni james. Ni wala man lng recall from people. All of his songs (that he produce) are forgettable.
Di nyo kase genre.. Yun lang yun.. Nakadepende na ba trending lahat ng bagay ngayon? Wala rin namang sense ibang mga kinakanta ngayon.. Kaloka double standards
No 12:45, Hindi ko alam kung bakit andon si Regine except that she has saturated the network together with her husband. I subscribe to TFC for a good R&R after work and on weekends but somehow their faces are clogging the channel. Nakakasawa.
Even if I don’t like her, I can admit na technical singer siya. Marami siyang mashi-share na tips if she’s judging. And she knows how to be on both sides since naging contestant na din siya before.
Mas may k nman si morisette kaysa kay james at moira. These two cant sing for their lives. While morisette is already recognise by other countries like korea and america due to her voice. U just being a blind or deaf 12:45
Moira doesn't deserve to be a judge in idol PH. Sa totoo lang iisa lang ang style ng pag kanta na nakaka depress sa mga tao. Dapat tumula na lang siya kesa kumanta.
Maraming suggestions para maging judges pero bakit sila ang pinili ng idolph, wala na tayong magagawa doon . Kumuda pa kayo ng kumuda pero di sila papalitan .
@4:56 that's what you think. But the producers and network listens to the audience. If the complaints persist and if the ratings remain as they are or get worse the producers might change up the judges next season or worse the network might not bring it back for season 2. so yeah we viewers have a lot of power over shows. You're probably just scared your sabaw idol will lose out on a job and tarnish his "credibility". idk why you lomi fans seem to think that the audience has no say in these shows.. who else is going to watch these shows if not the public?
Umay na kami kay Regine. She's really not that of a good judge either. She has the tendency to use the same words and description. Very generic. Paulit ulit.
i get his point pero wrong timing naman sana nung na announce saka nag suggest or after matapos kung may next season pa pero wala na ata may the voice kids na soon at ang baba ng ratings compared sa the voice
Si R lang ang fully aware sa kanyang pagiging judge. The trio? Trip Trip lang nila. Parang kaya na ngang dalhin mag-isa ni R yung show e,kung pwede nga lang sya mag-isa dun,tutal waley naman mga banat ng mga kasama nya,as audience tatamarin ka silang pakinggan,mapapa "Ha ano raw?!" Ka nalang sa sarili mo e.. Kakahawa kasi sa pagiging out of nowhere nun tatlo lols!
Kung gusto nila ng may HUMOR na judge anjan po sina Ogie Alcasid at Janno Gibbs tapos anjan sina Zsa zsa, Martin, Gary V and Jaya... Bakit nga ba baguhan at komedyante pa kinuhang judge???
We want to be entertained, not bored further - So NO Ogie and Janno Gibbs please. Hindi yun ang klase ng comedy na 'entertaining' to the current generation.
1:55 Gosh being a judge ang usapan! Charice is a very talented singer songwriter who was with David Pomeranz for a long time and had sung and worked with the best singers in the world. Top notch credentials under ber belt.
Basa ng comment. Di naman performer ang sinabi pagiging judge. Charice or Jake she or he is still good. Di matatawaran ang experience at di naman mababago non na qualified siya to be a judge. Common sense people. Ang boses niya ba ang gagamitin sa pagjujudge! Kaya ng judge eh may karapatan.
Atleast si jake zyrus mas okay magjudge. Di man ganun ka okay na boses ni jake pero un ears niya at eyes kay Charice pa rin. Look at KZ. Di man kagandahan noon pero Charice helped KZ na magmukhang star. Sabi nga ni kZ pinapahiram sya ni Charice ng gamit noon. Kaya ganun na lang pasasalamat ni KZ kay Charice/Jake
Jano??? May attitude and attendance issues nga d ba? Credible nga laki naman problema kakaharapin ng production, huwag na lang. wala na ata hatak si martin so malulugi. Gary nasa tnt na.
Hahah! Kaloka parang recorder na nagsasalita yung pagjajudge ng iba, yun at yun lang ang nasasabi kahit iba-iba mga contestant. Amboring nila magjudge O boring din kasi phasing ng Ph version nitong Idol chenenez na'to
Joey was right. Choose a credible judge at hindi yong mga putcho putcho. James tried hard to become one good judge but sad to say he comes off trying hard with his comments. Nagmukhang pabibo, andamibg sinasabi pero yong mukha blanko. parang gusto ko tuloy magtanobg, are you sure james?
Napaka respectful nga at maayos ang pagbibigay ni Direk Joey ng opinion niya ang daming sumugod na butthurt. What a classy act to apologize even if he doesn’t have to.
Maybe a good suggestion is a change of judges when they go to Idol City. Para naman magkaroon ng konting credibility. Janno will be a good replacement. Si Regine na lang ang iwan sa original. Para tumaas ang rating. Most na nakakausap ko, after watching the show once, di na umuulit.
warfreak lomis dami niyo ng inaaway na director ano akala niyo sa idols niyo saksakan ng talented at dapat sambahin ng mga credible directors or else world war? mahiya kayo.
