Image courtesy of www.kickerdaily.com
Source: www.gmanetwork.com
In a 35-page resolution, the Comelec second division said it voted 3-0 in favor of the petition filed by lawyer Estrella Elamparo, who is seeking the cancellation of Poe's certificate of candidacy for president.
The division sided with Elamparo's argument that Poe failed to meet the 10-year residency requirement mandated by the Constitution for a presidential candidate.
"Wherefore, in view of all the foregoing considerations, the instant Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel Certificate of Candidacy is hereby granted," the division said in its resolution.
"Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy for President of the Republic of the Philippines in the May 9, 2016 National and Local Elections filed by respondent Mary Grace Natividad Sonora Poe Llamanzares is hereby cancelled," it added.
The members of the division are Commissioners Al Parreño, Arthur Lim, and Sheriff Abas.
Poe's running mate, Sen. Francis Escudero, confirmed that she was disqualified by the Comelec second division, saying he received the information 10 minutes ago, but did not provide additional details.
The Comelec division said Poe, who was leading in various pre-election surveys on presidentiables, became a resident only on July 2006 when she applied for dual citizenship, or two months short of meeting the 10-year residency rule.
The division also said Poe "deliberately attempted to mislead or misinform the electorate or hide a fact from them when she supplied the answer '10 yeras and 11 months' to the question" on her period of residence in the Philippines in her COC.
Meanwhile, Poe's lawyers insisted that she became a resident in May 2005, according to a report on "24 Oras."
Poe's camp said they will appeal the decision with the Comelec en banc.
Elamparo's petition was just one of the four petitions seeking to disqualify Poe from the presidential race.
mabuti naman. Magandang balita
ReplyDeleteYeheyyyyy!
DeleteDi bale Grace, nagre-rating high naman ang Probinsiyano ng tatay mo, hehehe ;))
DeleteWhat now, CHIZ?
DeleteI told you! Hahahaha she failed to meet the 10 year requirement AND CHIZ "TRAPO" ESCUDERO KNEW THIS BECAUSE HE IS A LAWYER. Haha wag kasing masyadong ambisyosa/o. ANG DAMI PA NAMAN NILANG BUDGET (c/o ninongs ni Chiz sa kasal-kasalan nila ni Heart) NI ESCUDERO SA INFOMERCIALS.
DeleteHahah natawa naman ako sa probinsyano comment. Isa lang alam ko, si Grace ang pinakamaswerteng ampon sa balat ng lupa. Pero Grace DON'T PUSH YOUR LUCK TOO MUCH. Hilaw na hilaw ka pa kumbaga sa sinaing.
DeleteTuwang tuwa si ate Sheryl! Dance for joy for sure... hehe
DeleteHinde pa naman talaga Nya Na complete Ang residency eh. Tama Lang ang decision. No one should be above the law. Bravo comelec!
DeletePutcha, dual citizen pa sya nun inumpisahan residency counting nya??? that's big bullsh*t, di ba dapat counting from Filipino 'only' citizen onwards? anyways, why are we even considering her to be a President of Philippines, when she at one point in her life renounced her Filipino citizenship, tapos yun husband & children nya puro American citizen. that's like having a Philippine President with First Family who are American citizens. kalokohan yan, grabeh nakakatawa tlga sa buong mundo pag nanalo sya!
DeleteHindi niya nacomplete ang residency. What about the requirements when she ran for senator ? Can someone please explain. Kasi dito, iba ang rules.
DeleteMasyado naman kasing epal. Wait ka muna ateng hilaw na hilaw ka pa.
DeleteTHANK YOU!!!
DeleteIt took them long enough.
@7:13am, ang requirements po kasi for a senatorial candidate isnat least 2 years residency.
DeleteShe needs at least 10 years of residency to qualify as a president. 7 years pa lang sya resident sa philippines.
shocking news. si grace poe ang number one sa survey. ngayon wala na siya lumaki ang chance manalo ng ibang candidate.
ReplyDeleteOkay nga yan habang maaga pa. Magbaback out kasi dapat siya next year. PI nya!
DeleteMagbaback out na rin nyan si Duterte kc ok na ang desisyon kay Poe
DeleteIkaw na lang anon 12:04AM ang mag-back out!
DeleteTingnan mo nga naman, tama ako ahahaha!
