They could have settled for mediation instead of wasting the court's time with such rubbish. Naku Ellen. There are more important cases to warrant time and effort of the court.
A simple sorry would have sufficed. She wants to justify her nonsense by going through the cases in court.
She didn’t say sorry or even felt sorry sa bata na cyberbully niya. Thats the point na pinaglalaban nung nanay. Kung nanay ka at binabash yung anak mo dahil sa bintang sknya di mo ba kakasuhan para matuto?! Ellen just feels too entitled to say sorry. She doesn’t even want a settlement. Speaks of her personality. Ayaw patalo
Tama. Pinahiya ni Ellen ang anak niya gusto lang ng pamilya ng isang sorry, tapos sa 5 days na yun imbes na mag lie low nag post pa na nag manicure. Sarap ng buhay ni Ellen nung time na yun parang wala mag dedemanda sa kanya hahahha
12:38 hindi teh yung hindi muna gumamit ng social media nung time na yun lalo na binigyan siya ng 5 days para mag sorry. Common sense wag muna gumamit ng social media kung hindi naman siya mag sorry baka mas lalo minis yung mom ng teen.
Luh no way highway! Nung siya hinihingian ng sorry, mayabang siya at ayaw niya ibigay dun sa bata ngaun wag din ibigay sa kanya... tama lang yan EYE FOR AN EYE, kesihodang may anak na siya, baket nung nangyari naman tong issue na to buntis na siya yet she still proceeded to be a BRAT bout it, serves her right!
Gusto ni mother makaharap si Ellen. Hindi talaga siya kukuha ng settlement, basing sa picture may kaya yung pamilya ng teen. Sa school pa lang ni teen mahal na ang tuition.
Walang naman problema magbyahe from cebu to mla you can fly early in the morning and back to cebu in the same day, daming flights cebu is a flight hub for domestic and int'l flights..delaying tactics lang yan bagong panganak! Normal naman sya at walang sakit after few days okay ka na..magiisang buwan na! Sarap kurutin ng babaitang ito! This is my opinion i don't care what ellen's warrior of defenders say!
Mukhang madidismiss naman tong case na to. Unless someone has rewritten our penal laws and our rules on evidence.
What did ellen do? post the photo? does that act, by itself, constitute cyberbullying? diba yung mga nambully naman yung mga netizens na umiikot sa showbiz ang buhay? Those who posted nasty comments on the kid's ig feed. Why were they not sued?
Although hindi naman kailangan yung demand letter para magprosper yung criminal case, kakaiba yung lawyer na nag-advise to post her demand letter online. Paano kaya maeestablish yung receipt dun? Ano yun, nire-write mo yung Rules of Court?
Teh, galing na mismo sa 'yo. Kid. Meaning minor, child, not yet of legal age. Even if hindi counted as cyberbullying yung 'she just posted the kid's pic', bottomline is harassment of a minor pa rin ang ginawa nya which is a criminal offense.
She posted the photo of the kid with the word "paparazzi". Is that, by itself, criminally punishable? Civil siguro, pwede pa. Pagbabayadin lang siya ng damages. Pero under RA 10175? Malabo.
Our penal code defines libel as a public and malicious imputation of a crime, or of a vice or defect, real or imaginary, or any act, omission, condition, status, or circumstance tending to cause the dishonor, discredit, or contempt of a natural or juridical person, or to blacken the memory of one who is dead.
Stricto kasi criminal laws natin. Dapat pasok na pasok siya sa definition ng batas. Hindi porket nabully yung bata dahil sa pagpost ni ellen ng photo ay criminally liable na si ellen. She can be held civilly liable for posting the photos of an underage kid without the latter's consent.
But you'd really be stretching the law if you think posting a person's photo with the words paparazzi is libelous.
Yan ang mahirap sa atin. Hindi tayo nagbabasa ng batas. Tapos kapag hindi tayo sang ayon sa desisyon ng korte, sasabihin natin walang hustisya sa Pilipinas.
I know you are one and the same person based on the tone of your post. Laws are meant to protect the aggrieved, not the other way around. You can always interpret the law and circumvent it, stretch it to the point that you are able to skirt it, but it doesn't mean that what you did suddenly is moral because the law pronounces it to be so. Daming kurakot at lawyers ng mga criminal na ang gagaling at naippanalo ang kaso, but the law may deny it, yet its moral value remains. Yung proseso na lang, the bad publicity itself, the drama the case created- these are fibers of karma that even the laws created by humans will have no influence and say.
