Yung wording lang ni VG di ko nagustuhan sa pagjudge dun sa Luke. Pero di tin talaga siya papasa hinaype lang masyado ng mga tao yung pagkakajudge sa kanya. Ang daming off key ng lolo mo. At kahit pa sabi nga ni Regine parang nagkukwento lang daw ang reggae, try nila kantahin ang One Day or songs ni Bob Marley na di madadaan sa birut. Tingnan natin kung mabigyan nilang hustisya.
1:09, maka bash lang, Luke wasn't that great at all. May mga off tone din siya. Hindi naman charity ang pag pasok sa idol. You have to earn and deserve it.
James okay ka Lang? Alam ko pogi ka sa paningin ng ibang Tao pero boy, you ain’t a good singer at all.... you write songs naman pero ang babaw. Hinde ka si Justin Timberlake na May doctorate degree na ikaw anu ? As if May total package ka.
Justin Timberlake’s doctorate’s degree is HONORARY. He got it because he’s a celebrity. He didn’t actually go to school, like most people do, and busted their butt to receive it. 🙄
Hindi naman lahat ng binigyan nila ng Golden ticket eh total package or may looks. But Luke is one of the few na may artistry talaga. Yung iba marunong lang kumanta but that's it, bilang sa isang kamay yung magaling at may dating. Tsk
you don't makes sense. Even in idol US looks is important to make it even in auditions, without it you must have a killer voice or an outstanding personality
napanood ko yung audition clip nya at hindi rin ako nagalingan. makalat talaga at need more practice pa talaga. di ko lang mavoice out yung thoughts ko sa socmed kasi baka mabash din ako e di pa naman ako singer. isa lang akong casual viewer hahahaha.
anyway, i personally think na tama lang yung no nila vice kay luke this time. pwede pa naman bumalik next time. nag yes siguro si regine kasi may room for improvement naman talaga.
Agree ako dyan cyst. Andami nagshare sa fb na sayang daw ang talent blah blah blah tas binabash yung 3 judges so I was expecting magaling talaga si Luke. Pag nood ko, ano ba miski ako No siya for me. He has potential but the song choice was very wrong for his style of singing. It was all over the place basta naguluhan Lang ako. And narealize ko bakit pinaglalaban ng marami si Luke eh dahil may sad background siya. Alam niyo na naman dito awa is greater than talent lol.
Same opinion. And ang song choice talaga, sablay. Sabihin na nating sige pwede naman yung r&b gawing reggae, pero masyado syang nagstick sa original harmony at tempo, sana inayos nya ng tama kung irereggae nya
Me too sis! di ko nagustuhan yung rendition :( Ang gulo pakinggan di gaya ng mga reggae songs na napapakinggan ko na napapaindak ako. Sa kanya napapangiwi ako. Sorry this is just my opinion. I also saw his tweet with regards sa di pagkapasa sa Idol. ang yabang ng dating tss.
YUNG NGA BAKS EH! HINDI KA SINGER SO INVALID ANG OPINION MO. NAGALINGAN AKO KAY LUKE. SINGER AKO. SINONG MAS VALID ANG OPINION SA ATIN? MARAMI RIN AKONG FRIENDS NA SINGERS NA HUMAHANGA KAY LUKE.
So kawawa naman pala talaga yung walang looks pero may talent? Dapat wag na sila sumali sa idol oh. Sa the voice nalang. At least dub una palang boses lang talaga ng pinapakinggan. Tho i have to admit, hindi nakaka wow yung performance nung Luke. Sa totoo lang
Sino ba ang relevant ngayon ng contest winners? Di ba yung mga may talent and looks din? Pag hindi okay yung looks, mga 1 or 2 years, laos na. So dapat from the start, hanapin yung sisikat ng matagalan.
sila ang mga judges so sila ang may say. kayo na lkang umupo sa upuan nila para malaman nyo kkung gaano kahuhusay mga ibang contestants at kung gaano kahirap maging hurado
Not polished pa 'yung Luke. Pinakinggan ko lang 'yan. Di ako nanood kasi may ginagawa ako. Compare kay Koko ng The Voice, layo ng quality. But the potential is there.
