Source: www.philstar.com
To set the record straight, Inday Barretto didn’t actually start the word war that has divided her family. Her explosive letter to Funfare published last week was her answer to the ugly exchange of messages on Instagram from unidentified parties but suspected to be either Gretchen or Claudine (with whom Inday sided), or their defenders/sympathizers that dragged into the fray other members of the family especially, including Inday’s son Jayjay who came to Gretchen’s defense and Inday’s US-based daughter Gia to Inday and Claudine’s defense.
Other non-family members, like Mother Lily Monteverde of Regal Films and Robbie Tan of Seiko Films, two companies where Gretchen has done movies, claimed that Gretchen is a good daughter who worked hard for her family. Actress Tanya Montenegro issued her own statement, also defending Gretchen.
Asked by Boy Abunda on The Buzz last Sunday how the whole mess would end, hopefully peacefully, Gretchen said in a statement, “I don’t see any possibility of a reconciliation.”
Here now is the last word (knock on wood!) from Inday who wants to put a period to what her letter has started:
This is to respectfully inform anyone curious and concerned that the first statement to Ricky Lo was supposed to put a stop, a plea in fact, to the allegations maligning my daughter Claudine in social media.
It was never my intention to prolong it into the World War III level
I am back for the last time, now the target of vicious lies and allegations, a leading lady to a teleserye of made-up stories.
I was warned that it is hard to win a war against those evil unless one is evil, too.
I should be afraid having no money and power to get legal assistance. Many offered to talk on my behalf, people not related but have been part of and witness to our family life.
And so having no need for a Limping Cockroach to come out from a hole for a glimpse of light, I stand up unafraid to correct these vicious lies.
To Tanya, you say you respect me. Please don’t — keep it— you need that for yourself. I don’t need respect from someone like you. I have plenty of it from where I come from.
I know who you are, what you are, but you shocked the world at how you could face the camera so professionally comfortable in lying to tell a story of more than 30 years ago as if you were there when it happened, as if you were part and parcel of our household when not even our cats and dogs know you — tsk, tsk, tsk! — lying to the hilt without batting an eyelash. Unless you were coached to read a prepared story.
No. 1: No, Tanya, it is never true that Gretchen’s tuition was not paid. School is top priority of our payables.
No. 2: No money for recess and lunch? I don’t even want to dignify you on that since you are not a dignified one.
No. 3: So you saw Gretchen with a bruise of black and blue? Do you want to insinuate that we did that to her? We have no history of violence. Don’t be dramatic. People might ask you to convince them some more and all these events of 30 years ago, huh?
To Mother Lily: Yes, Mother Dearest, it is true that I was the one who used to pick up Gretchen’s checks because she was a minor, remember? But it is not true what you said that you know that not a cent went to her.
The cents went to pay for, 1) car, 2) driver, 3) yaya, 4) gasoline, 5) food, 6) clothes, 7) and others (kulang pa).
I hope you understand being a mother, too. And by the way, we still have the contract we signed with you.
To Robbie Tan: Thank you, Robbie, for having given Gretchen more work because you thought she needed money for the family. But for your information and correction, at age 18 she was no longer with us because she was already living-in with Joey Loyzaga and our family was already in Iloilo. We did not use her money, period, same way you made good business from the projects you made for her. More power to you.
For the last time on Gretchen being the bread winner, this much I can say: How can she be when her father and I were alive and still are?
Accusations and lies that I want to address:
• Gretchen sent her siblings to school? Three of them were already out of school when she joined show business at age 14. The projects she had when she was still under my care were never enough to pay for our, 1) rent, 2) electricity, 3) food on the table and 4) pay for the schooling…all of them on that meager income?
• The bill for Mr. Barretto’s first heart attack was paid for from a health insurance. The second heart attack that required a bypass, yes, was paid by Tonyboy Cojuangco, something which Gretchen never made us forget. I went to the billing section to settle the bill. I was told that it had already been paid from a PLDT account.
We are eternally grateful to Tony for that sincere generosity.
Gretchen, yes, I am letting you go to set you free from the burden of being a part of our family. Whatever else you want to exact from us to buoy up your portrayal of a damsel in distress that got you the sympathy and brought you to where you are now? Be happy. At least from this squabble, the truth has finally come out from the talks that have been going on behind our backs about you being an abused child admitted by you when you made sumbat through what you made Jayjay sign.
Thank you that we are able to correct the lies before dad and I close our eyes and give back to your father the dignity he deserves for he really is an honest and principled person. Again, for your sake, to remind you with no apologies for the lack of classy cars, bodyguards and bling-blings, our house, our home was what gave you these: A roof over your head, food in your stomach, clothes on your back and the love and care that you think is lacking when you were a nobody and had nothing.
God be with you, as He is with us, now that the truth has set us free
Omg inday barretto!!!
ReplyDeleteI hope they'll come to an agreement (for their father and children's sake) to stop airing their sentiments and loathe publicly. Buti pa sa Mindanao may Peace Talk! Haha. Sana naman someone from this clan starts to mediate nalang instead of adding fuel to the fire. At the end of the day, lahat kayo talo.
DeleteI hate greta... She doesn't give dignity to her dad... She wants to make the public believe na sya nagpakain sa pamilya nila. Liar
DeleteGretchen malapit na matapos oras ng nanay mo, lalo na ng tatay mo, naglabas k pa ng kung ano anong kasinungalingan na kesyo ikaw nagpakain sa kanila. Wala kang kwentang anak. Kaya naiintindihan ko ginawa ni Inday. Wala ng pagasang matapos ito ng matiwasay. Mamamatay na lang mga magulang mo ng may poot at galit sa yo. Sana makatulog k pa ng mahimbing lagdating ng panahon na yon.
Deleteand the saga continues.. *grabs caramel popcorn*
ReplyDeleteNa entertain pako dati. But now, it is just really sad. . . :(
ReplyDeleteako rin
Deletetrue, a lot of hurtful words have been said, ako nga na hindi nila kapamilya parang ang sakit na marinig yung mga bininitawan nilang mga salita eh, matagal na panahon ang paghilom ng sugat na yan sa kanila
DeleteAng masakit, pag namatay na ang mga magulang ni ms.gretchen na di sila nagkasundo. Kunsensya ni gretchen yan kasi utos yan na honor your mother and father pero di nya ginagalang ang parents nya porket mayaman sya. Nakapangasawa lang ng cojuangco.
DeleteSame here... sobra na nilang nasaktan ang isa't isa.
Deleteits so hard to tell sino nagsasabi ng totoo. sa tingin ko lang, mabait tlga si claudine but things changed when she left abs. she was a star there, pag ang tagal mong star tapos biglang hindi ka na ganun ka-star, siguro mahirap i-handle. tapos dumaan din sa post natal depression, kaya siguro nakagawa sya ng mga hindi maganda in public. maybe now shes really insecure about herself, syempre tumaba na sya, tapos wala syang network, tpos di niya alam pano ibabangon sarili niya. pero si gretchen, sana hindi na lang nagbitaw sa IG ng mga ganung salita. Sana kinausap na lang in private or something. Bilang sya naman yun Ate, sya yun maayos ang pagiisip, sana inintindi na lang nya. Im friends with one of gretchens cousin and si gretchen daw tlga ay maypagka user friendly. kung kanino sya makikinabang, yun kakaibiganin niya. lately na lang daw yan naging generous. pero si claudine daw, generous daw tlga. tumutulong daw tlga sa pamilya yan. hindi rin maganda gnwa ni inday pero kung kawawang kawawa na si claudine kay gretch, as a mom, anu nga naman ang gagawin mo. so now i understand her. ( dami ko lang sinabi. hahaha )
ReplyDeletenakoh, teh. claudine has been a she-devil ever since
Deleteano 2:07.. close kau no claudine?
