He should've just private messaged Bamboo about that. What mind of birthday greeting is that? He really needed to include that and bring it up again? If Bamboo is still upset or just doesn't want to make up with the person that's his decision. Don't ruin a dude's bday by bringing up old issues.
Korek. Hindi dapat samahan ng intriga ang b-day wish, dahil supposedly your sending "well wishes" to the person with the b-day. Eh, yung ganyan may halong "shade" na tinatawag. Bad si Mark Escueta.
Ano bang issue nila ma google nga jusko elementary pa kasi ako nung nanvyari yan but i like bamboo an rico blanco diko na naabutan yung banda days nila, one day magkikita yang mga yab na parang wala lang pag uugo ugo na sila
Rico & Bamboo are ok now. they're civil with each other. As with Nathan & Bamboo issue, Nathan got really upset when B quit 'Bamboo' the band. They tried to continue after B left pero di na sila pumatok. Kaya galit na galit si N at siniraan ng husto si B sa FB.
Itong Mark Escueta na ito sama ng ugali talaga! Una sinisiraan yung dating ka-grupo nila na sumali sa The Voice na si Jason Fernandez ngayon sumasawsaw naman kay Bamboo!
yung mga nagmamagaling diyan. naging bandmates pa uli si bamboo at nathan nung bamboo days, nung nag-comeback si bamboo. tigilan ninyo yung elementary days ninyo pa nangyari. iba naka-away ni bamboo noon kaya siya umalis ng rivermaya. sila ni nathan, bamboo days nang magka-away.
Ang issue ay hindi sa band ng Rivermaya. Nung nadisband ang Rivermaya at nagsolo so Rico Blanco, bumuo ng banda sila Bamboo, Nathan, Ira Cruz (bf ni Mylene Dizon) at Vic (can't remember the last time) ng band na "Bamboo". Sometime in 2012 nagdecide bigla si Bamboo na magsolo. Biglaan although ang press release ni Bamboo ay nagkaroon sila ng meeting amongst his band mates. Naoffend si Nathan kasi after madisband, kinanta pa rin ni Bamboo ang mga songs ng banda na naging tatak pa nya like "Hallelujah" "Pinoy Ako". These songs were never written by Bamboo. Kaya nasaktan si Nathan. Unlike nung time ni Rico with Rivermaya, si Rico talaga sumulat ng mga songs ng Rivermaya banda. Kaya Rico has nothing to do with the issue...
hindi ba parang ganyan din effect when he left river maya? not sure kung may similar issue sila ni rico but among the fans nagkaroon ng rico vs. bamboo thing because the songs that got popular got associated with bamboo too but where never written by him but all were written by rico?
1:38 No he didn't! Nathan wrote the song Noypi way before their band Bamboo existed. It was supposed to be sung by Karl Roy for his band Kapatid but he turned it down.
daming talak mga bes, kahit hindi sinulat yun ni Bamboo, we should gave him a credit. dahil boses nya yung tumatak at nakilala ng tao. eh di sige pakantahin yan si nathan na yan. tingnan natin kung sisikat yung mga songs.
So sumikat si bamboo dahil sa mga kanta na sinulat ni Nathan na hinde siya na Credit? Ganun ba kaya sila nag apat? So hinde magaling na composer si bamboo? Sorry dami questions
pasensya na 3:44 but the beauty of the songs still gets to me kahit hindi si Bamboo ang kumanta hindi exclusive sa boses ni Bamboo ang ganda ng mga kantang yun. For example yung 214 may ibang angle din sa version ni rico. Bamboo tard lang kayo.
Bamboo the band tried to carry on after B left the group. Nathan even did the solo part sa mga gigs nila. Kinanta nya hits nila pero di pumatok sa tao kasi identified na nga kay B yung mga songs. And useless to continue the band kasi nga Bamboo pero wala na naman si Bamboo, so to most people, it doesn't make sense anymore kaya wala silang choice kundi mag disband. Yun ang tingin kong isa sa reasons why galit na galit si N kay B. On B's part, from what I know, di na nya gusto yung nangyayari sa group kasi walang gig/concert na di lasing yung ibang kabanda nya. If you check some of the videos of their last gigs together, you can see N na lasing habang tumutugtog, and B being visibly upset about it.
Nathan wrote most of Bamboo the band songs, Rico wrote most of the Rivermaya songs. Bamboo has a great voice, but when he went solo wala na siyang kanta na tumatak because he doesn't write well.