Sabihin natin hindi malinis pagkanta ni Luke. Pero medyo positive kasi mga comments ng judges tapos biglang "no." Kasi nga hindi siya good looking. Yung si ate maganda na parang sintunado (Shai ba name nun? I forgot eh) na kumanta ng IDGAF, napa yes ang judges kahit na yung reaction nila ay napapailing sila. In general, mas pabor talaga ang mga tao sa maganda/gwapo. Example: BlackPink. Hindi naman kagalingan kumanta pero may stage presence at magaling mag perform. Ganun talaga. Maganda kasi. Eye candy.
yung blackpink wala ngang stage presence doon. magaling lang mag-perform at may good looks. pero kung iko-compare mo sa ibang idols na legend ay walang-wala sila.
sana inamin niya na lang hindi ganun kalinis ang rendition ng tao kesa dun sa "magaling siya pero total package ang hanap", ang lumalabas tuloy mas matimbang ang looks kesa sa talent. so sa mga chaka diyan wag na daw kayong mag audition kesohadang kaboses niyo si jlo or bruno mars hindi rin kayo tatanggapin.
Obviously, some people are just using Luke's performance to bash James. Hindi naman talaga kagalingan si Luke, hindi pulido ang performance. Maybe, with more practice, he can come back again.
That’s why the voice way is better.... they don’t look sa looks the Tao. Ewan ko ba hinde na ganun ka sikat ang idol sa ibang bansa bakit kinuha panito ng abs? Diba wala na American idol ngayon?
Per Simon Cowell, original American Idol judge, looks do matter. He was very upfront about that when rejecting talented hopefuls. The image is of an Idol, not just a good singer.
So what about people like Lewis Capaldi, James Bay, Ed Sheeran, Billie Eilish, members of bands like Bombay Bicycle Club and Foster the People? They aren’t considered conventionally attractive. Yet they make far better music and are more successful than any judge on any Filipino singing contest.
Aminin na naten. Mga Pinoy mahilig Sa guapo at magaganda. Kaya ung iba dito mema lang na kunware they’re after the talent not the looks c’mon people job haunting nga Dapat May pleasing personality eh Sa entertainment pa kaya? Na pag nde guapo nde pinapansin🙄 pinanood ko ung audition video nya nde din naman talaga magaling. Tho I appreciate reggae song cause I have been to Jamaica Pero nde ko sya naappreciate. Nde ako singer Pero I’m a listener. Not a fan of the judges too actually isa ako Sa mga naloka Bakit kasama ung Tatlo as judges haha.
May comment din ako dito sa judges eh. Pag nmimili sila minsan sasabihin “i want to give you a chance so its a yes for me” tapos sasabihin total package hinahanap.
Hindi naman masyado magaling yung luke, eh kung tingin nila hindi rin aabot sa ibang rounds why still give a chance, sayang lang ang slot sa iba na mas deserving. Masyado naman kasi impressed agad yun iba nadaan lang sa growl hahaha
Pwede ba, tama na yung pwede na, dapat laging pwedeng-pwede. The judges are looking for total package nga e, hindi yung pwede na. Tinataasan na nga nila standards nila sa pagpili, dami nyong reklamo na hindi fair.
Idol eh. Hindi lang dpat idol sa boses. Tanggapin na natin na pag may itsura ka plus point tlga. Wag nag pa hypocrite na kesho magaling keme. Eh mrami din nmn magaling na may itsura. Kahit ako ayokong nanood ng performer na di ma itsura. Magandang pakinggan sa spotify pro di ko panonoorin.
En sa un Ang gusto nya ano magagawa nyo..as if nman tatangkilikin nyo khit wlang looks. bkit ung ibsng singer na magaling kumanta bkit di mbigyan Ng break at hndi mpasikat ksi nga hndi complete package ung iba dito ipokrito din eh kunwari ung talent daw sus!..
Ang oa lang kasi masyado sa iba lalo na sa looks nung tao. Hindi naman sya kinawawa at wala naman nilait sa itsura nya. Its just sa isang comepetition may nanalo at natatalo talaga. Para naman katapusan na ng mundo kung d sya makuha. 🙄
Very unprofessional! Hindi niya kailangan i-explain kung bakit ligwak ang ibang contestants. Saka paano siya sure na agree ang lahat sa final 12 na kasali? E sa pagiging judge nga niya di agree lahat.