Matira ang matibay sa kakabayad sa lawyers dahil maraming process na puwedeng gawin bago matapos. Then may appeal process pa. In the meantime, bayad ng bayad sa lawyer pareho.
Yeah, that's why Ellen is dragging this out. She has the money to pay the lawyers. The complainant may not be poor but I'm sure Ellen is a lot richer. Strategy nya yan na patagalin until mapagod yung family. But unfortunately for her, I don't think the family will stop. Even if it is addtional expense, may paninindigan sila. They are fighting for a cause so they will see this through.
@2:00 only child yung girl. Atenista pa and mukang Hindi naman siya athlete so Hindi scholarship ang tuition. So malamang mayaman din sila.not everyone is showy about their money you know.
I hope there won't be any settlement! She was given a chance to apologize but instead, she showed arrogance and did a mockery of it. And in doing so, the child took more bashings from Ellen's fans. She needs to be penalized for her obnoxious and illegal acts.
Bakit di pwede mag byahe? Ako nanganak sa panganay tru cesarian 1 week pa lang nakapagbyahe na, barko pa po iyon..1 week po pwede na mag byahe unless may komplikasyon ang baby or ang mother, pero so far mukhang malusog nman si ellen and baby, e nung buntis nga todo beach pa,.tactics lang siguro para idelay.
Ito na naman ang mga gullible na commenters with their “iba-iba ang bawat pregancy” excuse. Kung yun nga nasa critical condition pwedeng i-airlift, siya pa kaya na nakapanganak na.
Oh ayan ateng Ellen, sa halip na spend mo time mo sa anak mo, ngaun mangunsime ka sa korte! Hinde lahat ng bagay nadadaan sa pagiging sikat at pera. Buti na lang laban kung laban talaga si mother dear.
Dream on inday! Nasaan na nga pala yung sinasabi niyang CCTV ng resto na kinainan nila? Ay oo nga pala, wala... walang ebidensya kaya NGANGA si tita Ellen lels
Smh, some people here. Isip isip din puro hanash ng guilty until proven innocent??? Iba din naman magisip mga tao dito...There must be a reason why ellen will never apologise and wont settle... wait wait nalang tayo. Di pa natin alam ang details sa kampo ni ellen.
Under age pa din yung binully ni Ellen sa social media. Paka bastos na tao nitong si Ellen. Tama yan, isa ka ng ina, tignan ko anong maramdaman mo pag may nang bully sa mga anak mo.
Ang sakin lang the girl can easily deny na she took more than one video. Siyempre and ilalabas niya lang yung video na mukang innocent.
Masyado lang hater mga tao and wants to think of ellen badly kaya walang naniniwala sakanya. But she is probably smart enough and aware enough as a celebrity so see kung sino ang talagang nag papap sakanya ng patago.
Agree ako na mali ung pag post niya ng minor sa IG niya, but I don't think the other girl is innocent as well.
Mali lang ni ellen sana inantay niya kung may lumabas nga na upload from the resto and tska sana siya rumesbak ng post niya.
2:29 Problema sa pinaglalaban mo teh wala kang ebidensya. Eto na ngang si Ellen kinukunan na din ng pic/video yung bata hindi naman nakikitang may paki sa saknya. Ni gulat wala, yung tipong sa akto nakunan. Walang mailalabas si Ellen kasi assumera lang sya!
Kahit anung anggulo MALI talaga si Ellen. Public place yun eh at common na sa mga tao to take picture kahit pagkain, ipost sa instagram or IG story hindi pinapalagpas syempre. at sino naman kataas taasang nagsasabi if ever na bawal mahagip si ellen ng cam? jusko pabida! wag syang feelingera.
Sus. Ang babaw honestly lang. Siguro kung di na nag file yung parents nung minor baka nakalimutan na & di na sana sha nato-trauma. Para naman sobrang injustice ginawa sa anak nila. Saka di nman na sha little kid para ma trauma diyan..if she felt na she was on the rigjt kahit pag usapan ka wala ka nman dapat ng patunayan. Pero since pinapa drag pa nila itong case parang lalo tuloy lumalaki & di maalis sa anak nila yung mapqg usapan. Kahit mali si ellen or not...give your "minor" a break na din from scrutiny and move on with her life diba?