2:30 true! Ang stressful na there’s always a need to defend your idol when they’re being criticized kasi they din not meet a certain standard. In the first place, Kung credible naman kasi si idol, wala silang maririnig na criticism e kaso nga hinde. So abang abang nalang sino next na aawayin nila. Lol
Dapat ba talaga singer para maging credible judge? Si Simon Cowell ba singer? Not to compare ha but some people gotta start somewhere to know if they can actually judge or not. Tayo nga viewers grabe makapag judge. I’m not a fan of Moira nor James but let’s give them a chance. If they don’t deliver this season, then let the franchise choose other people for judges for the next season.
Wag mo I compare si Simon Cowell sa kanila dahil wala sila pinag kaiba kay Cowell pwede ba. Si Cowell manager yun he manage singers. He gets yung may potential may boses at Star qualify may utak at may laman when he comments ...eh James and Moira meron ba? Siguro meron naman pero kulang pa sila sa expeirnce sa ganito ganap. Hinde pa sila hinog. They need more knowledge sa mga ganito program.
Dont ever compare Simon to those two, 2:49. Yes, simon is not a singer but he has a solid record that he can produce singer that could be worldwide sensations. While these two, nothing at all. Their foundation is too weak, no solid record, and just a newbie. They already given a chance, but this is their last chance. Sorry, not sorry
not necessarily pero yung may credible accomlishments to their belt naman sana, kung kukuha ng producer e di sana yung gaya ni Jonathan Manalo o ni Rox Santos, o kaya sina Thyro at Yumi. Kung star builder like Simon Cowell dapat yung established like Johnny Manahan o FMG
Ilang episode na sila binibigyan ng chance. Ilang linggo ng running ang show still same padin comments ng casual viewers. Nagiging laughing stock na nga sila e lalo if u check fb
No but we need people with Experience thats the key word. Simon cowell is legit because his success and experience speak for themselves he knows what he is talking about but james and moira what did they achieve to be able to guide the contestants ?nothing.
Hindi naman. Pero si Simon cowell kasi may reputation na before he became a judge. Established producer and star maker. From westlife to one direction iba na ang sinasabi ng credibility niya. Nakapagpasikat nga siya ng mga tao eh so it means mapagkakatiwalaan siya sa mga sinasabi at ginagawa niya. I truly hope na may next season pa but with the mediocre ratings and public reception.....
Simon is a producer. You don’t need to be a singer to have an ear for music and an eye for talent. JLo is not a real singer but she’s considered an icon. James and Moira are what? Si James may solid fanbase, panghatak ng views. Si Moira, viral girl, pero wala pang napatunayan.
Tumpak. I am not a fan too pero marurunong pa sa producers eh. Bakit kaya hindi sila magproduce para kunin nilang judge yung gusto nila, pati na si direk ba masyadong pabibo.
Anon 2:49, Simon worked for big recording companies in the past, he's a talent scout, and he's a music producer. He signed up Westlife in his recording company; and thus he was already a millionaire before American Idol made him a household name.
Hndi nman 11:41 pro kaya unhappy ang mga tao kasi obvious n hndi magaling n singers ang 2 which questionable ang pagbigay ng mga comments kung sila mismo hndi nila maiapply s mga sarili nila. Also, what people want is to have qualified person who can help to produce a legit idol, hndi ung ultimo mga judges ay hirapan iangat ang track records nila
Ang insensitive nga. Di man lang ba niya naisip anong ma feefeel ng mga current judges towards him for saying that. Magkakilala pa nmn sila. Kasi lang hndi nkapasok mga bet nila puro na hanash online. Kong hndi nka pasok meaning di pa nila time yun. Kasi if it's their time kahit sino pang judge yan mkakapasok yan.
Its Not insensitive opinion niya yan ang mga natamaan talaga ang mga lomis. Sa buhay talaga whether you like it Or Not makakatanggap ka ng ganyan comments oo masakit but sympre pag sineryoso mo Yung isang comment sayo it depends sayo How you handle it If may point edi baguhin mo you change its For the better naman E.
But u and ur co fans are way too sensitive and insensitive at the same time.
Sensitive because u cant accept any critique, even if it is deliver in a nice way and it is for the better of ur idol, u all treat it as bad and bash that person even if that person is way respected than ur idol.
Insenstive, associated with the one i said above, because u treat that person as if he/she didnt deserve to live. U treat them as if they are lowest to the lowest form. U degrading just for the sake of defending ur idol despite they only meant goodness and betterment.
So please, dont act as if u, your cofans, and your idols are the victims here
Toxic fandom dami inaaway. Kung magaling lang kasi idols nila, di sila makakatanggap ng ganitong criticism from direk. Nako lomis, di pwedeng lahat ng pupuna sa idols niyo ggyerahin niyo. Sa industriyang to kakampi ang dapat hinahakot niyo, hindi kaaway.
Because Simon Cowell is THE Simon Cowell. He was behind the discovery of Westlife, One Direction, Leona Lewis, Little Mix and Fifth Harmony. He really has the eye for those who have potential. Kumbaga may credibility na tlga siya bago isalang as a judge.
