hindi ko kilala si luke and i played the video but didn't watch, ginawa ko lang background. nung narinig ko yung kumanta, i thought ay hindi makakapasok to. and true enough, nag No nga yung tatlo. i actually felt disappointed kay regine kasi bakit sya nag yes when clearly hindi maayos yung pagkakanta. i felt na hindi sya dapat kinuhang judge, parang di sya marunong.
Parang baliktad. Sya nga nakakita ng potential eh, yung 3 na walang K magjudge yung dapat sibakin. Kaya naman mafix yung mga problema kay Luke, need lang ng coaching.
Si regine pa talaga ang dapat hindi kinuhang judge? Kumpara mo naman kay moira na laging inaantok, kay vice na tumitingin sa panlabas na anyo at kay james na auto-tune naman kumanta lol. Walang wala naman sila kay regine when it comes to singing.
For sure na currupt ung tenga mo ng mga umuusong kantahan sa pinas... ok ung version ng kanta nya.. may soul di lng basta typical na kanta na biritan o palamigan ng boses.
I agree 12:56. Nung 2nd part of the song, it was grating to the ear, MY ear at least. I can't ignore the flats and he could get away with it singing reggae but I don't think he'd be able to do it singing another genre.
50-50 chance but still, he would have been given a chance just like the rest who were able to go to the next round based on "we'll give you another chance and see what else you can do" or "can you sing again, i want to hear you doing another syle of singing"
Maybe this is unpopular opinion, pero I don’t find this as Idol material as well. Then, again, ang daming so-so singers silang binigyan ng chance. This makes me want to question their credibility in terms of judging a singing competition. Hindi lang dito sa particular na nag audition na ito. I don’t think sobrang special or unique pero may potential sana, and Mas deserving IMHO, kaysa sa ibang pinasok, like ung girl who sung IDGAF or yung kumanta ng Roses.
I actually think na people are reacting furiously dahil maitim sya at hindi kagwapuhan. Had it been the other way around na nag-no ang judges sa pogi or maputi, hindi naman kayo magrereact ng ganyan ka-oa because aminin, hindi naman talaga kagandahan yung remdition nya noh.
ang problema kasi, maraming nakapasang so-so at generic sa audition so bakit hindi nila itry papasukin to. Dude clearly has the talents to musically arrange an RnB song into a reggae one
9:08 it’s their choice kung may nakita silang something na nagconvince sa kanila magbigay ng another chance. Kahit sa US Idol, may binibigyan den ng chance pero may mas magaling na hindi binigyan. At the end of the day, kung nag agree kayo na may flats and sharp, then there you go. Wag na magtaka bat hindi nakapasok.
Not 12:57AM, but ang problema dun is puro kuda lang alam ng iba pero parang di nagtratranslate sa actions, and if pagbabasihan nga ang result ng eleksyon e you'd question kung nasaan ba tong mga woke na to na kuda ng kuda.
No. Just no. May mga reggae or ska version na magandang pakinggan, but this isn’t of those. Bob Marley’s voice is pure soul and angst na tipong may pinaglalaban at dinadaan niya sa pagkanta and you will easily get magnetized by his voice. Si kuya hindi ko alam kung anong gustong patunayan.
Anon 1:12. Nope. Hindi bagay yung kanta sa reggae style nya. Minsan kasi dapat wag gagawa lng basta basta ng version. Yung kinanta nya full of emotion and dapat yun ang mangyari na iparating sa mga nakikinig. Kaya ang mangyari, hindi naramdaman ng mga judges yung performance nya.
madumi but Regine perfectly explained the essence of reggae genre. hindi mo kailangan maging malinis at maging super concise sa key, timing at vocals. yung rawness makes up reggae
Pumikit ako para mafeel ko yung kanta. Waley talaga. Out of tune na parang binalahura yung kanta sa totoo lang. I can’t even call his version reggae. Baka bumangon sa libingan niya sa Manong Bob. Hahaha
Kasi maayos naman un and it’s reggae. She said that in the video. Hater ka lang ba ni regine? The guy’s voice has quality. Ang kapal ng boses nya at ang linis ng head tone nya. Tulad din ng sinabi ni regine.
Anuveh guyz. Obviously pampalubag yung ni Reg. She knows by saying yes and giving kind words won't help him because the other judges already said no. So she said it anyway so the guy won't feel too bad. But really, it's a No for her.
Si James minsan naman may point, pero si Moira talaga. Kung ano sinabi ng mga nakaraan mag comment sakanya dun lang din nya kinukuha yung sinasabi nya.
This is why I find singing competitions absurd. Puro pa-“technical” but in real life, yung dating talaga yung tinatangkilik. Just look at famous singers like Selena Gomez, Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus, etc. Not perfect ang voice but catchy songs.
Nagpapa-compete pa sila, di naman sisikat after and people are not even overly critical with “techniques.” These competitions are for pure entertainment and to ridicule people, imo. Just don’t watch it. There’s no point.
let's not make this about his looks or color. hindi naman talaga yun ang reason why they voted No. hindi talaga maayos ang pagkakanta. even regine nga na nag yes, sinabi na marumi ang pagkakanta.
