Sana mangyari sa parents mo dahil dyan sa comment mo. Brutal kung brutal but you asked for it. Napaka insensitive ng comment mo parang wala kang nanay!
Kasalanan niya is una sa pila yung babae! Now Kung nauna man lumabas yung baggage ng guy e dapat nagantay pa din siya na nakuha muna ng nasa harap niya yung mga baggage! Na iisang piraso lang naman ng bag! Kaya nga me term na courtesy...nakakapanginig ka ng laman!
Exactly! I sympathize with the family pero grabe ha, ang OA lang. Sometimes ang mga Pinoy mahilig mang-blame ng iba. Ok, siguro hindi siya tumulong sa nadapa pero di naman niya obligation na tumulong eh. Yun lang naman siguro ang "mali" niya. LET'S GET REAL, PEOPLE! Tsaka, sisihin pa nila ang Cebu Pac? Eh ano ang liability ng airline dun? She was merely a (would-have-been) passenger and the incident didn't happen inside the plane naman. Kaloka talaga!
1:01 It was clearly an accident. The lady ACCIDENTALLY tripped on the bag. Ok, sure, the man shouldn't have placed the bag there but to say he deliberately placed it there to trip others is surely false. The only bad thing the man did was that he did not show the least concern when the event happened in front of him. The rest was purely an ACCIDENT.
12:45 What? "Unjust vexation"??? Do you even know what that means? It only happens when there is coercion, te! When something is done against one's will. Sinabi ba ng guy na dapat madapa si ate sa bag niya? Kaloka to! Tsaka di crime ang mauna sa pila no! Ate looked like she even acquiesced to being behind the line if we argue na it's "crime" na mauna ka sa pila, lolololol. Besides, is the guy's "pag-una sa pila" the main cause of the tripping ni ate sa bag? Of course, not! The lady INADVERTENTLY and ACCIDENTALLY tripped on the bag.
It was just an accident. I sympathize with the family pero wag sana OA at lawsuit-happy. The guy doesn't owe you more than saying sorry.
From what school did you graduate from Pamintang Lawyer? Were you not taught of the elementary doctrine of "El que es causa de la causa es causa del mal causado?" Dunung-dunungan kasi. We should not encourage lawsuits but we should also not let people get away with these things
lol anong coercion pinagsasabi mo, paminta? unjust vexation doesn't even require coercion. do u even know what unjust vexation is? annoyance/vexation lang requirement nun oy. in tagalog, naasar or napahiya. grabe. lawyer ka ba tlga?
and true, aksidente ung nangyari, wag masyadong oa.
this is obviously an accident but caused by the guy's neglect. it's bad enough that this happened, but worse when he just walked away. sorry guys but I love mommies. This could have been fatal esp at her age. haaaayyyyyy
Ay sus Walang kinalaman ang coercion sa Unjust vexation, porket magkatunog ang dulo. Mahabagin... di ka pamintang lawyer noh, baklang parlorista ka lang eh. Aminin!
Feeling ko naman hindi alam n guy na bag nya nakapagpatumba sa matanda. Parang ang dating eh akala nya bgla nagcollapse. Hindi naman cguro ganun kasama si kuya para hndi tulungan kung lam nya sya ang cause
Art 2176 of the Civil Code states that "Whoever by act or omission causes damage to another, there being fault or negligence, is obliged to pay for the damage done." The man should be liable for the injuries sustained by the victim.
Que horror!!!...ang shupal ng fez ni manong he didnt even bothered to say sorry or help the poor woman and the guards my gosh! Theyre so lame in addressing the accident kasuhan ang dapat kasuhan!!!...yun na! Paaak!
di ba na-train ang mga personnel sa NAIA ng first aid? nkakatakot pla kng meron emergency mngyayari di nla alam gagawin. pinaupo pa nla sa gitna? kaloka!
12:40 Basa-basa naman before commenting. It didn't happen in NAIA, though I wouldn't be surprised if the staff there didn't know first aid either haha!
Honestly walang kasalanan ung guy. Its an accident kya kahit na magsorry sya wala pa din kaso o pede ireklamo sa knya. Ayun lang di sya nagsorry. Wala syang konsensya.
5:13 Paanong walang kasalanan yung lalaki? Mag isip ka nga!!! Normal ba na ibalandra ang bag sa dinadaanan ng tao? Hindi magkaka aksidente kung hindi nilagay nung gag*ng lalaki yung mga bags nya sa daanan!!! Natural makaka patid yun noh! Mag isip ka nga bago ka mag comment dito fp! Kaka highblood ka din!
There is clearly a criminal case here...Article 275 of the Revised Penal Code punishes "Anyone who shall fail to help or render assistance to another whom he has accidentally wounded or injured."
hindi ko nakitang nakipag unahan sya ng pila.ang probs din sa airport wala malalagyan ng bag.ganyan din gawa namin lagay nalang sa sahig kasi pag iwan lang sa table sasabihan lang din aloiin agad para iwas magkabuhol2 mga bag.d naman agad makakuha ng cart maliban kung may kasama ka.
WOW HA. Wow talaga, Kahit na sabihing aksidente ang nangyari, sana man lang nag-sorry tong si kuya. Eh parang walang nangyari eh. To think na nagulat din sya sa pagbagsak ng ale. Tsk2. Kids these days,,,
First the kid and the Montero, now this?! What is happening to our people?!
I experienced the same thing. I got held up inside the FX in Espana and all the passengers in the middle, in front and the driver did nothing. They just watched while the guy were trying to get my phone from my hand and pointing a knife on my face. I didn't let go until I realized that I also got my laptop with me. Worse, after the guy fled, all passengers went back in and the driver drove away as if nothing happened. No one offered help or at least console me. DEDMA LANG SILANG LAHAT! Nag-sakay pa yung driver ng pasahero sa Quiapo while I was crying my heart out at the back. The couple (yung sumakay sa Quiapo) were kind enough to offer me pamasahe but good thing na din I still have my wallet. Wala na ko nagawa dahil sa trauma and went home na lang.
Kapal nung mukha nung guy sa video! Mukhang hindi man lang nag-sorry!
I don't believe the man who owns the bag that the lady tripped on should be held responsible. It was clearly an accident. But the man should've at least checked on the lady and shown a little bit of concern.
Accident or not, it was the man's fault because he placed the bag right beside the woman. She didn't know that a bag was placed there because when she turned to get her stuff, there was no bag yet. Lagyan ba naman ng bag sa tabi ng paa! Shempre mapapatid ka talaga.
kindly check art. 275 of the revised penal code which penalizes Anyone who shall fail to help or render assistance to another whom he has accidentally wounded or injured.
5:20 So kung tumatawid ka sa dinadaanan ko at nasagasaan kita ng kotse ko i wont be held responsible kasi "accident" naman ang nangyari. Swerte naman ng makaka disgrasya syo di mo pala sisisihin LOL
Ok, given that accidents happen, he still has to be responsible for an accident he caused. Whether it was intentional or not. Hello, pag nakabangga ka ng car, kahit di mo sinasadya, kailangan mong panagutan ang damages.
Kawawa naman yung mom. I saw the full video on Facebook. Swak sa ilong, as in flat on her face ang hulog. And the man didn't even bother, even though when you look at him as it happened, kitang-kita niya na it was his error that caused the fall. Nakatingin kaya siya when the lady tripped over his bag. Makonsensiya ka naman!
Why would he be held liable? Kasi hindi nagsorry? Well dapat naman nagpakita sya ng concern pero to be held liable for that? Wag ito itulad sa car accidents this is different. Natapilok sya sa bag kasi hindi nya nakita. May fault yung babae. Wala namang sign na bawal ilagay sa spot na yun ang bags. Dont get me wrong, i sympathize with her entirely and i wish umayos na yung lagay nya pero hinay hinay lang tayong gamitin ang 'victim card'.
Hello Iba naman kaya yun??? Nagdridrive ka dapat focus ka! e sa video naman, hindi nakita nung babae yung bag. Ang dapat jan, ayusin ang mga airport maglagay ng mga rules para naiiwasan ang aksidente. Isisisi niyo lahat doon sa lalaki, e malay ba niya na mangyayari yun!
mga baks, negligence un. liable ka pa rin dun. same lang sa car accident, same lang sa dog bites. liable ka dahil we have a responsibility to the public not to cause any harm. public negligence ung kahit may nakausling pako sa gilid ng bahay mo. gets mo? magkakaibang level but still is the same.
Parang bloopers lang e pero hindi kasi makapaghintay yung Ga*ong Put*+%#! lalaki na parang me taxing naghihintay sa kanya at umaandar ang metro! Nakita naman niyang nauuna yung babae! Tapos patay mali lang ang Puny++**!!!!!
It was an accident. she should've been more careful sa dinadaanan niya. And the guy should've been more aware kung saan niya binaba yung carry on item niya. Sus too bad so sad but it's an accident! I don't think the guy is liable. It still boils down to, be aware of your surroundings.
2:28 But it wasn't his/her mom, so your comment is not applicable. And even if it was, the same will happen: you can't sue because you were not helped when you ACCIDENTALLY tripped on a bag. Mapag-uusapan naman yan eh.
dapat naman kasi yung bag sa dulo na kuhain hindi yung sinasalubong sa paglabas ng conveyor. Kung sana hindi atat yung lalake na kunin yung bag eh di sana naka iwas pa sa aksidente.
Ang OA ng FB post. Gusto pa mag reach out yung airport or cebupac. Ano namang kasalanan ng airport at ng cebupac sa pagka patid ng nanay mo teh?? Malinaw na accident walang may kasalanan, hala Sige Singilin mo ng danyos yung bag!
Nakakaawa ang lady pero Over naman itong nag post sa facebook na anak nya, hindi naman sinadya patirin ng lalake yung mom nya, clearly it was an accident, katawan mo dapat responsibilidad mo, napatid si Mom dahil Di rin sya tumingin sa nilakaran nya. Not a reason para sirain pagkatao nung lalake sa video. Papano naman sya mag sosorry me commotion na mga nagkagulo na guard na tumulong, kita naman sa video na tumingin yun lalake and parang hesitant and movement nya, di naman sya biglang layas na walang paki. Hwag Naman OA at lahat dadaanin sa social media, di porke nadisgrasya ang isang tao we will always look for somebody to blame.
Sino ba yang lalaking yan? Sarap gulpihin! Hindi man lang nya tinulungan yung babae at nag apologize! At yung mga guard bakit hindi man lang pinag sabihan yung lalaki? Sarap ihambalos dun sa lalaki yung mga bags nya! Pasensya na lumalabas pagka war freak ko pag nakaka basa ako ng mga ganitong mga taong nkaka perwisyo ng kapwa pero hindi pinapanagutan ang kanilang kasalanan kagaya nung nakasagasa ng bata na tumakas. Haaaay! Nakakalungkot makitang may mga taong walang puso at awa sa kapwa!
Sue that devil! He should atleast offer a helping hand when he saw the old lady on the floor. He knew from the start that he/his bag cause the accident. Leaving it on the middle. That area is suppose to be free from any clutter kasi people daanan yun. At yung mga guard, tang-a din...they should hold that guy for a while and ask a little info about him in case the old woman needs financial help.
Sue him for what?? You're funny! And financial help?? Are you serious? It's clearly an accident! Ang OA nyo! Yes the guy could have said sorry and helped the lady pero clearly hindi nya kasalanan!