Exciting to, ang daming magagaling at super talented na nakapasok. Anjan c alyssa, yung winner ng bolt of talent, anak ni mau, wycopa champion, tnt grand finalist, etc
Hahaha true 3:54. Sariling sikap si ate(7:09,7:06, at 7:08). Lumubog n ksi ang barko (or lubog n to begin with) at kailangan iangat ulit kungdi byebye career n
Aminin natn mababa ang ang ratings ng Idol Philippines kumpara sa ibang franchise shows ng Abs. Mas mataas pa nga ratings nung Dance Show nila Gary V na consistent 30% kahit more on singing show mga Pinoy.
I Find James Reid comments rehearsed. Yung alam na niya yung sasabihin sa each contestant makikita niya. Its coming from his mouth lang Not within him galing sa puso. He Just talk at Ma English kasi.... magaling siya dun.
Wala naman kayong magagawa kung ayaw niyo sa mga judges, at kahit pintasan niyo pa sila at ibash forever, hanggang dun na lang kayo. Sabi nga nung nag comment sa itaas , let the show to be finish atsaka kayo magrequest ng mga gusto niyo na judges. Bayad na yang mga judges na yang, too late for hanash.
Too late too to save their a**es 3:28. Last n nila ito at hndi n mauulit. Tinatapos (kung matatapos) for the sake of contract after all this is an international franchise
malakas ang magagawa naming as audience, unang una marami kami. Next, sa amin nakasalalay ang success ng mga shows. Kaya tanggal yan pag hindi pa umayos. May kalalagyan.
Ako naman OK lang si James, maganda siya mag comment at ang mga sinasabi niya may substance, kaaliw naman si vice at regine, ang sarap ng mga tunog ng tawa nila. OK din naman ang mga comment. Except Moira parang laging inaantok, or tinatamad ang dating kapag nagsalita. Parang walang gana at kulang sa vitamins
Sorry pero nag a aggree ako kay Direk Joey. And kelan pa naging kabastusan magsabi ng opinyon? Afterall, this is a TV SHOW. At lahat ng nakakapanuod entitled magbigay ng comment. Di naman below the belt yung sinabi ah? Sa true lang lol
true, sa tagal na niyang direk Joey sa industriya alam niya ang importansya ng credibility as a star maker. Last time I checked, meron pa rin tayong Freedom of Speech.
Agree with ditching Moira and James - Regine delivers the 'icon' singer, Vice delivers the 'entertainment' factor, ewan ko kung ano yung kay James and Moira but they are both SUPER BORING.
Hahaha who cares if they were chosen by the franchise!? We all know that they just chose a judge who has a big fan base enough to make the show a trend. Quantity over Quality sila.
ReplyDeleteDi matanggap kase ng fans ni V & J na walang talent sa pag-judge yung idol nila na naka-depende lang sa auto-tune ang mga kanta
DeleteTrue naman. Regine and Vice ok for me but Moira and James? Sorry. Both are boring and bland.
DeleteAnd utang na loob naman Moira, ang obvious na hindi talaga yan ang speed ng speaking voice mo. Kairita sa totoo lang.
Isama mo pa ang "God bless you" ni Billy all the time. At talagang sa kanya pa nanggaling yan ha.
Ibalik si Robi.
DeleteYung mga paggamit ng word na respeto.....hahahahahaha!
DeleteYung They were chosen for a reason ni baby santa claus. The reason is para maiba lang. Hahaha!
Delete12:30 whatever it is, that is the reason why these judges were chosen. and people should respect that reason. why? because the show is not for them, obviously. it is for those who appreciate the show despite all these questions on judges' credibility. and for the network, those people are anough reason.
DeleteSadly 11:40 only few appreciate this show, kya nga ang baba ng ratings nila eh
Delete11:40 pinagsasabe mo, the show is for everyone kaya mo nga napapanuod on free tv its just that they are not loving the show and just giving their opinions. im sure after ng hirit ng mga yan hindi na nila yan pinanuod.
DeleteNever akong nanood ng malaman ko ang judges ng Idol. Ito namang si Joey Reyes bakit nag suggest pa ng mga pangalan sinali pa si Moriseete. Puede ba may Zsa Zsa, may Kuh Ledesma etc.
Delete@11:40 those people are enough? that's why the ratings are so low. ang baba ng standards ng lomis.
DeleteDaming hurt hah
ReplyDeleteJadine fans karamihan bwahaha
Delete85% lomis ang butthurt
DeleteNotice ko rin mostly JaDine fans. Hurt sila for James kasi very obvious na hindi talaga siya magaling na judge, at marami talaga ang hindi convinced na tama o nararapat siyang judge sa contest na yan.
DeleteSorry pero I agree with Joey wholeheartedly. His choices are the better of the judges.
ReplyDeleteI don't get the hate but his suggestions have no ill-intent. Totoo naman need ng credibility. Butthurt lang mga tards. Aminin, flop ang Idol Ph dahil di credible ibang judges.
