Sorry ha pero ano ba yung ibig nyang sabihin sa bukambibig nyang itutuloy nya ang nasimulan ni FPJ? Mag-aartista ba sya? Kasi yun lang ang nagawa ng tatay niya diba?? If this is so, why is she trying to run for president??
Luhhhh di pa natigil si Ambisyosa? Uy Grace, hindi naman kinukwestyon ang pagiging foundling mo sa kaso na sinampa ni Atty. Elamparo. Yung 10 year RESIDENCY kasi ang usapan. Dapat nga matagal ka ng disqualified dahil 2010 ka lang naging full pledged Filipino dahil nubg 2006, nakadual citizenship ka pa. Kung papayag ang Comelec na tumakbo ka, parang sinabi na din nila na pwedeng tumakbo ang mga naturalized Filipino kahit di sila nakatira within 10 years. BATAS ANG SINISIRA MO GRACE!!!! Wag mo bulagin mga sumusuporta sayo sa maling paniniwala niyo ni Chiz.
But isn't by previously renouncing her Filipino citizenship, she lost her natural born status? And coz of that di nya na meet ang 10 yr residency requirement?
She might have dual citizenship which both the US and the Philippine allow. When she took her oath as a US citizen she lost her Filipino citizenship. But one can apply for Filipino citizenship take oath and be a citizen of both the US and the Philippines.
There is a jurisprudence in Political Law regarding this. So let me please enlighten you a bit.
A natural born citizen who loses her Filipino citizenship by pledging allegiance to another country may reacquire citizenship by repatriation, naturalization or direct act of Congress. Technically in this case, a person, who WAS a natural born Filipino, is re-taking what was once his, unlike in the case of foreigners who wishes to become naturalized Filipinos.
By pledging allegiance to the Philippines, a person reacquires his being a Filipino. From that very moment/date of reacquisition of Filipino citizenship, the 10-year residency requirement can already be reckoned with. Corollary in this scenario is the fact that the person is a natural born Filipino citizen, otherwise, the benefit of reacquisition of citizenship does not apply to him.
In the case of Poe, she is a foundling. Her bloodline is unknown. For her to be able to establish her natural born citizenship, she must first prove that either her father or mother is a Filipino. This is a basic CONSTITUTIONAL provision that even the great lawyer Chiz seems to ignore intentionally. Absent that proof, she is not eligible to reacquire Filipino citizenship. Her oath of allegiance to the Philippines makes her a NATURALIZED born citizen only. Further, counting the period of Poe's residence is a futile exercise if she is not a natural born citizen. IN ALL HER DISQUALIFICATION CASES, as a lawyer, I humbly believe that she is, to begin with, barred to hold any elective office.
She can't, she's not a natural born US citizen. She was not born there. You have to be born in the US or have US citizen parent if born somewhere else. Same problem.
Grace next election ka nalang mabuti pa. i hate it! bakit kailangan mo pang bangitin ang tatay mo sa official statement mo patay na yun tao wag mo na gamitin. if may nagawa ka nga mabuti para sa bayan lalabas at lalabas yan at marerecognize un ng tao kahit hindi mo sya gamitin. isa pa nakakainsulto para sa asawa mo na ang gamitin mo ay Poe. kung gusto mo tumakbo yung totoong name mo ang gamitin mo gamit ang apelido ng asawa mo hindi yung "grace poe" lang sige magpasurvey ka at ng malaman mo kugn ganu kaunti tao lang ang alam ang apelido mo.
No offense pero kung iclaim nya na natural born sya for the sake na makakatakbo pero sa puso nya Amerikana pa rin sya nagiging oportunista lamang sya. Sana kung feel nya natural born Filipino sya sana tinangkilik nya un Philippine passport nya hindi un american passport
Para sa aking hindi pa ganoon ka mature si grace po for presidency. Balik baliwan man si Sheryl Cruz pero may point. Balik baliwan man ang dating ni Duterte pero sa Pilipinas na baliw un mga tao kailangan un may magpapatino. Naalala ko si Duterte kay General Luna aggressive pero may leadership. Importante un mapapasunod tayo at matatakot mga Criminal!!!
