IPR issue kasi yun cyst. Original song writer ka naglapat ng music at hirap na hirap ka ipromote tapoa bumenta, syempre the credit should be from you. Cover artists would like to showcase their voice on outdoing the original artists. In this case, the coverband got more fame. Lets see if Agsunta could also produce songs that will be a sure hit like songs of December Ave. I like both bands pero medyo unfair lang sa original song writers to.
I understand the IPR issue. What I'm saying is, may mga uploads sila nung songs na kasama ung original artist, so obviously may permission. Why take down those too?
Hindi naman deleted. Ni-private lang nila. You would know it, kasi millions pa rin ang total views nila sa profile page nila. Kapag nag-delete ka ng video, madededuct yung views nun sa total number of views mo.
meron kasing royalties doon sa bandang mismong gumawa o yung composser ng kanta. Para pag sumikat na doon napupunta ang credit at binabayaran yuon. Bale ang issue nila ay intelectual property rights.
Tama naman official band na ang AGSUNTA until kelan sila makikinabang sa songs ng ibang tao at pagkakakitaan?
Parang kapag nagoncert ba sila sa Araneta or MOA arena then kakantahin nila songs ng ibang tao pero di bibigyan ng proper income ang original creator dahil sa palusot na cover lang. Panu na lang if di na gumawa ng songs ang original creator e di wala din ang Agsunta?
Simple lang. Those YouTubers ask for permission from record companies to cover their songs/music and they obtain licenses after paying the compulsory license fees to the record companies.
Yes! And take note that they don’t do covers right after the song is released. So we can’t really compare Agsunta and Boyce Avenue. The latter has proper ethics as a musician and has duly paid their dues.
mahilig kasi tayo sa gaya-gaya, from teleserye, music, fashion, structures, food at marami pang iba. tapos madalas hindi pa nagpapa-alam. minsan parang Xerox copy pa eh lol
Wow, Clem really is an intelligent man. I don't have any knowledge of this either but thru his posts alone, i guess i somehow understood what this is all about.
Not just December Ave’s songs were covered by Agsunta. Madami actually even from other artists. Nadrag lang ang Dec Ave kasi Zel bautista(vocalist) tweeted few weeks back regarding copying people’s work. Which was picked up by fans and pin pointed it to Agsunta. And so on and so forth. Haha
wow ha! nakalimutan na ba ng Orange and Lemons na kinopya lang din nila ang melody ng pinakasikay nilanf kantang Pinoy Ako from The Care’s Chandelier ???! and they earned off a lot of profit from it, too? tsk tsk In case nakalimutan mo na Clem, ipapaalala ko lang. New Wave fans are still pissed at you for being s copycat so please, preach elsewhere.
That's why his post was based on his personal experience. Napagdaanan na nya kaya alam na nya ang mangyayari. At para na rin mapaalala sa mga nakakabasa na wag nang gayahin kung ano man yung nagawa nila noon kasi alam nyang hindi maganda ang kalalabasan.
sorry but they never admitted that they copied the melody, they even acted offended when people called them out, so NO, as a new wave fan, you’re still not excused nor forgiven, Clem. wag magmalinis.
2:20 Di lang po Youtube ang problema. DA is banking on cover songs even on their official gigs ng hindi nagbabayad ng copyright sa original creator. Mas mahal pa bayad nila kesa sa original. Kinakalaban pa nga nila by releasing a cover kahit 1 month pa lang released yung original.
I follow agsunta so I actually do like their work pero ippoint out ko lang na yung statement mona "mas madalas mas maganda kesa sa original" ang covers nila is just YOUR opinion, it's not a fact.
Moreover, mas mahirap di hamak magcompose at gumawa ng kanta from scratch kaysa magcover and just simply jazz it up. Hindi comparable. Thats why may IPR na protection sa content creators, and agsunta is violating that. At the very least, highly unethical yung ginagawa nilang pagcover ng recently released songs kasi nagiging competitor sila ng content creator.
Pag gumawa ka ng painting then I photographed and photoshopped it a bit and then printed it in a different medium for much less cost than it took for you to paint it at binenta ko a month after mo irelease yung painting, ok lang sayo?