ReplyDeleteI agree. Matalinong opinyon.
Deleteyes! I share the same opinion, kung wala yung pagpatawa ni Vice, sa tingin niyo may manonood nitong antok na Moira?
DeleteFlop dahil NAKAKASAWA hindi dahil sa judges!
DeleteAlso, if they are choosing someone na magiging “idol” sa singing or stage performance, they need to have industry veterans or people who have proven their star power in the industry. Sikat si James as part of a love team, not as a singer or recording artist. Nagkaroon lang ng break sa recording dahil sa love team niya, pero hindi legit na recording artist. Si Moira naman, so bland as a judge, I don’t see that she can even confidently “judge” the aspirants. Tsaka parang sobrang hilaw to be considered a judge for a contest like that. Ewan, sa YT ko na lang pinapanood ang mga excerpts dahil hindi ko rin ma stand panoorin. Disappointing ang show na yan. Sana si Regine na lang at Vice, then another industry veteran na music producer or songwriter.
DeleteBut the biggest factor why it was nakakasawa is because of judges 9:42 since they always shown
DeleteEveryone has an opinion and we should learn respect each others' opinion. Kung yun ang gusto niya maging judge. Pti ako rin nman, ayaw ko n line of judges s show n yan. Pti cgurado ko nman may gusto din nman sila ilagay dyan
ReplyDeleteI think Direk Joey was just suggesting something on the show. He didn't mean to disrespect the existing judges. And yeah, you cannot blame the people, there are so many reaction papers afterwards. Sorry, I don't mean to be harsh but it will serve as a lesson as well whenever we conduct something, let's get judges that has experience and has carved their names in the stones of the showbiz.
ReplyDeleteOA lang yung mga fans ng jadine. Yun lang yon.
DeleteMay point naman c Direk. Kumuha ng credible na judges para mas maayos at maturuan for improvement un mapipiling contestants. Ang siste kasi kumuha ng judges based sa popularity kc nga naman business is business. Pang hatak ng viewers un mga sikat na may fan base na. Kumikitang kabuhayan nga naman🙄
ReplyDeleteI think vice was chosen because he’s a manager. So he should know pano i-market ang mga aspiring. Regine, alam naman natin lahat why she’s there. Moira and James on the other hand? I have no idea.
ReplyDelete12:45, James, writes and sings his own songs, he owns a recording company now, Careless Music Manila.
DeleteJames is a producer
DeleteSome Of their songs naman talaga si from the past pa... sinulat nila ex jowa niya. Hahahaha! Please naman girl writes? Ang babaw kaya ng nga songs nila. Hinde naman sikat! Thanks sa fans nila sila lang may alam ng kanta nila
DeleteNewbie producer to be exact 1:15 and 1:07. Wla p silang hit ni isa or kaL-LSS san song that they produce. Still not good to be qualified a judge
Deleteso what kung producer siya may napasikat na ba siyang ibang artist at kanta ng ibang artist? nagsisimula pa lang siya, thus no credibility kaya tigil-tigilan niyo na yang producer ek ek nyo
Delete1:07 yang pinaglalaban niyong songs ni james puro walang sense ang lyrics not to mention flop din kahit sa youtube so wala pa ding credibility. mas sikat pa nga energy gap song niya compared her original songs
DeleteProducer???? Of his own song?? Ano nha bang title?????
Deleteano ang sumikat na songs nitong James, para magkaalaman na. Parang yung una lang ang nag hit then yung mga susunod waley na!
DeleteMas Catchy pa nga yung songs nila before yung hanap hanap parapapa E at ang sarap
DeletePakinggan basta yung una album ni James Reid bet ko yun .... Not yung careless ha! Swear mas ok pa yun. Pero now parang ayaw na niya balikan yun Pinoy songs nila ng jowa niya.. pang na ewwww na sila and they dont even sing it na!:(
Wrong k 2:57, khit ung first song that he release ay hndi rin naghit. Walang naghit ni isa s naproduce ni james. Ni wala man lng recall from people. All of his songs (that he produce) are forgettable.
DeleteKya 1:07 and 1:15 wla p kyo mapapagyabang
Mabuti at magproduce siya ng sarili niyang kanta. Dahil walang magpoproduce para sa kanya!
Deletemeron naman sumikat na kanta si james. sikat till now sa schools. energy enegry gap🎵🎶🎵🎶. thank you milo hehe
DeleteHahahaahh 2:23. Un nga lng yta ang napasikat niya song n solo sya since catchy ung song. But what make it more interesting is the IRONY in it
DeleteDi nyo kase genre.. Yun lang yun.. Nakadepende na ba trending lahat ng bagay ngayon? Wala rin namang sense ibang mga kinakanta ngayon.. Kaloka double standards
DeleteNo 12:45, Hindi ko alam kung bakit andon si Regine except that she has saturated the network together with her husband. I subscribe to TFC for a good R&R after work and on weekends but somehow their faces are clogging the channel. Nakakasawa.
DeleteHahahah 4:23 i commonly listen to hiphop/club/rnb music like drake,jayz, etc. But not james' as he's song has no depth and his voice is irritating.