Haha nakakatawa yung mga nagrarant. Eh may mga di kagandahan diyan na singer na may magagandang boses naman pero di sinuportahan. Ending may mga itsura pa rin yung iniidolo. Sorry kung di siya nakuha. Hindi pa naman katapusan ng buhay niya. Ibig sabihin lang non di pa niya time.
James is good as a judge in idol he knows what he is talking about. Sa tutoo lang wala naman talagang wow factor yung Luke para ipasa nila. He has a voice but really nothing special. Kaya I agree with all three judges.
Not a fan of anyone but come'on! Listen Kokoi's reggae vs this Luke! Tong mga to di lang tinanggap ginawa na issue. Kayo lang naman tong nagpapalaki. E di naman talaga magaling yung Luke. E nagkataon, di kayo judge so sorry!
Aha, so you're bringing up Kokoi eh dito nga mismo sa website na eto maraming nag bash kay Kokoi noon dahil reggae lang daw ang alam kantahin. So dahil hindi niyo trip si Luke ico-compare niyo siya sa mga sobrang tagal nang nagpe-perform. Like Kokoi matagal nang nagpeperform sa Boracay bago sumali sa The Voice. Nyahahahaha! People talaga. Makakalimutin kayo kung sobra niyong nilait si Kokoi noon. Hahaha! Hypocrites!
His piece wasnt that good! I dont know san galing tong rebulusyon na toh. He didnt fit the bill..PERIOD. James isnt a bad judge either, hes one of the sensible ones.
umay na sa issue na 'to. Move on na people. hindi naman nilait o kinawawa ang looks nya. yung total package na sinasabi kasi isang genre lang ang kaya nyang kantahin which is reggae. hindi naman reggae idol philippines ang title ng show. dapat kahit anong genre kaya mo kantahin. hindi rin lahat trip ang reggae. d sila nagfofocus sa isa lang.
I agree with James, lalo na yung company niya mismo (Careless Manila INC.) kung saan siya ang owner naghahanap ng new talent at recording artists, of course kukunin mo total packages.
Kelly Clarkson won the first Idol competition and many followed who didn't have the superstar manufactured look so bottomline, it's still about the talent AND charisma. In saying that, I wasn't that impressed with Luke (or maybe the build up let me down) BUT I have to agree that they let in lesser talents with mediocre voices, no musicality nor artistry.
This is very well said. I do believe in James and Regine’s capabilities as judges, Vice is ok, Moira not so much. but based on Luke’s audition, I trust James on this one.
James is not that good as a judge (others would say di qualified) but Luke is not that good as a singer, too.
I love reggae music but I have to agree with Regine na kalat yung arrangement nya. Akala ko sobrang galing kasi maraming nag reklamo but Luke's rendition was a mess. He could sing but he murdered the song. Yun lang.
Luke baylon is a good singer, for me wrong song choice di kc bagay ung song na ginawan nia ng reggae beat.. di porket nag reggae na magaling and dapat pasok agad.. timing is everything..
Watch and you'll see that James is actually making a lot of sense and he is able to articulate his thoughts well. And this reggae singer is not even that good. Watch all the videos in Youtube and James is right, you'll know why this reggae dude did not make it. His rendition was shaky, out of tempo, and there is really a lot of missed notes. Let's just be objective here. And if you're saying he should get plus points for soul, you have not yet seen the other contenders.
what do you mean bytotal package? magaling kumanta, guapo at maganda? para pdeng pang artista? Pinoy Idol yan, singer ang hinahanap jan despite the looks! James guapo ka, pero di ka nababagay maging judge ng isang prestigious singing competition gaya nito!
Ang problema, how can you find the “total package” from one audition? Hindi ba dapat binibigyan muna ng chance to find out if meron pang ibubuga? So kung hindi looks yung kasama sa “total package”, ano? Typical ABSCBN freezer factory. Lol.