2:20 This "Ei kung ayaw ipakanta sa iba ang kanta nila wag nang magpublish or publish sa cassette tape. Singer tas ayaw ishare ang kanta." is third world mentality. Exactly the mindset of a pirate.
ok lng mag cover pero pag sumusweldo na kayo from youtube. mag bigay naman sana kayo dun sa original na gumawa ng kanta..laki ng pera nakukuha ng mga youtubers... at least 6 digits na sweldo? dba. pa cover2x lng. wag feeling pa victim.. gawa kayo ng original songs then market it sa mga followers nio..more people would appreciate that...
Anong issue sa kanila ni Agsunta de Rossi? Ang haba kasing basahin.
ReplyDelete1:50 ang corny and its too obvious
DeleteOo nga 2:49 hahahaha
Delete2:49 init ng ulo mo. Relax :)
DeleteTaking down everything was a bit harsh. Yung ibang videos naman, kasama nila ung artist, like JROA. Why remove everything? :(
ReplyDeleteIPR issue kasi yun cyst. Original song writer ka naglapat ng music at hirap na hirap ka ipromote tapoa bumenta, syempre the credit should be from you. Cover artists would like to showcase their voice on outdoing the original artists. In this case, the coverband got more fame. Lets see if Agsunta could also produce songs that will be a sure hit like songs of December Ave. I like both bands pero medyo unfair lang sa original song writers to.
DeleteI understand the IPR issue. What I'm saying is, may mga uploads sila nung songs na kasama ung original artist, so obviously may permission. Why take down those too?
DeleteHindi naman deleted. Ni-private lang nila. You would know it, kasi millions pa rin ang total views nila sa profile page nila. Kapag nag-delete ka ng video, madededuct yung views nun sa total number of views mo.
Deletemeron kasing royalties doon sa bandang mismong gumawa o yung composser ng kanta. Para pag sumikat na doon napupunta ang credit at binabayaran yuon. Bale ang issue nila ay intelectual property rights.
Deletei hope this guy's profound explanation will influence the conflicting parties to look at things from each other's perspective
ReplyDeleteTama naman siya
ReplyDeleteTama naman official band na ang AGSUNTA until kelan sila makikinabang sa songs ng ibang tao at pagkakakitaan?
ReplyDeleteParang kapag nagoncert ba sila sa Araneta or MOA arena then kakantahin nila songs ng ibang tao pero di bibigyan ng proper income ang original creator dahil sa palusot na cover lang. Panu na lang if di na gumawa ng songs ang original creator e di wala din ang Agsunta?
Ang dami namang youtubers na gumagawa ng covers like boyce avenue. Nakakapagconcert pa sila even abroad. How come dito lang satin may issue na ganito?
ReplyDeleteSimple lang. Those YouTubers ask for permission from record companies to cover their songs/music and they obtain licenses after paying the compulsory license fees to the record companies.
DeleteGawa kasi kayo sarili niyong kanta
ReplyDeleteTotoo naman dapat kapag sikat na at mag cocover dapat nagbabayad naman talaga ng royalties dun sa singer.
ReplyDeleteSo how dow popular cover bands like Boyce Avenue operate? Do they pay royalties to the original singers?
ReplyDeleteYes.. nagbabayad ang boyce avenue
DeleteYes! And take note that they don’t do covers right after the song is released. So we can’t really compare Agsunta and Boyce Avenue. The latter has proper ethics as a musician and has duly paid their dues.
Deletemahilig kasi tayo sa gaya-gaya, from teleserye, music, fashion, structures, food at marami pang iba. tapos madalas hindi pa nagpapa-alam. minsan parang Xerox copy pa eh lol
ReplyDeleteWow! Very insightful! Wonderfully explained. Tama lang pala magalit ang December Avenue.
ReplyDeleteMatalino sya. He explained it very well
DeleteAng sarap basahin. Walang paligoy ligoy at may flow.
ReplyDeletecorrect itong mga point ni sir, dapat mag ingat din yung mga susunod na banda sa pag cover at mga vloggers na gumagamit ng mga music ng walang paalam.
ReplyDeleteWow, Clem really is an intelligent man. I don't have any knowledge of this either but thru his posts alone, i guess i somehow understood what this is all about.
ReplyDeleteanong song ba ang issue?
ReplyDeleteKinover ata ung song ng December Ave.