DeleteHi Claudine! I hope you're better na :D
Deletedapat hindi bino-broadcast ang away pamilya sa publiko, lalo na ang isang ina na kampihan ang isang anak at siraan ang isa. ang kawawa dito ang kanilang ama na may sakit sa puso, malamang ngayon ay nagdudusa sa kinahinatnan ng kanyang pamilya. kaya ang masasabi ko lang ay TUMAHIMIK KAYONG LAHAT DAHIL NAKAKAHIYA KAYO! LAHAT NG PAMILYA ME BAHO PERO KAYO LANG ANG MISMONG NANGANGALANDAKAN NG BAHO NYO SA PUBLIKO! SHUT THE F**K UP!!!
Deletemabait si claudine? kaya pala nakipagsuntokan kay Tulfo noon eh.
DeleteWeh?? Napakataray daw po ni claudine!!! Si greta daw ang generous, yung mga damit na ginagamit niya for tv ads na once or twice lang niya ginamit kadalasan niyang binibigay nalang sa mga maid.
DeleteDysfunctional is an apt word
ReplyDeletethey actually gave a whole new meaning to this word
DeleteBoom! Kakalurkey!
ReplyDeleteDapat kay inday wlang pinapanigan kc pareho nyang anak un... Anong klaseng kang ina.. Kahit may nagawa mang mali dapat wala kang kampihan.dpat inaayos mo problema ng mga anak mo!!!
ReplyDeleteBaka naman kasi sobra na...
DeleteOo nga. Baka kung makasumbat si gretchen sagad buto. Buti pa si cristine, kahit ganun un mas maitim pa din budhi ni gretchen. Si cristine mahal nya si Ara. Si Ara mabait, never nanumbat. Wala si gretchen sa kalingkingan ni Ara
DeleteShame to you Greta!
ReplyDeletebakit shame on Greta? I dont understand why? It sounded more like the mother has some issues
Deletehello nabasa mo ba kung anu si sinabi ni greta about kay claudine?
DeleteJudgmental lang ang peg. Magtigil ka nga.
DeleteYes I did and they didn't mention Claudine's name anywhere in the post. Even if it was about Claudine, they still used discretion by making it somewhat anonymous like its a warning they know who it is. It's about Marjorie's daughter's basher right? I read somewhere that the photos used by the basher can only be found in Claudine's cellphoe. I think that's enough justification to warn her that they know its her, isn't it?
DeleteSaan pa ba mgmamana ng ugali sila greta,tingnan moh nanay,kong makastqueen sa anak sa dyaryo kala moh d nila pinakinabangan,tayung mga anak,halos walang paki kong anu man sabihin sa atin ng ibang tao,pero pg ina na ang nagsabi ng mga kahinaan natin sa buong mundo,laglag heart natin,
Deletehindi nabanggit ni minsan ni greta at marjorie ang pangalan ni claudine. nag react lang tong si Inday Barretto. so ibig sabihin guilty?
DeleteHello e gawa2 lang naman yan ni Greta pano niya malalaman sa cel ni Claudine yun chncheck niya ba yun??? how weird...
DeleteSana gawing reality tv series ang buhay ng family na to.
ReplyDeletewagi ang mother! finally tapos na to! sana!
ReplyDeleteNo. She is the biggest loser of all of them.
DeleteBest time to be a third world echosera...hahaha
ReplyDeleteang Tanging Pamilya. Sa tingin ba nila may mananalo sa ginagawa nila. WALA! worst baka lahat sila mawalan ng career. Palagay ko e kaya ganyan si Gretchen dahil ayaw nia na magkasabay sila ni Claudine sa ABS kase masasapawan na siya.
ReplyDeleteI doubt may masasapawan pa si Claudine, she dug a deep grave for herself considering her actions in recent years. Mahirap makalimutan yung pics nya na nambubugbog sya!
DeleteTrue!
Deleteoy ismyuski, wala daw silang history of violence, eka ni mudrabels!
DeleteDo not judge her dahil lang dun. Talentwise magaling talaga si Claudine. One reason kung bakit hindi din sya nagcocomment at nakikipagbangayan she's trying to clean her personality kase nga she wants a come back
Deleteno history of violence. ?? Yung totoo?? Bakit bayolente si claudine? malamang kahit pano may influence dyan ang family
DeleteFeeling ko ampon lng tlga c gretta
ReplyDeleteAgree kase dun sa 2nd to the last paragraph nung very first letter ni Inday Baretto she said quote:
Delete"I have always loved you as one of my own, and always will but love of my family belongs to the heart and not the garbage can"
What does that tell us? Diba parang inamin nya na di nya anak si Gretchen.
Hindi kaya anak sya sa labas? Medyo iba itsura nya sa mga kapatid nya eh... although, pwedeng dahil lang yon sa botox.
Deletekamusta naman ito si 2:32, overanalysis ang peg! may buhay kang iba teh?
DeletePero kamukha naman ni Gretchen yung mga kapatid nya ah?
DeleteJusko malakas ang ebidensya. Hilatsa palang ng mukha nila e iisa.
Deletepssst..popcorn tsaka coke...pengeng straw ha...
ReplyDeleteAng gagandang lahi panay awayan... sayang lng ang fame nyo, sinisira nyo ang mga pagkatao nyo. Pinagfifiestahan tuloy kayo.
ReplyDeleteParang hnd nanay c inday.. feeling ko wlang nanay na magsasalita ng ganyan sa totoo nyang anak kahit gano pa ka-sutil
ReplyDeleteKahit pa ampon pa yan si gretchen eh. WALANG NANAY ANG GANYAN. SO EVIL.
DeleteMeron nanay ko ganyan sa akin kaya naka relate ako kay greta kahit ako ang nakatulong sa kanila pero pinsa Diyos kasi pag nanay ang nagsalita nanoniwala ang mga tao kaya sa Diyos na lang ako nagtiwala at talagang masakit
Deleteinday is heartless
DeleteI believe her. I know Gia personally. And that brother who sided with Gretchen is and was a heavy D user. Claudine, despite her inequities, is and was a good daughter and sister. If there is someone who has talent, iris Claudine. I've heard horror stories about how much of a b$#ch Gretchen was and is.
ReplyDeleteows talaga lang ha! Hirap sa ibang Pilipino hilig gumawa ng kwento PROVE IT
DeleteGia is the older sister of the three - she finished in Ateneo and never considered showbiz.
Deletefyi dear, all of them were raised as b*****s, even your friend gia, they're all self-centered and entitled individuals, but not a big surprise though, they were all raised by one
DeleteSiyanga? Post your real name to prove you're Gia's close friend. Charing!
DeleteI agree with you, 4:02. especially now na nag labas na naman ng letter itong mother nila.
DeleteI need not prove anything to you people. Was just saying. 6 degrees baby! And if none of you have a claim to that, shut your twats.
DeleteEh si Clau Clau din heavy D user daw diba?
DeleteKilala ng friend ko ang isang mayaman na ex ng isa sa mga brothers nila. Let me just say na talagang unbearable daw talaga ang tatlong bruhang yan (marjorie, gretch and clau). D ko alam kung sino sa kanila ang totoo, but i think all of them has a contribution sa conflict na to.
Deletehello Gia! is that you?
Deleteisa lang ang masasabi ko at siguro ng karamihan: kung masasama man talaga ang ugali nila gretchen at claudine, may pinagmanahan sila.