This only proves na mas magaling na judge si James kay Regine hahaha. He judged rightfully. Kaya yung mga nagsasabing di bagay si James sa Idol, ano kayo ngayon di ba agree din kayo sa kanya
in fairness sa 4 na judges, si R lang talaga ung may K pero sya pinakawalang kwenta magjudge at comment... best singer doesnt equate to best judging...
This show is so lame.
ReplyDeleteBec of the judges
DeleteJudges ka dyan. Kayo lang ang may ayaw, mas madaming may gusto. Yang Moira lang ang dapat palitan
DeleteAnd James and vice.
DeleteAng ingay hahahahaha....
ReplyDeleteReacting to the netizens-- ah, bothered sya kasi trot. Besides, the "total package" includes one's looks.
ReplyDeletewe know naman dapat maganda at gwapo
ReplyDeletekahit hindi maganda o gwapo basta may dating.
DeleteHindi naman talaga total package si Luke sa totoo lang
ReplyDeleteTrue. He's not even that good. Di nya matanggap
DeleteSame as james and moira pero naging judge sila
Delete1:19 kasi may narating at naabot na sila sa industriya.
DeleteTotal package naman si James at Moira. They can sing and write music. They have charm kaya nga sikat sila. Bitter lang kayo talaga.
Delete1:19am, true. James is not even tall. Moira not sexy. Pero they are singers rin. Anong total package nila? Alangan namang appeal? Wala naman.
DeleteJames was a revelation as a judge here. On point palagi, walang paliguy-ligoy. Si Moira...nevermind.
Deleteahm, James can dance and sing and can produce good music. Moira can write hits. not total package?
Deleteano beauty contest or talent competition? ano ba talaga
DeleteWala naman kasi alam sa music tas naging judge ng isa music show hahahaha
DeleteAlam naman nating lahat na kinuha lang si James at vice para panghatak ng viewers
1:47 di naman ganun kalayo narating nila asus
DeleteYung wording lang ni VG di ko nagustuhan sa pagjudge dun sa Luke. Pero di tin talaga siya papasa hinaype lang masyado ng mga tao yung pagkakajudge sa kanya. Ang daming off key ng lolo mo. At kahit pa sabi nga ni Regine parang nagkukwento lang daw ang reggae, try nila kantahin ang One Day or songs ni Bob Marley na di madadaan sa birut. Tingnan natin kung mabigyan nilang hustisya.
DeleteLuke isnt a total package but he deserveda YES. Porket d nag drama ata nagpilit mag comedy or magpapansin, NO na agad.
Delete2:00 kahit sino naman marunong magsulat ng kanta swerte lang talaga sila kasi na overhype sila. lol
DeleteTotoo. Hindi talaga magaling si Luke.
DeleteA basta yung isa niyong kasama hindi rin Idol Philippines judge material. Pwede bang ma vote out din yun?
ReplyDeleteI agree, nakakaantok yung isa sa mga judges hindi karapat dapat maging judge.
DeletePalitan na sana yang Moira.
DeleteSame with James, Regine lang talaga ang legit diyan lol
DeleteJames is surprisingly good
DeleteLuke have the voice, but not so with the looks
ReplyDeleteJames have the looks, but not so with the voice
Oops
At sino ba nag sabi na not so with the looks?
Delete1:09, maka bash lang, Luke wasn't that great at all. May mga off tone din siya. Hindi naman charity ang pag pasok sa idol. You have to earn and deserve it.
DeleteWho told tou Luke isn’t cute?
Delete1:58 kailangan pa bang ipagdildilan eh halata naman. wag kang maang maangan diyan as if hindi mo nafi-feel yung gusto niyang ipahiwatig.
DeleteKahit sa voice wala si Luke. Anobeeey.
Delete3:16 ah tlga sige check mo s youtube ng malaman mo.
Deletelets get over it. remember candice glover got rejected in Idol to but came back big time.
ReplyDeleteJames okay ka Lang? Alam ko pogi ka sa paningin ng ibang Tao pero boy, you ain’t a good singer at all.... you write songs naman pero ang babaw. Hinde ka si Justin Timberlake na May doctorate degree na ikaw anu ? As if May total package ka.
ReplyDeleteJustin Timberlake’s doctorate’s degree is HONORARY. He got it because he’s a celebrity. He didn’t actually go to school, like most people do, and busted their butt to receive it. 🙄
DeleteAng bitter mo sobra
DeleteHe is not in the contest.