Public's interest or your sole interest? Maliwanag naman na atleast 10 years residency ano pa kuda mo? Bakit di kana ba makakatakbo sa 2022? From MTRCB Chair to Senator ang tayog naman ng gusto mo Grace. Magpahinog ka muna bago mag aspire ng higher position. Wala akong narinig na batas o bill na ikaw ang sole author. Pano kang magiging presidente kung simpleng rule lang ng pagtakbo hindi mo masunod at talagang tigas ng ulo mo. Atat ka masyado. Sa totoo lang nakakabwisit na
Dura Lex Sed Lex. The law may be harsh, but it is the law. Ano pa silbi ng Constitution if selective lang din application nito. How do you expect us to have a president na siya mismo, lumalabag sa batas.
Korek! Simpleng pa fill up lang ng certificate if candidacy di mo pa magawa ng tama, at sinumpaan mo pa yun, magpre-presidente ka pa? Give it a rest at try to fix your citizenship and your family's before running for any position again.
Huwag na sana gamitin ang taong bayan, ambiyosa nmn masyado nito mukhang wala nmn patutunguhan ang bansa kung nahalal sana siya.Tigilan na ri ang pag gamit kay FPJ at mga foundling lumalabas tuloy pagiging mangagamit mo.
Hayy nakkk nameeen, fishing for public sympathy si Ateng. Cry me a river, Grace. Kaya hirap talagang umusad ang bansa natin eh because of govt officials like you Grace Poe, na sya ding hindi rumerespeto sa batas. Follow the law Grace, and be a good example. bye girl
Mag artista kn lang gracia poe sa showbiz kahit american citizen ka puedeng puede ka pumasok.wag ka ng magpumilit na tumakbong presidente maawa ka naman sa taong bayan panay ka fpj fpj. At saka bakit mo igigive up ang citizenship mo?? Amerkana ka na nga ayaw mo pa
By saying "i hope the interest of the people will prevail in the decision of Comelec en banc" , she knows that technically she really is not qualified in terms of residency/citizenship for presidency
I guess blessing in disguise para sa kanya to. Maganda nga para di masyadong mapahiya. Stay in the senate and get more experience then in a few years time you should be ready for presidency.
Tama na yannn! Pabebe voice
ReplyDeleteSorry ha pero ano ba yung ibig nyang sabihin sa bukambibig nyang itutuloy nya ang nasimulan ni FPJ? Mag-aartista ba sya? Kasi yun lang ang nagawa ng tatay niya diba?? If this is so, why is she trying to run for president??
Deletehaha oo nga noh..
DeleteNa-evict ka na sa PBB - Presidentiables, di ka na welcome sa bahay ni Kuya sa Malacañang! Tama na kuda, ate! Let it go!
DeleteMuch like they did to FPJ daw, asus, e ikaw tong gamit ng gamit sa pangalan ng adoptive father mong showbiz royalty.
DeleteLuhhhh di pa natigil si Ambisyosa? Uy Grace, hindi naman kinukwestyon ang pagiging foundling mo sa kaso na sinampa ni Atty. Elamparo. Yung 10 year RESIDENCY kasi ang usapan. Dapat nga matagal ka ng disqualified dahil 2010 ka lang naging full pledged Filipino dahil nubg 2006, nakadual citizenship ka pa. Kung papayag ang Comelec na tumakbo ka, parang sinabi na din nila na pwedeng tumakbo ang mga naturalized Filipino kahit di sila nakatira within 10 years. BATAS ANG SINISIRA MO GRACE!!!! Wag mo bulagin mga sumusuporta sayo sa maling paniniwala niyo ni Chiz.
ReplyDeleteGrace, no one is interested. Drop your candidancy.
ReplyDeleteCorrect. If she still gets votes - direcho yun sa trash can!
DeleteGrace Ambisyosa Poe
DeleteSabi ni madam MDS, SC daw ang may huling desisyon sa problema mo. Gora ka na dun! Now na! Lol
ReplyDeleteBut isn't by previously renouncing her Filipino citizenship, she lost her natural born status?
ReplyDeleteAnd coz of that di nya na meet ang 10 yr residency requirement?
Correct me if I'm wrong, guys.