ReplyDeletenot siding with anyone but this saga is so out of class - not only for the mother but also to everyone else embroiled in this issue, including the feuding siblings.
Yan din una kong naisip nung unang lumabas letter ni mommy inday sa star,kung makastqueen sa anak nia kala moh d pinakinabangan,naisip ko,d nakakapgtataka ugali ni claudine at greta sa nanay pala nagmana
DeleteKORAK! ang puno ng mangga ay hindi mamumunga ng saging! san ka naman nakakita ng sarili mong anak, sisiraan mo sa publiko. whether true or not ang mga pinagsasabi nya tungkol ke gretchen, anak ng powtek, anak nya yan! she should have just told them to both shut up!
DeleteWala magtagal daw katulong sa inday b na yan kasi ang sama ng ugali to the max
Deleteo sige, kung ano ang puno, yun din bunga di ba?
DeleteMas may integrity yun mom than JayJay. Kasi feel na feel mo yun sinasabi niya hindi scripted at walang screening of words! E, itong si Jayjay parang scripted lahat ng sinasabi. Parang may tntry icircumvent at iprove. Athough, yun part na may problem si Claudine, I believe. Ang tawag dun, depression. When a person is depressed nagbabago talaga yan. kasi agitated parati. I also believe si Claudine mabait talaga before when she was with Rico Yan. A lot of people who know her has been saying that. At ang pinakamasama sa lahat? - ALWAYS si Gretchen! But syempre things have changed and Claudine has undergone a lot of trials. The biggest one is the death of Rico Yan. Mahirap talaga iovercome yun especially mahal mo yun tao and dahil sa bad timing sayo pa sinisi ang lahat. So yun mom, naturally ipprotect si Claudine when she needs them the most kasi nafeel talaga nila yun love niya sa kanila bakit nila hindi siya tutulungan ngayon na down siya. By tulong meaning help her have an environment wherein she can peacefully get better, which Gretchen wont allow her to have, kasi nga may galit sa kanya ang reyna. Pero yun statements niya kay Gretchen, parang hindi na about Claudine. Parang ang dami niya nang matagal na kinikimkim. Si Gretchen wala naman yan paki sa kahit kanino e? Maski her own family. kasi she feels she can fix all problems and get away with all her money and beauty. Mabuti nalang in fairness at siya talaga ang pinakamaganda at may anak siya kaya hindi siya kayang iwan. However, these things are never sustainable. what if tumanda siya? Ever wonder bakit 1 lang ang anak niya kay Tonyboy? Enough na siguro yun to hold him at the same time mammaintain niya ang beauty at figure niya. NAPAKASELFISH!!!!
ReplyDeletefeeling mo lang yun...:-)
DeleteMa-feeeeeeeeeeeeling! Oooohhoh, ma-feeeeeeling :D
DeleteWelcome to FP,Anon 2:22/Mommy Inday! Reader ka pala ng FP! :)
Delete" I also believe si Claudine mabait talaga before when she was with Rico Yan."
DeleteEh alam m b n tinanggihan nya c Isko Moreno na maka love team kc mahirap at galing Tondo daw...ano na c Isko ngaun? nakaalis n s level na minamata nya...
hello! lahat ng sinasabi based yan saan? first hand experience mo ba yan with them, for you to judge greta as napaka slefish, and claudine as mabait talaga at bakit pati kung ilan naging anak niya kailangan pakialaman mo pa? Tao nga naman.. may narinig o nabasa lang ng konti akala mo kilalang kilala na..
DeleteI'm not a fan of Claudine, but I like her as an actress. If ever she will have a movie or TV series in the future, I will surely watch.
Deleteay, opposite naman tayo, anon 6:39. I used to like and respect Claudine. pero after all the negative things na lumabas about her, especially the NAIA incident na may video recording, kahit ano pang gawin ng babaeng ito, never ko na shang susuportahan pang muli. sirang-sira sha sa akin. well, opinion ko lang yan. kung gusto mo shang suportahan, go. pero not me. no, no, no!
Deletei think bitter lang si grecha dahil mas fave talaga si clau
ReplyDeleteThe bunso is always the favorite in the family. I don't know why but it seems common to most families...
DeleteHay ang nanay na ayaw magpaawat. Annabelle speaks kapag may nang aagrabyado sa anak nya. Si Inday nagsasalita para agrabyaduhin ang anak. Even if Gretchen is at fault what Inday is doing is not helping their family at all. It takes two to tango.
ReplyDeleteso true, she made annabel rama look like an angel
Deletei'm agree! wehehe
DeleteAnon 4:04, winner ka teh!!! LOL!!!!
DeleteNgayon ko mas naappreciate si annabell.kaloka namang nanay si Inday.
DeleteSi Gretchen matalino for not speaking up. Expert na expert kasi siya sa manipulation and mind games! Malamang maraming beses niya nang ginawa ito kaya pikon na pikon na sa kanya ang mommy niya! Step 1: Gamitin si Joaquin para may family member na magddiscredit sa nanay niya. Tabla na sila. Step 2: Gumamit ng isang friend, si Tanya, para may outsider na magcconfirm sa sinasabi ni Joaquin to build her credibility na sinira ng nanay niya. Step 3: Idemanda ang kapatid niyang si Gia (take note: hindi ang nanay niya na mas marami pang sinabi about her) para lubusan masaktan at magsisi and parents niya for doing that to her! Gretchen: Palaliman nalang ng bulsa. Tignan lang natin sino ang unang maggive-in! BRAVO!!!!
ReplyDeleteAng galing mong maganalyze.. Parang ganun na nga. Grabe naman si gretchen. Nagsisimba pa kaya sya?
DeleteAsa kapa,kaugali ni mommy inday si greta,kaya hate na hate nia
DeleteI agree anon 2:35!
DeleteAno 2:35, ikaw lang may sense na comment na nabasa ko. haha
Deletei agree!!!!
DeleteAyaw patalo ng Nanay! Parang hindi anak ang kaaway.
ReplyDeleteI'm so glad my Mom is not like her. I'll be so heartbroken if my own mother say something like that. Just think about the pain Gretchen is in reading about every word her mom spouts. I read the post made by Gretchen and Marjorie and no matter how I look at it, it just doesn't justify this hatred.
ReplyDeleteI think we don't know enough to know why both sides did what they did. Gretchen has always been the prodigal daughter, and a mother should love her unconditionally. Do we have all the facts? I doubt it.
Delete3:35 yeah right!
DeleteTrue, it doesn't justify hatred. But the things that Gretchen has done in the past to her family justifies her need of correcting it in the public once and for all.
DeleteThen again your not Gretchen, and you (or your siblings) might not be capable of what she can do to the family.
DeleteOh my god. Something is wrong with this family.
ReplyDeleteWhat I can say is, it takes something huge and truly unforgivable for a mom to disown a daughter. Inday could have chosen to do many things. This was her choice.
I feel bad money is the issue...but as these things go, money is usually the reason for these family tragedies.
I hope they all apologize to each other one day.
Teh!hindi money ang issue dito...basabasa dn d2 sa blog ni fp...nauna sina gretchen atakihin si claudine...napuno na ang nanay kaya sumulay kay rico lo...kampo ni gretchen nagpalabas ng breadwinner ek ek na yan via kuya jj na empleyado pla ni greta c/o tonyboy
DeleteI mean ricky lo.. hehehe
Deleteworst mother ever!!! no wonder bakit naging sutil siguro si greta!!! diba na banggit niya na napagdaanan na niya ma depress when she gave birth to greta?? baka simula nong nangyari yon don siya nagkaroon ng hatred kay greta, making greta what she is now.. evil as what they say!!!!