Anon 12:27 sana madapa ka rin dahil sa kapabayaan ng ibang tao para malaman mo pakiramdam. Ewan ko lang kung masabi mo pang accident pag muka mo ang nasubsob. Baka mas OA ka pa mag react pag ikaw na ang nasaktan LOL
b*ll$#** na lalaking may ari sa maletang humarang sa daanan nung matanda!!! prang t@ng@ lang si kuya! buti pa ung lalake sa kabila nakuhang tumulong, sya prang wala lang. kuya sana madapa ka rin una muka mo.as in una ung muka mo!!!! kabanas ka!!! kung sino ka man!!
I dont see why they have to post this and hunt the guy with the bag. Para ano? Para mag sorry? Wala siyang kasalanan. Hindi rin niya ginusto yung nangyari. Sinadya niya ba?pinost lang ito to gain sympathy. or para mabash yung guy. Actually, sa part na yan, laging aligaga ang mga tao. Kasi lahat ng gamit pinapatanggal diba. Naoobserve ko lang. Lahat nagmamadaling isuot at kunin ang mga gamit.
Ang kasalanan nung lalakeng naka yellow wala syang common sense! Kasalanan ng airport or airlines staff yan. Dapat sinabihan nila yung lalake na tumabi at itabi yung luggages nya kasi abala sya don sa daan! Doon pa talaga nagsuot ng sapatos ha!
When I watched the video i think the man didnt know it was his bag's fault. But seeing a woman tripped in front of you he doesnt seem bothered and just walk away. Thats his mistakes
No doubt the guy was a jerk for having no reaction at all to the incident but we can see in the video that it was not intentional, there was no malice nor it was a pre-meditated event. If there is no intention to harm, where is the culpability? Accidents happen and it was unfortunate that it happened to her mother but to ask for compensation not only for her mother but to her Parents is stretching justice far beyond its scope. And the act of cyber bullying an individual in social media in the guise of justice when there was no established fact of culpability is by itself is an act of terrorism too.
Social media has been used and abused by some and this is one example of its excesses. My sympathy is with your Mother and maybe if your intention was for that jerk guy to say sorry to your mom then I would gladly agree with you, after all, being a Gentleman is a rarity nowadays but since the premise of your call was all about compensation then.... try harder next time to convince us.
12:11 I don't think it's cyber bullying it's more on AWARENESS for the people to consider things that might cause accidents not only for yourself but with others too. Being a responsible citizen will not make u less of a person instead it will make yourself proud dahil gumagawa ka Ng tama.. But if this incident didn't even bothered him kahit nangyari sa harap nya kung ako ang nanay Nya kakahiya q sya.
Yuck dumb guy. Dun talaga nilagay yung bag sa tabi ng babae. If it was me, itatabi ko yun sa tabi ko or sa space na walang mahaharangang tao. Tapos he saw the accident keber lang. Sarap sampalin sa itlog.
Sana me makakilala sa lalake at pakisulat ng info dito. Maski man lang sa salita na ibato sa kanya e maramdaman nya sakit na dinanas nung matanda.
Parang na imagine ko nanay ko na na mild stroke mahina tuhod kung sa kanya nangyari un, magwawala talaga ako at pag uupakan ko ung me ari ng bag. Deadma lang talaga sya na nagsuot ng shoes e
Itong lalaki hindi nagiisip. Una: nakita na niyang may katabi siya, hinarang pa rin ang bag sa harap sa katabi. Pangalawa: hindi pa nagsorry. Napakaselfish lang.
Anong accident ang pinagsasasabi nyo?!? It was definitely the guy's mistake! Why did he put his bag there? Eh hindi naman bag/luggage counter yun. Daan yun, for heaven's sake! He wasn't considerate for other people who are also picking up their bags! Kapag ang parking lot ba may nakatayong tao, babanggain nyo yung tao basta-basta? Di ba bubusina man lang kayo to let the person know that you'd want to park on that space? That's being considerate. This douche bag is not only inconsiderate, he's also very incompassionate. So evil! My God!
The guy just placed his bag there. Did he deliberately put it there just so to trip others? Of course not. It was just an accident. Plain and simple. Wag OA mag-react please.
Anon 1:16 Ok ka lang? Paanong wag OA mag react??? Nasaktan yung matandang babae dahil sa ginawa nung guy and hindi man lang nag apologize eh sya nag lagay ng bags nya dun kaya nadapa yung babae so paanong hindi kami mag rereact! Hindi man lang nag pakita ng concern yung lalaki dun sa nangyari
It was an accident. PERIOD. Walang liability si Kuya. Mali lang siguro na parang di siya concerned or di niya tinulungan yung old lady pero still, di niya obligation ang tumulong.
2:38 logical? rational? E di ikaw na!!! Ganda pala ng rationale mu eh Hindi nya obligation e sya may ari Ng bag na pakalat2.. Tsk irrational kamo! SHUNGA PA MORE
Guys please dont say if the person has committed fault or no fault unless you've passed the bar. Do not take the word "liability" lightly. (Which of course he clearly has in this case.)
12:58 Bags nung lalaki ang dahilan kung bakit nadapa yung babae so anong pinag sasasabi mo dyan na hindi responsibilidad nung lalaki ang tumulong! Pansin ko lang and dami nyo dito sa fp na kapareho ng pag uugali ng lalaki, MGA WALANG PAKIALAM SA KAPWA! Sana madapa din kayo una muka sa espalto!
Nde pagiging rational yun. Selfish ka kamo. No man is an island. Papano ka ba pinalaki ng magulang mo at wala kang compassion sa mga nasaktan. Be mindful of your actions dahil lahat un me consequences. Ok lang sana kung ikaw lang lagi ang napeperwisyo pero kung sa negligence na ibaba lang ang bag kung san at me natisod, its a human national reaction na dapat tumulong at magpasintabi dahil kung d nya kinalat sa kung san ang bag nya wala sanang naaksidente.
Kung ganyan ang rationalization mo sa lahat ng aksidente masahol ka pa sa hayop.
11:50 totally agree with you 101% ibang tao dito pinag pipilitan tlga na aksidente ang nangyari pero di nila kino consider yung fault nung guy sa pagkakalagay ng bags nya sa daanan kaya naka tisod ng tao.
$@$&$$ Patay malisya si Manong, as if he didn't know that his negligence caused the old woman to fall down. Eh he should be cautious sa luggages na inilagay nya lang sa dinadaanan ng tao, at least nilagay man lang nya sa bandang gitna. He didn't bother help or apologise to the lady. Hmmp sana hindi ka binangungot that night.
It was indeed an accident. Pero sana man lang nag sorry yung guy or at least offered help. Hindi yung dedma lang. Gamit nya at katan*ahan nya ang nag cause nang accident ano. At sa nag sabi na the lady should have been more careful, eh sinu ba naman mag expect na may bag pala dun? Common sense lang hu.
Ikaw na mismo nagsabi, 1:24. "Responsibilidad". Therefore, it only appeals to public morals or customs. No one is "obligated" to help others. Not helping others when they tripped over is not a crime. Though masama nga ang ginawa niya because he didn't show empathy or concern, pero that's it. No compulsory monetary damages. Kung makita man sya at magbigay, it's all voluntary.
Huy pamintang lawyer san ka bang gumraduate na law school. Shut up and stop miseducating people here. May kaso si lola. article 365 of the revised penal code please pakibasa. Reckless imprudence yan diba? Siya ang proximate cause diba? if you refer to 265/266 may at least slight physical injuries kasi naospital si lola diba? Naku naku naku.
Tsaka yung mga shungang airport personnel pwede din kasuhan ng administrative case Kasi duty nilang ipara si kuyang nakadilaw. Hay! You are out of order.
Hindi yan accident! Hindi nagiisip yun lalaki na daanan yun pinaglagyan nya ng bag nya. At alam naman nya me katabi sya. Kapal ng mukha akala mo parang walang nangyari di pa nagsorry.
12:52 Girl, google mo "appeal to emotion". If you graduated from college and you didn't know that, your school is obviously a diploma mill. Harhar! Kidding...or not! Lol
1:37 Cge ang "BAGS" na ang may kasalanan. May "ISIP at PAA" yung mga bags. Nag lakad sila mag isa papunta sa tabi ng babae kaya nakadisgrasya! Masaya ka na teh? Ang bags ang dapat sisihin hindi yung may ari ng bags.
Pag ang bata tumatakbo ng hindi tumitingin sa pinupuntahan, sinisisi ang bata. "Ikaw kasi hindi ka tumitingin" ang ipinapangaral. Hindi kasalanan ng silya o mesa. Pag ang matanda hindi tumitingin sa nilalakaran, kasalanan ng may-ari. Ano ba talaga?
Aksidente nga. Pero liable si insensitive na kuya dahil kung hindi niya hinarang ang bag niya sa dadaanan ng old lady, hindi mangyayari to. It's his carelessness that caused the accident. Hindi man lang humingi ng dispensa eh. Hit and run, grabe.
"Insensitivity" is not a crime. Yes, mali siya for not showing concern kahit katiting lang sana but you can't sue people for not helping you. It's no one's obligation to help.
Hindi naman sinabi na ang pagiging insensitive ang crime. Ang pagiging iresponsable ng lalake ang dahilan ng aksidente. Halimbawa, may matanda sa daan na pakalat kalat. Kung ikaw ang driver sa sasakyan, iiwas ka at di ka gagawa ng kahit na ano para masaktan siya dahil alam mo na responsibilidad mo yun. Kung may utak ka na marunong magmalasakit sa iba in the first place hindi mo ihaharang ang bag mo sa daanan. Malinaw pa sa sikat ng araw na walang presensya ng pagiisip itong lalaki na ito at walang pakialam sa kaligtasan ng kapwa niya.
Sempre titingin ka muna sa dadaanan mo diba bgo ka mag lakad! Same thing sa parking lot o pag tawid titingin ka muna sa paligid kung may sasakyan bgo ka tumawid kc baka masagasaan ka!
Kung mangyari yan sa matandang kamag-anak niyo na babae ... example sa nanay o lola niyo sabihin niyo...mama o lola tingin ka kasi sa dinadaanan mo?! Dapat hindi nilagay ng hayop na lalake na yon ang bag niya dun...dapat sa tabi niya...at di sa space or harap ng matandang babae.
1:57 pano pa sya mka tingin sa dinadaanan Nya e nun tumalikod sya andun kaagad Ang bag.. Pag ikaw ba tumalikod tumitingin ka BA sa baba kaagad or mas tumitingin ka sa malayo? And besides ni Hindi nga ung matanda nkapag 1 step man LNG natalisod kaagad sya. Paano mu kya Masasabi na TINGIN TINGIN KA MUNA SA DADAANAN.
Maiba lang ako, bakit kasi nagaalis pa ng sapatos sa airport. When i went to the USA AND other countries no need mag alis ng shoes, unless high boots ang suot mo. Sa atin naman kasi OA pagka strict. Sana si kuya kinuha ang shoes at nagsuot sa dulo nalamg ng conveyer para hindi siya abala.
I live in the US and travel a lot. There are still a lot of airports requiring you to remove your shoes. Only kids younger than 12 are exempt from this rule. I'd rather have OA na security than have another terrorist incident. As far as that man is concerned, shame on him. Although he was in the wrong for putting that bag in the way, clearly, he did not intend this to happen. However, to walk away? not apologize? Do nothing?? That makes him scum in my book. He deserves to at least be publicly shamed for that.
Walang kasalanan yong lalake. Tumingin siguro sa daanan pagmay time. Kahit dalhin niyo pa kung saan mang korte. Di naman niya tinulak ang babae. Bakit xa magsosorry? Dahil sa katan*ahan ng iba?
This is what is wrong with our society. People like you who are devoid of concern for others, people whose ego is bigger than his/her heart. Mga taong nakadisgrasya na ay mayabang pang ayaw magsorry man lang. Kahit gaano ka pa kaedukado pag wala kang modo, wala kang kwentang tao.