Mababaw nman pala bakit hindi nlng tapusin ni Ellen? Kasi karapatan ng ina pagtanggol anak nya, why cant Ellen speak for herself? Kung wala lang toh edi matatapos na ang lahat.kung may gusto patunayan si Ellen ilabas nya.
yun na nga pinapahaba pa ni ellen eh. kaya lalo tumatagal! hindi nya pwede takasan ang batas. kung nakapagfile ang parents ni minor ibig sabihin may pinagalaban sila. ellen is super duwag.
Nakahanap ng katapat ang pagiging bratinella at entitled ni Ellen.
ReplyDeletePara namang aping-api un anak niya eh palusot lang naman din na kinukuhanan kuno un food.
DeleteThey could have settled for mediation instead of wasting the court's time with such rubbish. Naku Ellen. There are more important cases to warrant time and effort of the court.
DeleteA simple sorry would have sufficed. She wants to justify her nonsense by going through the cases in court.
Anon 5:31, kung gawain mo don't assume that everyone else does the same palusot that you do.
Deleteitong si 5:31... don't assume that everyone knows the starlets sa pinas showbiz. choz!
DeleteShe didn’t say sorry or even felt sorry sa bata na cyberbully niya. Thats the point na pinaglalaban nung nanay. Kung nanay ka at binabash yung anak mo dahil sa bintang sknya di mo ba kakasuhan para matuto?! Ellen just feels too entitled to say sorry. She doesn’t even want a settlement. Speaks of her personality. Ayaw patalo
Delete5:31, that is for the court to say and not us
DeleteWell your point is invalid @5:31 unless taga korte ka, wag kame!
Deleteaba matindi talaga tama nitong si madam ellen, ayaw ng peace of mind! kalurks instead na i-spend na lang sa anakis ang time and attention
ReplyDeleteServes her right! Akala mo kung sinong importante.
ReplyDeleteGo go go! Wag ka papayag ng settlement
ReplyDeletego fight! dont settle for money, ano akala nya lahat nabibili?
ReplyDeletenung xa pinakiusapan ayaw tapos mgayon gusto makipagsettle.
Tama. Pinahiya ni Ellen ang anak niya gusto lang ng pamilya ng isang sorry, tapos sa 5 days na yun imbes na mag lie low nag post pa na nag manicure. Sarap ng buhay ni Ellen nung time na yun parang wala mag dedemanda sa kanya hahahha
Delete8:14, ano ang gusto mo, kailangan umiiyak sa posting niya? Hahaha!
Delete12:38 hindi teh yung hindi muna gumamit ng social media nung time na yun lalo na binigyan siya ng 5 days para mag sorry. Common sense wag muna gumamit ng social media kung hindi naman siya mag sorry baka mas lalo minis yung mom ng teen.
Delete8:14, i feel like she was taunting the girl & the parents
DeleteThat’s the point nga 2:18, nangiinis nga siya haha unbothered kasi nga siya
DeleteWhat’s going to happen to Ellen if ever she loses? Makulong ba siya? š±
ReplyDeleteNope. It’s a civil case so penalty or fine
DeleteAte sang planeta ka galing?Prosecutor? Akyat sa court? Doesn't ring any bells?
DeleteReview your revised penal code atihhhh.
To lawyers here, what will happen if indeed Ellen is found guilty?
ReplyDeleteLuh no way highway! Nung siya hinihingian ng sorry, mayabang siya at ayaw niya ibigay dun sa bata ngaun wag din ibigay sa kanya... tama lang yan EYE FOR AN EYE, kesihodang may anak na siya, baket nung nangyari naman tong issue na to buntis na siya yet she still proceeded to be a BRAT bout it, serves her right!
ReplyDeleteKudos to Ellen’s lawyer. Pero I think in the end, settlement din ending nito. Kaloka yung nanay. Anu raw
ReplyDeleteNapasubo na lang si nanay ngayon kaya puro interview sa media.
Deletekasalanan mo yan ellen. ginusto mo ng problema face the music
ReplyDeleteBaka kailangan pang mag pa mani and pedi bago magpakita sa korte...