ReplyDeletebaka simula pagkabata ipinapadama nya na kay greta na devil siya or what!!! knowing na may capability siya talaga na magbitaw ng masasakit na salita! on media, ano pa kaya pag nasa tahanan ka niya!!
root of all evil si inday!!!!
i think it is common to most nanay na protektahan bunso,
DeleteYes,may pinagmanahan si greta,pati na mga kapatd nia,ng nabasa ko ung sulat ni mommy inday,na ang sabi,its not bongga naman,sabi ko wow,sa kanya pala nakuha ni greta ung the way she talks,its not bongga naman,hahaha
Deletehinay hinay lang, baka atakihin ka sa puso niyan. masyado kang affected. teka ang tanong, anak ba talaga niya si greta? mukhang galing sa ibang matris. kakaiba ang ugali.
DeleteAnon 2;59, a person's actions, attitude cannot be blamed on someone else. lets just say na wala talagang amor si inday kay Greta, so magiging masama na lang si Greta bec of that? greta is capable of thinking naman siguro diba? she can choose, to be good still or to be bad. Hindi pwedeng ganun, lahat isisisi mo sa iba kesyo masama magulang mo or what. kung may pinag aralan si Greta, kung matalino sya, she should have known better.
DeleteHala ka,7:04,hinuhulma ang bata ng magulang habang lumalaki,pgpinakita at pinadama ng magulang na hate ka nila,automatic yan sa bata na hate sia ng parents nia,usually,makukuha ng bata ung treatments na ginamit sa kanya ng parents nia,minsan hindi yan lumalabas kaagad pero mostly,pag ung anak naging parent nah dalawa lang ang choices nian,una:hindi nia napapansin na ung ayaw niang ginagawa sa kanya ng parents nia habang lumalaki eh sia na palang ginagawa nia sa current anak nia or two,isusumpa nia at sisiguraduhin hindi nia gagawin or iaaply ung bad treatments na inabot nia sa sariling magulang,usually kasi nagsasanga sanga yan
DeleteWe don't know everything. So we don't have the right to judge anyone of them.
Deleteganun ba? 9:21 lahat tayo dito nanghuhusga! break muna sa pagka ipokrito pag may time! wahahahah! at ang masasabi ko lang.. ang mga anak ay repleksyon ng isang magulang.. ang anak ni greta ay isang simple, desente, humble at higit sa lahat greta brought her up too well well well.. at according to tonyboy, c greta lang talaga ang nag aruga sa anak niya, coz he's always away doing business.. which means, lahat ng mga good or bad qualities na meron siguro ang anak niya ngayon, yun ang klase ng produkto meron si greta! siguro, ayaw gawin ni greta ang ginawa sa kanya ng salbahe niyang ina!!!
Deleteagree with anon 5:11. ung mga parents, sa bunso tlga yan side kahit pa ung may kasalanan ung bunso. na experience ko na yan first hand, kahit awayin ng lahat ng anak, basta ung bunso, anjan, ok lng.. at kahit 100 times mag lie ung bunso, ok lng, bunso eh. Claudine has never shown any remorse nung nambugbog xa sa halos kaedad na ng tatay nya, so what do you expect from a spoiled, rotten, bit**y brat like her? gusto lng ni Inday makabali c Claudine dahil tingin nya mas kailangan ni Claudine un compared to Gretchen, but it's not Gretchen's fault na nalaos c Claudine so...
Deletei am a mother of 3 and i have experienced something similar sa side ng mom ko, they are 9 siblings and nagkaroon din sila ng issues but my grandmother never sided with anyone. un ang mali ni inday. pero i believe her and what she is saying. siguro sobra na din talaga ugali ni gretchen kaya nakapagsalita na siya. also, no matter how hard you try at kahit gano pa kaganda at pagpapalaki mo sa mga anak mo , paglaki nila meron ma silang kanya kanyang isip at prinsipyo sa buhay. di nyo pwede isisi ke inday yun. at hindi rin naman totoo na kung ano ang puno siya ring bunga and vice versa.
ReplyDeleteThe true measurement of loving someone is loving them when they are least loveable. Kung si Gretchen ang mali sorry to say pero di sya mahal ng nanay nya.
ReplyDeletemasaya na ngayon si Greta since the sympathy is with her edi naachieve niya rin ang goal niya. Nanalo nanaman siya sa mind games tactic niya! Ilan beses niya narin ginawa yan - magpapasagasa kasi ayaw siyang payagan magartista, magpapakamatay kung hindi siya pananagutan ni tony boy. She always gets her way with these tactics. Hay kung may ganyan akong kapatid na napakainsecure at walang magawa sa buhay mapipikon rin ako. Para siyang tinik sa lalamunan! Obviously, kaya lang naman hindi siya nagmumukhang masama e kasi hindi siya ang mismong nagsasalita. GUMAGAMIT lang siya ng mga tao to lie and the get sympathy of the public. E yung nanay siya mismo ang nagsasalita kaya siya talaga ang magmumukhang masama. Sana gumamit nalang din siya ng ibang tao para even ang playing field
ReplyDeleteHello,kuhang kuha ni greta ugali ng nanay nia,mas matalino nga lang si greta kasi iba ang ginagamit na pantapat,katulad din ni cladine,lawyers agad agad,san pa ba yan mgmamana kungdi sa taong ngpalaki sa kanila,from infant to preteens nakukuha ng mga bata ung kung panu sila trinato ng parents nila,kung si greta gumagamit ng ibang tao,tapos si claudine gumagamit ng lawyers,ang ina naman nila public humiliation sa sariling anak,san paba ngmana,nag iiba nga lang ng tactics dahil sa panahon silang mag iina pero ang punot dulo ugaling ina pa rin,
Deletetumpak!!! pak na pak! from being an infant, preteens?? just take a look at greta's daughter.. she's really brought up terrifically!!!
Deletebakit ang mga tao ang lalim na rin ng opinyon about this!? just enjoy it like a reality show, people! masyado kayong involved na parang ito lang ginagawa nyo maghapon kakareply sa mga posts at paganalyze! goshhhhhh
ReplyDeleteGrabe tong nanay na to!
ReplyDeleteIf I would choose between Anabelle Rama and Inday as my mom, I will definitely choose Anabelle! Pasaway si Anabelle, pero makikipagpatayan talaga sya para sa anak nya. On the otherhand, Inday is the exact opposite!
Nagyon lang siguro lumabas yun mom kasi hindi niya na kaya. Gretchen doesn't know how to fight fair. Mahirap kasi silang 2 ni Clau parehong public persona tapos si Gretchen yun may upper hand sa media. Kaya the fight has to be public para patas ang laban
ReplyDeleteAng problema,naipakita nia sa publiko kong san namana ang bad traits ng magkakapatid,tama bang ikompara nia ang mgkapatid sa pggamit ng salitang teleserye queen at st queen sa public dyaryo pa talaga,kung matino siang ina,kakausapin nia sila greta at marj ng personal na tigilan na si claudine,yun ay kung totoo na silang dalawa ang nggugulo not the other way around,oh d kaya kung gusto nia pa ring madyaryo,sana fair ang ginawa nia,like to ask them to shut their piehole,ang ginawa nia,siniraan nia isang anak nia to justify na mabuti ung isa pa niang anak,and remember comparing ur children in front of them is a big no no,lalo na if hindi maganda,kasi maitatatak yan sa utak ng bata na iba sia sa kapatid nia at dun na magsisimula ang pleasing games hanggang sa lumaki na sia at may sariling isip,jan na mgsisimula ang sutel na attitude,comparison is a big no no sa parenting
Deleteanon 8:36 if matalino ka ring tao you wouldn't judge any of them.You aren't part of their family.Little that we know about their stories.