DeleteMorissette? Are you kidding me???
ReplyDeleteWhy not? I’d rather go with Morisete than with that human sleeping pill Moira
DeleteEven if I don’t like her, I can admit na technical singer siya. Marami siyang mashi-share na tips if she’s judging. And she knows how to be on both sides since naging contestant na din siya before.
DeleteMas may k nman si morisette kaysa kay james at moira. These two cant sing for their lives. While morisette is already recognise by other countries like korea and america due to her voice. U just being a blind or deaf 12:45
DeleteMoira doesn't deserve to be a judge in idol PH. Sa totoo lang iisa lang ang style ng pag kanta na nakaka depress sa mga tao. Dapat tumula na lang siya kesa kumanta.
DeleteMaraming suggestions para maging judges pero bakit sila ang pinili ng idolph, wala na tayong magagawa doon . Kumuda pa kayo ng kumuda pero di sila papalitan .
Delete@4:56 that's what you think. But the producers and network listens to the audience. If the complaints persist and if the ratings remain as they are or get worse the producers might change up the judges next season or worse the network might not bring it back for season 2. so yeah we viewers have a lot of power over shows. You're probably just scared your sabaw idol will lose out on a job and tarnish his "credibility". idk why you lomi fans seem to think that the audience has no say in these shows.. who else is going to watch these shows if not the public?
DeleteMga butthurt na jejedine fans lang naman yang madaldal lol
ReplyDeletebuti na lang babalik na The Voice Kids with credible coaches lol
ReplyDeleteVery tru n tru kdyan 12:51. May gahd, i cant wait for this show to be axe
DeleteSana hindi na lang kids. Tapos ilagay si Regine instead of sharon!
DeleteUmay na kami kay Regine. She's really not that of a good judge either. She has the tendency to use the same words and description. Very generic. Paulit ulit.
DeleteWell, he is right. The current judges are so bad. You can’t believe them. Puro nonsense.
ReplyDeleteTrue! maang maangan pa ang basher na gumagawa gawa ng fake account, iisang tao lang naman din yon. Wag kami!
DeleteHahahahaha......wala naman talaga silang credibility. Kalokohan lang.
ReplyDeletei get his point pero wrong timing naman sana nung na announce saka nag suggest or after matapos kung may next season pa pero wala na ata may the voice kids na soon at ang baba ng ratings compared sa the voice
ReplyDeleteWla nang next season ang idol. Ni hndi nga alam kung makakasurvive or matatapos nila itong season n ito eh. Kya ok n magshare while its still hot
Deletebuti nga palitan na yan, at tanggalin na yung ayaw ng mga tao. Bakit kailangan ipagpilitan sa viewers yung ayaw nila makitang mga judges?
DeleteSi R lang ang fully aware sa kanyang pagiging judge. The trio? Trip
ReplyDeleteTrip lang nila. Parang kaya na ngang dalhin mag-isa ni R yung show e,kung pwede nga lang sya mag-isa dun,tutal waley naman mga banat ng mga kasama nya,as audience tatamarin ka silang pakinggan,mapapa "Ha ano raw?!" Ka nalang sa sarili mo e.. Kakahawa kasi sa pagiging out of nowhere nun tatlo lols!
Anjan naman big 4 humor + credibility regine jaya ogie janno...oh well
DeleteHmmm.....nobody is watching it anyway.
ReplyDeleteKaya nga dami nagrereklamo eh.. Meaning may nanonood pa rin haha
Delete4:24, no, they are just commenting on the comments. Gets mo.
Deletesa tatlong ayaw ni direk joey parang halos lahat ng comments galing sa lomis , mahahalata mo talaga kung kaninong fantards ang mga iyakin eh.
ReplyDeleteHay jadines ang iinit nanaman ng ulo niyo. Kaya ang sarap niyo asarin E. Iba talga kayo pag High blood parang end Of the world na
ReplyDeleteand worst pati age and hitsura ng taong nagbigay ng constructive criticism lalaitin din and ending sila pa pavictim sa huli.
DeleteKung gusto nila ng may HUMOR na judge anjan po sina Ogie Alcasid at Janno Gibbs tapos anjan sina Zsa zsa, Martin, Gary V and Jaya... Bakit nga ba baguhan at komedyante pa kinuhang judge???
ReplyDeleteTama na po sa mga yun. Nasa tnt na sila. Enough of ogie and regine please. Hindi nga sumikat yung x factor nina martin kaya wala na kasunod
DeleteUmay na Umay na kami Kay Ogie at Regine.
DeleteWe want to be entertained, not bored further - So NO Ogie and Janno Gibbs please. Hindi yun ang klase ng comedy na 'entertaining' to the current generation.
DeleteTbh, regine lang credible...anjan naman sina martin, ogie, jano,etc
ReplyDeleteGARY V
DeleteMARTIN N.
Sa makabagong tunoh at henerasyon at legit si CHARICE
Charice's voice is not that stable, unlike before
Delete1:55 Gosh being a judge ang usapan! Charice is a very talented singer songwriter who was with David Pomeranz for a long time and had sung and worked with the best singers in the world. Top notch credentials under ber belt.