ReplyDeleteMasyado kasing ambisyosa.
ReplyDeletemarami kasi nag uudyok
Deletepagpatuloy na lang ni Grace Poe ang pagiging action star ng tatay nya. kasi yun naman talaga ang sinimulan ng tatay nya.di ba?
ReplyDelete-chaRRing Tatum
7:30 I'm also against Grace running as president but your comment is purely kab*b*han!
Delete7:30 iskwakwa ang tono mo 'Day! Huwag mo na idamay ang tatay na namayapa na!
DeleteLakas ng tawa q dito! 😂
DeleteCool!
Delete8:18 and 8:20, I think charring tatum (LOL) said that kasi on one speech Grace Poe said gusto lang nya ituloy yung sinumulan ng father nya.
DeleteThe humor is lost on some people. Ako lakas mg tawa ko
Delete@8:20 day, kay grace mismo nanggaling yung sinabi ni charring tatum lol. kaloka ka
DeleteCharring Tatum is on point! Her father never held a government position , her father was an action star. Therefore her father's legacy is making action movies. Kung gusto niyang ipagpatuloy go ahead by all means.
DeleteThe law is harsh but that is the law
ReplyDeleteTroot!
DeleteCan chiz run alone or kailangan may partido?
ReplyDeletemainit ulo ni chiz. balak pa naman nya tsaka nya ipapadisqualify kapag nanalo na... joke lang chiz at heart! baka nagbabasa kayo dito hahaha.
DeleteHe can still run. Independent na siya.
DeleteHahha lol oo nga no para kung sila nanalo at baka madisqualify si Poe eh di sya na ang presidente !
DeleteNatumbok mo 12:46. Buti na lang na disqualify ng maaga si grace, kaysa naman mag uumpisa na ang eleeksyon or nanalo na siya saka pa ma disqualify.
DeletePatay kang CHIZ ka!!!
DeletePano mo nalaman? - chez en hak
DeleteIf di sya naging super ambisyosa, at nag run na lang for VP, im sure di siya pinuputakte ng mga kasong ganyan ngayon.
ReplyDeletePardon my ignorance. Tamad din ako mag-google. Wala bang residency requirement ang VP? Or meron pero shorter than 10 years?
Deletenagpabuyo kc kay chiz.
Delete12:41 kashungahan tlga, dapat hindi lng 10years residency kundi 25years! hello pinakamataas na position yan President at VP sa Pilipinas, mahiya nman kayu sa balat nyu kun nangibang bayan na pala kayu tapos nagaambisyon pa kyu maging Presidente ng basang to!
Deletefor Anon 12:41
DeleteQualification for Philippine President and Vice-President:
1. natural born citizen of the Philippines
2. registered voter
3. able to read and write
4. at least 40 years of age on the day of election
5. resident of the Philippines for at least 10 years immediately preceding the election.
8:12 nag pauto kasi sa makesong salita.
Delete12:41, you cannot be a president, vp and senator if you are not a natural born citizen. At least that's as far as I know. Kaya palaisipan kung pano nakalusot iyan sa senado. Another case of 'kung walang nakapansin, pupuwede'?
DeleteAnon 5.03.. 2 yrs lang ang required residency for Senator
DeleteRequired residency yes 12:18. But candidate should be natural born Filipino, not naturalized. Tama ba?
DeleteWith this latest deveIopment, I bet all the other presidential candidates are smiling ear to ear.
ReplyDeleteSomeone somewhere in Manila is doing the dance of joy. May pag asa na daw ang manok niya. Yehey, abswelto na siya sa mga kaso pagtapos ng termino niya.
DeleteButi nga! Ambisosyang froglet! Ipagpatuloy mo na ang sinimulan ni FPJ. Mag-artista ka na.
ReplyDeleteAw!! Im no for Grace Poe but this news saddened me. Better luck next time Grace. More experience pa. I know your good but lack of experience and strengthen your personality pa. Maybe in 2022.
ReplyDeleteHay salamat naman. Lakas ng loob tumakbo wala pa naman napapatunayan.
ReplyDeleteWow ha. Makapagpasalamat kala moh isa xa sa kalaban ni Grace.