DeleteSinabi ko bang matalino ako,at sa nglabasan letters nila para sa isat isa,hindi na kailangan ng talino,automatic na iisipin ng lahat na sa ina nagmana ang mgkakapatid,kung magbitiw ng salita sa mga anak kala moh walang kasing sama ung anak,ung mga tipong mga mamatay tao,eh ung problema eh away mgkapatid,sanay na tayu jan noh,away bati away bati,kaya dapat sana pinashut up na lang nia ung dalawa niang anak,imbis na mgsulat para sa dyaryo at tawaging evil at st queen anak niang isa na babae pa naman,eh ina sia eh,usually ang magkapatid na close ngsasakitan yan physically and tru words pero pagdating ng ilang araw close na naman yan,sabay na naman yang mgshopping,kaso sa case na ito,ang mother dear ang nagpalala ng sitwasyon,kimunferm pa nia ung mga haka haka,at ung isang letter nia,ngbabasag daw ng mga plato ung mgkapatid pgnagagalit,ang napansin talaga nia habang ngbabasag ung mga anak,ay ung kung anu ang binabasag at halaga ng pinagbabasag,plastic daw kay claudine mamahalin naman ang kay greta,ang weird ni mother dear
DeleteNagawa niyong magsumbatan, magbatuhan, magbastusan at magdemandahan sa harap ng publiko na kung tutuusin sana man lang umupo kayo sa isang mesa, pinag usapan tong gulong to among yourselves sa loob ng bakuran niyo. Napakahirap bang gawin yun?
ReplyDeleteSa tingin ko eventually magbabati2 rin naman sila... Yun nga lang forever nang tarnished ang image ni Gretchen at lalo pa siyang hindi matatanggap ng family ni Tonyboy and ng high society. Forever na siyang paguusapan behind her back kasi they know the real her and now it has been confirmed even by her own family. Yun nanay wala nang paki alam kasi diba sabi niya she wil close her eyes soon na?
ReplyDeleteOoh at sasabihin din ng high etchos na may pinagmanahan,at matagal ng kilala ang ugali ni greta kahit tau na pangkariniwan mamayanan alam,ang siste,kinumperma ng ina kung saan namana mga bad traits ng magkakapatid
DeleteAll of them are not "angels" but i think i will side with Inday kahit mejo nakaka annoy yung way of writing nya.
ReplyDeletei do not think kaya ng isang ina na siraan deliberately yung anak nya ng ganun ganun lang kung talagang walang ginawang masama. Talagang nasa dulo na din sya.
Marami naman nang issue na dumaan like nung nag away sila Marj+Clau vs Greta and it all boils down sa pagiging mapagmataas ni Greta. Hindi ba may away din si Greta tsaka D*wn nung shampoo commercial dahil din sa somewhat same issue? Kahit nga nanay ng partner nya, may issue din with her.
Hindi sa hate ko si Gretchen coz wala naman syang ginawa sa akin pero if you look into it objectively, parang sya lagi cause of friction.
May pinagmanahan
Deleteanon 8:40 you cannot repeatedly say may pinagmanahan.my choices tayo.lahat nang kamalian isisi sa iba?????so yung mga criminal sa munti criminal din ang mga magulang nila kasi nga my pinagmanahan?think.
Deleteit's hard to judge mrs. inday barretto. for all her bashers, don't you think inday just easily decided to side with claudine? easily let go of gretchen? i'm not a mother but i don't think this situation is easy for her. she's already on her twilight years. i don't think she deserves this kind of squabble among her children especially the treatment gretchen is giving her.
ReplyDelete#3 "We have no history of violence. Don’t be dramatic. People might ask you to convince them some more and all these events of 30 years ago, huh?" Selective memory Manang Inday Barretto? Need I remind you Thrilla in NAIA feat. your beloved Daughter Claudine Barretto-Santiago vs Mon Tulfo?
ReplyDeletewhat she meant was "I and my husband...". di naman masamang maganalyze paminsan minsan :)
DeleteKaya pala ganyan mga anak niya. Talaga namang Kung ano ang puno siya rin ang bunga.
ReplyDeletefeeling ko hindi anak ni inday si greta. unthinkable kasi talaga na masasabi ng isang ina yan sa kanyang anak, para lang kampihan ang isa pang anak..
ReplyDeleteI also think na hindi kagandahan ang ugali ni greta towards her family kasi may mali sa pagpapalaki sa kanya. parang isa syang anak na laging left out unappreciated. kaya ng tumanda at nagkapera ay naging mayabang at insecure. Again for me its inday's fault.
Kung akala mo matatapos na dito lahat Inday, nagkakamali ka... Kase Greta is back with a vangeance. Abangan mo sa linggo! *evil laugh*
ReplyDeleteVangeance teh? Si Vangeance Labalan ba?
DeleteThis family never fails to entertain me with! Wag niyong itigil please!
ReplyDeleteAnonymous May 4, 2013 at 2:59 PM
ReplyDeleteYou are so lacking in logic, uninformed to say the least. If you are a mother, you will know that even with your best intentions,there will be among your children who will become bad, while others become good. The same environment, the same upbringing, the same values taught. Each one is unique, ant this uniqueness is manifested as we grow older. When we become fully capable of judgment, we realize that we can choose our own path. I am not siding with Inday, but being a mother myself with many children, I sympathize with her.
May ugali talaga na iba sa mgkakapatid at hindi un dahilan para itrato moh ng hindi maganda ung naiiba ,pero sa kasong ito,namana ng magkakapatid ang ugali ng ina,kung makapgbitiw ng st queen si mommy inday sa dyaryo daig pa si rama kung mura sa tv,
Deleteright.
DeleteUgghh kajirits talaga tong si Inday!
ReplyDeleteKahit na sabihin mong pinalaki mo ng maayos si gretchen, pinalamon, pinaaral and other stuff. WALA SIYANG KARAPATAN NA MAGDISOWN NG ANAK.
Ano si gretchen, laruan, bagay, baboy? TAO SIYA. Kahit anong sama pa niyan eh. TAO PARIN YAN. MAHIYA KA SANA SA PINAGSASABI MO! Parang tinanggalan mo ng pagkatao yung tao. Ikaw kaya? Gawin sayo yan. Ewan ko lang kung hindi ka maging suicidal.
You just lost my respect as a person.
How I wish na mauntog ka inday and mahiya ka sa pinanggagagawa mo.
P.S. wag kang magmalinis especially wag na wag mong gamitin si God to favor your side.
Second worst Mother after my Mother. I wonder why you became MOTHERS if you do things like these. Nanganak pa kayo no? Sana pwede pumili ng magiging Ina bago kami ipinanganak.
ReplyDeleteBakit what's your story naman?
DeleteHala bakit naman?hindi ka tinatrato ng mabuti ng mother moh?
Deletesana rin pwede pumili ng anak bago isilang.
DeleteEto ang talagang may pinaghuhugutan!
DeleteHindi ang problema ng pamilya ang isyu dito dahil hindi natin alam ang totoo. Ang problema yung pag-disown ni Inday kay Gretchen in public. Hindi gawain ng matinong ina ang ganun. Kung anuman ang problema sa mga anak niya dapat siya ang mamagitan at wala dapat ksmpihan. Parang ang lalim lalim ng galit ni Inday kay Gretchen para hiyain niya ito ng ganyan. Like Claudine, Inday also needs professional help.