Ang galing mo anon 02:46am! Sana sa susunod madapa ka!! Kung susuriin mong mabuti, inilagay talaga nya sa kung saan malalagay sa alanganin ung matanda! Hindi yan ang tawag katangahan nung babae kc sino ba nmang matino ang maglalagay sa daraanan, malinaw na hindi nga sa unahan eh!! Tignan mong maige!!!
Kasalanan niya dahil binaba ng lalake ang bag niya sa hindi dapant babaan ng bag. Dapat dun niya binaba yung bag niya sa dulo at hindi pag labas pa lang ng xray machine. Hindi kailangan tumingin ng babae dahil wala dapat bag dun in the first place.
What's wrong with you Anon 2:46? Yes, it is obviously an accident and perhaps he may not be held accountable for this incident BUT he should at least show concern and help that woman. If that woman is your mom or a relative, I am SURE you will eat your words!
315 pm there is no law that mandates people to help those who are in distress. Being a Good Samaritan is a personal choice. No one can force a person to help out. If you look at the video there are a lot of people helping the lady already, so with all those people around her , tell us what do you want him to do?
The guy was heartless. i agree it was an accident brought about by katan*ahan kasi we should be mindful where we put our stuff esp if it's enroaching other people's space. But then again, dapat nkatingin din tayo where we're going. Grabe yung mama nakatingin lang when he witnessed what caused the accident and could walk away calmly as if walang nangyari.
"Parang sadya". Kaso hindi eh. Nilagay niya lang and the lady did not look at where she was going. The guy can be faulted for not showing concern or sympathy pero that's it.
yun din ang naisip ko parang sinadya!!! kahit ako di ko iisipin na may bag sa dada-anan ko noh kasi mga tao sa unahan ko nagsi-alisan na so didiretso na lang ako at hindi ako titingin. napaka OA ko naman kung bawat hakbang ko check ko kung may papatid sa akin.
i dont agree na sinadya niya. and sorry pero para sakin di kasi tumitingin sa dinadaanan ung nadapa kaya siya natalisod. hate me for this but if maghahanap tayo ng may kasalanan, kasalanan un ng nadapa. we can'a always blame someone else for our katangahan.
Haay nako posting something like this in fb is so cheap. Yung mga tao naman nahusgahan na agad ung isa kung maka comment wagas. Problema na nila yan. Anyway, the incident is just an accident. Baka may iba iniisip si kuya kaya.sya di natulungan haha. Case of stupidity ng both parties.
Hindi nakatingin yung lalake nung nadapa yung babae. Wala din nagsabi sa kanya. Malay ba niya kung bigla pala nahimatay yung babae? ACCIDENT ITO, daming kumukulong dugo dito.
I felt sorry for the woman. But based on the video and knowing its at the airport..a busy place sana konting alalay lang tayo. Pero sa video clueless ang guy na natripped sa bag si ale. And he didnt bother first hes in a hurry to go out and 2nd meron na 3 guys umaalalay. Again, i felt sorry for the woman pero to send this all over media and manawagan to look for that guy and pay whatever---- way to overboard! Girl aksidente ang nangyari. Now if what you are saying na sana naging compassionate yong guy - nasa knya na yun. Pero legally, it was at the airport, busiest place on earth.
Mga BULAG ang nagsasabing HINDI kasalanan ng lalake! Malinaw na inilagay ng kupal na yan sa unahan ng babae ung bags nya! Malinaw na makakasanhi ng aksidente! Tama aksidente ang nangyari na sana naiwasan kung yang lalake na yan responsable! Parang kau dun na nagsasabing d dapat sisihin ung lalake, tanong ko lang kau ba paggumagamit ng extension wire igaharang nyo sa daraanan? Na alam mong pupwedeng maka aksidente? Or magtatapon ka ba ng balat ng saging sa daraanan ng tao na alam mong may madudulas??!!! ANO SAGOT!!!!
This is purely accident on the part of the lady.. In a rush and busy situations like these, sometimes we are unmindful of our steps lalo na kung pare-parehong pagod sa biyahe o puyat o antok.. On the part of the guy, hindi natin alam kung bakit absentmindedly eh dun niya nilagay yung bag niya.. kasi nga nakita nya yung sapatos niya dun sa conveyor at dali-dali nyang kinuha ito para isuot too late to find out na may nadapa na pala dahil sa bag niya.. Maybe in his thoughts alam niyang wala siyang kasalanan.. Wala siyang naramdamang guilt dahil wala siyang ganung intensyon na saktan yung babae.. Yung feeling na yun ang naging dahilan kung bakit nawala sa puso niya ang pag aalala sa sinapit ng babae.. Alam niyang wala siyang kasalanan.. Andun ang pagkakamali.. Dapat nag-SORRY siya dahil siya ang factor sa pagkakadapa nung babae.. Umiral ang Dedma Attitude.. By this time, may nararamdaman na ang kanyang kunsensya.. At sa klase ng taong nakita natin sa video, iiral pa rin sa kanya ang dedma attitude..
Kitang kita nung manhid na lalake na nadapa ang matandang babae dahil sa bag niya, tapos parang tuod lang wala man lang ginawa ang lalake. grabe anong nangyayari sa lipunan!? bakit dumadami ang mga katulad ng lalakeng to wala man lang ni katiting na malasakit sa paligid!?
It's so abvious that the man and the woman were not on their usual sense of self. Bot were absent minded. It's just an accident. And it do happen, in the most unexpected ways.
Teh, given na "accident" ang nangyari kumbaga hindi sinasadya, pero bakit HINDI man Lang SIYA nag apologize? Ni HINDI mukhang na-concern yun mamang yon dun sa nadapa?! So SELFISH na iniwan niya Lang yun nadapa without asking a medical help around that airport EH wala, umalis ang hinayupak na mamang yon!
"The incident caused injury to the left side of Hofilena's face, fractured her left shoulder bones, and dislocated her left shoulder joints that totally disabled her, a complaint she filed before the Regional Trial Court of Bacolod said."
Kahit aksidente, the victim is 64-years old, sana tumulong man lang siya..
10:04 AM, YOU TEACH KIDS TO ALWAYS LOOK WHERE THEY ARE GOING. THERE WAS NO SIGN THAT STATED DO NOT PUT YOUR BAGS THERE. I FLY IN AND OUT OF INTERNATIONAL AIRPORTS, THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS THAT OBSTRUCT THE PASSAGEWAYS. Bags , kids , outstretched legs are things that an ordinary person CAN expect to find there or should see and avoid. We all have an obligation to watch where we're going. TO WATCH YOUR OWN THINGS IS A PERSONAL DECISION AS WELL AS CONCERN FOR OTHER PEOPLE. BUT THEIR IS NO LAW THAT MANDATES THAT. SO, DON'T DUH ME BUT DUH YOURSELF! THAT'S WHAT FREE WILL IS ALL ABOUT! YOU TAKE CARE OF YOUR OWN BELIEFS AND VALUES BUT YOU CAN NOT IMPOSE YOUR WILL, BELIEFS OR VALUES ON OTHERS. The accident happened as well because of the woman's carelessness and that is her obligation to herself. A person needs to take care of her own self, health and safety as these things are not other people's obligation. Your argument is moot! Reasonableness is not established.
WHat happened to to our society? I can't believe you guys are blaming the woman for the guy's stupidity. WHo is in his right mind would put his language one the walkway? ANd who in his right mind would blame the woman for the accident? Plain stupid. It was the man's fault because he is stupid. ALong with that, the Airport Management has negligence. They should have put a Sign somewhere to remind passengers like him to not to put their bags on walkways. And they should have someone assigned in that area to monitor the passengers.
sobrang kasalanan talaga ng guy kahit san mo tignan.. unang una.. nauna yung girl dun sa pwesto.. then why would you put your bag in front of the person before you.. common sense diba?! ilagay mo yung bag mo sa pwesto mo or sa likod mo.. yung girl she doesnt need to look kse wala namang dapat nakalagay dun.. besides ni hinde nga sya naka full step.. umikot pa lang sya to make her 1st step she tripped na.. mali na nga yung guy sa paglagay nung bag.. and yet the nerve of him pa to walk away from the scene.. kita naman nya na the girl tripped from his bag.. or kahit pa na iba ang situation na kunwari hinde sa bag nya nadapa yung girl.. di ba human nature dapat ang instict ng tao is to help out or at least ask kung ok lang ba sya.. this guy grabe..!! he just walked away..!! ngayon lang ako nakakita ng ganyang tao..
Look at the video closely and watch where her eyes and her head was positioned. Ok ? Don't be overrun by your emotions! Accidents do happen unfortunately. That's why there is such a word as accident.
12:33, accidents do happen pero you should be responsible for the damages you caused. Same concept ng may mabangga ka, accident. Pero diba binabayaran ang damages ng na accident mo? Siguro ikaw yung nag hit and run dun sa isang bata... accident eh??
10:02 am the woman as well contributed to the accident. WHY? She was careless! We all have an obligation to watch where we're going. It is her duty to herself to look and avoid what is in front of her.
One's responsibility is to make sure he or she is not in the way of others so as not to cause harm. If ganyan thinking mo then people would be careless... they can put their stuff anywhere, park anywhere, litter anywhere, and your sole responsibility would be to avoid other people's carelessness. This thinking is absurd!
The man has been negligent and caused serious injury! Analogy, if you put pots sa balcony mo and nahulog sa ground and may nabagsakan and namatay, may responsibilidad yung may ari ng pots sa pagkakamatay ng nahulugan. In this instance, kung di ba naman pulpol yung mama harangan ang daanan (daanan, hindi baggage counter) at di bantayan yung bag nya na naka cause ng accident, dapat sya managot! He is liable under the civil law.
Negligence definitely not , idiotic yes . As they say look where you are going. Liability no. If you say so which part of civil or criminal law says that? An apology perhaps ? But , how can a person apologize for something that he was not aware of doing? Yes he was indifferent to the whole incident but there is no law to compell people to extend a helping hand at all times. Yes honey, there is a thing called free will. I can choose what to do and not to do.
5:06 i agree! Nangyari na yan sa akin. Yung unit ko sa pasig natanggal yung glass ng window at nahulog sa driveway ng parking area at nahulugan isang car na dumadaan. Aksidente yun malinaw. Hindi ko naman sinadyang bakbakin yung sealant ng glass para mahulog. Sa lakas ng hangin nung bumabagyo natanggal na pala yung glass sa kalumaan. Pero since sa window ko nang galing yung glass responsibilidad kong akuuin yung dapat ko bayarang damage at humingi ng pasensya sa naperwisyo tao. Yung babae sa video 64 yrs old nagka injury sa face, nagka fracture sa bones. Nadislocate pa ang left shoulder nya. Sobrang laking problema naidulot nung pagkaka lagay nung bags sa tabi nya. Sana man lang nag stay muna yung lalaki at he made sure na maayos muna kalagayan ng babae bago sya umalis.
12:30, do you know what negligence means? Pabaya! Being an idiot is besides the point. Whether he apologizes or not, he should be liable. Pa free will - free will ka pa dyan, so ok lang patayin kita dahil may free will ako? At hindi ako masasakdal dahil sa free will na yan??
According to the Philippine Civil Law: Art. 20. “Every person who, contrary to law, wilfully or negligently causes damage to another, shall indemnify the latter for the same.”
He was so dumb. He should've not placed his things in a place where it can be an obstruction to someone or something. If it was me, I'll place it on my side or on a space away from anybody else. And he could've least helped the woman, obviously he saw it and was like "keber".