Deletehe is Jake Zyrus now so call him that, on the other hand his voice is no longer comparable to the old Charice
DeleteBasa ng comment. Di naman performer ang sinabi pagiging judge. Charice or Jake she or he is still good. Di matatawaran ang experience at di naman mababago non na qualified siya to be a judge. Common sense people. Ang boses niya ba ang gagamitin sa pagjujudge! Kaya ng judge eh may karapatan.
DeleteAtleast si jake zyrus mas okay magjudge. Di man ganun ka okay na boses ni jake pero un ears niya at eyes kay Charice pa rin. Look at KZ. Di man kagandahan noon pero Charice helped KZ na magmukhang star. Sabi nga ni kZ pinapahiram sya ni Charice ng gamit noon. Kaya ganun na lang pasasalamat ni KZ kay Charice/Jake
DeleteDavid Foster Anon 2:30 not Pomeranz
DeleteNo to jake zyrus na.
DeleteJano??? May attitude and attendance issues nga d ba? Credible nga laki naman problema kakaharapin ng production, huwag na lang. wala na ata hatak si martin so malulugi. Gary nasa tnt na.
DeleteBakit nga ba sina Moira and James?? and vice??
ReplyDeleteMalaki ang fanbase kasi nila. You know influencers
DeleteBecause of fanbase/popularity, nothing more or less. Their records such as few hits, being a newbie producer, and such are just accessories
Deleteboring itong Moira na ito, sana tama na pagpapahype sa kanya, pareparehas lang tunog na antukin yung mga kanta niya.
DeleteHahah! Kaloka parang recorder na nagsasalita yung pagjajudge ng iba, yun at yun lang ang nasasabi kahit iba-iba mga contestant. Amboring nila magjudge O boring din kasi phasing ng Ph version nitong Idol chenenez na'to
ReplyDeleteJoey was right. Choose a credible judge at hindi yong mga putcho putcho. James tried hard to become one good judge but sad to say he comes off trying hard with his comments. Nagmukhang pabibo, andamibg sinasabi pero yong mukha blanko. parang gusto ko tuloy magtanobg, are you sure james?
ReplyDeleteMoira is useless. Too pabebe at her age. Kakairita Ng nga jirit na parang echo lang naman sys ng ibang judges.
ReplyDeletewag na ipa judge yan, wala naman din credibility yung kanta niya. Lasheng lahat.
DeleteHindi na dapat nag-apologize si Direk. Direk, a composer himself, is also entitled to his own opinion. Mga pabeast mode lang itong mga fantards.
ReplyDeleteNapaka respectful nga at maayos ang pagbibigay ni Direk Joey ng opinion niya ang daming sumugod na butthurt. What a classy act to apologize even if he doesn’t have to.
DeleteMaybe a good suggestion is a change of judges when they go to Idol City. Para naman magkaroon ng konting credibility. Janno will be a good replacement. Si Regine na lang ang iwan sa original. Para tumaas ang rating. Most na nakakausap ko, after watching the show once, di na umuulit.
ReplyDeleteAs far as rating, Hindi si Regine ang dahilan. Si Vice.
DeleteJanno has issues so no to him. Ikaw na lang magproduce kung gusto mo si janno.
Deletewarfreak lomis dami niyo ng inaaway na director ano akala niyo sa idols niyo saksakan ng talented at dapat sambahin ng mga credible directors or else world war? mahiya kayo.
ReplyDelete2:30 true! Ang stressful na there’s always a need to defend your idol when they’re being criticized kasi they din not meet a certain standard. In the first place, Kung credible naman kasi si idol, wala silang maririnig na criticism e kaso nga hinde. So abang abang nalang sino next na aawayin nila. Lol
DeleteDapat ba talaga singer para maging credible judge? Si Simon Cowell ba singer? Not to compare ha but some people gotta start somewhere to know if they can actually judge or not. Tayo nga viewers grabe makapag judge. I’m not a fan of Moira nor James but let’s give them a chance. If they don’t deliver this season, then let the franchise choose other people for judges for the next season.
ReplyDeleteWag mo I compare si Simon Cowell sa kanila dahil wala sila pinag kaiba kay Cowell pwede ba. Si Cowell manager yun he manage singers. He gets yung may potential may boses at Star qualify may utak at may laman when he comments ...eh James and Moira meron ba? Siguro meron naman pero kulang pa sila sa expeirnce sa ganito ganap. Hinde pa sila hinog. They need more knowledge sa mga ganito program.