DeleteHindi naman lahat ng binigyan nila ng Golden ticket eh total package or may looks. But Luke is one of the few na may artistry talaga. Yung iba marunong lang kumanta but that's it, bilang sa isang kamay yung magaling at may dating. Tsk
ReplyDeleteaminin na nating sumisintunado yang luke na yan.
DeleteDapat pala sinabi ng idol na req ay may ibang department. Eh singing competition yan sa america
ReplyDeleteyou don't makes sense. Even in idol US looks is important to make it even in auditions, without it you must have a killer voice or an outstanding personality
Delete1:54 looks? Tagal ko na nanonood ng american idol di kailangan ng looks
Delete1:54 precisely. They are looking for someone to be the next IDOL. If it’s just singing, then audition for The Voice.
DeleteBasta ang wish ko ay sana sumikat ang mananalo. Ang daming singing contest pero wala namang sumikat gaya ni Sarah G.
ReplyDeleteiba kase pag mabait at may hardwork sa craft
Deleteano na pala nangyari sa grand winner sa Philippine Idol and Pinoy Idols?
Deletenapanood ko yung audition clip nya at hindi rin ako nagalingan. makalat talaga at need more practice pa talaga. di ko lang mavoice out yung thoughts ko sa socmed kasi baka mabash din ako e di pa naman ako singer. isa lang akong casual viewer hahahaha.
ReplyDeleteanyway, i personally think na tama lang yung no nila vice kay luke this time. pwede pa naman bumalik next time. nag yes siguro si regine kasi may room for improvement naman talaga.
yon nga eh, si regine lang ang nag yes eh sya lang ang may K na mag no, yang tatlong walang pakinabang jan sa show sila pa nag no. sa true lang.
DeleteAgree ako dyan cyst. Andami nagshare sa fb na sayang daw ang talent blah blah blah tas binabash yung 3 judges so I was expecting magaling talaga si Luke. Pag nood ko, ano ba miski ako No siya for me. He has potential but the song choice was very wrong for his style of singing. It was all over the place basta naguluhan Lang ako. And narealize ko bakit pinaglalaban ng marami si Luke eh dahil may sad background siya. Alam niyo na naman dito awa is greater than talent lol.
DeleteMaganda naman boses niya
DeleteYung iba nga pag maganda boses pero di ganon kaganda performance pinapakanta pa ulit eh.
Sila no agad sila kay luke kasi nga di gwapo.
Same opinion. And ang song choice talaga, sablay. Sabihin na nating sige pwede naman yung r&b gawing reggae, pero masyado syang nagstick sa original harmony at tempo, sana inayos nya ng tama kung irereggae nya
DeleteMe too sis! di ko nagustuhan yung rendition :( Ang gulo pakinggan di gaya ng mga reggae songs na napapakinggan ko na napapaindak ako. Sa kanya napapangiwi ako. Sorry this is just my opinion. I also saw his tweet with regards sa di pagkapasa sa Idol. ang yabang ng dating tss.
DeleteYUNG NGA BAKS EH! HINDI KA SINGER SO INVALID ANG OPINION MO. NAGALINGAN AKO KAY LUKE. SINGER AKO. SINONG MAS VALID ANG OPINION SA ATIN? MARAMI RIN AKONG FRIENDS NA SINGERS NA HUMAHANGA KAY LUKE.
DeleteSo kawawa naman pala talaga yung walang looks pero may talent? Dapat wag na sila sumali sa idol oh. Sa the voice nalang. At least dub una palang boses lang talaga ng pinapakinggan. Tho i have to admit, hindi nakaka wow yung performance nung Luke. Sa totoo lang
ReplyDeleteSino ba ang relevant ngayon ng contest winners? Di ba yung mga may talent and looks din? Pag hindi okay yung looks, mga 1 or 2 years, laos na. So dapat from the start, hanapin yung sisikat ng matagalan.
Delete"Idol" kasi ang hinahanap so dapat FULL PACKAGE - voice, looks, personality & charm ;)
Deletetrue don sila sa asian got talent may talent mga judges ...