She might have dual citizenship which both the US and the Philippine allow. When she took her oath as a US citizen she lost her Filipino citizenship. But one can apply for Filipino citizenship take oath and be a citizen of both the US and the Philippines.
DeleteThere is a jurisprudence in Political Law regarding this. So let me please enlighten you a bit.
DeleteA natural born citizen who loses her Filipino citizenship by pledging allegiance to another country may reacquire citizenship by repatriation, naturalization or direct act of Congress. Technically in this case, a person, who WAS a natural born Filipino, is re-taking what was once his, unlike in the case of foreigners who wishes to become naturalized Filipinos.
By pledging allegiance to the Philippines, a person reacquires his being a Filipino. From that very moment/date of reacquisition of Filipino citizenship, the 10-year residency requirement can already be reckoned with. Corollary in this scenario is the fact that the person is a natural born Filipino citizen, otherwise, the benefit of reacquisition of citizenship does not apply to him.
In the case of Poe, she is a foundling. Her bloodline is unknown. For her to be able to establish her natural born citizenship, she must first prove that either her father or mother is a Filipino. This is a basic CONSTITUTIONAL provision that even the great lawyer Chiz seems to ignore intentionally. Absent that proof, she is not eligible to reacquire Filipino citizenship. Her oath of allegiance to the Philippines makes her a NATURALIZED born citizen only. Further, counting the period of Poe's residence is a futile exercise if she is not a natural born citizen. IN ALL HER DISQUALIFICATION CASES, as a lawyer, I humbly believe that she is, to begin with, barred to hold any elective office.
--atty. may soriano :)
Para sa akin, once na renounce na nya Filipino citizenship nya, di na sya dapat tumakbo. She chose to be American eh di sa America sya tumakbo!
DeleteYou are right! Her residency info when she filed her candicacy mismo was the proof that she is not qualified because she lacks the 10 year residency.
DeleteShe can't, she's not a natural born US citizen. She was not born there. You have to be born in the US or have US citizen parent if born somewhere else. Same problem.
DeleteEh dba gusto mo naman tlga sundan yapak ni Fpj.. Ayan na sumusunod kna. Malapit kna tlga madisqualified.
ReplyDeleteWhatever.
ReplyDeleteGrace next election ka nalang mabuti pa. i hate it! bakit kailangan mo pang bangitin ang tatay mo sa official statement mo patay na yun tao wag mo na gamitin. if may nagawa ka nga mabuti para sa bayan lalabas at lalabas yan at marerecognize un ng tao kahit hindi mo sya gamitin. isa pa nakakainsulto para sa asawa mo na ang gamitin mo ay Poe. kung gusto mo tumakbo yung totoong name mo ang gamitin mo gamit ang apelido ng asawa mo hindi yung "grace poe" lang sige magpasurvey ka at ng malaman mo kugn ganu kaunti tao lang ang alam ang apelido mo.
ReplyDeleteNo offense pero kung iclaim nya na natural born sya for the sake na makakatakbo pero sa puso nya Amerikana pa rin sya nagiging oportunista lamang sya. Sana kung feel nya natural born Filipino sya sana tinangkilik nya un Philippine passport nya hindi un american passport
ReplyDeleteMind you, buong pamilya nya, US passport pa! Pag nagkataon eh di wow, ang first family eh onaks?!? Sila na!
DeletePara sa aking hindi pa ganoon ka mature si grace po for presidency. Balik baliwan man si Sheryl Cruz pero may point. Balik baliwan man ang dating ni Duterte pero sa Pilipinas na baliw un mga tao kailangan un may magpapatino. Naalala ko si Duterte kay General Luna aggressive pero may leadership. Importante un mapapasunod tayo at matatakot mga Criminal!!!
ReplyDeleteE d WOW!
ReplyDeleteE d WOW!
ReplyDeletePublic's interest or your sole interest? Maliwanag naman na atleast 10 years residency ano pa kuda mo? Bakit di kana ba makakatakbo sa 2022? From MTRCB Chair to Senator ang tayog naman ng gusto mo Grace. Magpahinog ka muna bago mag aspire ng higher position. Wala akong narinig na batas o bill na ikaw ang sole author. Pano kang magiging presidente kung simpleng rule lang ng pagtakbo hindi mo masunod at talagang tigas ng ulo mo. Atat ka masyado. Sa totoo lang nakakabwisit na
ReplyDeleteTapos na Poe!