ReplyDeleteTama ka. Maling mali ang ginawa ni Inday. It is really sad to see a family falling apart because of a mother. Children are crazy sometimes. But parents should never take sides. Much worse itakwil ang anak. Sabihin na nating mali si Greta, pero mas mali na pagkaisahan sya ng pamilya nya at itakwil sya ng nanay nya. Pahiyain in public at sabihan ng masasakit na salita. Now for those who are wondering why barretto sisters have bad characters, there's the answer before your eyes. What the mother did speaks a lot about what these kids esp Greta have gone through. A mother will never do that to her children. Very sad.
DeletePuro pera at utang na loob ang pinaghuhugutan
ReplyDeletePlease po sa father ni clau2 at greta, sabihin nyo sa asawa ninyong si inday barretto to stop na po.please stop this na. Nakakahiya na tong mga sinasabi ng asawa nyo. Sana , kung ano pamang mga naririnig nyong negative about sa family nyo wag na patulan. Mahiya naman kayo kahit konti. Barreto sisters and brothers wake up na! Ipa shut up na c madir! I can feel na sobrang galit c nanay kay greta. Ewan kung bakit.
ReplyDelete-AM (Affected Much)
tawang tawa ako dun sa please stop stop this na! lol may pagka inday barreto
DeleteLahat naman sila may mali. Una, mali si Greta nung magparinig sya sa Instagram. Pero mali rin na mag-issue ng letter si Mommy Inday, na obviously siding with Claudine and disowning Gretchen. Tapos gumatong pa sina Jayjay and Gia... throwing hurtful words... sumbatan... siraan. And so on and so forth.
ReplyDeleteMaitatama ba ang mali ng isa pang pagkakamali?
It's a never-ending battle. Battle within the family. And the sad thing is, lahat sila talo. Tsk Tsk.
Kahit ako ang nanay at may SINUNGALING akong anak na gaya ni Gretchen na sabi ng sabi na siya ang bumuhay sa amin, aba, magsasalita din ako. Gretchen has done all these to herself. Akala nya kasi, she can get away with anything dahil she's under the protection of tonyboy's money. Pinoprotektahan siya ng mga kaibigan nya sa showbusiness dahil din sa pera niya. When you think about it, bkit ba nasa shwbiz pa si Gretchen hanggang ngayon? Gaya ba siya ni Dawn na magaling umarte? Magaling ba sya mag host? Magaling ba siyang singer o dancer? Pang "pwede na" lang lahat ng talents niya. Kaya lang siya may binalikang career eh dahil siya ang pambansang kabit ng isa sa richest men sa bansa, Bow.
ReplyDeleteKatulad ka din ni mommy inday,kung makapagstqueen sa anak sa public dyaryo pa,at anung paki natin sa tinahak nilang buhay,kung si claudine na d nag isip at nagpadalos dalos na hiyain sarili sa public,si greta na pinili ang lalaking kasal na,pero ang isang ina na hiniya sa publiko ang isang anak para maisalba ang isa pa is a big no no,
Deleteexactly my sentiments.
Deletetama sabi sa isang comment, gawing reality tv show na ito! The Barettos, parang The Kardashians lang! ilagay sa channel 4 o 13!
ReplyDeleteano kaya mapapala nila dito? hindi porke't nasaktan ka, kailangan mo ng manakit din? kung sakali, magiging masaya ka ba kung makakapanakit ka? - IKA
ReplyDeleteunless you become a mother of several adult children yourself, you will never understand Mrs. Inday.
ReplyDeleteDiko talaga nakuha ang ang logic sa ginawa ni Mrs Inday,galing din ako sa malaking pamilya,anim kaming babae,mula noon hanggang ngayon marami kaming hindi pgkakaunawaan,pero ang nanay namin,sinisigurado mula noon hanggang ngayon na kong pgsasalitaan nia kami ng hindi maganda since ng aaway nga(disiplina),sinusure nia na walang ibang taong nakikinig,kahit sa harap ng mga kaibigan namin never kaming minura ng mother namin,pg uwi na lang daw sa bahay,dahil hindi daw un gawain ng isang ina na ipahiya kami sa ibang tao,baka maisip ng iba na puede na din kaming ipahiya since sariling nanay namin eh ginawa un,hindi ko kailangan maging ina ng maraming anak para maintindihan ko na mali ang ginawa niang pgkompara,pagtawag na st queen anak nia at pgtatakwil sa publiko,para anu?isalba ang isa pa niang anak na alam niang may malaking problema sa utak,lahat ng mgkakapatid ng aaway kahit gaano pa kaclose,pero mali sia ng idaan nia sa dyaryo,
DeleteSabi ni mommy Inday anak niya si Gretchen dahil dinala niya sa sinapupunan niya ng siyam na buwan. Pero nakakapagtaka naman na ganyan niya tratuhin ang sarili niyang anak. Iypng iba nga kahit maling mali na ginagawa ng anak ipinagtatanggol at pino-protektahan ng nanay para hindi masira ang reputasyon ng anak. Mother instinct iyan e.
ReplyDeleteMabuti pa ang aso marunong mag-protekta sa mga tuta niya.
It doesn't really matter who is at fault. Siblings can really be crazy, but parents esp the mother should never take sides. Parents should bridge understanding among children, not take sides and divide them. Much worse itakwil ang isang anak over another who isn't a saint either. The way Inday came out public to destroy her daughter, speak much of what kind of mother she is. Hence the kind of family they have....dysfunctional. So sad.
ReplyDeleteTotoo yan,siblings do get crazy,anim din kaming mgkakapatid na babae,kampi kampihan din kami pghindi nagkakaintindihan,ung nasundan at sumonod usually ang mgkakasangga yan pero pg anjan na ang parents namin lalo na nanay namin solve lahat balik na naman sa tawanan,next month away na naman,pero never kaming pinagalitan sa harap ng bisita at mga kaibigan namin,panghihiya na kasi un,at hindi un madaling kalimutan ng bata,un ang naging mali ni inday,jinaryo pa
Deletenung una, intriguing. tapos naging entertaining. then depressing. ngayon, pathetic nalang ang pamilyang ito, starting with the mom....mahiya naman kayo sa aming mga tsismosa....nasusuka na kami! bwahaha
ReplyDeleteMay umay factor din pala pag masyadong malaman ang balita... kumabaga masyadong malasa, masarsa, kaya ang mga chismosang nakikisawsaw sa isyu e nawawalan na ng gana! haha!!!
Deletelol.. natawa naman ako sa sinabi mo 8:23!
Deletebakit hiyang hiya siya aminin na naghirap sila? eh bakit si gretchen ang nagbabayad ng driver, yaya, clothes, etc? di ba dapat magulang yun?
ReplyDeleteDriver yaya/PA at clothes para sa mga shoots siguro.
DeleteAn intervention from the father in PRIVATE needed badly for EVERY MEMBER of this family. It's about time he put his foot down between his wife & children & initiate a family meeting. A well respected person as a moderator outside the family should be present to intervene when things goes emotional. As a family they can fix this squabble, no court can fix the emotional outburst that has been spewed in media. Going to court will only hurt all of them & will only make matters worst to feast on by the public fed my the media. The people surrounding each & every member of this family should mediate to stop further pain inflicted amongst them & not fan the fire to keep it burning. Common, the frenzy over the negative aspect of the BARRETO'S should stop & it will only stop from THEM. To the mother, stop feeding the media for all to know your disgust & negativity to your own children. As a mother you are the one who's suppose to nurture & protect them. To the father, you don't want to leave this world unhappy seeing how each & every member of your family hanging each others neck publicly. Do something. To the BARRETO siblings, respect begets respect. Do not eat each other alive in public, HIYA does not exist amongst each & every one of you. HUMILITY, FORGIVENESS, LOVE & RESPECT are the core of family unity that is lacking among each & everyone of you..... May this family open their eyes & see how badly public perceived them because of their own doing.