DeletePwede din sa tawag ng tanghalan..talent din basehan dun..
DeleteSa the Voice sila dapat sumali wag sa idol
DeleteYaan niyo na, si Nadine nga pasok sa music label niya na walang talent sa pagkanta, dinadaan Lang sa awra hahaha, ganyan daw ang total package hahaha
DeleteNot a fan but my point si James. I was surprised to see how well he judge compared to Moira and Vice.
ReplyDeleteAgree. His comments were surprisingly on point.
DeleteYes his comments have depth
DeleteTruth.. Si Moira kung ano ano lang ang sinasabi
Deletesila ang mga judges so sila ang may say. kayo na lkang umupo sa upuan nila para malaman nyo kkung gaano kahuhusay mga ibang contestants at kung gaano kahirap maging hurado
ReplyDeleteNot polished pa 'yung Luke. Pinakinggan ko lang 'yan. Di ako nanood kasi may ginagawa ako. Compare kay Koko ng The Voice, layo ng quality. But the potential is there.
ReplyDeleteSabihin natin hindi malinis pagkanta ni Luke. Pero medyo positive kasi mga comments ng judges tapos biglang "no." Kasi nga hindi siya good looking. Yung si ate maganda na parang sintunado (Shai ba name nun? I forgot eh) na kumanta ng IDGAF, napa yes ang judges kahit na yung reaction nila ay napapailing sila. In general, mas pabor talaga ang mga tao sa maganda/gwapo. Example: BlackPink. Hindi naman kagalingan kumanta pero may stage presence at magaling mag perform. Ganun talaga. Maganda kasi. Eye candy.
ReplyDeleteyung blackpink wala ngang stage presence doon. magaling lang mag-perform at may good looks. pero kung iko-compare mo sa ibang idols na legend ay walang-wala sila.
DeletewoaAh. baka kay rose palang mapanganga ka na. Di mo alam sinasabi mo dyan, blackpink pa talaga ah haahahaha huwAww
DeleteHindi naman talaga magaling ang Blackpink kumanta. Maganda lang sila. Hahaha
Deletesana inamin niya na lang hindi ganun kalinis ang rendition ng tao kesa dun sa "magaling siya pero total package ang hanap", ang lumalabas tuloy mas matimbang ang looks kesa sa talent. so sa mga chaka diyan wag na daw kayong mag audition kesohadang kaboses niyo si jlo or bruno mars hindi rin kayo tatanggapin.
ReplyDeleteTooomooooo
Deletedoon sila mag audition sa "The VOICE" wag sa "IDOL Philippines"
DeleteThis!
DeleteObviously, some people are just using Luke's performance to bash James. Hindi naman talaga kagalingan si Luke, hindi pulido ang performance. Maybe, with more practice, he can come back again.
ReplyDeleteThat’s why the voice way is better.... they don’t look sa looks the Tao. Ewan ko ba hinde na ganun ka sikat ang idol sa ibang bansa bakit kinuha panito ng abs? Diba wala na American idol ngayon?
ReplyDeletePer Simon Cowell, original American Idol judge, looks do matter. He was very upfront about that when rejecting talented hopefuls. The image is of an Idol, not just a good singer.
ReplyDeleteSo what about people like Lewis Capaldi, James Bay, Ed Sheeran, Billie Eilish, members of bands like Bombay Bicycle Club and Foster the People? They aren’t considered conventionally attractive. Yet they make far better music and are more successful than any judge on any Filipino singing contest.
DeleteAminin na naten. Mga Pinoy mahilig Sa guapo at magaganda. Kaya ung iba dito mema lang na kunware they’re after the talent not the looks c’mon people job haunting nga Dapat May pleasing personality eh Sa entertainment pa kaya? Na pag nde guapo nde pinapansin🙄 pinanood ko ung audition video nya nde din naman talaga magaling. Tho I appreciate reggae song cause I have been to Jamaica Pero nde ko sya naappreciate. Nde ako singer Pero I’m a listener. Not a fan of the judges too actually isa ako Sa mga naloka Bakit kasama ung Tatlo as judges haha.
ReplyDeleteWell it is a popularity competition para sa isang next artista ng KaF. Pansahog na naman Sa asap Yung nagiging winner.