I agree, minsan sablay talaga ibang judges but this, well.. hindi naman din sya... let’s say hasa na to be the next “idol”. So bakit ang daming galit? Si Vice may fave syang reggae singer sa Tawag ng Tanghalan and sobrang galing talaga nun. I believe he wont say no kung nakikita talaga nyang may x-factor
Madaming galit kase feeling nila, naapi or na-discriminate yung contestant because of his looks. Kung maputi siguro si kuya o may itsura, hindi ganyan yang mga pa-woke people na yan. Lol.
May pagka Paolo Nutini yon boses nya, I guess hindi familiar yon ibang judges sa ganyan boses at style. Nadisappoint ako kay James, akala ko mageget nya yon style ni koyah.
There were times na they asked a contestant to sing another song para marinig nila kung ano ang sound sa ibang kanta. Why didn’t they ask Luke to do that? Pero iyong isang good looking guy, kilig na kilig si Moira at may pakindat kindat pa ng kilay sa contestant. Masyadong very transparent. Di kilos ng isang may asawa nang babae.
E yung perf na sinasabe mo nakulangan lang sila pero “wala namang mali”, e yung dito mismong si regine sinabe nya marame daw flats and what not. Ayun parang nakulangan/bitin lang walang impact.
I wanna say na baka dahil kanya kanyang taste, kaya di nakapasa sa ibang judges, pero honestly hinde ako nagalingan. Yung reggae sound nya para sakin hinde authentic, pilit. Yung voice na ginagamit nya sounds fake and forced na gawing jamaican sounding. Sorry, I really listened na walang tinginan sa video, pero hinde sya pleasant to listen to. I was rooting for him sa start kse ang ganda and naantig ako sa kwento ng buhay nya, but I was disappointed sa performance.
Opinion ko lang, just like may opinion din yung mga nag-isip na bias yung judges because of his looks and sobrang nagagalingan sa kanya.
Remember this is Idol franchise. Most likely they're looking for the total package meaning looks, talent and marketable in their first season (ignoring other versions) unlike in The Voice and TNT where your first step to get in is really your talent. Sure there have been not so good looking idol winners in the past but I guess their talents were exceptional and realistically aren't that much active anymore. Only Kelly and Carrie are still relevant with the exception of non-winner Jhud. I won't be surprised if he gets a No because his performance isn't exceptional.
Luke made the R&B song different, his own. Mahirap ang gagawin mong ibang genre ang original song pero he nailed it and it was catchy and fun. Yung sinasabing "marumi" pa can easily be ignored and is easily polished in the future performances. He deserved that chance. Buti pa ang The Voice. They didn't have to look at one's looks.
Hahahaha, natawa ako kay Moira magsalita, ganyan ba tlaga sya sa totoong buhay? First time ko sya narinig, napahalakhak ako. My god, bat ba to judge? 😂 Parang wlang substance.
Hindi malinis pagkakanta niya. He’s trying too hard to make it sound reggae but he failed. Wala din sa tono. And it’s not even about his looks nor his color.
Okay naman siya eh. Meron talagang style na ganun yung boses. Sayang. Maybe not enough to get the golden price but surely enough para sa golden ticket.
Voice alone maganda naman yung tone nya and he sounds good. What i like about him is hindi cookie cutter and confident mag freestyle and improv. Singing for me is not about being perfect and technical..boring kung ganun. You need to be at the moment and sing your heart out ala Whitney Houston
@2:21 AM - he wasn't having a Whitney moment, he was having an office party/talent show/team building videoke moment. Like what one comment here says, reggae didn't come naturally to him or at least not for the song he performed
It's very disappointing na hindi sila nag yes. Maganda naman ang boses ni Luke. Siguro hindi lang nila nagustuhan yung type of music kasi reggae, hindi sila ganun ka-open minded sa ibang klase ng kanta. The judges could have asked him to sing another song, another type of music, kung hindi nila gusto ang reggae.
Typical.. Hindi pa kasi open sa atin ang ibang genre basta mabirit ka at mataas boses mo. Lalo na kung may looks ofcourse pasok ka.. Unlike sa shows sa ibang bansa na talagang magkakaiba ung mga competitors.. Un lng..
Pansin ko Lang ang labanan Kung sino ang magiging Sikat Hindi ang pinaka magaling. It's all about kita. Malaki ang power ng ABS CBN para mahubog ang ating taste natin sa music.
I listened to it using it as a background, too. He may have some parts that needed polishing, but his overall performance and tone of voice is really good. Hence, I agree with Regine's judgment as he really has a potential. I watched another video judging another contestant, but they gave a chance to this girl even though di rin masyadong pulido ang pagkakanta niya. No wonder marami ang nagreact sa audition na ito kay Baylon coz I believe the netizens did see his potential as I did.