ReplyDeleteNOT A ROOM NURSE FROM SUNNYBROOK TO
Baka kaya sobrang depressed si Claudine is dinadamdam nya til now yung nangyari kay Rico Yan. After his death unti unti syang lumalala, hanggang sa naging violent na sya. Baka naguiguilty sya (God knows kung bakit ayaw syang papuntahin sa libing ni Rico ng pamilya Yan noon) or baka nanghinayang sya dahil narealize nya na yun ung biggest LOSS nya sa buhay, di nya kasi pinahalagahan. Kung talagang happy sya with Raymart, edi sana peaceful ang outlook nya sa buhay. Hindi sana sya violent dahil meron syang pagpapahalaga sa own family nya na maaaring mapahiya and all. She could've been a bright star til now if she was still with Rico, siguro yun iniisip nya. She used to be fine with Rico before. No brouhahas like these anda all.
ReplyDeleteOMG pathetic!!! I am really sad for Inday Baretto well shes ilongga and she will never back off - pero hindi rin nya inisip it will never ever good to her family and to claudines come back or i dont think my ecocomeback pa ang mental grl or ang fave daughter nya. Also Y single out la greta when infact marjorie also did a comment on IG. My advise for La Greta dont settle this in court kasi there is more to life than this - everything will be vanished n family will always be there khit ano pa man......bec if you settle thi in court - the taint will really remain up until sa next generation ng baretto family. Very very SAD if ever man. Claudine also should not used her mother khit sha pa ang bumubuhay sa parents nya till this day - ksi nakaka awa lang tlaga cla e picture out very lame ang issues n super dysfunctional dhil lang sa kasikatan-hindi dpat pamaresan.
ReplyDeletehindi na dapat talaga ito idaan sa korte pamilya sila pero siguro nasaktan itong Greta lalo nung hindi pumagitna ang mom niya sa awayan nila. siguro naisip niya, sino pa ba siya sa pamilya nila eh itinakwil na siya hindi lang ng kanyang ina kundi kapatid pa na without any trail pa? kung para sa mommy niya eh hindi na siya kabilang, eh sino ba naman itong Greta para isiksik pa ang sarili at maghope pa ng mabuti para sa pamilya nila, di'ba? walang anak-anak, ina-ina, kapatid-kapatid ang style ng pamilyang ito kasi, eh.
DeleteDoes it really matter to Inday baretto kung ano ang tingin sa kanila ng tao? Bakit pa nya need mag final release ng statement. Bakit ayaw nya patalo. Eh magrelease man sya ng statement o hindi. Sira na ang image nya at ng mga anak nya dahil sa ginawa nilang gulo. Bakit need pa nya magsalita against gretchen eh sa huli. Lahat sila katatawanan lang sa pinaggagawa nila. Hindi naman sya magmumukhang mabait pag inilabas nya ang baho ng anak nya. It just shows kung anong klaseng pamilya sila, kung anong klaseng anak at kung anong klaseng nanay sya.
ReplyDeletetama.
Deletehindi ko na binasa ng buo. skim na lang. my two cents: PLEASE STOP THIS NONSENSE. nakakapagod na kayong pamilya. tama na, please.
ReplyDeletekung maka alimpusta at asta tong si greta kala mo kung sino e kabit naman. kahit kelan di ka matatanggap ng pamilya ni tony boy.
ReplyDeletenow, inday and Gia stopped talking, WHY? scared na sila, kasi libelous naman talaga mga sinabi nila ke greta. They really pushed greta to her limits. kaya nagppaawa na sila.
ReplyDeleteIm glad my mom is not like INDAY.
Kaka-umay to the max! Mega doper sawa on this family circus.
ReplyDeletei think nasaktan cguro tlg yung nanay dahil parang pinalalabas sa mga story na walang na provide ang tatay nila at kinelangan magwork in greta para mag provide..parang nakakinsulto naamn kais yun sa tatay na anak mo bubuhay sayo...masakit yun sa magulang na sumbatan ka ng anak na wala kang nagawa para sa kanila...pero agree ako na may problema si claidne sa isip kelangan nya magpatingin....agree din ako na mahilig sa materyal na bagay ang greta, why else mo papatulan ang tony if not for the money?
ReplyDeleteSa pagkakaalam ko, mas kaya ng anak magtakwil sa magulang. Pero ang ina, kahit gaano kasama ang anak hindi kaya magawang itakwil ang isang anak kahit nasa kanya na lahat ng kasamaan sa mundo.
ReplyDeleteSana matapos na lahat ito. Ang problema sa pamilya sa bahay tinatapos, hindi sa kalye o kung saan pa man. Parehong hindi madali lahat ang mga pinagdadaanan nila bilang pamilya. Sa ating mga pilipino, siraan ka na ng ibang tao, kakayanin mo. Pero pagkadugo mo na ang kalaban mo, mahirap gamitin ang mga sugat.
Don't you think trny na iconfront at kausapin si Greta ng matino before??? isipin nyo 30 years na yun at never naman siyang nagsalita ng ganyan sa public so meaning ito na and last draw niya kasi naffeel niya na wala nang pagasa itong si Gretchen at kailangan na ng matapang na katapat once and for all. If you will read all of her statements carefully, dun lang sa first letter nina ang about Claudine. While Claudine might be her triggering factor, its obvious that her sentiments against Gretchen was not caused by Claudine alone and definitely not this time ALONE. Punong puno na talaga siya sa galit! I myself wouldn't know how to confront a daughter who is drunken by power and material wealth and playing with the lives of her parents and not as wealthy siblings. Paano ka maglelet go sa mundo knowing na yan and mangyayari sa kanila in the future if you don't settle it and just allow it to stay that way. Pahamak talaga yan si Gretchen. Lahat ng nakaaway nina have the same issue against her - feeling niya she's rich and powerful(not her money!) and above everyone else. Kung among kinaganda ng mukha nina ganun din kaitim and loob niya.
ReplyDeleteOriginally, this war is against Greta and Claud not Greta and mommy Inday, lumala lang dahil may pinanigan si mother and she is telling all the bulls*** against Greta. Do you think hindi lalala ang away kung hindi gagawin 'yan ng isang ina?
Deletehonestly, I think Inday is at an age wherein she doesn't really care what people think about her. Ang gusto niya lang mangyari ay lumabas and tunay na ugali ni Gretchen sa publiko para maturuan siya ng leksyon once and for all. Kasi feeling niya unfair sa mga anak niyang naagrabiyado ni Gretchen before tapos si Gretchen pa and nagmumukhang kawawa. Palaban talaga ang ina. She won't Gretchen get away this time! Pero I'm sure may sariling mga plano itong si Gretchen. Hindi ito susuko ng basta2 esp. she has all the money in the world to burn! For sure, gagantihan niya ang ina niya by using her siblings as bait where it will hurt the most.
ReplyDeletetrue! Iniisip ko sinasampal lagi ni greta sa mukha niya ang pera dahil yun lang nag meron siya. I mean, duh, i mean, she's only with tony boy because of his money and her daughter is way too angat to live low.
DeleteMali pa din 'yong pamamaraan niya. For me, disowning a child is a big no no to me. Dapat nag-isip siya ng mas effective na paraan dahil ina pa naman siya.