ReplyDeleteSana lumabsn family nung bata para maturuan ng leksyon ang ibon
ReplyDeletewhy is it so hard for her to apologize? she's dragging this para makaganti sya titindi ang gastos ng kabila.
ReplyDeleteKarma winsšš
ReplyDeleteGusto ni mother makaharap si Ellen. Hindi talaga siya kukuha ng settlement, basing sa picture may kaya yung pamilya ng teen. Sa school pa lang ni teen mahal na ang tuition.
ReplyDeleteWalang naman problema magbyahe from cebu to mla you can fly early in the morning and back to cebu in the same day, daming flights cebu is a flight hub for domestic and int'l flights..delaying tactics lang yan bagong panganak! Normal naman sya at walang sakit after few days okay ka na..magiisang buwan na! Sarap kurutin ng babaitang ito! This is my opinion i don't care what ellen's warrior of defenders say!
ReplyDeleteChild advocate yata yung nanay nung kid so there's no way this Ellen will get away with it
ReplyDeleteThis is true. She is an advocate for child rights
Deletekawawa naman mga fans. sabi pa naman nila "let them be" at simple na ang pamumuhay nila kaya nakakaproud. huhu
ReplyDeleteMukhang madidismiss naman tong case na to. Unless someone has rewritten our penal laws and our rules on evidence.
ReplyDeleteWhat did ellen do? post the photo? does that act, by itself, constitute cyberbullying? diba yung mga nambully naman yung mga netizens na umiikot sa showbiz ang buhay? Those who posted nasty comments on the kid's ig feed. Why were they not sued?
Although hindi naman kailangan yung demand letter para magprosper yung criminal case, kakaiba yung lawyer na nag-advise to post her demand letter online. Paano kaya maeestablish yung receipt dun? Ano yun, nire-write mo yung Rules of Court?
She posted a photo of a minor without consent and captioned it with accusations.
DeleteAgree 1:30. At dahil don nabully c MINOR. Besides, binigyan ng family n girl c ellen ng chance pra mgsorry pero ngmaldita p sya. Ellen deserve this!
DeleteTeh, galing na mismo sa 'yo. Kid. Meaning minor, child, not yet of legal age. Even if hindi counted as cyberbullying yung 'she just posted the kid's pic', bottomline is harassment of a minor pa rin ang ginawa nya which is a criminal offense.
DeletePwede kayong magbasa ng text ng batas online.
DeleteShe posted the photo of the kid with the word "paparazzi". Is that, by itself, criminally punishable? Civil siguro, pwede pa. Pagbabayadin lang siya ng damages. Pero under RA 10175? Malabo.
Our penal code defines libel as a public and malicious imputation of a crime, or of a vice or defect, real or imaginary, or any act, omission, condition, status, or circumstance tending to cause the dishonor, discredit, or contempt of a natural or juridical person, or to blacken the memory of one who is dead.
Stricto kasi criminal laws natin. Dapat pasok na pasok siya sa definition ng batas. Hindi porket nabully yung bata dahil sa pagpost ni ellen ng photo ay criminally liable na si ellen. She can be held civilly liable for posting the photos of an underage kid without the latter's consent.
But you'd really be stretching the law if you think posting a person's photo with the words paparazzi is libelous.
Yan ang mahirap sa atin. Hindi tayo nagbabasa ng batas. Tapos kapag hindi tayo sang ayon sa desisyon ng korte, sasabihin natin walang hustisya sa Pilipinas.
@4:16 ang mahirap sa pilipinas kahit maliit na bagay o malaki basta artista may lusot.
Delete4:16, feelings kasi ang pinaiiral nila hindi batas.
Delete10:21 / 4:16
DeleteI know you are one and the same person based on the tone of your post. Laws are meant to protect the aggrieved, not the other way around. You can always interpret the law and circumvent it, stretch it to the point that you are able to skirt it, but it doesn't mean that what you did suddenly is moral because the law pronounces it to be so. Daming kurakot at lawyers ng mga criminal na ang gagaling at naippanalo ang kaso, but the law may deny it, yet its moral value remains. Yung proseso na lang, the bad publicity itself, the drama the case created- these are fibers of karma that even the laws created by humans will have no influence and say.