May boses naman siya kaya siguro napa-Yes si Regine but the way he sang the song is not good, parang pilit yung pagka-reggae niya, mas ok yata na R & B kinanta niya, parang mas bagay sa boses niya.
ba naman kasi. pag mag aaudition dapat nakapagpractice at galingan na parang pang finals na. kung nakitang madumi yong kinanta dapat tanggapin nyo. madami pang magaaudition sympre nahihirapan din ang judges pumili.
ang oa naman talaga ng iba. kung di nagustuhan ng judges dapat tanggapin nyo. kahit iba ibang genre pa ng kanta yan, kung malinis talaga ang pagkakanta ma yeyes yan. d kesyo "ay reggae singer cool/galing, dapat YES na yan" dapat paikutin mo yung judges kasi kung magaling ka yung charisma na din mapapansin syo. d nga raw malinis yung kinanta so tanggap2x rin diba? no sila so tanggapin nyo.
I agree with the rest of the judges. At that time pinipilit nyang gawing reggae yung kanta pero sadly hindi nya na achieve. Wrong choice of song and it seems na hindi rin natural sa kanya yung ganong genre.
Moira and James, andaming sinabi kala ko mag YES... plastic!!! kala mo naman ke gagaling...never watched kahit isang episode nitong palabas na to at sa FP lang ako nakakasagap ng balita... still prefer The Voice, legit judges with legit talent....
It's the judges take, he can join other contests baka andun ang swerte nya. The show could have been better if there were a different set of judges except for one.
As if namang iboboto ng mga nagmamarunong na memang bashers yan.. Fact is, hindi kayo ang judge, wala rin kayo sa lugar mag salita dahil mga pinapapanalo nyo eh ung mga may kwentong nakakaawa. Kaya hayaan nyo na yung desisyon, sila may trabaho nun, wag kayong manood kung ayaw nyo yung resulta.
Not to bandwagon or anything but this guy is really good at Reggae. It may not be the other judge's cup of tea but IDOL Ph should be objective di yung kung ano lang yung nagugustuhan mo. Pero siguro kasi they don't really look at talent alone, gusto din nila ng marketability and that's the sad thing about the business. Andaming talented artists sa Pilipinas but not all has the marketability to survive the industry.
Disclaimer: Marketability does not always equate to looks.
May masasabi at masasabi talaga ang viewers sa idol philippines di ba naman mga batikan judges nila well except kay regine. Imagine james reid saying you're not hitting the right notes when in fact sya nga d mahit ang tamang notes and minsan naka autotune pa.hahaha
sa totoo lng di namn deserve nung 2 judges pra maging judges. there are a lot of singers who deserve more. kaya iba talaga c abs, dun sa mas sikat, quantity over quality.
Pinasok nga nila yung kumanta ng IDGAF na maganda lang at wala naman ka special2x sa boses nun. Lam naman natin looks versus voice muna diyan lalo na si vice.
his audition wasn't that good kaya diko lam bat dami nagagalit, unang una wrong choice ng song, at hindi talaga pleasant pakinggan unlike ibang reegae artist na napapanuod ko sa tnt.. move on na, final na yung desisyon ng mga judges, pangit naman kung pabalikin pa ulit join nalang ulit next season..
I watched the video and the guy was off key at times. There was nothing distinct about his voice, his tone, his range. The most unique thing about his performance was his take on the song but even if it was, it was a song for chilling and not winning a singing competition. It's good to celebrate diversity pero just because naiiba ung genre nya - reggae - and he's not a conventional pretty boy doesn't mean he was exceptional. And sincerity in singing doesn't mean he's got soul. Wala talaga. If any, Regine's yes was a pity vote.
Agree with your observation. It was a good attempt at reggae but impressionable at most. My only beef is Moira. I hardly know her or her songs pero ganun ba talaga siya? She looks so out of place and so lethargic. She gives me then vibes that she'd rather be someplace else than there.
Ang importante, napaguusapan yung show. Hahaha. 3.3 million views na at 30k comments na salungat sa decision ng judges. Ang winner dito ay ang Idol PH at ABSCBN hahahaha HAIL CORPORATE
WTF to those people saying hes not that great, check out his youtube channel! akala nyo talaga ang gagaling nyo e talagang alam ni regine ang ginagawa nya. may nagsasabi pa tlgang pampalubag loob?? NO, hnd talaga magaling mag judge yung tatlo. Pinapanood ko IdolPH since nang start and ever since tlga hndi consistent yung tatlong yan sa pagjujudge. or at least si moira my aray pa pero si Vice?? si James?? so dissappointed
Remember when charice was rejected? The. She went abroad and got accepted, that's the only time they accepted her back in the Philippines. Same thing will happen here with Luke.
And Sandara Park. Though not Filipina, but the way she was treated sa Pinas before 2NE1 eh ginawa siyang katawa tawa & comedian. Ngayon naman... mga Pinoy talaga.
You would think na si James who’s all about changing OPM and being daring sa music would at least say YES to the potential. But nooooo... Ang gulo din.