Delete8:33 I am with you
Deletenagpadala sa survey at sulsol ni Cheese
Ayoko kay Grace nung panahon na nagiingay ang INC at nagcause ng matinding traffic hindi
Deleteman lang sya pumalag
9:33 inform yourself. Hindi porke ayaw kay Grace Poe para sa ibang kandidato na. Malay mo para siya sa bayan. Nung una gusto ko din siya. Matapang sa mga committee, that was what set her apart initially, tapos nadikit kay Chiz na sobrang biased, look up what Chiz did sa hearing kay Bobby Ongpin. Saka wala pa din talagang naiauthor na batas ang lola mo. Ni draft man lang.
DeletePoe is not yet ready to run the country anyway. Just to add, to comelec, kailangan pa ba talagang may mag file muna ng petition to disqualify ang isang hindi qualified na candidate bago ito idisqualify?
ReplyDeleteKaya nga, nabalita na un conflicting COC nya. Di man lng inaksyonan kagad ng comelec, hinintayboa talagang may magreklamo. Sa susunod kasi baguhin un reqt ng vp and pres.
DeleteHindi nila pwede basta aksyonan. Kapag filing ng coc all they can do is to receive the coc nothing more. Kapag determination ng nuisance candidates hindi rin nila pwede DQ si Poe kasi hindi siya nuisance. Kaya kelangan ng petition for DQ para maaksyunan nila. Thats the process. Good decision Comelec.
DeleteNaku, baka umatras na si Duterte nito. Miriam, Mar, at Binay ang maiiwan. Well, kahit naman sino ang manalo, we are doomed. Unhealthy vs Meh vs MehMeh
ReplyDeleteGood news yan para sa kapakanan ng lahat ng Filipino. Malamang nagtititili si Keso sa dismaya upon hearing that news no? So anong Plan B mo Keso? Puro kamalasan ang dumating sa iyo since naging kayo ni Heart db? Wellllll, pareho naman kasi kayong "bad" eh ;)
ReplyDeleteD ba siya ang may ideya ng binay pnoy tandem dati? Sa tingin mo kanino siya papanig ngayon?
DeleteNaturned-off ako kay Chiz ng nag Noy-Nay siya kasi alam mong may nilulutong kalokohan, kahit sinong manalong VP wag lang si Cheese!!! Leni R na lang.
DeleteHay mabuti naman. Masyado pa syang raw para magpresidente. Papauto kasi sa mga nakapaligid sa kanya eh!
ReplyDeletekaya nga hindi sya fit maging presidente akalain mo nauto sya ni chiz. na kung tutuusin alam ng lahat ng LP dapat sya. dba nga may part na sabi dati na hinubog nila si grace para humalili pero tinalikuran sila. though okey lang tumalikod sa kanila pero sana ang dahilan ay may sarili siayng paninindigan,hindi dahil may nagsulsol lang.
DeleteSabi ng kampo nila e si Susan Roces daw ang magiging substitute kapag na-disqualify si Grace. Pero sabi ng Comelec bago lumabas itong decision na ito ay hindi daw puwede magkaroon ng substitution kay Grace dahil sa nagka-karoon lang daw ng substitute kapag same ng partido. e di ba tumatakbo as independent si Grace Poe at wala ata siyang partido kaya hindi daw siya puwede.
ReplyDeleteJuicecolored. Magaling na aktres si ma'am susan, pero hanggang doon na lang. Huwag nang gawing mala Tita Cory part 2 ang peg.
Delete''you've stolen the presidency, not just twice, but thrice!!!''
ReplyDeleteweh
DeleteMagiging president yan si grace in the future kung di nag pasulsol kay chiz ng tumakbo agad kung nag vp muna siya
Deleteok lang naman maging presidente si Grace pero sana wag muna ngayon. masyado pa maaga for her. tapos un family nya american citizen padin tapos anu un kapag nanalo tsaka lang nila igigive up ang pagiging american citizen?
ReplyDeletesabi ng kampo ni grace parang iaapila pa nila yung case so tignan natin. pero for me mas naniniwala ka dapat madisqualify sya dahil khit sa SET ba yun? yun 3 justice dun bumoto para madisqualify sya eh.nanalo lang sya dun gawa ng 5 senador na bumoto sa kanya.
Too ambitious girl...