Matira ang matibay sa kakabayad sa lawyers dahil maraming process na puwedeng gawin bago matapos. Then may appeal process pa. In the meantime, bayad ng bayad sa lawyer pareho.
ReplyDeleteYeah, that's why Ellen is dragging this out. She has the money to pay the lawyers. The complainant may not be poor but I'm sure Ellen is a lot richer. Strategy nya yan na patagalin until mapagod yung family. But unfortunately for her, I don't think the family will stop. Even if it is addtional expense, may paninindigan sila. They are fighting for a cause so they will see this through.
DeleteKahit may paninindigan sila, mas masaklap mag-ubos ng pera sa ganito lang namang klaseng kaso.
DeleteNot sure how Philippines court works but usually sa abroad the losing party case pays for the lawyer/court fees of the other party.
DeleteTe marami din sila pambayad sa lawyerrrrrr hahaha
Delete7:45, I think it’s the same, the losing party pays for the legal fees as part of damages
Delete9:07, tingnan natin kung gaano sila tatagal sa kakabayad.
Delete@2:00 only child yung girl. Atenista pa and mukang Hindi naman siya athlete so Hindi scholarship ang tuition. So malamang mayaman din sila.not everyone is showy about their money you know.
DeleteTheir family’s very down to earth. Sobrang babait
DeleteI hope there won't be any settlement! She was given a chance to apologize but instead, she showed arrogance and did a mockery of it. And in doing so, the child took more bashings from Ellen's fans. She needs to be penalized for her obnoxious and illegal acts.
ReplyDeleteBakit di pwede mag byahe? Ako nanganak sa panganay tru cesarian 1 week pa lang nakapagbyahe na, barko pa po iyon..1 week po pwede na mag byahe unless may komplikasyon ang baby or ang mother, pero so far mukhang malusog nman si ellen and baby, e nung buntis nga todo beach pa,.tactics lang siguro para idelay.
ReplyDeleteIba-iba mag-buntis, manganak at mag-recover ang mga tao.
DeleteSobrang maarete lang yan kasi.
DeleteRason ng kaartehan @1:23 wag kame!
Deleteiba iba nga. yung iba kasi may tinatawag na palusot o kaduwagan.
Delete1:23 iba-iba din ang palusot ng mga gagawa ng iskandalo na di kaya panindigan. Kaartehan lang yang sinasabi mo.
DeleteIto na naman ang mga gullible na commenters with their “iba-iba ang bawat pregancy” excuse. Kung yun nga nasa critical condition pwedeng i-airlift, siya pa kaya na nakapanganak na.
DeleteKung pwede nga siya magbiyahe eh kung hindi nga naman niya gusto? Sorry nalang saten na mga chismosa lang dito hahaha
Deletehindi nya gusto? edi diretso na sya sa korte.
DeleteOh ayan ateng Ellen, sa halip na spend mo time mo sa anak mo, ngaun mangunsime ka sa korte! Hinde lahat ng bagay nadadaan sa pagiging sikat at pera. Buti na lang laban kung laban talaga si mother dear.
ReplyDeleteMay ebidensya si Ellen hahhaa kaya d rin siya mag settle! Watch out for her comeback!
ReplyDeleteDream on inday! Nasaan na nga pala yung sinasabi niyang CCTV ng resto na kinainan nila? Ay oo nga pala, wala... walang ebidensya kaya NGANGA si tita Ellen lels
Delete3:33, paano mo nalaman na wala? Dahil hindi ipinakita sa media?
Delete8:06 kailangan ipakita yan sa media kung gusto nya maligtas.
Delete1:29, sa prosecutor ipinapakita iyan, hindi sa media.
DeleteSmh, some people here. Isip isip din puro hanash ng guilty until proven innocent??? Iba din naman magisip mga tao dito...There must be a reason why ellen will never apologise and wont settle... wait wait nalang tayo. Di pa natin alam ang details sa kampo ni ellen.
ReplyDeleteShe is a drama queen, feeling special kahit na hindi naman special.
DeleteHindi pala special pero nandito ka. Hahaha!
Deleteano naman kung andito kami? yung sitwasyon nya ang paespesyal sya noh.