Thank you 3:07. 2:00AM is also right. Mark Escueta's inclusion of an old issue on a birthday greeting is in bad taste. Just greet the person and do not add negative comments. Bad joke or outright malicious?
Meron bang royalties system sa Pinas katulad sa Hollywood regarding songwriting? Dapat songwriters sa Pinas set for life na kung marami silang kanta na hits at tinitugtog pa hanggang ngayon.
Di ko magets kung bakit hindi pde kantahin ng dating singer ang isang kanta na pinasikat nya? behind the camera lang ang composer, pero frontman pa din ang singer right? dun tyo sa issue ni nathan, kung talagang mahusay sya at may karisma sa tao, bakit hindi n lang sya ang nag frontman ng bamboo band? then, check natin kung kaya nyang pasikatin. i doubt mga bes.
3:49 copyright issues. technically, if you wrote those songs, you own them. if sang them, well, you just sang them pero di pag may-aari ang kanta. and please, stop saying "behind the camera lang ang composer". the composers are very vital to the music industry. they are the backbones of the existence of the singers. without their songs, the singers have nothing to sing.
because nathan did something big to bamboo, and don't push him to do the thing that he dont want..somethimes forgiving people takes time,,he caused a big wound to him, let time heal fix it.. dont tell because it's birthday or anything.. bamboo showered by good karma and i love him so much! hahahahahaha
I think Mark Escueta meant well, siguro gusto na talaga nyang magkabati yung dalawa kaya pabiro nyang hinirit. Tama naman sya matatanda na sila so forgive and forget na.
Ganito kasi yan mga bes, twice ng nangiwan si Bamboo. Swerte siya iconic mga kanta ng banda niya. Yes maganda boses niya, kaya nga puros cover nalang siya ngayon eh. But if it weren't for his former band mates he won't be called rock maestro, siguro mga ka linya niya si Jed Madella, same sila maganda boses. For the record, siya tumawag kay Nathan humingi ng tulong before siya umuwi ng pinas from the states��
have u heard bamboo's songs, very poetic and profound which ganun din sya in person. halos lahat ng kanta sa bamboo sya nagsulat. hindi lang sya bragging.
8:45 you must be referring to rico blanco who is a great lyricist. bambo's lyrics ate is ok lang but not great. but he is a vey passionate singer kaya keri na. sa totoo lang minsan di ko maintindihan si bamboo pag kumakanta unless i already know the lyrics to what he is singing.
Inggit. Wala kasing career
ReplyDeletebased sa fb post, d ko magetz bakit may inggit anon 12:18am pki explain
DeleteSad life ka bes
DeleteHe's just teasing and trying to make them friends again, ganun Diba ?
DeleteJolens will not like this
Deletewala nman akong na-sens na inggit sha
DeleteInggit talaga? Naggreet na nga inggit pa din? Diba pwede dinaan na lang sa biro para maging ok sila.
DeleteBakit? Anong meron?
ReplyDeleteHaha 7 years old pa lang kasi si Bamboo. Pagbigyan. Lol
ReplyDeletealways a rivermaya fan..
ReplyDeletenakakalungkot naman dahil sobrang fan nila ako since 1995 grade 2 ako nun, sana maayos pa tapos reunion with bamboo and rico sa philippine area
ReplyDeleteANong ganap?
ReplyDeleteCan't blame Bamboo... grabe ang accusations ni Nathan sa kanya dati. He even posted it on FB para sirain si B. Good thing dedma lang si B about it.
ReplyDeleteAno po ba ang issue? Kaya ba nagbreak ang Rivermaya? Yung mga last years na lang ni Rico Blanco as frontman ang naabutan kong era ng Rivermaya eh.
Delete1:06 money matters (based sa fb post before ni Nathan)
Deleteeto iyung tampuhan/away na hindi na talaga naka moved on ang mga involved. elementary pa ako nung issue ito, hanggang ngayon hindi pa din nagkaayos
ReplyDeleteMagbati na kayo ang tatanda na nyo.
ReplyDeletenagka-edad lang pero ang iba sa kanila, immature pa rin, tulad ni rico na hanggang ngayon, walwal pa rin.
DeleteHe should've just private messaged Bamboo about that. What mind of birthday greeting is that? He really needed to include that and bring it up again? If Bamboo is still upset or just doesn't want to make up with the person that's his decision. Don't ruin a dude's bday by bringing up old issues.
ReplyDeletetrue. panira din ng birthday etong mark.
Deletetama ngayon dami pa tuloy naiintriga..