THAT is the bad influence of trashy kpop, a music industry where the main criteria of choosing a SINGER is based on what they call VISUALS. Nahawa na kayo sa bulok na sistema ng bulok na kpop na yan that's why you turn down real and talented singers. Disgusting!
hindi ko kilala si luke and i played the video but didn't watch, ginawa ko lang background. nung narinig ko yung kumanta, i thought ay hindi makakapasok to. and true enough, nag No nga yung tatlo. i actually felt disappointed kay regine kasi bakit sya nag yes when clearly hindi maayos yung pagkakanta. i felt na hindi sya dapat kinuhang judge, parang di sya marunong.
ReplyDeleteParang baliktad. Sya nga nakakita ng potential eh, yung 3 na walang K magjudge yung dapat sibakin. Kaya naman mafix yung mga problema kay Luke, need lang ng coaching.
DeleteSi regine pa talaga ang dapat hindi kinuhang judge? Kumpara mo naman kay moira na laging inaantok, kay vice na tumitingin sa panlabas na anyo at kay james na auto-tune naman kumanta lol. Walang wala naman sila kay regine when it comes to singing.
DeleteFor sure na currupt ung tenga mo ng mga umuusong kantahan sa pinas... ok ung version ng kanta nya.. may soul di lng basta typical na kanta na biritan o palamigan ng boses.
DeleteSi Regine lang ang legit dun sa apat. It takes one to know one.
Delete@1:01 teh, idol to, not the voice. walang coach coach dito na merong taga ayos lol
DeleteKaya nagkaron pa ng uproar or baka patrend ng network/showPR na din mismo yang uproar dahil nag yes pa itong si Regine!
DeleteHindi ako marunong pagdating sa kung nasa tono or maganda ang boses pero kung sa Voice yan kumanta me iikot na chair para sa rendition niyang yun?
DeleteI agree 12:56. Nung 2nd part of the song, it was grating to the ear, MY ear at least. I can't ignore the flats and he could get away with it singing reggae but I don't think he'd be able to do it singing another genre.
Deletesiguro dapat sa the Voice yan sumali hindi sa idol , iba ang hinahanap nila sa idol.
DeleteMagaling syang kunanta at maganda boses,reggae nga eh baka hindi akam ng mga judges kung ano yun haha
Deleteang hinahanap nila ung bumibirit, pag magaling tumili, sumigar or bumirit, pasok yun ;)
DeleteBingi ba itong si Regine? Hindi maganda ang pagkakakanta nya kahit reggae. Nawala sa tono unang pasok pa lang.
DeleteThe REAL question is, had he gone through idol city, would you all have voted for him?
ReplyDelete50-50 chance but still, he would have been given a chance just like the rest who were able to go to the next round based on "we'll give you another chance and see what else you can do" or "can you sing again, i want to hear you doing another syle of singing"
DeleteExactly. Ang gagaling magkomento. Pero, bibilhin ba nila ang CD? Makikinig ba sila ng reggae at ska? And I agree, it's not that pulido.
Delete1:40 how do you know that reggae is the only genre that he does when he wasn't given a chance to prove his abilities and capability?
DeleteIf you have a sob story before joining, malaki chance mo talaga manalo. #sadtruth
DeleteMaybe this is unpopular opinion, pero I don’t find this as Idol material as well. Then, again, ang daming so-so singers silang binigyan ng chance. This makes me want to question their credibility in terms of judging a singing competition. Hindi lang dito sa particular na nag audition na ito. I don’t think sobrang special or unique pero may potential sana, and Mas deserving IMHO, kaysa sa ibang pinasok, like ung girl who sung IDGAF or yung kumanta ng Roses.
DeleteMas bagay sa boses nya yung mga Ray Charles o Nat King Cole songs
DeletePero pag puti yan pasok yan sa kanila
ReplyDeleteMagrereact din ba yung mga pa-woke na yan if the contestant is not black? Or if pogi si kuya?
DeleteI actually think na people are reacting furiously dahil maitim sya at hindi kagwapuhan. Had it been the other way around na nag-no ang judges sa pogi or maputi, hindi naman kayo magrereact ng ganyan ka-oa because aminin, hindi naman talaga kagandahan yung remdition nya noh.
DeleteAnon 1.44 sobrang agree ako sa sinabi mo
Deleteang problema kasi, maraming nakapasang so-so at generic sa audition so bakit hindi nila itry papasukin to. Dude clearly has the talents to musically arrange an RnB song into a reggae one
Delete9:08 it’s their choice kung may nakita silang something na nagconvince sa kanila magbigay ng another chance. Kahit sa US Idol, may binibigyan den ng chance pero may mas magaling na hindi binigyan. At the end of the day, kung nag agree kayo na may flats and sharp, then there you go. Wag na magtaka bat hindi nakapasok.
DeleteBingo! That’s the thing they have. Tisoy o Puti, pasok agad.
Deletena-disappoint din ako nung di siya nakapasok tapos may ipinapasok at binibigyan ng chance na pwedeng mag-improve daw. ang labo lang.