Ang mali nung lalaki is, hindi man lang sya tumulong kahit mag sorry man lang knowing na bag nya yung dahilan kung bakit nadapa yung victim. Sana man lang itinabi nya gamit nya at tumulong sya na buhatin at paupuin yung victim. But blaming the guy for what happened is wrong, it was unintentional. Hindi siguro nya naisip na possible na madapa yung victim gawa hinarang nya yung bag nya.
LIABILITY OCCURS WHEN THE PERSON HAS ESTABLISHED THAT SHE HERSELF DID EVERYTHING TO AVOID IT. THE VIDEO DOES NOT LIE! SHE AIN'T LOOKING WHERE SHE IS GOING. IT'S THE SAME AS IF SOMEBODY SLIPS ON DOG POOP OUTSIDE MY HOUSE, I AM NOT LIABLE AS I AM NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR CLEANING EVERY DOG POOP THAT IS LEFT THERE.
You cannot avoid everything as you have no control of what other people do. Kahit sobrang pag iingat mo pero other people are careless, it can cause you harm. The video doesn't lie and it is not ok to leave your bag unattended especially on the way of other people.
Poop in front your house is different especially if it's not your dog's poop. And in the video, it is the man's bag that caused harm to the woman because of his carelessness.
Hey people it was an ACCiDENT! Both of them were at fault. The guy for obstructing and the woman for not looking where she was going.. I did not know that refusing to help , being indifferent and being unapologetic for an incident that one is totally unaware of is a crime. Tsk tsk tsk
No one is saying it is a crime. He did not need to help her stand up, apologize and be sympathetic. What he needs is to be liable for the injury he has caused! Accident or intentional basta naka agrabyado ka kailangan mo managot. Otherwise people could all be careless and not be liable for damages!
accidents can be avoided....if you are using your head. That guy seems to be in his own bubble. The Lady of course didn't anticipate the bag to be there because in the first place it wasn't there when she got at that point in the line. That guy has no sensitivity to others. Of course on top of that the bag shouldn't be there, the lady was also preoccupied with fixing her things or whatever next thing she is going to do because having an object beside her legs is not even the correct thing to happen having those bags near her legs would be the last thing to anticipate. I think that guy is just plain stupid. Of course he didn't help her, and it seems he just froze because I think for one he already felt guilty, and second, he could sense he could get in trouble if he apologized and let them be aware it was his bag that caused the accident. The security and the other people should have that ability to find out what happened, they probably thought she just felt dizzy or what....poor lady...that guy next to her in line is just an all around douche.
sana ma identify ung lalake ng makasuhan, ng mabigyan ng leksyon. Ang sakit sa loob panoorin papano kung nanay o lola mo yun. Nde totoo na d alam ng lalake and d nya napansin na sa bag nya natisod ung matanda. Nakatingin sya the whole time.
Based sa mga comments dito debating if kasalanan nung lalaki or not so san lulugar ang airport lalo na ang cebu pacific?? Ni hindi nga alam kung pasahero din ba ng cebu pacific si kuya??
For those who said na OA Ang post Ng anak sa fb or sa nag sabing pinost Nya just to gain sympathy and sa nagsabing accident LNG walang kasalanan ung lalaki and dapat no need to ask for financial assistance ksi nga accident??!!! Kaso kahit sang angolo mu tignan aksidente man o Hindi dapat ung lalaki tumbling man LNG kahit papano and he can't deny na d nya alam ksi kitang kita sa video na ung babae got tripped bcoz of his bag. He detest even bothered to show concern sa mas matnda sa kanya and even some said na sana tumingin din ung matanda sa dinadaanan nya eh kahit ikaw nga cguro first thing that u will do pag talikod e tumingin sa malayo Hindi ung pag talikod mu sa baba ka kaagad titingin and tama ung observation nang iba ni Hindi man nkapag 1 step ung matanda ksi nga ung irresponsible na guy dun talaga sa likod Ng babae nilagay ung bag.and Hindi LNG bag ha BAGS. And the fact na nag cause un nang injury and damages sa family I don't think na e blame LNG lahat sa babae. Na keso Hindi sya tumingin sa dinadaanan. And yes walang kasalanan Ang airline dun but ung airport can b blamed Kasi wla silang sariling ambulance. Pano na LNG pag may mga ganyan emergency mag aantay na LNG lagi. Tsk tsk tsk I HOPE THIS WILL SERVE AS A LESSON TO EVERYBODY AMD KY KUYA NA VERY IRRESPONSIBLE ALAM MU KUNG ANO ANG NANGYARI AT NAKITA MU so sana makonsensya ka at harapin mu ung Tao na kinaused mu Ng damaged. GOD BLESS YOU ALL
the man caused the lady's fall because he showed: 1) no manners for not waiting his turn, and 2) no common sense or lack of concern for the safety of others. In short, this incident could have been avoided if only he had been a gentleman.
Kung may baril ako at nag paputok sa langit tapos may tinamaan sa kabilang baranggay, may kasalanan ba ako? The same thing lang yun with this guy. Nag lagay ako ng obstruction sa daanan tapos may nadapa kaya dapat siyang managot. Hindi lang ikaw ang tao sa mundo kaya paminsan minsan, be accountable sa mga actions mo.
Purely an accident!! Hindi nga lang nagpakitang tao yun guy na mag sorry kya madami nagrere-act, but hey! there are bigger national issues that you can argue about guys!!!
Yung ibang nag cocomment dito wala sigurong alam sa kalakaran sa airport dito sa pinas. Ganyan talaga ang gawa pag madami ka bag na kinukuha from scanner. Ibababa mo sa tabi mo ung iba. Disoriented sila pareho. Kaya nga ung nanay ko, inaalalayan namin parati. Si ate hindi nya tiningnan nilalakaran nya. Naka 2 steps pa sya bago mag dive.
Sus sa nakikita ko, di alam ng lalaki na bag nya nakaharang kaya natumba si Ate, purely accident lang ang nagyari. Si ate naman maka sabi ng magbabayad at di matatakasan ang ginawa ng lalaki. Teh kung walang video makakahusga ka kaya kaagad ng ganyan. At ito may video intindihin muna wag kaagad magsalita ng ganyan sa social media. Maaring walang may gusto sa nangyari. Si kuya naman sana andun pa rin ang pagkaPilipino nya na dapat tumulong kay ate para maiahon sabagay ika nga ' Every individual has its own individual differences' eh baka nga di likas sa kanya ang matulungin kaya ayun naging issue sa kanya na pinabayaan nya lang ang nangyari.
I don't think the man realized that the woman tripped on his bag. It happened so fast. There were people in uniform helping the woman so he did not bother to join in. In general, the wisest thing to do in an accident is to let the professionals do their job. Meron kasi tayong usi mentality kaya binubully si Manong. Konting hinahon lang. The poster of this video clearly stated that he/she wants APOLOGY and MONEY. Piling on the guy will produce neither.
OMG i just saw this now. I paused and replayed the video over and over and saw that the man actually saw what happened but acted oblivious to the accident! kapal na mukha di man lang nag offer ng tulong at nag apologize as dedma lang sya. i hope the lady fully recovered from this.
Anong kasalanan ng lalake? Sorry lang tapos.
ReplyDeleteSana mangyari sa parents mo dahil dyan sa comment mo. Brutal kung brutal but you asked for it. Napaka insensitive ng comment mo parang wala kang nanay!
DeleteKasalanan niya is una sa pila yung babae! Now Kung nauna man lumabas yung baggage ng guy e dapat nagantay pa din siya na nakuha muna ng nasa harap niya yung mga baggage! Na iisang piraso lang naman ng bag! Kaya nga me term na courtesy...nakakapanginig ka ng laman!
DeleteUnjust vexation iyan. Hinarang ang bag, nakipag unahan sa pila. Naka cause siya ng harm sa ginawa niya. Kup@l nakakagigil. kawawa talaga
DeleteExactly! I sympathize with the family pero grabe ha, ang OA lang. Sometimes ang mga Pinoy mahilig mang-blame ng iba. Ok, siguro hindi siya tumulong sa nadapa pero di naman niya obligation na tumulong eh. Yun lang naman siguro ang "mali" niya. LET'S GET REAL, PEOPLE! Tsaka, sisihin pa nila ang Cebu Pac? Eh ano ang liability ng airline dun? She was merely a (would-have-been) passenger and the incident didn't happen inside the plane naman. Kaloka talaga!
Delete- Pamintang Lawyer
5.07 are you blind? He CAUSED the old lady to fall flat on her face. That was HIS fault.
Deletenamiss ko tong si pamintang lawyer.
Delete1:01 It was clearly an accident. The lady ACCIDENTALLY tripped on the bag. Ok, sure, the man shouldn't have placed the bag there but to say he deliberately placed it there to trip others is surely false. The only bad thing the man did was that he did not show the least concern when the event happened in front of him. The rest was purely an ACCIDENT.
DeleteThe feeling isn't mutual, 1:24! Hahaha! Kidding!
Delete- Pamintang Lawyer
12:45 What? "Unjust vexation"??? Do you even know what that means? It only happens when there is coercion, te! When something is done against one's will. Sinabi ba ng guy na dapat madapa si ate sa bag niya? Kaloka to! Tsaka di crime ang mauna sa pila no! Ate looked like she even acquiesced to being behind the line if we argue na it's "crime" na mauna ka sa pila, lolololol. Besides, is the guy's "pag-una sa pila" the main cause of the tripping ni ate sa bag? Of course, not! The lady INADVERTENTLY and ACCIDENTALLY tripped on the bag.
DeleteIt was just an accident. I sympathize with the family pero wag sana OA at lawsuit-happy. The guy doesn't owe you more than saying sorry.
- Pamintang Lawyer
1:01 di ko maiwasan matawa, as in fall flat on her face ha,lol correction it's called actual planking!
DeleteFrom what school did you graduate from Pamintang Lawyer? Were you not taught of the elementary doctrine of "El que es causa de la causa es causa del mal causado?" Dunung-dunungan kasi. We should not encourage lawsuits but we should also not let people get away with these things
DeleteI know who you are, Pamintang Lawyer... HAHA!
Deletelol anong coercion pinagsasabi mo, paminta? unjust vexation doesn't even require coercion. do u even know what unjust vexation is? annoyance/vexation lang requirement nun oy. in tagalog, naasar or napahiya. grabe. lawyer ka ba tlga?
Deleteand true, aksidente ung nangyari, wag masyadong oa.
Pamintang Lawyer -
DeleteSaan mo napulot yung elements ng unjust vexation? Hahaha kaloka si bakla galingan pa ang pagpapanggap next time.
this is obviously an accident but caused by the guy's neglect. it's bad enough that this happened, but worse when he just walked away. sorry guys but I love mommies. This could have been fatal esp at her age. haaaayyyyyy
DeleteAy sus Walang kinalaman ang coercion sa Unjust vexation, porket magkatunog ang dulo. Mahabagin... di ka pamintang lawyer noh, baklang parlorista ka lang eh. Aminin!
DeleteFeeling ko naman hindi alam n guy na bag nya nakapagpatumba sa matanda. Parang ang dating eh akala nya bgla nagcollapse. Hindi naman cguro ganun kasama si kuya para hndi tulungan kung lam nya sya ang cause
DeleteArt 2176 of the Civil Code states that "Whoever by act or omission causes damage to another, there being fault or negligence, is obliged to pay for the damage done." The man should be liable for the injuries sustained by the victim.
DeleteI agree with 3:31. accident na pwede sana naiwasan kung nag isip ung lalaki sa pinaglagyan nya ng bag nya at ung mga tao na malapit sa paligid nya.
Deletenakilala na ba sino ang lalaki?