DeleteDont ever compare Simon to those two, 2:49. Yes, simon is not a singer but he has a solid record that he can produce singer that could be worldwide sensations. While these two, nothing at all. Their foundation is too weak, no solid record, and just a newbie. They already given a chance, but this is their last chance. Sorry, not sorry
Deletenot necessarily pero yung may credible accomlishments to their belt naman sana, kung kukuha ng producer e di sana yung gaya ni Jonathan Manalo o ni Rox Santos, o kaya sina Thyro at Yumi. Kung star builder like Simon Cowell dapat yung established like Johnny Manahan o FMG
DeleteIlang episode na sila binibigyan ng chance. Ilang linggo ng running ang show still same padin comments ng casual viewers. Nagiging laughing stock na nga sila e lalo if u check fb
DeleteNo but we need people with Experience thats the key word. Simon cowell is legit because his success and experience speak for themselves he knows what he is talking about but james and moira what did they achieve to be able to guide the contestants ?nothing.
DeleteHindi naman. Pero si Simon cowell kasi may reputation na before he became a judge. Established producer and star maker. From westlife to one direction iba na ang sinasabi ng credibility niya. Nakapagpasikat nga siya ng mga tao eh so it means mapagkakatiwalaan siya sa mga sinasabi at ginagawa niya. I truly hope na may next season pa but with the mediocre ratings and public reception.....
DeleteSimon is a basher! Kaya nga sumikat yung Idol na yan dahil sa mga direct hit at mga bombs niya!
DeleteSimon is a producer. You don’t need to be a singer to have an ear for music and an eye for talent. JLo is not a real singer but she’s considered an icon. James and Moira are what? Si James may solid fanbase, panghatak ng views. Si Moira, viral girl, pero wala pang napatunayan.
DeleteTumpak. I am not a fan too pero marurunong pa sa producers eh. Bakit kaya hindi sila magproduce para kunin nilang judge yung gusto nila, pati na si direk ba masyadong pabibo.
DeleteExactly! The judges are not there to compete so why are they being judged as to how well they sing?
DeleteDi ba???? Beauty queens lang ba ang puede mag-judge sa beauty contest?
DeleteAnon 2:49, Simon worked for big recording companies in the past, he's a talent scout, and he's a music producer. He signed up Westlife in his recording company; and thus he was already a millionaire before American Idol made him a household name.
DeleteHndi nman 11:41 pro kaya unhappy ang mga tao kasi obvious n hndi magaling n singers ang 2 which questionable ang pagbigay ng mga comments kung sila mismo hndi nila maiapply s mga sarili nila. Also, what people want is to have qualified person who can help to produce a legit idol, hndi ung ultimo mga judges ay hirapan iangat ang track records nila
DeleteSimon Cowell is a talent manager and has a very good eye for talents. Gets mo? Just look up the talents he made successful.
DeleteAng insensitive nga. Di man lang ba niya naisip anong ma feefeel ng mga current judges towards him for saying that. Magkakilala pa nmn sila. Kasi lang hndi nkapasok mga bet nila puro na hanash online. Kong hndi nka pasok meaning di pa nila time yun. Kasi if it's their time kahit sino pang judge yan mkakapasok yan.
ReplyDeleteIts Not insensitive opinion niya yan ang mga natamaan talaga ang mga lomis. Sa buhay talaga whether you like it Or Not makakatanggap ka ng ganyan comments oo masakit but sympre pag sineryoso mo
DeleteYung isang comment sayo it depends sayo How you handle it If may point edi baguhin mo you change its For the better naman E.
But u and ur co fans are way too sensitive and insensitive at the same time.
DeleteSensitive because u cant accept any critique, even if it is deliver in a nice way and it is for the better of ur idol, u all treat it as bad and bash that person even if that person is way respected than ur idol.
Insenstive, associated with the one i said above, because u treat that person as if he/she didnt deserve to live. U treat them as if they are lowest to the lowest form. U degrading just for the sake of defending ur idol despite they only meant goodness and betterment.
So please, dont act as if u, your cofans, and your idols are the victims here
Really? So kahit na pangit, sige lang. Baba naman nang standards mo.
DeleteToxic fandom dami inaaway. Kung magaling lang kasi idols nila, di sila makakatanggap ng ganitong criticism from direk. Nako lomis, di pwedeng lahat ng pupuna sa idols niyo ggyerahin niyo. Sa industriyang to kakampi ang dapat hinahakot niyo, hindi kaaway.
ReplyDeletewalang fandom, halatang iisang tao ang poser at may ibat ibang accounts. Pls check the style of writing at ang mga time stamps magkakasunod. Wag kami!
DeleteBecause Simon Cowell is THE Simon Cowell. He was behind the discovery of Westlife, One Direction, Leona Lewis, Little Mix and Fifth Harmony. He really has the eye for those who have potential. Kumbaga may credibility na tlga siya bago isalang as a judge.
ReplyDeletePatawa naman kc c James at Moira!! Pero tyak naman na c Vice ang humatak kay James dhil pogi sya.. Regine has 2 STAY but d 3?? Has 2 b ousted..
ReplyDeleteAlways trending at nakakasabik yung magiging transformation ng mga nakapasok as they move to the next level. Love Always
ReplyDeleteExciting to, ang daming magagaling at super talented na nakapasok. Anjan c alyssa, yung winner ng bolt of talent, anak ni mau, wycopa champion, tnt grand finalist, etc
ReplyDeleteThe judges compliment each other. We love the show.