Deletemapipilitan pa si bamboo makipagbati e birthday nga nya
DeleteKorek. Hindi dapat samahan ng intriga ang b-day wish, dahil supposedly your sending "well wishes" to the person with the b-day. Eh, yung ganyan may halong "shade" na tinatawag. Bad si Mark Escueta.
DeleteAno bang issue nila ma google nga jusko elementary pa kasi ako nung nanvyari yan but i like bamboo an rico blanco diko na naabutan yung banda days nila, one day magkikita yang mga yab na parang wala lang pag uugo ugo na sila
ReplyDeleteRico & Bamboo are ok now. they're civil with each other. As with Nathan & Bamboo issue, Nathan got really upset when B quit 'Bamboo' the band. They tried to continue after B left pero di na sila pumatok. Kaya galit na galit si N at siniraan ng husto si B sa FB.
DeleteGrabe naman ang mga'to. Mag-move on na kayo. Be a better man.
ReplyDeleteEasier said than done.
Deletetrue. masyadong malalim ang issue ni Nathan at B.
DeleteA Rivermaya reunion with Bamboo & Rico will surely rock the concert scene.
ReplyDeleteItong Mark Escueta na ito sama ng ugali talaga! Una sinisiraan yung dating ka-grupo nila na sumali sa The Voice na si Jason Fernandez ngayon sumasawsaw naman kay Bamboo!
ReplyDeletekorek! kya wala rin ngtatagan na vocalist ng rivermaya dahil dw sa ugali nito
Deleteyung mga nagmamagaling diyan. naging bandmates pa uli si bamboo at nathan nung bamboo days, nung nag-comeback si bamboo. tigilan ninyo yung elementary days ninyo pa nangyari. iba naka-away ni bamboo noon kaya siya umalis ng rivermaya. sila ni nathan, bamboo days nang magka-away.
ReplyDelete259am, that's why you tell the story of what happened because not everyone knows about their alleged away issue.
DeleteBaka naman elementary talaga sila nung nag Bamboo band si Nathan at hindi Rimermaya
DeleteAng issue ay hindi sa band ng Rivermaya. Nung nadisband ang Rivermaya at nagsolo so Rico Blanco, bumuo ng banda sila Bamboo, Nathan, Ira Cruz (bf ni Mylene Dizon) at Vic (can't remember the last time) ng band na "Bamboo". Sometime in 2012 nagdecide bigla si Bamboo na magsolo. Biglaan although ang press release ni Bamboo ay nagkaroon sila ng meeting amongst his band mates. Naoffend si Nathan kasi after madisband, kinanta pa rin ni Bamboo ang mga songs ng banda na naging tatak pa nya like "Hallelujah" "Pinoy Ako". These songs were never written by Bamboo. Kaya nasaktan si Nathan. Unlike nung time ni Rico with Rivermaya, si Rico talaga sumulat ng mga songs ng Rivermaya banda. Kaya Rico has nothing to do with the issue...
ReplyDeleteStill inappropriate parin to post a birthday greeting with that kind of message. He could've just sent a personal message.
DeleteOh my ! It make sense since after hallelujah and pinoy ako wla n syang hit songs since di nmn pala sya nag sulat .
Deletehindi ba parang ganyan din effect when he left river maya? not sure kung may similar issue sila ni rico but among the fans nagkaroon ng rico vs. bamboo thing because the songs that got popular got associated with bamboo too but where never written by him but all were written by rico?
DeleteThank you 3:07! Ikaw lang sumagot sa mga katanungan ng lahat.
Deleteare u kidding me, bamboo wrote most of bamboo (band songs) esp the english ones. mr. clay, much has been said, truth.. etc
DeleteNo, sorry to burst your bubble. Mr. clay, much has been said and truth was written by Nathan.
Deleteyan 8:28 kaya galit si Nathan. people actually think Bamboo wrote those great songs with impact. Of course Bamboo does not bother to give credit
Deletewrong! Bamboo wrote those songs...
Deletewrong! Bamboo wrote those songs...
Delete1:38 No he didn't! Nathan wrote the song Noypi way before their band Bamboo existed. It was supposed to be sung by Karl Roy for his band Kapatid but he turned it down.
Deletedaming talak mga bes, kahit hindi sinulat yun ni Bamboo, we should gave him a credit. dahil boses nya yung tumatak at nakilala ng tao. eh di sige pakantahin yan si nathan na yan. tingnan natin kung sisikat yung mga songs.