DeleteIto na lang ang ganap sa buhay niya, wala na siyang publicity, the longer she drags this, the longer she will stay “in the scene”
DeleteSiguradong meron siyang ebidensiya. Kaya nga nag-file siya ng counter affidavit. Hahaba lang ito.
ReplyDeleteUnder age pa din yung binully ni Ellen sa social media. Paka bastos na tao nitong si Ellen. Tama yan, isa ka ng ina, tignan ko anong maramdaman mo pag may nang bully sa mga anak mo.
Deletehintayin na lang natin ang evidence ng bawat kampo.
DeleteI think pwede nilang ikatwiran na hindi nila alam na underage yung bata.
DeleteShe is disgusting. Seyempre she’ll be talked about for a while which is what she wants. More drama, attention and promo for her.
ReplyDeleteEllen will lose. She is the one who spread the “fake news”.
ReplyDeleteHAHAHA.. BURN!
ReplyDeleteAng sakin lang the girl can easily deny na she took more than one video. Siyempre and ilalabas niya lang yung video na mukang innocent.
ReplyDeleteMasyado lang hater mga tao and wants to think of ellen badly kaya walang naniniwala sakanya. But she is probably smart enough and aware enough as a celebrity so see kung sino ang talagang nag papap sakanya ng patago.
Agree ako na mali ung pag post niya ng minor sa IG niya, but I don't think the other girl is innocent as well.
Mali lang ni ellen sana inantay niya kung may lumabas nga na upload from the resto and tska sana siya rumesbak ng post niya.
2:29 Problema sa pinaglalaban mo teh wala kang ebidensya. Eto na ngang si Ellen kinukunan na din ng pic/video yung bata hindi naman nakikitang may paki sa saknya. Ni gulat wala, yung tipong sa akto nakunan. Walang mailalabas si Ellen kasi assumera lang sya!
DeleteAgree ako sayo 2:29
DeleteKahit anung anggulo MALI talaga si Ellen. Public place yun eh at common na sa mga tao to take picture kahit pagkain, ipost sa instagram or IG story hindi pinapalagpas syempre. at sino naman kataas taasang nagsasabi if ever na bawal mahagip si ellen ng cam? jusko pabida! wag syang feelingera.
Delete5:59, siguradong ikaw ang assumera. Ikaw ba ang lawyer, prosecutor or judge para ipakita sa iyo ang ebidensiya?
Delete- not 2:29
Agree with 229. Dont think the 'minor' is innocent
Delete2:19 mali ka. thinking is different with having the evidence. When you said, "I think..." mali ka na agad.
DeleteSus. Ang babaw honestly lang. Siguro kung di na nag file yung parents nung minor baka nakalimutan na & di na sana sha nato-trauma. Para naman sobrang injustice ginawa sa anak nila. Saka di nman na sha little kid para ma trauma diyan..if she felt na she was on the rigjt kahit pag usapan ka wala ka nman dapat ng patunayan. Pero since pinapa drag pa nila itong case parang lalo tuloy lumalaki & di maalis sa anak nila yung mapqg usapan. Kahit mali si ellen or not...give your "minor" a break na din from scrutiny and move on with her life diba?
ReplyDeleteHello diba may ig stories si ellen na nag hahamom pa na may evidence daw siya. Talaga gusto niya ng gulo she asked for it
DeleteSi nanay kasi sumagot, kaya nalaman ng mga tao kung sino si anak.
DeleteTindi ni 10:04 baluktot tlaga ang utak!
DeleteMababaw nman pala bakit hindi nlng tapusin ni Ellen? Kasi karapatan ng ina pagtanggol anak nya, why cant Ellen speak for herself? Kung wala lang toh edi matatapos na ang lahat.kung may gusto patunayan si Ellen ilabas nya.
Deleteyun na nga pinapahaba pa ni ellen eh. kaya lalo tumatagal! hindi nya pwede takasan ang batas. kung nakapagfile ang parents ni minor ibig sabihin may pinagalaban sila. ellen is super duwag.
DeleteKung duwag si Ellen, hindi siya magpa-file ng counter affidavit.
DeleteSana hindi panigan si Ellen dito. Talagang mali ang ginawa nya kahit ano pang sabihin ng fans nya.
ReplyDeleteLaw versus feelings. Law must be it.
Delete