ReplyDeleteYes way too ambitious and ignorant of the law. One inexperienced person down . I hope the Filipino people will be smart about their choices.
DeleteAmbitious at uto uto kay chiz.
DeleteAyan! Naniwala kasi kay chiz.
ReplyDeleteKaya nga. Nagpauto kasi kay Chiz yan tuloy nabokya in the end.
Deletekorek
DeleteImagine the millions of pesos spent for her campaign, tv ads, appearances. Sana ginamit na lang pantulong sa mga nangangailangan. Kung gusto niyang pagpatuloy sinimulan ni FPJ ganun gawin niya, her dad helped without ever letting the public know. Saka na yang presidency, you're a good person Mrs. Llamanzares, I just hope you'd find you and grow a pair. Be firm and consistent.
DeleteSo backout na si Duterte?
ReplyDeleteafter fpj died, nagulat ako bigla sumulpot itong si Grace galing amerika sa kamalayan ng pilipino tapos after a short period tatakbo for presidency??? i dont know her, i dont know her husband baka ala first gentleman arroyo yan, at di ko rin like anak nya na bigla na lang sumulpot sa presscon ni jasmine curtis at binulabog lahat just because he is grace poe's son
ReplyDeletebakat tumakbo si chiz for presidency nito, now that's a big twist in this never ending saga
walang POErever :((
ReplyDeleteambisyosa kasi...hilaw pa sya...wag muna ngaun!
ReplyDelete-xoxo-
I am rooting for Mar Roxas. He was my boss so I can vouch for his character and credentials. He works hard. Far from corrupt. In fact, he wanted to know where every cent goes to. He values transparency and everything has to be accounted for. He has high hopes and great vision for his country. You can see his passion and dedication as public servant.
ReplyDeletetalaga lang ha .... sino ang maniniwala na ganyan sya?
Deleteplease tell him to hire a good PR man or to repackage him nagmumukha syang trying hard sa pinanggagawa nya. i have no question about his intentions, sagwa lang ng pinanggagawa nya
DeleteBetter luck next time Grace. Next time huag masyadong naniniwala Kay chiz.. Madaldal masyado...
ReplyDeletemataas ang lipad ng saranggola ni poepe
ReplyDeletenatawa ako dito :-)
DeleteNagmamadali kasi..di naman talaga qualified!
ReplyDeletebe careful what you wish for Grace Poe
ReplyDeleteit will hit you smack in your face
Look here, I thought many are really pro-Grace. Kase diva laging top sa mga surveys.I also thought ako lang may reservations sa kanya as candidate for president.
ReplyDeleteBut really, am ok with the Comelec's decision. To think 3-0. So in letter of the law talagang di sya qualified.
Ambisyosa kase...
It's not meant to be.
ReplyDeleteKulang ka ng residency maliwang pa sa sikat ng araw. Alangan namang bilangin pagtira mo dito nung foreigner ka pa. Masyado kasing nagmadali. Ayan paano pag dineklara ka ng SC na hindi natural born. Tanggal ka na sa Senado hindi ka pa pwedeng tumakbog Presidente kahit kailan. Takbo ka na lang mayor sa San Juan o QC. Di na kailangang natural born dun. lol
ReplyDeleteSa mga past interviews nya sabi nya kong ididisqualify sya at susundin ang batas at tatanggapin nya bat ngayon umaapela na?
ReplyDeleteNever say die ang motto niya.
Deletesayang daw kasi komersyal kung mababalewala
DeleteBUTII NGA!!!! ANG THICK NG FEZ PARA MAG PRESIDENT, KAPALLLLLLLLLLL
ReplyDeleteBeing on TOP of the surveys doesn't guarantee that majority of Filipinos will vote for you. What has Grace done for the country anyway? MTRCB? Artista fame of her adopted father? She always insists in every speech that she will FINISH what her father started in 2004.
ReplyDeleteQuestion is: What did your adopted father start in 2004? Running for the presidency? He was never an elective or appointive public official. He had no experience in government service.
What could have been his contributions? We never heard him speak eloquently in discussing different national issues, policies and arguments.
Lastly, Grace should stop using her father as an excuse to run for the presidency because there was never a BEGINNING in the first place. Grace misled the Filipino public in her citizenship and residency issues. Those are the real and legal issues.