ReplyDeleteAng daming woke sa Pinas ano? Masyadong nauutilize ang freedom of speech. So ironic given the unofficial result of the 2019 election.
ReplyDeleteAnong problema dun?
DeleteNot 12:57AM, but ang problema dun is puro kuda lang alam ng iba pero parang di nagtratranslate sa actions, and if pagbabasihan nga ang result ng eleksyon e you'd question kung nasaan ba tong mga woke na to na kuda ng kuda.
DeleteNo. Just no. May mga reggae or ska version na magandang pakinggan, but this isn’t of those. Bob Marley’s voice is pure soul and angst na tipong may pinaglalaban at dinadaan niya sa pagkanta and you will easily get magnetized by his voice. Si kuya hindi ko alam kung anong gustong patunayan.
ReplyDeleteMaganda ung version nya actually..or baka na sanay ka nalng sa mga idol mong malamya o galit kung maka awit.
DeleteTama ka. Di magandang pakinggan ang version niya. Medyo madumo ng unti.
DeleteAnon 1:12. Nope. Hindi bagay yung kanta sa reggae style nya. Minsan kasi dapat wag gagawa lng basta basta ng version. Yung kinanta nya full of emotion and dapat yun ang mangyari na iparating sa mga nakikinig. Kaya ang mangyari, hindi naramdaman ng mga judges yung performance nya.
DeleteHindi naman kasi pang-reggae yung song choice nya. Maipilit lang. sana ibang song na lang yung ginawan nya ng reggae version.
Deletemadumi but Regine perfectly explained the essence of reggae genre. hindi mo kailangan maging malinis at maging super concise sa key, timing at vocals. yung rawness makes up reggae
DeleteTrue. Hindi sa madumi, it's more of kulang sa reggae vibe. Pilit na pilit.
DeleteOh well. Infairness to Regine. Very sensible mag judge. Hindi lang basta yes or no
ReplyDeleteHahahahaha, no. Malabo siya lagi.
DeletePumikit ako para mafeel ko yung kanta. Waley talaga. Out of tune na parang binalahura yung kanta sa totoo lang. I can’t even call his version reggae. Baka bumangon sa libingan niya sa Manong Bob. Hahaha
ReplyDeletelabo ni regine. dami raw flats and marumi yung pag kanta pero she said yes.
ReplyDeleteKasi maayos naman un and it’s reggae. She said that in the video. Hater ka lang ba ni regine? The guy’s voice has quality. Ang kapal ng boses nya at ang linis ng head tone nya. Tulad din ng sinabi ni regine.
DeleteBomalabs talaga! Malabo pa sa sabaw ng pusit itong si Regine!
DeleteAnuveh guyz. Obviously pampalubag yung ni Reg. She knows by saying yes and giving kind words won't help him because the other judges already said no. So she said it anyway so the guy won't feel too bad. But really, it's a No for her.
DeleteHindi naman talaga magaling? Iniba lang ung genre kagulo na kayo? Kahit di naman talaga magaling
ReplyDeleteTas porket di daw maputi at pogi. Hindi lang talaga magaling, PERIOD
DeleteDi din ako nagalingan sakanya. Dami lang feeling woke jusko nakikisakay lang
DeleteSi James minsan naman may point, pero si Moira talaga. Kung ano sinabi ng mga nakaraan mag comment sakanya dun lang din nya kinukuha yung sinasabi nya.
ReplyDeleteThis is why I find singing competitions absurd. Puro pa-“technical” but in real life, yung dating talaga yung tinatangkilik. Just look at famous singers like Selena Gomez, Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus, etc. Not perfect ang voice but catchy songs.
ReplyDeleteNagpapa-compete pa sila, di naman sisikat after and people are not even overly critical with “techniques.” These competitions are for pure entertainment and to ridicule people, imo. Just don’t watch it. There’s no point.
Miley cyruz is a great singer with a great voice. Ewan ko lang sa dalawang pang binaggit mo.
DeleteKasi Regine sees real talent. Puro looks lang hanap:(
ReplyDeletelet's not make this about his looks or color. hindi naman talaga yun ang reason why they voted No. hindi talaga maayos ang pagkakanta. even regine nga na nag yes, sinabi na marumi ang pagkakanta.
DeleteWrong choice of song kase. Iconic yung kanta, mahirap baliin. Make or break, ika nga. Oh well, baka may wild card nman.. sali na lang ulit
ReplyDeleteI agree, minsan sablay talaga ibang judges but this, well.. hindi naman din sya... let’s say hasa na to be the next “idol”. So bakit ang daming galit? Si Vice may fave syang reggae singer sa Tawag ng Tanghalan and sobrang galing talaga nun. I believe he wont say no kung nakikita talaga nyang may x-factor
ReplyDeleteMadaming galit kase feeling nila, naapi or na-discriminate yung contestant because of his looks. Kung maputi siguro si kuya o may itsura, hindi ganyan yang mga pa-woke people na yan. Lol.
Deletewhat did you mean when you said "hindi naman din sya HASA to be the next idol"?