Que horror!!!...ang shupal ng fez ni manong he didnt even bothered to say sorry or help the poor woman and the guards my gosh! Theyre so lame in addressing the accident kasuhan ang dapat kasuhan!!!...yun na! Paaak!
ReplyDeletedi ba na-train ang mga personnel sa NAIA ng first aid? nkakatakot pla kng meron emergency mngyayari di nla alam gagawin. pinaupo pa nla sa gitna? kaloka!
Delete12:40 Basa-basa naman before commenting. It didn't happen in NAIA, though I wouldn't be surprised if the staff there didn't know first aid either haha!
DeleteNAIA??? Bacolod nga dba? Ako naman kinalaman Ng NAIA dito? Hindi ko ho lahat Ng airport Sa Pilipinas, NAIA.
Delete1:52 Sabog comment mo te. Tulog na haha.
DeleteHonestly walang kasalanan ung guy. Its an accident kya kahit na magsorry sya wala pa din kaso o pede ireklamo sa knya. Ayun lang di sya nagsorry. Wala syang konsensya.
ReplyDelete5:13 Paanong walang kasalanan yung lalaki? Mag isip ka nga!!! Normal ba na ibalandra ang bag sa dinadaanan ng tao? Hindi magkaka aksidente kung hindi nilagay nung gag*ng lalaki yung mga bags nya sa daanan!!! Natural makaka patid yun noh! Mag isip ka nga bago ka mag comment dito fp! Kaka highblood ka din!
DeleteExactly! That's the point. The whole lawsuit thing is over the top. Pinoy nga naman, naghahanap palagi ng masisisi. Kaloka! OA!
Deletewalang kasalanan??? ilagay mo ba naman ang bag mo na kakulay ng carpet sa likod ng isang tao na pag humarap eh madadapa. nagiisip ka ba?
DeleteThere is clearly a criminal case here...Article 275 of the Revised Penal Code punishes "Anyone who shall fail to help or render assistance to another whom he has accidentally wounded or injured."
Deletehindi ko nakitang nakipag unahan sya ng pila.ang probs din sa airport wala malalagyan ng bag.ganyan din gawa namin lagay nalang sa sahig kasi pag iwan lang sa table sasabihan lang din aloiin agad para iwas magkabuhol2 mga bag.d naman agad makakuha ng cart maliban kung may kasama ka.
DeleteWOW HA. Wow talaga, Kahit na sabihing aksidente ang nangyari, sana man lang nag-sorry tong si kuya. Eh parang walang nangyari eh. To think na nagulat din sya sa pagbagsak ng ale. Tsk2. Kids these days,,,
ReplyDeletehe's not even a kid. nasa tamang pag-iisip na dapat yan, sana man lang nag-sorry or inalalayan man lang!
Deletealam mo yung sarcastic?
DeleteWapakels yung mamang may kasalanan.. nakakaloka! Deadma lang nakita naman nyang nadapa dahil sa bag nya. Tsk tsk..
ReplyDeleteFirst the kid and the Montero, now this?! What is happening to our people?!
ReplyDeleteI experienced the same thing. I got held up inside the FX in Espana and all the passengers in the middle, in front and the driver did nothing. They just watched while the guy were trying to get my phone from my hand and pointing a knife on my face. I didn't let go until I realized that I also got my laptop with me. Worse, after the guy fled, all passengers went back in and the driver drove away as if nothing happened. No one offered help or at least console me. DEDMA LANG SILANG LAHAT! Nag-sakay pa yung driver ng pasahero sa Quiapo while I was crying my heart out at the back. The couple (yung sumakay sa Quiapo) were kind enough to offer me pamasahe but good thing na din I still have my wallet. Wala na ko nagawa dahil sa trauma and went home na lang.
Kapal nung mukha nung guy sa video! Mukhang hindi man lang nag-sorry!
I don't believe the man who owns the bag that the lady tripped on should be held responsible. It was clearly an accident. But the man should've at least checked on the lady and shown a little bit of concern.
ReplyDeleteAccident or not, it was the man's fault because he placed the bag right beside the woman. She didn't know that a bag was placed there because when she turned to get her stuff, there was no bag yet. Lagyan ba naman ng bag sa tabi ng paa! Shempre mapapatid ka talaga.
DeleteI agree...dapat tinulungan niya yung matanda at hindi parang ewan lang siyang walang ginawa..palibhasa "K....P...L!
Deletekindly check art. 275 of the revised penal code which penalizes Anyone who shall fail to help or render assistance to another whom he has accidentally wounded or injured.
Delete5:20 So kung tumatawid ka sa dinadaanan ko at nasagasaan kita ng kotse ko i wont be held responsible kasi "accident" naman ang nangyari. Swerte naman ng makaka disgrasya syo di mo pala sisisihin LOL
Deletetama ka 10:50
DeleteOk, given that accidents happen, he still has to be responsible for an accident he caused. Whether it was intentional or not. Hello, pag nakabangga ka ng car, kahit di mo sinasadya, kailangan mong panagutan ang damages.
ReplyDeleteKawawa naman yung mom. I saw the full video on Facebook. Swak sa ilong, as in flat on her face ang hulog. And the man didn't even bother, even though when you look at him as it happened, kitang-kita niya na it was his error that caused the fall. Nakatingin kaya siya when the lady tripped over his bag. Makonsensiya ka naman!
Why would he be held liable? Kasi hindi nagsorry? Well dapat naman nagpakita sya ng concern pero to be held liable for that? Wag ito itulad sa car accidents this is different. Natapilok sya sa bag kasi hindi nya nakita. May fault yung babae. Wala namang sign na bawal ilagay sa spot na yun ang bags. Dont get me wrong, i sympathize with her entirely and i wish umayos na yung lagay nya pero hinay hinay lang tayong gamitin ang 'victim card'.
DeleteHello Iba naman kaya yun??? Nagdridrive ka dapat focus ka! e sa video naman, hindi nakita nung babae yung bag. Ang dapat jan, ayusin ang mga airport maglagay ng mga rules para naiiwasan ang aksidente. Isisisi niyo lahat doon sa lalaki, e malay ba niya na mangyayari yun!
Deletemga baks, negligence un. liable ka pa rin dun. same lang sa car accident, same lang sa dog bites. liable ka dahil we have a responsibility to the public not to cause any harm. public negligence ung kahit may nakausling pako sa gilid ng bahay mo. gets mo? magkakaibang level but still is the same.
DeleteParang bloopers lang e pero hindi kasi makapaghintay yung Ga*ong Put*+%#! lalaki na parang me taxing naghihintay sa kanya at umaandar ang metro! Nakita naman niyang nauuna yung babae! Tapos patay mali lang ang Puny++**!!!!!
ReplyDeleteIt was an accident. she should've been more careful sa dinadaanan niya. And the guy should've been more aware kung saan niya binaba yung carry on item niya. Sus too bad so sad but it's an accident! I don't think the guy is liable. It still boils down to, be aware of your surroundings.
ReplyDeleteKung mother mo ang nadapa at nagka injury anon 5:31 ganyan pa rin kaya ang sasabihin mo?
Delete2:28 But it wasn't his/her mom, so your comment is not applicable. And even if it was, the same will happen: you can't sue because you were not helped when you ACCIDENTALLY tripped on a bag. Mapag-uusapan naman yan eh.
DeleteAnon 2:52 Am
DeleteArticle 275 of the revised penal code. Google it!
dapat naman kasi yung bag sa dulo na kuhain hindi yung sinasalubong sa paglabas ng conveyor. Kung sana hindi atat yung lalake na kunin yung bag eh di sana naka iwas pa sa aksidente.
ReplyDeleteAng OA ng FB post. Gusto pa mag reach out yung airport or cebupac. Ano namang kasalanan ng airport at ng cebupac sa pagka patid ng nanay mo teh?? Malinaw na accident walang may kasalanan, hala Sige Singilin mo ng danyos yung bag!
ReplyDeleteNakakaawa ang lady pero Over naman itong nag post sa facebook na anak nya, hindi naman sinadya patirin ng lalake yung mom nya, clearly it was an accident, katawan mo dapat responsibilidad mo, napatid si Mom dahil Di rin sya tumingin sa nilakaran nya. Not a reason para sirain pagkatao nung lalake sa video. Papano naman sya mag sosorry me commotion na mga nagkagulo na guard na tumulong, kita naman sa video na tumingin yun lalake and parang hesitant and movement nya, di naman sya biglang layas na walang paki. Hwag Naman OA at lahat dadaanin sa social media, di porke nadisgrasya ang isang tao we will always look for somebody to blame.
ReplyDeletetbh feeling ko kashungahan talaga un. pero dapat nga nag sorry manlang si manong.
ReplyDeleteSino ba yang lalaking yan? Sarap gulpihin! Hindi man lang nya tinulungan yung babae at nag apologize! At yung mga guard bakit hindi man lang pinag sabihan yung lalaki? Sarap ihambalos dun sa lalaki yung mga bags nya! Pasensya na lumalabas pagka war freak ko pag nakaka basa ako ng mga ganitong mga taong nkaka perwisyo ng kapwa pero hindi pinapanagutan ang kanilang kasalanan kagaya nung nakasagasa ng bata na tumakas. Haaaay! Nakakalungkot makitang may mga taong walang puso at awa sa kapwa!
ReplyDeleteSue that devil! He should atleast offer a helping hand when he saw the old lady on the floor. He knew from the start that he/his bag cause the accident. Leaving it on the middle. That area is suppose to be free from any clutter kasi people daanan yun. At yung mga guard, tang-a din...they should hold that guy for a while and ask a little info about him in case the old woman needs financial help.
ReplyDeleteSue him for what?? You're funny! And financial help?? Are you serious? It's clearly an accident! Ang OA nyo! Yes the guy could have said sorry and helped the lady pero clearly hindi nya kasalanan!
Delete12:27 eh kung accidentally nasagasaan ka ng kotse, sorry lang?
DeleteAnon 12:27 sana madapa ka rin dahil sa kapabayaan ng ibang tao para malaman mo pakiramdam. Ewan ko lang kung masabi mo pang accident pag muka mo ang nasubsob. Baka mas OA ka pa mag react pag ikaw na ang nasaktan LOL
DeleteAnon 12:27
DeleteArticle 275 of the revised penal code. It's clearly a criminal case!
b*ll$#** na lalaking may ari sa maletang humarang sa daanan nung matanda!!! prang t@ng@ lang si kuya! buti pa ung lalake sa kabila nakuhang tumulong, sya prang wala lang. kuya sana madapa ka rin una muka mo.as in una ung muka mo!!!! kabanas ka!!! kung sino ka man!!
ReplyDeleteI don't think he's responsible for paying her hospitalization fees, but as a human being he should have at least shown some ounce of concern.
ReplyDeletewtf!
ReplyDeleteI dont see why they have to post this and hunt the guy with the bag. Para ano? Para mag sorry? Wala siyang kasalanan. Hindi rin niya ginusto yung nangyari. Sinadya niya ba?pinost lang ito to gain sympathy. or para mabash yung guy. Actually, sa part na yan, laging aligaga ang mga tao. Kasi lahat ng gamit pinapatanggal diba. Naoobserve ko lang. Lahat nagmamadaling isuot at kunin ang mga gamit.
ReplyDeleteSorry, pero mukhang clueless c Manong that his bag caused the lady's accident.
ReplyDeleteAng kasalanan nung lalakeng naka yellow wala syang common sense! Kasalanan ng airport or airlines staff yan. Dapat sinabihan nila yung lalake na tumabi at itabi yung luggages nya kasi abala sya don sa daan! Doon pa talaga nagsuot ng sapatos ha!
ReplyDeleteAnong airline staff? Wala nmn sila kinalaman jan.