Maganda sanang laban kung kasali siya sa Presidential candidates! Miriam or Duterte tlga pinagpipilian ko pero dahil unang pagboto ko Tatay ko tatanungin ko kung sino.
ReplyDeleteWrong dear, you have your own mind and rights, vote for your president whom you think will serve you today and in the future rightfully and truthfully. Exercise your right, exercise your freedom to choose, you may ask your tatay but decide on your own. Orty!
DeleteDuterte ka nalang teh. Miriam will not win. May health issues pa.
Deletehindi nya kayang i-appeal ito sa supreme court after nya i-criticize yung 3 supreme court justices who voted not in her favor, after her disqualification case before the Senate electoral tribunal was denied. ngyon comelec na nag disqualify sa kanya. vindicated ang mga SC justices. kulang pa sya sa residency ang di pa nya na-prove na natural born citizen sya. Tama yung pinsan nyang si Sheryl Cruz, now is not the time for her to run. vindicated din sya.
ReplyDeletekaya nga eh nganga ang 5 na senador bumoto pabor sa kanya. alam na para lang sa kapakanan din nila(5 senador) un. kaya duda talaga sa nangyari sa SET dahil ang 3 justice ay pabor madisqualify at big deal un kung tutuusin
DeleteIpalit na lang si Alma! Alma/Chiz na tayo!
ReplyDeleteOmg! Walang pag asa ang pinas baks!
DeletePanalo toh! Haha #winner
DeleteVERY.. GOOD.. NEWS. Best news to start my day that Poe got disqualified to run for President. Imagine mo naman, diretso syang tumakbo for Senator back in 2010. Wala din syang pinag-kaiba nina Bong Revilla Jinggoy, o ang bug*k na si Tito Sotto na mga hindi dumaan sa lower level na govt positions. From artista to Senado! Kapaaaaal talaga. Ito naman si Poe humugot sa kasikatan ni Panday, nanalo out of sympathy votes. Walang hiya talaga.
ReplyDelete1:41am Ok na sana comment mo. sorry Pero nagreasearch ka ba bago ka magalit? Yung mga binanggit mo sila tito sotto, bong at jinggoy nagstart sila sa local position. Hindi sila artista tapos straight to senate kaloka!
DeleteTama ka dian
DeleteAy, 1:41 AM bata ka pa. Hindi mo na inabot yung pagiging vice mayor at mayor ni Tito Sotto. Opo, nanggaling sya dun. At isa pa, hindi mo ba alam na pamilya sila ng mga pulitiko, matagal na? In fact, isa ang lolo nilang si Vicente Sotto (the first) sa mga miyembro ng Asemblea noong panahon ng pagtatayo ng Commonwealth government. Mag-aral kasi wag puro showbiz!
Deletemiriam magaling lang magsalita.. ang tagal ng senator. wala naman akong nakitang ginawa nya kung di maghighblood sa senado.. kaya duterte na lang ako..
ReplyDeleteOhooooy excuse me!!! Marami yang batas na sinulat at pinasa! Huwag kang magmarunong. Research din pag may time ha! She's not a brilliant lawyer for nothing at hindi rin siya pinili bilang ICC judge dahil sa wala.
DeleteI want to vote for Miriam. Her mind can take the challenge but her health might not handle the pressure.
FYI, isa sa pinakamasipag na senador po sya. Authored and co-authored hundreds of laws. Malamang sa bawat araw ng buhay mo, nakikinabang ka sa isa sa mga batas na pinangunahan nya itaguyod pero dahil iba ang konsepto mo ng "nagawa" o "dapat ginagawa" ng isang senador, hindi mo ito alam. Kung hindi ka masyado aware sa functions ng isang senador, ipinapaalala ko po na primordial dyan ang pagsasalita lalo sa deliberations nila at balitaktakan. Kung walang Miriam, malamang madaming walang kwentang batas na naipasa ang mga mandarambong sa gobyerno. She's the counterbalancer in the Senate. KONTRAPELO IN A GOOD WAY. Sa legislature po kabilang si miriam kaya hndi tangible o kongkretong imprastruktura ang mga nagawa nya. Kaya kung hindi ka masyadong aware sa mga batas ng Pilipinas o kung sino nag-author o co-author nito, tahimik na lang po, okay?