DeleteMay pagka Paolo Nutini yon boses nya, I guess hindi familiar yon ibang judges sa ganyan boses at style. Nadisappoint ako kay James, akala ko mageget nya yon style ni koyah.
ReplyDelete90 percent good looks, 10 percent talent. Si James Reid yun. Nagtaka pa kayo na hindi sila marunong pumili ng talented singers. 🙄
ReplyDeleteSi James na naging jusge eh sobrang dami sa network nila ang higit na mas magiling sa kanya sa singing. Basura talaga ang ph idol na yan. Kaloka.
DeleteWow really, James is not talented? Singer, songwriter, producer. He is better in music than acting.
DeleteI saw his audition. Ang gulo ng pagkanta niya. Naawa lang si Regine that's why she said yes.
ReplyDeleteThere were times na they asked a contestant to sing another song para marinig nila kung ano ang sound sa ibang kanta. Why didn’t they ask Luke to do that? Pero iyong isang good looking guy, kilig na kilig si Moira at may pakindat kindat pa ng kilay sa contestant. Masyadong very transparent. Di kilos ng isang may asawa nang babae.
ReplyDeleteE yung perf na sinasabe mo nakulangan lang sila pero “wala namang mali”, e yung dito mismong si regine sinabe nya marame daw flats and what not. Ayun parang nakulangan/bitin lang walang impact.
DeleteI wanna say na baka dahil kanya kanyang taste, kaya di nakapasa sa ibang judges, pero honestly hinde ako nagalingan. Yung reggae sound nya para sakin hinde authentic, pilit. Yung voice na ginagamit nya sounds fake and forced na gawing jamaican sounding. Sorry, I really listened na walang tinginan sa video, pero hinde sya pleasant to listen to. I was rooting for him sa start kse ang ganda and naantig ako sa kwento ng buhay nya, but I was disappointed sa performance.
ReplyDeleteOpinion ko lang, just like may opinion din yung mga nag-isip na bias yung judges because of his looks and sobrang nagagalingan sa kanya.
Remember this is Idol franchise. Most likely they're looking for the total package meaning looks, talent and marketable in their first season (ignoring other versions) unlike in The Voice and TNT where your first step to get in is really your talent. Sure there have been not so good looking idol winners in the past but I guess their talents were exceptional and realistically aren't that much active anymore. Only Kelly and Carrie are still relevant with the exception of non-winner Jhud. I won't be surprised if he gets a No because his performance isn't exceptional.
ReplyDeleteTatlong seasons na ang pinoy idol from different networks. Walang sumikat. Ang sikat dito Yung walang talent.
DeleteRegine really know how to play the ‘game’.
ReplyDeleteLuke made the R&B song different, his own. Mahirap ang gagawin mong ibang genre ang original song pero he nailed it and it was catchy and fun. Yung sinasabing "marumi" pa can easily be ignored and is easily polished in the future performances. He deserved that chance. Buti pa ang The Voice. They didn't have to look at one's looks.
ReplyDeleteHahahaha, natawa ako kay Moira magsalita, ganyan ba tlaga sya sa totoong buhay? First time ko sya narinig, napahalakhak ako. My god, bat ba to judge? 😂 Parang wlang substance.
ReplyDeletetawa din ako dun sa "Favorite ko talaga yang reggae... ang lalim pero may kulang" and Regine was like hmmm. Ano daw Moira?
DeleteMahilig gumamit ng "potential" ang judges . What does their word "potential" apply to, looks or Voice?
ReplyDeleteHindi malinis pagkakanta niya. He’s trying too hard to make it sound reggae but he failed. Wala din sa tono. And it’s not even about his looks nor his color.
ReplyDeleteOkay naman siya eh. Meron talagang style na ganun yung boses. Sayang. Maybe not enough to get the golden price but surely enough para sa golden ticket.
ReplyDeleteVoice alone maganda naman yung tone nya and he sounds good. What i like about him is hindi cookie cutter and confident mag freestyle and improv. Singing for me is not about being perfect and technical..boring kung ganun. You need to be at the moment and sing your heart out ala Whitney Houston
ReplyDelete@2:21 AM - he wasn't having a Whitney moment, he was having an office party/talent show/team building videoke moment. Like what one comment here says, reggae didn't come naturally to him or at least not for the song he performed
DeleteI watched it. Parang hindi naman sya ganun kagaling para makapasok.
ReplyDeletePero aminin mas magaling PA to sa mga nakuhang na merong looks di ba? Nakakaloka
DeleteIt's very disappointing na hindi sila nag yes. Maganda naman ang boses ni Luke. Siguro hindi lang nila nagustuhan yung type of music kasi reggae, hindi sila ganun ka-open minded sa ibang klase ng kanta. The judges could have asked him to sing another song, another type of music, kung hindi nila gusto ang reggae.