DeleteWhen I watched the video i think the man didnt know it was his bag's fault. But seeing a woman tripped in front of you he doesnt seem bothered and just walk away. Thats his mistakes
ReplyDeleteNo doubt the guy was a jerk for having no reaction at all to the incident but we can see in the video that it was not intentional, there was no malice nor it was a pre-meditated event. If there is no intention to harm, where is the culpability? Accidents happen and it was unfortunate that it happened to her mother but to ask for compensation not only for her mother but to her Parents is stretching justice far beyond its scope. And the act of cyber bullying an individual in social media in the guise of justice when there was no established fact of culpability is by itself is an act of terrorism too.
ReplyDeleteSocial media has been used and abused by some and this is one example of its excesses. My sympathy is with your Mother and maybe if your intention was for that jerk guy to say sorry to your mom then I would gladly agree with you, after all, being a Gentleman is a rarity nowadays but since the premise of your call was all about compensation then.... try harder next time to convince us.
12:11 I don't think it's cyber bullying it's more on AWARENESS for the people to consider things that might cause accidents not only for yourself but with others too. Being a responsible citizen will not make u less of a person instead it will make yourself proud dahil gumagawa ka Ng tama.. But if this incident didn't even bothered him kahit nangyari sa harap nya kung ako ang nanay Nya kakahiya q sya.
DeleteYuck dumb guy. Dun talaga nilagay yung bag sa tabi ng babae. If it was me, itatabi ko yun sa tabi ko or sa space na walang mahaharangang tao. Tapos he saw the accident keber lang. Sarap sampalin sa itlog.
ReplyDeleteSana me makakilala sa lalake at pakisulat ng info dito. Maski man lang sa salita na ibato sa kanya e maramdaman nya sakit na dinanas nung matanda.
ReplyDeleteParang na imagine ko nanay ko na na mild stroke mahina tuhod kung sa kanya nangyari un, magwawala talaga ako at pag uupakan ko ung me ari ng bag. Deadma lang talaga sya na nagsuot ng shoes e
Itong lalaki hindi nagiisip. Una: nakita na niyang may katabi siya, hinarang pa rin ang bag sa harap sa katabi. Pangalawa: hindi pa nagsorry. Napakaselfish lang.
ReplyDeleteAnong accident ang pinagsasasabi nyo?!? It was definitely the guy's mistake! Why did he put his bag there? Eh hindi naman bag/luggage counter yun. Daan yun, for heaven's sake! He wasn't considerate for other people who are also picking up their bags! Kapag ang parking lot ba may nakatayong tao, babanggain nyo yung tao basta-basta? Di ba bubusina man lang kayo to let the person know that you'd want to park on that space? That's being considerate. This douche bag is not only inconsiderate, he's also very incompassionate. So evil! My God!
ReplyDeleteThe guy just placed his bag there. Did he deliberately put it there just so to trip others? Of course not. It was just an accident. Plain and simple. Wag OA mag-react please.
DeleteAnon 1:16 Ok ka lang? Paanong wag OA mag react??? Nasaktan yung matandang babae dahil sa ginawa nung guy and hindi man lang nag apologize eh sya nag lagay ng bags nya dun kaya nadapa yung babae so paanong hindi kami mag rereact! Hindi man lang nag pakita ng concern yung lalaki dun sa nangyari
DeleteIt was an accident. PERIOD. Walang liability si Kuya. Mali lang siguro na parang di siya concerned or di niya tinulungan yung old lady pero still, di niya obligation ang tumulong.
ReplyDeleteKamag-anak ka ba ng walang kaluluwang lalake na yan? O di kaya kapatid ka nya? Or ikaw mismo ito?.. shunga!
Delete2:07 No, I am not all that you said. I am merely a logical and rational person na nag-iisip at di nagpapadala sa emotions. Apir!
Delete2:38 logical? rational? E di ikaw na!!! Ganda pala ng rationale mu eh Hindi nya obligation e sya may ari Ng bag na pakalat2.. Tsk irrational kamo! SHUNGA PA MORE
DeleteGuys please dont say if the person has committed fault or no fault unless you've passed the bar. Do not take the word "liability" lightly. (Which of course he clearly has in this case.)
Delete12:58 Bags nung lalaki ang dahilan kung bakit nadapa yung babae so anong pinag sasasabi mo dyan na hindi responsibilidad nung lalaki ang tumulong! Pansin ko lang and dami nyo dito sa fp na kapareho ng pag uugali ng lalaki, MGA WALANG PAKIALAM SA KAPWA! Sana madapa din kayo una muka sa espalto!
DeleteNde pagiging rational yun. Selfish ka kamo. No man is an island. Papano ka ba pinalaki ng magulang mo at wala kang compassion sa mga nasaktan. Be mindful of your actions dahil lahat un me consequences. Ok lang sana kung ikaw lang lagi ang napeperwisyo pero kung sa negligence na ibaba lang ang bag kung san at me natisod, its a human national reaction na dapat tumulong at magpasintabi dahil kung d nya kinalat sa kung san ang bag nya wala sanang naaksidente.
DeleteKung ganyan ang rationalization mo sa lahat ng aksidente masahol ka pa sa hayop.
Sana din d mangyari sa nanay mo yan
11:50 totally agree with you 101% ibang tao dito pinag pipilitan tlga na aksidente ang nangyari pero di nila kino consider yung fault nung guy sa pagkakalagay ng bags nya sa daanan kaya naka tisod ng tao.
Delete$@$&$$ Patay malisya si Manong, as if he didn't know that his negligence caused the old woman to fall down. Eh he should be cautious sa luggages na inilagay nya lang sa dinadaanan ng tao, at least nilagay man lang nya sa bandang gitna. He didn't bother help or apologise to the lady. Hmmp sana hindi ka binangungot that night.
ReplyDeletemay puso ba itong lalakeng ito? nakita naman nya pero deadma lang, tinignan lang nya. oo aksidente, pero sana man lang nag sorry sya.
ReplyDeleteIt was indeed an accident. Pero sana man lang nag sorry yung guy or at least offered help. Hindi yung dedma lang. Gamit nya at katan*ahan nya ang nag cause nang accident ano. At sa nag sabi na the lady should have been more careful, eh sinu ba naman mag expect na may bag pala dun? Common sense lang hu.
ReplyDeleteAnong hindi nya obligasyong tumulong? Responsibilidad nyang tumulong kasi yung bag nya ang nag cause nang accident. Kalokah!
ReplyDeleteIkaw na mismo nagsabi, 1:24. "Responsibilidad". Therefore, it only appeals to public morals or customs. No one is "obligated" to help others. Not helping others when they tripped over is not a crime. Though masama nga ang ginawa niya because he didn't show empathy or concern, pero that's it. No compulsory monetary damages. Kung makita man sya at magbigay, it's all voluntary.
Delete- Pamintang Lawyer
Huy pamintang lawyer san ka bang gumraduate na law school. Shut up and stop miseducating people here. May kaso si lola. article 365 of the revised penal code please pakibasa. Reckless imprudence yan diba? Siya ang proximate cause diba? if you refer to 265/266 may at least slight physical injuries kasi naospital si lola diba? Naku naku naku.
DeleteTsaka yung mga shungang airport personnel pwede din kasuhan ng administrative case Kasi duty nilang ipara si kuyang nakadilaw. Hay! You are out of order.
- Ladlad na lawyer
Jusmiyo ATTORNEY-NO-CASE! Kanina ko pa nababasa comments mo dito kaloka ang pinag sasasabi mo. Pamintang paminta lang lol
DeleteHindi yan accident! Hindi nagiisip yun lalaki na daanan yun pinaglagyan nya ng bag nya. At alam naman nya me katabi sya. Kapal ng mukha akala mo parang walang nangyari di pa nagsorry.
ReplyDeleteSa nagsasabing hindi fault ng lalaki, isipin nyo nlang paano kung nanay nyo or misis nyo ang na-ganon. Would you still react the same?
ReplyDeleteIt was purely an accident. Both parties obviously didn't want it to happen. And, you can't argue using appeal to emotion. That's logical fallacy.
Delete- Pamintang Lawyer
PAMINTANG LAWYER Dba dapat sa name mu pa LNG mas ikaw Ang nakakaalam Ng law.. Hahaha And what's appeal to emotion!?
Delete12:52 Girl, google mo "appeal to emotion". If you graduated from college and you didn't know that, your school is obviously a diploma mill. Harhar! Kidding...or not! Lol
Delete- Pamintang Lawyer
The title is right. The man's bag caused the accident. Not the man. And of course, the woman was not looking.
ReplyDeleteCorrect! Exactly!
Delete1:37 Cge ang "BAGS" na ang may kasalanan. May "ISIP at PAA" yung mga bags. Nag lakad sila mag isa papunta sa tabi ng babae kaya nakadisgrasya! Masaya ka na teh? Ang bags ang dapat sisihin hindi yung may ari ng bags.
DeletePag ang bata tumatakbo ng hindi tumitingin sa pinupuntahan, sinisisi ang bata. "Ikaw kasi hindi ka tumitingin" ang ipinapangaral. Hindi kasalanan ng silya o mesa. Pag ang matanda hindi tumitingin sa nilalakaran, kasalanan ng may-ari. Ano ba talaga?
DeleteAksidente nga. Pero liable si insensitive na kuya dahil kung hindi niya hinarang ang bag niya sa dadaanan ng old lady, hindi mangyayari to. It's his carelessness that caused the accident. Hindi man lang humingi ng dispensa eh. Hit and run, grabe.
ReplyDelete"Insensitivity" is not a crime. Yes, mali siya for not showing concern kahit katiting lang sana but you can't sue people for not helping you. It's no one's obligation to help.
DeleteHindi naman sinabi na ang pagiging insensitive ang crime. Ang pagiging iresponsable ng lalake ang dahilan ng aksidente. Halimbawa, may matanda sa daan na pakalat kalat. Kung ikaw ang driver sa sasakyan, iiwas ka at di ka gagawa ng kahit na ano para masaktan siya dahil alam mo na responsibilidad mo yun. Kung may utak ka na marunong magmalasakit sa iba in the first place hindi mo ihaharang ang bag mo sa daanan. Malinaw pa sa sikat ng araw na walang presensya ng pagiisip itong lalaki na ito at walang pakialam sa kaligtasan ng kapwa niya.
DeleteHopefully, walang anak itong lalaking ito. Kung hindi, maipapasa pa nya ang kanyang rotten manners sa future generation. Makakarma karin manong.
ReplyDeleteSempre titingin ka muna sa dadaanan mo diba bgo ka mag lakad! Same thing sa parking lot o pag tawid titingin ka muna sa paligid kung may sasakyan bgo ka tumawid kc baka masagasaan ka!
ReplyDeleteYes, yes! Eto ang di makita ng ibang OA kung mag-react. Tingin2 sa dinadaanan please!
DeleteYes!
DeleteKung mangyari yan sa matandang kamag-anak niyo na babae ... example sa nanay o lola niyo sabihin niyo...mama o lola tingin ka kasi sa dinadaanan mo?! Dapat hindi nilagay ng hayop na lalake na yon ang bag niya dun...dapat sa tabi niya...at di sa space or harap ng matandang babae.
Delete1:57 pano pa sya mka tingin sa dinadaanan Nya e nun tumalikod sya andun kaagad Ang bag.. Pag ikaw ba tumalikod tumitingin ka BA sa baba kaagad or mas tumitingin ka sa malayo? And besides ni Hindi nga ung matanda nkapag 1 step man LNG natalisod kaagad sya. Paano mu kya Masasabi na TINGIN TINGIN KA MUNA SA DADAANAN.