ReplyDeleteSabi ni Ms. Poe, igagalang nya ang magiging desisyon ng kinauukulan. Pero ngayong hindi pabor sa kanya ang dsisyon, panay apela naman. Hay!
ReplyDeleteDragging FPJ again???
ReplyDeleteUtang na loob, maawa ka sa sarili mo. Itigil mo na yan. Minsan wag laban ng laban
ReplyDeleteDura Lex Sed Lex. The law may be harsh, but it is the law. Ano pa silbi ng Constitution if selective lang din application nito. How do you expect us to have a president na siya mismo, lumalabag sa batas.
ReplyDeleteKorek! Simpleng pa fill up lang ng certificate if candidacy di mo pa magawa ng tama, at sinumpaan mo pa yun, magpre-presidente ka pa? Give it a rest at try to fix your citizenship and your family's before running for any position again.
DeleteAbsolutely correct ka!
DeleteAgree
DeleteParang kilala kita. hahaha Anyway bongga ka, i agree with you!
DeleteGet over it already, you're not going to win anyway.
ReplyDeleteHuwag na sana gamitin ang taong bayan, ambiyosa nmn masyado nito mukhang wala nmn patutunguhan ang bansa kung nahalal sana siya.Tigilan na ri ang pag gamit kay FPJ at mga foundling lumalabas tuloy pagiging mangagamit mo.
ReplyDeleteMakasalita si Grace akala mo utang na loob ng bayan na kakandidato sya. Utang na loob, isa kang oportunista!
ReplyDeleteMay hashtag hashtag ka pang LabanPOE2016. Itigil mo na yan and wait for 2022 and run again. Hilaw ka pa.
ReplyDeletelahat nln sinasabi ntong c grace me FPJ na kasama.
ReplyDeletesmh.
Hayy nakkk nameeen, fishing for public sympathy si Ateng. Cry me a river, Grace. Kaya hirap talagang umusad ang bansa natin eh because of govt officials like you Grace Poe, na sya ding hindi rumerespeto sa batas. Follow the law Grace, and be a good example. bye girl
ReplyDeleteHindi pala nya na meet yung minimum residency requirments e d kahit pa totoong natural born filipino sya e hndi pa din sya tlaga qualified.
ReplyDeletei hate to say this pero... ang tigas mo ateng!
ReplyDeleteI hope she stops hoping and just run in the next election after 2016. This is a sign, a sign she is ignoring!
ReplyDeletewait lang, sa senatorial race ba, lesser ng years of residency ang kelangan bago tumakbo? kasi why only now?
ReplyDeletedapat nung last election pa sana di ba.. kinalkal na lang sguro ngaun kasi for presidency na..
pero i'm in for comelec's decision. not yet time Grace. We don't need you yet :)
senator na lang po muna.. wag atat.
iba po ang required number of years of residency for president at senator :-)
Delete6yrs of recidency ang required for senators
DeleteMag artista kn lang gracia poe sa showbiz kahit american citizen ka puedeng puede ka pumasok.wag ka ng magpumilit na tumakbong presidente maawa ka naman sa taong bayan panay ka fpj fpj. At saka bakit mo igigive up ang citizenship mo?? Amerkana ka na nga ayaw mo pa
ReplyDeleteBy saying "i hope the interest of the people will prevail in the decision of Comelec en banc" , she knows that technically she really is not qualified in terms of residency/citizenship for presidency
ReplyDeleteI guess blessing in disguise para sa kanya to. Maganda nga para di masyadong mapahiya. Stay in the senate and get more experience then in a few years time you should be ready for presidency.
ReplyDeleteHILAW KA PA! Sariling desisyon mo nga di mo mapanindigan, pano kung presidente ka na?
ReplyDelete"INTEREST OF THE PEOPLE"? Eh what about the Rule of Law, Madam? Mukhang yan naman yata ang pinag uusapan dapat eh.
ReplyDelete