ReplyDeleteTypical Pinoy. Nagpa-platinum ang mga artistang singer na panget ang boses. Sa botohan naman ieelect naman mga taong
ReplyDeleteTypical.. Hindi pa kasi open sa atin ang ibang genre basta mabirit ka at mataas boses mo. Lalo na kung may looks ofcourse pasok ka.. Unlike sa shows sa ibang bansa na talagang magkakaiba ung mga competitors.. Un lng..
ReplyDeletePansin ko Lang ang labanan Kung sino ang magiging Sikat Hindi ang pinaka magaling. It's all about kita. Malaki ang power ng ABS CBN para mahubog ang ating taste natin sa music.
ReplyDeleteI listened to it using it as a background, too. He may have some parts that needed polishing, but his overall performance and tone of voice is really good. Hence, I agree with Regine's judgment as he really has a potential. I watched another video judging another contestant, but they gave a chance to this girl even though di rin masyadong pulido ang pagkakanta niya. No wonder marami ang nagreact sa audition na ito kay Baylon coz I believe the netizens did see his potential as I did.
ReplyDeleteMay boses naman siya kaya siguro napa-Yes si Regine but the way he sang the song is not good, parang pilit yung pagka-reggae niya, mas ok yata na R & B kinanta niya, parang mas bagay sa boses niya.
ReplyDeleteba naman kasi. pag mag aaudition dapat nakapagpractice at galingan na parang pang finals na. kung nakitang madumi yong kinanta dapat tanggapin nyo. madami pang magaaudition sympre nahihirapan din ang judges pumili.
ReplyDeleteang oa naman talaga ng iba. kung di nagustuhan ng judges dapat tanggapin nyo. kahit iba ibang genre pa ng kanta yan, kung malinis talaga ang pagkakanta ma yeyes yan. d kesyo "ay reggae singer cool/galing, dapat YES na yan" dapat paikutin mo yung judges kasi kung magaling ka yung charisma na din mapapansin syo. d nga raw malinis yung kinanta so tanggap2x rin diba? no sila so tanggapin nyo.
ReplyDeleteTRUE
DeletePakibalik na po ng The Voice
ReplyDeleteSi Regine lang naman talaga ang legit diyan jusko
ReplyDeleteHindi siya kasi mass appeal, walang dating, sintunado at wala sa tiyempo ang pagkanta. Trying hard magpaka reggae
ReplyDeleteObviously Hindi pang competition ang dating niya lalo na yung kinanta niya. Walang impact sa audience lalo na sa judge.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the rest of the judges. At that time pinipilit nyang gawing reggae yung kanta pero sadly hindi nya na achieve. Wrong choice of song and it seems na hindi rin natural sa kanya yung ganong genre.
ReplyDeleteIt's also a No for me.
ReplyDeleteAng dami kasing pabebe na binigyan ng ticket sa next round ng Idol so why not give this guy a chance as well?
ReplyDeleteTrue. Yan ang issue eh.
DeleteMoira and James, andaming sinabi kala ko mag YES... plastic!!! kala mo naman ke gagaling...never watched kahit isang episode nitong palabas na to at sa FP lang ako nakakasagap ng balita... still prefer The Voice, legit judges with legit talent....
ReplyDeleteReggae na ba yun? Parang nagtano lang na mabilis magsalita. May basis naman pala ung tatlong nag-No.
ReplyDeleteSabaw Yung talking nag-NO esp Moira and james
DeleteThe show is not worth watching. Maglinis na lang tayo ng bahay kesa panoorin ang palpak na show na ito.
ReplyDeleteIt's the judges take, he can join other contests baka andun ang swerte nya. The show could have been better if there were a different set of judges except for one.
ReplyDeletebecause of this backlash, may wildcard yan, papasok din yan! haha
ReplyDeleteMay wildcard round naman talaga ang Idol, applicable across all their franchises.
DeleteBaka may pa WILDCARD yan mga yan kaya nag NO clang tatlo n judge...
ReplyDeleteHindi naman talaga ganun kagaling siya kumanta. Parang pilit niyang ginagawa yung pagka reggae style niya. Pero talagang walang dating. My opinion.
ReplyDeleteBaduy ng contest na 'to.
ReplyDeleteAs if namang iboboto ng mga nagmamarunong na memang bashers yan.. Fact is, hindi kayo ang judge, wala rin kayo sa lugar mag salita dahil mga pinapapanalo nyo eh ung mga may kwentong nakakaawa. Kaya hayaan nyo na yung desisyon, sila may trabaho nun, wag kayong manood kung ayaw nyo yung resulta.
ReplyDeleteNot to bandwagon or anything but this guy is really good at Reggae. It may not be the other judge's cup of tea but IDOL Ph should be objective di yung kung ano lang yung nagugustuhan mo. Pero siguro kasi they don't really look at talent alone, gusto din nila ng marketability and that's the sad thing about the business. Andaming talented artists sa Pilipinas but not all has the marketability to survive the industry.
ReplyDeleteDisclaimer: Marketability does not always equate to looks.
Dapat kasi binigyan ng chance. Bakit yung cosplayer, binigyan ng chance?