Deletetama ka jan Raymart is definitely not equal to Rico. Rico is more respectable and hindi niya papatulan si Mon Tulfo. Baka hindi rin magmumura si Claudine sa harap niya at if ever mahihiya rin si Mon Tulfo kunan siya ng video if Rico Yan was there. Iba talaga. Kaya ang lesson learned is choose your partner very carefully. Dapat mature, responsible, intelligent and respectable para maging has madali ang buhay may-asawa. IT MATTERS. Hindi pwede ang pwede na. Pero siyempre ang pagkalaos darating talaga yan pero baka mas kampante and peaceful ang buhay Claudine ngayon. She can still choose to be like that, pero maximum effort lang nga sa part niya.
ReplyDeleteParang scripted. Hidden cam na lang ang kulang, reality show na. Keeping Up with the B's (B**ches).
ReplyDeleteBelow the belt kasi ang mga pinagkakalat ni Greta, puro kasinungalingan pa. E ano naman ang mukhang ihaharap ng magulang sa ibang tao eh siniraan na sila sa ibang tao, parang lumalabas inutil sila. Hindi naman yan simpleng matigas ang ulo. Ito inaapakapakan talaga sila ta pinaglalaruan. Anong klaseng anak yan? Kaya ngayon kinocorrect lang ng nanay niya bahala na kung anong isipin ng ibang tao basta siya nasabi niya na ang MATAGAL niya nang gustong sabihin.
ReplyDeleteKasalanan pa din ni mommy Inday 'yan kasi walang lalabas na anak kung hindi siya nanganak. At walang lalabas na ganyang anak kung pumapagitna siya sa awayan ng mga anak niya. So, ibabalik ko 'yong tanong mo, anong klase kang ina kung naganak-anak ka tapos itatakwil mo din lang?
Deletewould you protect a child na kulang nalang isuka ka at ang iba mo pang mga anak? Knowing that every time she's there napapahamak ang iba mong mga anak? Na sinisiraan ka pati na ang iba mo pang mga kapamilya para magmukha siyang mabango? yun kinausap mo na ng matino pero hindi ka naman pinapakinggan at nakikita mong laging nasasaktan ang iba mong anak? THE HELL WITH HER! you have to protect those who need it the most.
ReplyDeleteSo, ibig mong sabihin mas gugustuhin mo pang pumanig dun sa isa imbes na pumagitna? Huh! Hindi mo alam kung anong kahulugan ng pagiging ina kung ganun. Kawawa ka naman!
Deletehello Inday!
Deletesorry, but I would rather lose a child and keep the rest in peace and harmony than to have a single piece of rotten fruit that destroys the rest of the family and will likely be a bad role model to other family members and in the next generation. Proven na yan over and over again. Bumalik nalang siya kapag nagbago na siya.
DeleteHindi ka pwedeng gumitna kung walang gitna. Play fair kung hindi naman even ang playing field. Walang mangyayari
DeleteNaman..
ReplyDeleteGretchen is NOT crazy sometimes. She is living in her own make believe reality and other people are just pawns in her game.
ReplyDeleteI hope the Mom stays quiet na. Masama bang maging mahirap or maghirap at some point sa buhay?
ReplyDeleteShe keeps defending and proving how mayabang she is and how disfunctional ang family niya.
Sana inaway na din ni Inday Barretto ang mga Tulfo dati, kaaway iyon ni Claudine eh. Si Gretchen lang ba kaya ni Inday?
ReplyDeleteIm actually siding with Inday Barretto. Greta is in the showbiz industry and she has connections, she can tame people with her money , kita mo nga yung kapatid, kumakampi kay greta kasi PLDT nagpapalamon sa kanya. Anyway, what im trying to say is with greta's record, she really is a big B
ReplyDeleteFamily of Fame Wh**es, and Wh**es! Bwahahahahahaha!!!
ReplyDeleteLahat ng kumakampi kay Greta, sinusuwag ni Inday. Sana kampihan ni Tulfo si Greta, para matakot naman si Inday. LOL Si Greta lang kasi ang kaya ni Inday.
ReplyDeletebakit nga ba si gretchen lang yung inatake ni inday at hindi si marjorie? di ba sabay naman silng umaatake dun sa basher sa instagram? hindi naman nila direktang inatake si claudine ha. claudine's name wasn't mention at all. bakit nag react si inday? ibig sabihin totoo? guilty? ok lang naman na kampihan nya si claudine pero not to the extent na itakwil nya ang isa pa nyang anak. akala ko ba walang magulang ang kayang gawin yan sa anak nya? dapat hindi nya na rin binuksan yung issue tungkol sa "st queen" na yun. sarling anak pinahiya. ngayon hindi ako magtataka kung ba't ganyan sina gretchen, marjorie at claudine.... may pinagmanahan.
ReplyDeleteAng ibig Kong sabihin sa sana pwede pumili ng magulang lalo na ng Ina ay: Sana makakapili tayo ng isang Ina na marunong mag guide ng tama sa anak. Yes I know in a family a mother has a favourite among her children, hindi nawawala iyon pero hwag naman ipamukha at ipahiya sa publiko. Tao rin naman ang anak na nasasaktan. I can relate to Gretchen that's why I can say her Mom is the 2nd worst Mother in the world. If my Mom is just fair and she treated me well when I was young then I wouldn't feel this insecure. Kayo nga mura-murahin ka sa harap ng ibang tao habang bata ka pa tapos paparinggan at ikukumpara sa kapatid sa harap ng mga Kaibigan nya tapos pag nagkapamilya ka pa bukod tanging ikaw lang ang hindi pinamanahan samantalang ang kapatid mo may mana. Matutuwa ka ba? At kahit na ganon ginawa niya sa iyo pag sila naghirap tutulungan mo pero ang isusukli pa sa iyo ay pagsasabihan ka pa na kulang pa ang tulong mo sa laki ng ginastos nila sa iyo nuon kahit na obligasyon nila iyon bilang mga magulang. Take note hindi rin ako inampon sariling dugo at laman nila ako, just like Gretchen so sa tingin nyo ba masaya? Kaya hindi nyo masisisi si Gretchen na ganyan ang kalalabasan ng pag uugali nya although we make our own path nakakabit pa rin ang lahat ng pinagdaanan mo kaya kung pwedeng pumili ng Ina pipiliin ko iyong taong mamahalin ako at hindi I di-degrade. So itatanong nyo nasaan ang Tatay ko habang nangyayari lahat Ito? Katulad ng Tatay ni Gretchen for sure sunod-sunuran sa asawa nya. I bet ganon nga. BTW Ilongga din Nanay ko.
ReplyDeleteKung titignan mo ang focal point ng stories nila, its definitely NOT about Claudine. Siya lang ang umpisa pero ang gusto talagang ipoint out ni Inday kay GRETCHEN, YOU WERE NEVER THE BREADWINNER OF THE FAMILY KAYA TUMIGIL KA NA ONCE AND FOR ALL. Stop dreaming and spreading all the lies!!! Bahala ka na sa buhay mo basta wag mo lang kami idamay. Yun lang.
ReplyDeleteHowever evil your child/children is/are, a Mom does not do that, more so, publicly. Inday claims that the reason why she's doing this is to clear all the lies. But who cares if it's a lie or the truth, correcting the lies bago sila kunin ni Lord ba? If what she's saying is the truth, God knows them already. But God also sees what you do as a Mom. Sana nga bago pa sila kunin ni Lord, they all reconcile, ask forgiveness and forgive each other...
ReplyDeleteang daming binabayaran ni greta nung menor de edad pa cya ha yaya, driver, gasoline, food, rent kulang pa! kapal din ni mommy ha! ndi pa cya breadwinner sa lagay na yan,
ReplyDelete