ReplyDeleteMay comment din ako dito sa judges eh. Pag nmimili sila minsan sasabihin “i want to give you a chance so its a yes for me” tapos sasabihin total package hinahanap.
ReplyDeleteMore practice pa kay Luke and better song choice. Parang hindi naman kasi naghanda sa totoo lang.
ReplyDeleteHindi naman masyado magaling yung luke, eh kung tingin nila hindi rin aabot sa ibang rounds why still give a chance, sayang lang ang slot sa iba na mas deserving. Masyado naman kasi impressed agad yun iba nadaan lang sa growl hahaha
ReplyDeletePwede ba, tama na yung pwede na, dapat laging pwedeng-pwede. The judges are looking for total package nga e, hindi yung pwede na. Tinataasan na nga nila standards nila sa pagpili, dami nyong reklamo na hindi fair.
ReplyDeleteIdol eh. Hindi lang dpat idol sa boses. Tanggapin na natin na pag may itsura ka plus point tlga. Wag nag pa hypocrite na kesho magaling keme. Eh mrami din nmn magaling na may itsura. Kahit ako ayokong nanood ng performer na di ma itsura. Magandang pakinggan sa spotify pro di ko panonoorin.
ReplyDeleteEn sa un Ang gusto nya ano magagawa nyo..as if nman tatangkilikin nyo khit wlang looks. bkit ung ibsng singer na magaling kumanta bkit di mbigyan Ng break at hndi mpasikat ksi nga hndi complete package ung iba dito ipokrito din eh kunwari ung talent daw sus!..
ReplyDeletehinde siya magaling period
ReplyDeleteoo i listen to reggae na appreciate ko un genre
walang kinalaman ang looks or color
duh! agree with the judges na nag NO
Agree ako sayo
DeleteAng oa lang kasi masyado sa iba lalo na sa looks nung tao. Hindi naman sya kinawawa at wala naman nilait sa itsura nya. Its just sa isang comepetition may nanalo at natatalo talaga. Para naman katapusan na ng mundo kung d sya makuha. 🙄
ReplyDeleteTalaga naman ding di magaling. Sintunado talaga
DeleteVery unprofessional! Hindi niya kailangan i-explain kung bakit ligwak ang ibang contestants. Saka paano siya sure na agree ang lahat sa final 12 na kasali? E sa pagiging judge nga niya di agree lahat.
ReplyDeleteEwan ko sayo James!
ReplyDeleteHaha nakakatawa yung mga nagrarant. Eh may mga di kagandahan diyan na singer na may magagandang boses naman pero di sinuportahan. Ending may mga itsura pa rin yung iniidolo. Sorry kung di siya nakuha. Hindi pa naman katapusan ng buhay niya. Ibig sabihin lang non di pa niya time.
ReplyDeleteJames is good as a judge in idol he knows what he is talking about. Sa tutoo lang wala naman talagang wow factor yung Luke para ipasa nila. He has a voice but really nothing special. Kaya I agree with all three judges.
ReplyDeleteNot a fan of anyone but come'on! Listen Kokoi's reggae vs this Luke! Tong mga to di lang tinanggap ginawa na issue. Kayo lang naman tong nagpapalaki. E di naman talaga magaling yung Luke. E nagkataon, di kayo judge so sorry!
ReplyDeleteAha, so you're bringing up Kokoi eh dito nga mismo sa website na eto maraming nag bash kay Kokoi noon dahil reggae lang daw ang alam kantahin. So dahil hindi niyo trip si Luke ico-compare niyo siya sa mga sobrang tagal nang nagpe-perform. Like Kokoi matagal nang nagpeperform sa Boracay bago sumali sa The Voice. Nyahahahaha! People talaga. Makakalimutin kayo kung sobra niyong nilait si Kokoi noon. Hahaha! Hypocrites!
DeleteHis piece wasnt that good! I dont know san galing tong rebulusyon na toh. He didnt fit the bill..PERIOD. James isnt a bad judge either, hes one of the sensible ones.