ReplyDeleteJusko si Regine lang naman ang legit singer diyan Yung tatlo waley lol
ReplyDeleteMay masasabi at masasabi talaga ang viewers sa idol philippines di ba naman mga batikan judges nila well except kay regine. Imagine james reid saying you're not hitting the right notes when in fact sya nga d mahit ang tamang notes and minsan naka autotune pa.hahaha
ReplyDeleteTAMA.. NAGULAT NGA TLGA AKO NAGING JUDGE SYA...
DeleteThis is true. At hingal nga yan pag kumakanta ng live eu
DeleteWRONG CHOICE LNG NG SONG, PRANG HE TRIED SO HARD NA MAGING REGGAE YON SONG, PERO GIVEN NAMAN NA MAY BOSES SYA. MAS
DeleteBAGAY SA KNYA R&B.
sa totoo lng di namn deserve nung 2 judges pra maging judges. there are a lot of singers who deserve more. kaya iba talaga c abs, dun sa mas sikat, quantity over quality.
ReplyDeletePinasok nga nila yung kumanta ng IDGAF na maganda lang at wala naman ka special2x sa boses nun. Lam naman natin looks versus voice muna diyan lalo na si vice.
ReplyDeleteNaku, naku, naku. I smell the wildcards. Haha
ReplyDeletehis audition wasn't that good kaya diko lam bat dami nagagalit, unang una wrong choice ng song, at hindi talaga pleasant pakinggan unlike ibang reegae artist na napapanuod ko sa tnt.. move on na, final na yung desisyon ng mga judges, pangit naman kung pabalikin pa ulit join nalang ulit next season..
ReplyDeleteI watched the video and the guy was off key at times. There was nothing distinct about his voice, his tone, his range. The most unique thing about his performance was his take on the song but even if it was, it was a song for chilling and not winning a singing competition. It's good to celebrate diversity pero just because naiiba ung genre nya - reggae - and he's not a conventional pretty boy doesn't mean he was exceptional. And sincerity in singing doesn't mean he's got soul. Wala talaga. If any, Regine's yes was a pity vote.
ReplyDeleteAgree with your observation. It was a good attempt at reggae but impressionable at most. My only beef is Moira. I hardly know her or her songs pero ganun ba talaga siya? She looks so out of place and so lethargic. She gives me then vibes that she'd rather be someplace else than there.
DeleteNo such as pity vote for Regine. Kung di talaga nila type, makutong na NO sila lahat. Regine heard potential kaya siya nagYES
DeleteAng importante, napaguusapan yung show. Hahaha. 3.3 million views na at 30k comments na salungat sa decision ng judges. Ang winner dito ay ang Idol PH at ABSCBN hahahaha HAIL CORPORATE
DeleteI am 3:54pm. Sorry po. Pero I agree wala talaga sya sa tune. I listen sa lahat ng genre/music na gusto ko but wla tlga sya. Voice is ok tbh.
ReplyDeleteHe wasn’t that great so I’m not surprised they said No!
ReplyDeleteThe judges do not rely on voice alone.
ReplyDeleteWTF to those people saying hes not that great, check out his youtube channel! akala nyo talaga ang gagaling nyo e talagang alam ni regine ang ginagawa nya. may nagsasabi pa tlgang pampalubag loob?? NO, hnd talaga magaling mag judge yung tatlo. Pinapanood ko IdolPH since nang start and ever since tlga hndi consistent yung tatlong yan sa pagjujudge. or at least si moira my aray pa pero si Vice?? si James?? so dissappointed
ReplyDeletePuro bandwagon comments na naman. Sa totoo lang hindi naman kasi naghanda yung contestant. Kita naman sa performance.
ReplyDeletePinas kasi, napakahina nang “judges daw”.
ReplyDeleteI’m surprised there are people watching that show. It’s horrible because of the judges. They know nothing talaga.
ReplyDeleteRemember when charice was rejected? The. She went abroad and got accepted, that's the only time they accepted her back in the Philippines. Same thing will happen here with Luke.
ReplyDeleteAnd Sandara Park. Though not Filipina, but the way she was treated sa Pinas before 2NE1 eh ginawa siyang katawa tawa & comedian. Ngayon naman... mga Pinoy talaga.
DeleteNo wala naman talaga siyang dating to be on idol ph. Boses walang wow factor. Kaya no talaga
ReplyDeleteYou would think na si James who’s all about changing OPM and being daring sa music would at least say YES to the potential. But nooooo... Ang gulo din.
ReplyDeleteTHAT is the bad influence of trashy kpop, a music industry where the main criteria of choosing a SINGER is based on what they call VISUALS. Nahawa na kayo sa bulok na sistema ng bulok na kpop na yan that's why you turn down real and talented singers. Disgusting!
ReplyDeleteTama din na hindi rin siya nakapasa sa audition lumabas kase ang tunay niyang ugali na mayabang na wala pa nga siyang narating.
ReplyDeleteMadaming gustong mag judge dito. Di kayo na lang ang judge
ReplyDelete