DeleteMaiba lang ako, bakit kasi nagaalis pa ng sapatos sa airport. When i went to the USA AND other countries no need mag alis ng shoes, unless high boots ang suot mo. Sa atin naman kasi OA pagka strict. Sana si kuya kinuha ang shoes at nagsuot sa dulo nalamg ng conveyer para hindi siya abala.
ReplyDeleteApril 2014 pa yan te. The last time I flew on a plane (and that was yesterday), I didn't need to remove my shoes sa security check. NAIA to ha.
DeleteI live in the US and travel a lot. There are still a lot of airports requiring you to remove your shoes. Only kids younger than 12 are exempt from this rule. I'd rather have OA na security than have another terrorist incident. As far as that man is concerned, shame on him. Although he was in the wrong for putting that bag in the way, clearly, he did not intend this to happen. However, to walk away? not apologize? Do nothing?? That makes him scum in my book. He deserves to at least be publicly shamed for that.
Deletekahit paghubarin pa nila lahat ng tao jan sa airport marami pa rin terorista dito sa pinas! hay!
DeleteI am not blaming the guy for what happened pero of may isip syang nilalang eh di nya ilalagay yun dun sa pdeng maka aksidente. Hays!
ReplyDeleteNakaka high blood ang lalaking nasa video. Kitang kita nya na kasalanan nya pero parang walang nakita! Kawawa naman ang matandang babaeng nadapa.
ReplyDeleteWalang kasalanan yong lalake. Tumingin siguro sa daanan pagmay time. Kahit dalhin niyo pa kung saan mang korte. Di naman niya tinulak ang babae. Bakit xa magsosorry? Dahil sa katan*ahan ng iba?
ReplyDeleteCorrect!
DeleteThis is what is wrong with our society. People like you who are devoid of concern for others, people whose ego is bigger than his/her heart. Mga taong nakadisgrasya na ay mayabang pang ayaw magsorry man lang. Kahit gaano ka pa kaedukado pag wala kang modo, wala kang kwentang tao.
DeleteAng galing mo anon 02:46am! Sana sa susunod madapa ka!! Kung susuriin mong mabuti, inilagay talaga nya sa kung saan malalagay sa alanganin ung matanda! Hindi yan ang tawag katangahan nung babae kc sino ba nmang matino ang maglalagay sa daraanan, malinaw na hindi nga sa unahan eh!! Tignan mong maige!!!
DeletePwede xa magsorry. Pero more than that wala na...
DeleteKasalanan niya dahil binaba ng lalake ang bag niya sa hindi dapant babaan ng bag. Dapat dun niya binaba yung bag niya sa dulo at hindi pag labas pa lang ng xray machine. Hindi kailangan tumingin ng babae dahil wala dapat bag dun in the first place.
DeleteTotally AGREE Anon. 3:01am
DeleteWhat's wrong with you Anon 2:46? Yes, it is obviously an accident and perhaps he may not be held accountable for this incident BUT he should at least show concern and help that woman. If that woman is your mom or a relative, I am SURE you will eat your words!
Delete315 pm there is no law that mandates people to help those who are in distress. Being a Good Samaritan is a personal choice. No one can force a person to help out. If you look at the video there are a lot of people helping the lady already, so with all those people around her , tell us what do you want him to do?
Delete12:41 Correct! Tumpak! The other commenting here are obviously being over-emotional. Pinoy nga naman. #smh
DeleteThe guy was heartless. i agree it was an accident brought about by katan*ahan kasi we should be mindful where we put our stuff esp if it's enroaching other people's space. But then again, dapat nkatingin din tayo where we're going. Grabe yung mama nakatingin lang when he witnessed what caused the accident and could walk away calmly as if walang nangyari.
ReplyDeleteBakit nilagay ng tan*ang lalaki yung bag niya sa dadaanan ng babe. Parang sadyang pinatid niya ito!!! Walang kuwentang tato ito ng lalakeng ito!!!
ReplyDelete"Parang sadya". Kaso hindi eh. Nilagay niya lang and the lady did not look at where she was going. The guy can be faulted for not showing concern or sympathy pero that's it.
DeleteCgurado ka ng un lang ang mali nung lalake? Eh kyng harangan kaya kita ng kable na alam kong dadaanan mo anong masasabi mo??!!!!
Deleteyun din ang naisip ko parang sinadya!!! kahit ako di ko iisipin na may bag sa dada-anan ko noh kasi mga tao sa unahan ko nagsi-alisan na so didiretso na lang ako at hindi ako titingin. napaka OA ko naman kung bawat hakbang ko check ko kung may papatid sa akin.
Deletei dont agree na sinadya niya. and sorry pero para sakin di kasi tumitingin sa dinadaanan ung nadapa kaya siya natalisod. hate me for this but if maghahanap tayo ng may kasalanan, kasalanan un ng nadapa. we can'a always blame someone else for our katangahan.
DeleteDaan daan sa dinadaanan. What happened was an accident. Obviously, di sinadya yun. Unless the guy was psychopath, which is parang di naman.
DeleteHay naku sa mga ganitong eksena nakakamiss si Claudine, yun lang haha
ReplyDeletetama! ganyan mga tao ang dapat binubugbog ni klaw klaw!!!
DeleteHaay nako posting something like this in fb is so cheap. Yung mga tao naman nahusgahan na agad ung isa kung maka comment wagas. Problema na nila yan. Anyway, the incident is just an accident. Baka may iba iniisip si kuya kaya.sya di natulungan haha. Case of stupidity ng both parties.
ReplyDeleteHindi nakatingin yung lalake nung nadapa yung babae. Wala din nagsabi sa kanya. Malay ba niya kung bigla pala nahimatay yung babae? ACCIDENT ITO, daming kumukulong dugo dito.
ReplyDeleteI felt sorry for the woman. But based on the video and knowing its at the airport..a busy place sana konting alalay lang tayo. Pero sa video clueless ang guy na natripped sa bag si ale. And he didnt bother first hes in a hurry to go out and 2nd meron na 3 guys umaalalay. Again, i felt sorry for the woman pero to send this all over media and manawagan to look for that guy and pay whatever---- way to overboard! Girl aksidente ang nangyari. Now if what you are saying na sana naging compassionate yong guy - nasa knya na yun. Pero legally, it was at the airport, busiest place on earth.
ReplyDeleteMga BULAG ang nagsasabing HINDI kasalanan ng lalake! Malinaw na inilagay ng kupal na yan sa unahan ng babae ung bags nya! Malinaw na makakasanhi ng aksidente! Tama aksidente ang nangyari na sana naiwasan kung yang lalake na yan responsable! Parang kau dun na nagsasabing d dapat sisihin ung lalake, tanong ko lang kau ba paggumagamit ng extension wire igaharang nyo sa daraanan? Na alam mong pupwedeng maka aksidente? Or magtatapon ka ba ng balat ng saging sa daraanan ng tao na alam mong may madudulas??!!! ANO SAGOT!!!!
ReplyDeleteThis is purely accident on the part of the lady.. In a rush and busy situations like these, sometimes we are unmindful of our steps lalo na kung pare-parehong pagod sa biyahe o puyat o antok.. On the part of the guy, hindi natin alam kung bakit absentmindedly eh dun niya nilagay yung bag niya.. kasi nga nakita nya yung sapatos niya dun sa conveyor at dali-dali nyang kinuha ito para isuot too late to find out na may nadapa na pala dahil sa bag niya.. Maybe in his thoughts alam niyang wala siyang kasalanan.. Wala siyang naramdamang guilt dahil wala siyang ganung intensyon na saktan yung babae.. Yung feeling na yun ang naging dahilan kung bakit nawala sa puso niya ang pag aalala sa sinapit ng babae.. Alam niyang wala siyang kasalanan.. Andun ang pagkakamali.. Dapat nag-SORRY siya dahil siya ang factor sa pagkakadapa nung babae.. Umiral ang Dedma Attitude.. By this time, may nararamdaman na ang kanyang kunsensya.. At sa klase ng taong nakita natin sa video, iiral pa rin sa kanya ang dedma attitude..
ReplyDeleteKitang kita nung manhid na lalake na nadapa ang matandang babae dahil sa bag niya, tapos parang tuod lang wala man lang ginawa ang lalake. grabe anong nangyayari sa lipunan!? bakit dumadami ang mga katulad ng lalakeng to wala man lang ni katiting na malasakit sa paligid!?
ReplyDeleteHe should at least helped her the whole thing was an accident.
ReplyDelete- babaeng laging nadadapa
It's so abvious that the man and the woman were not on their usual sense of self. Bot were absent minded. It's just an accident. And it do happen, in the most unexpected ways.
ReplyDeletekawawa naman si kuya at nabubully sa social media..it was a freak accident d naman nya sinadya yun--
ReplyDeleteTeh, given na "accident" ang nangyari kumbaga hindi sinasadya, pero bakit HINDI man Lang SIYA nag apologize? Ni HINDI mukhang na-concern yun mamang yon dun sa nadapa?! So SELFISH na iniwan niya Lang yun nadapa without asking a medical help around that airport EH wala, umalis ang hinayupak na mamang yon!
Delete"The incident caused injury to the left side of Hofilena's face, fractured her left shoulder bones, and dislocated her left shoulder joints that totally disabled her, a complaint she filed before the Regional Trial Court of Bacolod said."
ReplyDeleteKahit aksidente, the victim is 64-years old, sana tumulong man lang siya..
No mea culpa for the guy honey. Try going to international airports , bags are everywhere so therefore look where you are going.
Delete12:36, and you also have to watch your bags (and stuff)... na hindi makaka cause ng agrabyado sa iba...duh!!
Delete10:04 AM, YOU TEACH KIDS TO ALWAYS LOOK WHERE THEY ARE GOING. THERE WAS NO SIGN THAT STATED DO NOT PUT YOUR BAGS THERE. I FLY IN AND OUT OF INTERNATIONAL AIRPORTS, THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS THAT OBSTRUCT THE PASSAGEWAYS. Bags , kids , outstretched legs are things that an ordinary person CAN expect to find there or should see and avoid. We all have an obligation to watch where we're going. TO WATCH YOUR OWN THINGS IS A PERSONAL DECISION AS WELL AS CONCERN FOR OTHER PEOPLE. BUT THEIR IS NO LAW THAT MANDATES THAT. SO, DON'T DUH ME BUT DUH YOURSELF! THAT'S WHAT FREE WILL IS ALL ABOUT! YOU TAKE CARE OF YOUR OWN BELIEFS AND VALUES BUT YOU CAN NOT IMPOSE YOUR WILL, BELIEFS OR VALUES ON OTHERS.
DeleteThe accident happened as well because of the woman's carelessness and that is her obligation to herself. A person needs to take care of her own self, health and safety as these things are not other people's obligation. Your argument is moot!
Reasonableness is not established.
WHat happened to to our society? I can't believe you guys are blaming the woman for the guy's stupidity. WHo is in his right mind would put his language one the walkway? ANd who in his right mind would blame the woman for the accident? Plain stupid. It was the man's fault because he is stupid. ALong with that, the Airport Management has negligence. They should have put a Sign somewhere to remind passengers like him to not to put their bags on walkways. And they should have someone assigned in that area to monitor the passengers.
ReplyDeletesobrang kasalanan talaga ng guy kahit san mo tignan.. unang una.. nauna yung girl dun sa pwesto.. then why would you put your bag in front of the person before you.. common sense diba?! ilagay mo yung bag mo sa pwesto mo or sa likod mo.. yung girl she doesnt need to look kse wala namang dapat nakalagay dun.. besides ni hinde nga sya naka full step.. umikot pa lang sya to make her 1st step she tripped na.. mali na nga yung guy sa paglagay nung bag.. and yet the nerve of him pa to walk away from the scene.. kita naman nya na the girl tripped from his bag.. or kahit pa na iba ang situation na kunwari hinde sa bag nya nadapa yung girl.. di ba human nature dapat ang instict ng tao is to help out or at least ask kung ok lang ba sya.. this guy grabe..!! he just walked away..!! ngayon lang ako nakakita ng ganyang tao..