ReplyDeleteSunod sunod comments te 7:09? Di naman halatang ikaw din si 7:06 at 7:08
DeleteHahaha true 3:54. Sariling sikap si ate(7:09,7:06, at 7:08). Lumubog n ksi ang barko (or lubog n to begin with) at kailangan iangat ulit kungdi byebye career n
DeleteNot we. Ikaw lang isa.
DeleteSheesh what is up with netizens going nuts when anyone expresses free speech? Madness.
ReplyDeleteTapusin na dapat idol puro negativity yang show na yan
ReplyDeleteAminin natn mababa ang ang ratings ng Idol Philippines kumpara sa ibang franchise shows ng Abs. Mas mataas pa nga ratings nung Dance Show nila Gary V na consistent 30% kahit more on singing show mga Pinoy.
ReplyDeleteFor me, dapat may producer din dapat, yung marunong talaga tumingin ng potential ng talent. Real singers won’t be enough.
ReplyDeleteMay producer(james) but not qualified yet since he's a newbie who is also struggle to make a hit
DeleteI Find James Reid comments rehearsed. Yung alam na niya yung sasabihin sa each contestant makikita niya. Its coming from his mouth lang Not within him galing sa puso. He Just talk at Ma English kasi.... magaling siya dun.
ReplyDeletemay curse ata tong franchise na ito. pangatlong station na to ha
ReplyDeleteWala naman kayong magagawa kung ayaw niyo sa mga judges, at kahit pintasan niyo pa sila at ibash forever, hanggang dun na lang kayo. Sabi nga nung nag comment sa itaas , let the show to be finish atsaka kayo magrequest ng mga gusto niyo na judges. Bayad na yang mga judges na yang, too late for hanash.
ReplyDeleteToo late too to save their a**es 3:28. Last n nila ito at hndi n mauulit. Tinatapos (kung matatapos) for the sake of contract after all this is an international franchise
Deleteang importante napintasan namin sila sa mga kapalpakan nila.
DeleteMeron naman pero patatapusin muna yang season 1. Nakikinig din ang producers. Pero depende kung ok naman ang ratings.
Deletemalakas ang magagawa naming as audience, unang una marami kami. Next, sa amin nakasalalay ang success ng mga shows. Kaya tanggal yan pag hindi pa umayos. May kalalagyan.
DeleteWrong ka. Low ratings, walang nanonood = cancel na. Gets mo.
DeleteHahahahaha.....that means one season lang baks pag walang audience.
DeleteAko naman OK lang si James, maganda siya mag comment at ang mga sinasabi niya may substance, kaaliw naman si vice at regine, ang sarap ng mga tunog ng tawa nila. OK din naman ang mga comment. Except Moira parang laging inaantok, or tinatamad ang dating kapag nagsalita. Parang walang gana at kulang sa vitamins
ReplyDeleteSorry pero nag a aggree ako kay Direk Joey. And kelan pa naging kabastusan magsabi ng opinyon? Afterall, this is a TV SHOW. At lahat ng nakakapanuod entitled magbigay ng comment. Di naman below the belt yung sinabi ah? Sa true lang lol
ReplyDeletetrue, sa tagal na niyang direk Joey sa industriya alam niya ang importansya ng credibility as a star maker. Last time I checked, meron pa rin tayong Freedom of Speech.
DeleteKalurks! Pinoy Idol. From the world renowned American Idol,with Simon Cowell. Kaso yung Ph franchise naging waley puchu-puchu levels lol!
ReplyDeletePa-audition sana muna ng judges bago magpa-audition ng contestant. Lol.
ReplyDeletecheck na check! oo para hindi naman mga puchuhin.
DeleteMOrisette TALAGA Direk? Seryoso? Gary V lagi na lang
ReplyDeletetrots. as if naman very successful. puro hype naman. yes mataas ang range pero hindi genuine singer.
DeleteHater ka lang dahil Hindi nabanggit ang idol mo.
Delete8:48 Fan ka lang. But 12:47 is right, magaling na kung magaling si Moriseete, pero di rin sya magiging credible na judge.
DeleteMaganda sana kung ang line up ng judges is may dalawang legit singer, isang voice coach at isang magaling na record producer.
ReplyDeleteBad show, worst “judges” daw.
ReplyDeleteTama siya, All four are bad.
DeleteThese judges are no good. That’s too obvious.
ReplyDeleteKayo na lang mag judge, kayo magaling eh.
ReplyDeletesi moira na lang ang alisin, palitan ng mas maayos mag judge. kung aalisin si james, wala nang mababash na pogi. cheret.
ReplyDeleteAgree with ditching Moira and James - Regine delivers the 'icon' singer, Vice delivers the 'entertainment' factor, ewan ko kung ano yung kay James and Moira but they are both SUPER BORING.
ReplyDeletesana songwriting contest na lang. we need more original materials. daming magagaling na singers, puro covers lang naman at tiktok lol
ReplyDeleteThis show is just banking on negative publicity para makakuha ng ratings 😂😂😂
ReplyDeleteHorrible show, terrible judges. Enough said.
ReplyDelete