DeleteSo sumikat si bamboo dahil sa mga kanta na sinulat ni Nathan na hinde siya na Credit? Ganun ba kaya sila nag apat? So hinde magaling na composer si bamboo? Sorry dami questions
DeleteAnu issue ni Rico and Nathan naman bakit hinde sila okay?
DeleteFriends si Nathan at Rico, wala silang issue
Deletepasensya na 3:44 but the beauty of the songs still gets to me kahit hindi si Bamboo ang kumanta hindi exclusive sa boses ni Bamboo ang ganda ng mga kantang yun. For example yung 214 may ibang angle din sa version ni rico. Bamboo tard lang kayo.
DeleteBamboo the band tried to carry on after B left the group. Nathan even did the solo part sa mga gigs nila. Kinanta nya hits nila pero di pumatok sa tao kasi identified na nga kay B yung mga songs. And useless to continue the band kasi nga Bamboo pero wala na naman si Bamboo, so to most people, it doesn't make sense anymore kaya wala silang choice kundi mag disband. Yun ang tingin kong isa sa reasons why galit na galit si N kay B. On B's part, from what I know, di na nya gusto yung nangyayari sa group kasi walang gig/concert na di lasing yung ibang kabanda nya. If you check some of the videos of their last gigs together, you can see N na lasing habang tumutugtog, and B being visibly upset about it.
DeleteOhh thanks anon 3:07
ReplyDeleteEtong si Nathan lahat inaaway pati si Ocho Toleran inaaway
ReplyDeleteNathan wrote most of Bamboo the band songs, Rico wrote most of the Rivermaya songs. Bamboo has a great voice, but when he went solo wala na siyang kanta na tumatak because he doesn't write well.
ReplyDeleteThank you 3:07. 2:00AM is also right. Mark Escueta's inclusion of an old issue on a birthday greeting is in bad taste. Just greet the person and do not add negative comments. Bad joke or outright malicious?
ReplyDeleteMeron bang royalties system sa Pinas katulad sa Hollywood regarding songwriting? Dapat songwriters sa Pinas set for life na kung marami silang kanta na hits at tinitugtog pa hanggang ngayon.
ReplyDeletemeron din syang post kay Rico Blanco! hahahaha nakakatuwa
ReplyDeleteDi ko magets kung bakit hindi pde kantahin ng dating singer ang isang kanta na pinasikat nya? behind the camera lang ang composer, pero frontman pa din ang singer right? dun tyo sa issue ni nathan, kung talagang mahusay sya at may karisma sa tao, bakit hindi n lang sya ang nag frontman ng bamboo band? then, check natin kung kaya nyang pasikatin. i doubt mga bes.
ReplyDelete3:49 copyright issues. technically, if you wrote those songs, you own them. if sang them, well, you just sang them pero di pag may-aari ang kanta. and please, stop saying "behind the camera lang ang composer". the composers are very vital to the music industry. they are the backbones of the existence of the singers. without their songs, the singers have nothing to sing.
Deletebecause nathan did something big to bamboo, and don't push him to do the thing that he dont want..somethimes forgiving people takes time,,he caused a big wound to him, let time heal fix it.. dont tell because it's birthday or anything..
ReplyDeletebamboo showered by good karma and i love him so much! hahahahahaha
I think Mark Escueta meant well, siguro gusto na talaga nyang magkabati yung dalawa kaya pabiro nyang hinirit. Tama naman sya matatanda na sila so forgive and forget na.
ReplyDeleteGanito kasi yan mga bes, twice ng nangiwan si Bamboo. Swerte siya iconic mga kanta ng banda niya. Yes maganda boses niya, kaya nga puros cover nalang siya ngayon eh. But if it weren't for his former band mates he won't be called rock maestro, siguro mga ka linya niya si Jed Madella, same sila maganda boses. For the record, siya tumawag kay Nathan humingi ng tulong before siya umuwi ng pinas from the states��
ReplyDeletehave u heard bamboo's songs, very poetic and profound which ganun din sya in person. halos lahat ng kanta sa bamboo sya nagsulat. hindi lang sya bragging.
ReplyDeleteSiya ba talaga nagsulat nun o si Rico Blanco
Delete8:45 you must be referring to rico blanco who is a great lyricist. bambo's
Deletelyrics ate is ok lang but not great. but he is a vey passionate singer kaya keri na. sa totoo lang minsan di ko maintindihan si bamboo pag kumakanta unless i already know the lyrics to what he is singing.
Husband pala ito ni ateng Jolina Magdangal si Mark Escueta.
ReplyDelete