ReplyDeleteLook at the video closely and watch where her eyes and her head was positioned. Ok ? Don't be overrun by your emotions! Accidents do happen unfortunately. That's why there is such a word as accident.
Delete12:33, accidents do happen pero you should be responsible for the damages you caused. Same concept ng may mabangga ka, accident. Pero diba binabayaran ang damages ng na accident mo? Siguro ikaw yung nag hit and run dun sa isang bata... accident eh??
Delete10:02 am the woman as well contributed to the accident. WHY?
DeleteShe was careless! We all have an obligation to watch where we're going. It is her duty to herself to look and avoid what is in front of her.
One's responsibility is to make sure he or she is not in the way of others so as not to cause harm. If ganyan thinking mo then people would be careless... they can put their stuff anywhere, park anywhere, litter anywhere, and your sole responsibility would be to avoid other people's carelessness. This thinking is absurd!
DeleteThe man has been negligent and caused serious injury! Analogy, if you put pots sa balcony mo and nahulog sa ground and may nabagsakan and namatay, may responsibilidad yung may ari ng pots sa pagkakamatay ng nahulugan. In this instance, kung di ba naman pulpol yung mama harangan ang daanan (daanan, hindi baggage counter) at di bantayan yung bag nya na naka cause ng accident, dapat sya managot! He is liable under the civil law.
ReplyDeleteAre you a lawyer? Just curious.
DeleteNegligence definitely not , idiotic yes .
DeleteAs they say look where you are going.
Liability no. If you say so which part of civil or criminal law says that?
An apology perhaps ? But , how can a person apologize for something that he was not aware of doing?
Yes he was indifferent to the whole incident but there is no law to compell people to extend a helping hand at all times. Yes honey, there is a thing called free will. I can choose what to do and not to do.
5:06 i agree! Nangyari na yan sa akin. Yung unit ko sa pasig natanggal yung glass ng window at nahulog sa driveway ng parking area at nahulugan isang car na dumadaan. Aksidente yun malinaw. Hindi ko naman sinadyang bakbakin yung sealant ng glass para mahulog. Sa lakas ng hangin nung bumabagyo natanggal na pala yung glass sa kalumaan. Pero since sa window ko nang galing yung glass responsibilidad kong akuuin yung dapat ko bayarang damage at humingi ng pasensya sa naperwisyo tao. Yung babae sa video 64 yrs old nagka injury sa face, nagka fracture sa bones. Nadislocate pa ang left shoulder nya. Sobrang laking problema naidulot nung pagkaka lagay nung bags sa tabi nya. Sana man lang nag stay muna yung lalaki at he made sure na maayos muna kalagayan ng babae bago sya umalis.
Delete12:30, do you know what negligence means? Pabaya! Being an idiot is besides the point. Whether he apologizes or not, he should be liable. Pa free will - free will ka pa dyan, so ok lang patayin kita dahil may free will ako? At hindi ako masasakdal dahil sa free will na yan??
DeleteAccording to the Philippine Civil Law:
Art. 20. “Every person who, contrary to law, wilfully or negligently causes damage to another, shall indemnify the latter for the same.”
He was so dumb. He should've not placed his things in a place where it can be an obstruction to someone or something. If it was me, I'll place it on my side or on a space away from anybody else. And he could've least helped the woman, obviously he saw it and was like "keber".
ReplyDeleteAng mali nung lalaki is, hindi man lang sya tumulong kahit mag sorry man lang knowing na bag nya yung dahilan kung bakit nadapa yung victim. Sana man lang itinabi nya gamit nya at tumulong sya na buhatin at paupuin yung victim. But blaming the guy for what happened is wrong, it was unintentional. Hindi siguro nya naisip na possible na madapa yung victim gawa hinarang nya yung bag nya.
ReplyDeleteYou are wrong. Intentional or not you should be liable sa kapahamakan na idinulot mo.
DeleteLIABILITY OCCURS WHEN THE PERSON HAS ESTABLISHED THAT SHE HERSELF DID EVERYTHING TO AVOID IT. THE VIDEO DOES NOT LIE! SHE AIN'T LOOKING WHERE SHE IS GOING. IT'S THE SAME AS IF SOMEBODY SLIPS ON DOG POOP OUTSIDE MY HOUSE, I AM NOT LIABLE AS I AM NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR CLEANING EVERY DOG POOP THAT IS LEFT THERE.
DeleteYou cannot avoid everything as you have no control of what other people do. Kahit sobrang pag iingat mo pero other people are careless, it can cause you harm. The video doesn't lie and it is not ok to leave your bag unattended especially on the way of other people.
DeletePoop in front your house is different especially if it's not your dog's poop. And in the video, it is the man's bag that caused harm to the woman because of his carelessness.
yung Mamang offender may-ari ng Palmas del Mar Resort, Bacolod City.
ReplyDeleteHey people it was an ACCiDENT! Both of them were at fault. The guy for obstructing and the woman for not looking where she was going.. I did not know that refusing to help , being indifferent and being unapologetic for an incident that one is totally unaware of is a crime. Tsk tsk tsk
ReplyDeleteNo one is saying it is a crime. He did not need to help her stand up, apologize and be sympathetic. What he needs is to be liable for the injury he has caused! Accident or intentional basta naka agrabyado ka kailangan mo managot. Otherwise people could all be careless and not be liable for damages!
Deleteaccidents can be avoided....if you are using your head. That guy seems to be in his own bubble. The Lady of course didn't anticipate the bag to be there because in the first place it wasn't there when she got at that point in the line. That guy has no sensitivity to others. Of course on top of that the bag shouldn't be there, the lady was also preoccupied with fixing her things or whatever next thing she is going to do because having an object beside her legs is not even the correct thing to happen having those bags near her legs would be the last thing to anticipate. I think that guy is just plain stupid. Of course he didn't help her, and it seems he just froze because I think for one he already felt guilty, and second, he could sense he could get in trouble if he apologized and let them be aware it was his bag that caused the accident. The security and the other people should have that ability to find out what happened, they probably thought she just felt dizzy or what....poor lady...that guy next to her in line is just an all around douche.
ReplyDeletesana ma identify ung lalake ng makasuhan, ng mabigyan ng leksyon. Ang sakit sa loob panoorin papano kung nanay o lola mo yun. Nde totoo na d alam ng lalake and d nya napansin na sa bag nya natisod ung matanda. Nakatingin sya the whole time.
ReplyDeleteAnong kaso ang pwede isampa???? SIge nga teh
DeleteBased sa mga comments dito debating if kasalanan nung lalaki or not so san lulugar ang airport lalo na ang cebu pacific?? Ni hindi nga alam kung pasahero din ba ng cebu pacific si kuya??
ReplyDeleteFor those who said na OA Ang post Ng anak sa fb or sa nag sabing pinost Nya just to gain sympathy and sa nagsabing accident LNG walang kasalanan ung lalaki and dapat no need to ask for financial assistance ksi nga accident??!!! Kaso kahit sang angolo mu tignan aksidente man o Hindi dapat ung lalaki tumbling man LNG kahit papano and he can't deny na d nya alam ksi kitang kita sa video na ung babae got tripped bcoz of his bag. He detest even bothered to show concern sa mas matnda sa kanya and even some said na sana tumingin din ung matanda sa dinadaanan nya eh kahit ikaw nga cguro first thing that u will do pag talikod e tumingin sa malayo Hindi ung pag talikod mu sa baba ka kaagad titingin and tama ung observation nang iba ni Hindi man nkapag 1 step ung matanda ksi nga ung irresponsible na guy dun talaga sa likod Ng babae nilagay ung bag.and Hindi LNG bag ha BAGS. And the fact na nag cause un nang injury and damages sa family I don't think na e blame LNG lahat sa babae. Na keso Hindi sya tumingin sa dinadaanan. And yes walang kasalanan Ang airline dun but ung airport can b blamed Kasi wla silang sariling ambulance. Pano na LNG pag may mga ganyan emergency mag aantay na LNG lagi. Tsk tsk tsk I HOPE THIS WILL SERVE AS A LESSON TO EVERYBODY AMD KY KUYA NA VERY IRRESPONSIBLE ALAM MU KUNG ANO ANG NANGYARI AT NAKITA MU so sana makonsensya ka at harapin mu ung Tao na kinaused mu Ng damaged. GOD BLESS YOU ALL
ReplyDeleteAlagaan mo namang nanay mo sis! OA ka naman talaga dami mong kuda!
Deletethe man caused the lady's fall because he showed: 1) no manners for not waiting his turn, and 2) no common sense or lack of concern for the safety of others. In short, this incident could have been avoided if only he had been a gentleman.
ReplyDeleteKung may baril ako at nag paputok sa langit tapos may tinamaan sa kabilang baranggay, may kasalanan ba ako? The same thing lang yun with this guy. Nag lagay ako ng obstruction sa daanan tapos may nadapa kaya dapat siyang managot. Hindi lang ikaw ang tao sa mundo kaya paminsan minsan, be accountable sa mga actions mo.
ReplyDeletePurely an accident!! Hindi nga lang nagpakitang tao yun guy na mag sorry kya madami nagrere-act, but hey! there are bigger national issues that you can argue about guys!!!
ReplyDeleteAgree
DeleteYung ibang nag cocomment dito wala sigurong alam sa kalakaran sa airport dito sa pinas. Ganyan talaga ang gawa pag madami ka bag na kinukuha from scanner. Ibababa mo sa tabi mo ung iba. Disoriented sila pareho. Kaya nga ung nanay ko, inaalalayan namin parati. Si ate hindi nya tiningnan nilalakaran nya. Naka 2 steps pa sya bago mag dive.
ReplyDeleteParang wala na sya sa FB. Hindi ko na ma-search name ni ate.
ReplyDeleteSus sa nakikita ko, di alam ng lalaki na bag nya nakaharang kaya natumba si Ate, purely accident lang ang nagyari. Si ate naman maka sabi ng magbabayad at di matatakasan ang ginawa ng lalaki. Teh kung walang video makakahusga ka kaya kaagad ng ganyan. At ito may video intindihin muna wag kaagad magsalita ng ganyan sa social media. Maaring walang may gusto sa nangyari. Si kuya naman sana andun pa rin ang pagkaPilipino nya na dapat tumulong kay ate para maiahon sabagay ika nga ' Every individual has its own individual differences' eh baka nga di likas sa kanya ang matulungin kaya ayun naging issue sa kanya na pinabayaan nya lang ang nangyari.
ReplyDeleteEh bakit andito ka 8:46 if there are bigger national issues kang sinasabi dyan. Dun ka mag marunong sa topic na sinasabi mo!
ReplyDeleteI don't think the man realized that the woman tripped on his bag. It happened so fast. There were people in uniform helping the woman so he did not bother to join in. In general, the wisest thing to do in an accident is to let the professionals do their job. Meron kasi tayong usi mentality kaya binubully si Manong. Konting hinahon lang. The poster of this video clearly stated that he/she wants APOLOGY and MONEY. Piling on the guy will produce neither.
ReplyDeleteOMG i just saw this now. I paused and replayed the video over and over and saw that the man actually saw what happened but acted oblivious to the accident! kapal na mukha di man lang nag offer ng tulong at nag apologize as dedma lang sya. i hope the lady fully recovered from this.
ReplyDelete