DeleteSi Miriam kasi hindi epal kaya hindi mo masyadong alam ang mga nagawa niya. Un anti-signage of public works bill AKA anti-epal bill at anti-political dynasty bill, author sya nun. Di nyo ba naobserve na di pa sya nglilibot sa bansa para mangampanya kasi di pa start ng campaign. Di tulad ng iba, busy sa pangangampanya, kamusta naman ang trabaho nila, iba na siguro ang gumagawa.
Deletemiriam magaling lang magsalita.. ang tagal ng senator. wala naman akong nakitang ginawa nya kung di maghighblood sa senado.. kaya duterte na lang ako..
ReplyDeletenah! try mo icheck lahat ng achievements nya from the start na maging public servant sya hanggang ngayon.. baka wala pa sa kalahati ng duterte mo
DeleteFYI, isa sa pinakamasipag na senador po sya. Authored and co-authored hundreds of laws. Malamang sa bawat araw ng buhay mo, nakikinabang ka sa isa sa mga batas na pinangunahan nya itaguyod pero dahil iba ang konsepto mo ng "nagawa" o "dapat ginagawa" ng isang senador, hindi mo ito alam. Kung hindi ka masyado aware sa functions ng isang senador, ipinapaalala ko po na primordial dyan ang pagsasalita lalo sa deliberations nila at balitaktakan. Kung walang Miriam, malamang madaming walang kwentang batas na naipasa ang mga mandarambong sa gobyerno. She's the counterbalancer in the Senate. KONTRAPELO IN A GOOD WAY. Sa legislature po kabilang si miriam kaya hndi tangible o kongkretong imprastruktura ang mga nagawa nya. Kaya kung hindi ka masyadong aware sa mga batas ng Pilipinas o kung sino nag-author o co-author nito, tahimik na lang po, okay?
DeleteBalik ulit sa US passport.
ReplyDeleteSheryl while singing the chorus line for Mr Dreamboy to cheeze ha ha ha .. Mr Dreamboy mr Dreamboy ha ha ha .
ReplyDeleteButi nga hehehe
ReplyDeleteAmbisyosa cya masyado!..presidente agad2!!!..nawalan ako ng gana nung magsalita At pumabor pa cya sa isang relihiyon, mahinang klase,pano uupo yn wlng silbe rin ganun pa rin ang magiging buhay natin pilipino!..didiktahan lng cya ng magiging vice nya!..
ReplyDeleteI hope miriam will just run for vice presidency... Im still torn bet defensor and duterte.
ReplyDeleteFor me, once you've given up your citizenship and became an american, you've lost your right to run for public office. Gusto mo maging american di ba, so stay there. You can't have 2 masters!
ReplyDeleteHindi mo pa talaga oras. Wag na mapilit te!
ReplyDeleteSome other time nalang Grace. Tutal ang bata mo pa talaga para maging presidente.
ReplyDeleteNO FOR DUTERTE WEEEHH!!!
ReplyDeleteWhy is everyone so afraid of Senator Poe? Is it because people see her as an honest and smart politician? Another woman president will probably do the country some good.
ReplyDeleteAnonymousDecember 2, 2015 at 7:53 AM - honest? come on. meron siyang simulated birth certificate kung saan nakalagay doon ang biological parents niya ay sina fpj at susan roces at ito ang pinasa niya sa BI para sa dual citizenship niya!
DeleteThe end of the road for Poe.
ReplyDeleteWill she apply for US citizenship again?
ReplyDeleteI guess it's back to the US of A for Poe.
ReplyDeleteDapat i uphold ang batas. If by law deemed unfit sha because one of the criteria is dapat filipino citizen. Dapat respetuhin nya un.
ReplyDeleteYes! She thinks too highly of herself. Serves her right for listening to Escudero. And Escudero, I'll bet my bottom dollar you'll never win the vice presidency.
ReplyDeleteYES! No one is exempted from the law.
ReplyDeleteHuwag muna mag bunyi ang mga anti POE hindi pa final decision, may SC pa excited naman kayo masyado eh.
ReplyDeleteWhy did you edit this post. Do you really think that we wouldn't notice? You are not reliable to. And one observant like me and not telling everyone would be enough. You have no credibility and you are completely BIAS.
ReplyDelete