ReplyDeleteShai wasn't good either yet James said yes to her so much for being sensible
Delete"I like your voice"lol lol lol
Deleteumay na sa issue na 'to. Move on na people. hindi naman nilait o kinawawa ang looks nya. yung total package na sinasabi kasi isang genre lang ang kaya nyang kantahin which is reggae. hindi naman reggae idol philippines ang title ng show. dapat kahit anong genre kaya mo kantahin. hindi rin lahat trip ang reggae. d sila nagfofocus sa isa lang.
ReplyDeleteI agree with James, lalo na yung company niya mismo (Careless Manila INC.) kung saan siya ang owner naghahanap ng new talent at recording artists, of course kukunin mo total packages.
ReplyDeleteBaka Careless Music Manila teh hahahaha
DeleteHindi ko magets bakit nagagalit Kay James. Hindi naman talaga maganda and pagkakakanta, wala sa tiyempo at may part na sintonado.
ReplyDeleteKelly Clarkson won the first Idol competition and many followed who didn't have the superstar manufactured look so bottomline, it's still about the talent AND charisma. In saying that, I wasn't that impressed with Luke (or maybe the build up let me down) BUT I have to agree that they let in lesser talents with mediocre voices, no musicality nor artistry.
ReplyDeleteThis is very well said. I do believe in James and Regine’s capabilities as judges, Vice is ok, Moira not so much. but based on Luke’s audition, I trust James on this one.
DeleteJames is not that good as a judge (others would say di qualified) but Luke is not that good as a singer, too.
ReplyDeleteI love reggae music but I have to agree with Regine na kalat yung arrangement nya. Akala ko sobrang galing kasi maraming nag reklamo but Luke's rendition was a mess. He could sing but he murdered the song. Yun lang.
total package nman tlga dito. pde c luke sa TNT or the voice pag meron na.
ReplyDeleteComing from an auto-tune singer... high credibilty...👏👏👏
ReplyDeleteDi ko gets why they have to be judged na di dpat maging judge s idol ph?! They represent what is music today...
ReplyDeleteLuke baylon is a good singer, for me wrong song choice di kc bagay ung song na ginawan nia ng reggae beat.. di porket nag reggae na magaling and dapat pasok agad.. timing is everything..
ReplyDeleteWatch and you'll see that James is actually making a lot of sense and he is able to articulate his thoughts well. And this reggae singer is not even that good. Watch all the videos in Youtube and James is right, you'll know why this reggae dude did not make it. His rendition was shaky, out of tempo, and there is really a lot of missed notes. Let's just be objective here. And if you're saying he should get plus points for soul, you have not yet seen the other contenders.
ReplyDeleteAg daminh missed notes rin ni james pero bakit sya naging judge?
Deletewhat do you mean bytotal package? magaling kumanta, guapo at maganda? para pdeng pang artista? Pinoy Idol yan, singer ang hinahanap jan despite the looks! James guapo ka, pero di ka nababagay maging judge ng isang prestigious singing competition gaya nito!
ReplyDeleteAng problema, how can you find the “total package” from one audition? Hindi ba dapat binibigyan muna ng chance to find out if meron pang ibubuga? So kung hindi looks yung kasama sa “total package”, ano? Typical ABSCBN freezer factory. Lol.
ReplyDeleteThis only proves na mas magaling na judge si James kay Regine hahaha. He judged rightfully. Kaya yung mga nagsasabing di bagay si James sa Idol, ano kayo ngayon di ba agree din kayo sa kanya
ReplyDeleteHilo ka na. Di nga makaanta ng maayos ng live w/o auto tune sa mic
DeleteJames you have no idea how hard it is to watch you crush dreams of people more talented than you.
ReplyDeleteCORRECT! HAHAHAHA! AUTOTUNE BOY LANG YAN SI JAMES EH, PUTEK MAS MAGALING PA AKO KUMANTA DIYAN!
Deletein fairness sa 4 na judges, si R lang talaga ung may K pero sya pinakawalang kwenta magjudge at comment...
ReplyDeletebest singer doesnt equate to best judging...
Si regine lang ang legit na pwedeng humusga sa singing ng contestant. Yung 3 pwede na tanggalin kasi wala pang napapatunayan.
ReplyDeleteWtf the judges probably think that Luke can't sing other music genres aside from reggae.
ReplyDelete