DeleteNot just December Ave’s songs were covered by Agsunta. Madami actually even from other artists. Nadrag lang ang Dec Ave kasi Zel bautista(vocalist) tweeted few weeks back regarding copying people’s work. Which was picked up by fans and pin pointed it to Agsunta. And so on and so forth. Haha
DeleteThis is sad. :(
ReplyDeleteAng talino! Amg simple pero direktang naipaliwanag ang sitwasyon na walang kinilingan or minasama. Galing!
ReplyDeletewow ha! nakalimutan na ba ng Orange and Lemons na kinopya lang din nila ang melody ng pinakasikay nilanf kantang Pinoy Ako from The Care’s Chandelier ???! and they earned off a lot of profit from it, too? tsk tsk In case nakalimutan mo na Clem, ipapaalala ko lang. New Wave fans are still pissed at you for being s copycat so please, preach elsewhere.
ReplyDeleteKaya nga his post makes so much sense kasi nga he’s talking from experience
DeleteI was about to say the same thing. Did they pay royalties to The Care ?
DeleteTama! New wave fan here akala nya siguro porke hindi lumabas commercially yung single wala nang makaka recognize ng original song
DeleteThat's why his post was based on his personal experience. Napagdaanan na nya kaya alam na nya ang mangyayari. At para na rin mapaalala sa mga nakakabasa na wag nang gayahin kung ano man yung nagawa nila noon kasi alam nyang hindi maganda ang kalalabasan.
DeleteOn a previous interview, back when they were a band (w Mcoy), na address na yan.
Deletesorry but they never admitted that they copied the melody, they even acted offended when people called them out, so NO, as a new wave fan, you’re still not excused nor forgiven, Clem. wag magmalinis.
DeleteWow. This guy is intelligent.
ReplyDeleteActually nasolve na ito nang Youtube. Kaya ang cover songs dapat ang title “Song title by original singer cover by 2nd singer”.
ReplyDeleteEi kung ayaw ipakanta sa iba ang kanta nila wag nang magpublish or publish sa cassette tape. Singer tas ayaw ishare ang kanta.
kung ung pera ang habol, mag file nang claim sa Youtube. Pwede kasing imonetize nang orig artist ang cover songs.
magaganda ang cover nang Agsunta, madalas mas maganda kesa sa original. di naman nila basta kinanta ang songs, may improvement din silang ginawa
2:20 Di lang po Youtube ang problema. DA is banking on cover songs even on their official gigs ng hindi nagbabayad ng copyright sa original creator. Mas mahal pa bayad nila kesa sa original. Kinakalaban pa nga nila by releasing a cover kahit 1 month pa lang released yung original.
DeleteI follow agsunta so I actually do like their work pero ippoint out ko lang na yung statement mona "mas madalas mas maganda kesa sa original" ang covers nila is just YOUR opinion, it's not a fact.
DeleteMoreover, mas mahirap di hamak magcompose at gumawa ng kanta from scratch kaysa magcover and just simply jazz it up. Hindi comparable.
Thats why may IPR na protection sa content creators, and agsunta is violating that. At the very least, highly unethical yung ginagawa nilang pagcover ng recently released songs kasi nagiging competitor sila ng content creator.
Pag gumawa ka ng painting then I photographed and photoshopped it a bit and then printed it in a different medium for much less cost than it took for you to paint it at binenta ko a month after mo irelease yung painting, ok lang sayo?
2:20 This "Ei kung ayaw ipakanta sa iba ang kanta nila wag nang magpublish or publish sa cassette tape. Singer tas ayaw ishare ang kanta." is third world mentality. Exactly the mindset of a pirate.
Delete2:51 AGSUNTA* is banking... Sorry. Hahahaha
ReplyDeleteVery well said.
ReplyDeleteAgsunta lang kase yung kumikita from Youtube. At saka parang kinokomtensya pa nila yung original bands/artist. BTW. Very well said Clem!
ReplyDeleteok lng mag cover pero pag sumusweldo na kayo from youtube. mag bigay naman sana kayo dun sa original na gumawa ng kanta..laki ng pera nakukuha ng mga youtubers... at least 6 digits na sweldo? dba. pa cover2x lng. wag feeling pa victim.. gawa kayo ng original songs then market it sa mga followers nio..more people would appreciate that...
ReplyDelete