Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Inspiration or Imitation: Alone Thai Movie vs. Guni Guni


73 comments:

  1. imitation! please sana naman hindi pati story pareho...o baka pinapangit na version ng thai movie na alone yang guni-guni...i saw that movie and it was pretty good...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah its good coz its thai eh. Entertainment kc skanila sa thai, most especially in korea is a serious business eh d ktulad dito na parang gnagawa nilang mang mang ang mga audience. Pero I think mukang maganda nmn tong guni guni, let's see muna. And then judge them. Sna nmn mag-grow na ang script at effect ng philippine horror.

      Delete
    2. Korek!! buti na nga lang this past few years, there are some horoor stories na talaga nag improve... tulad ng sukob tsaka ng feng shui... the stories developed started to get some depth... tingnan niyo na lang Koreanovela... the stories are great... di tulad ng pinoy, si walang hanggan parang walang hanggan ang paulit ulit ng kwento... from start to finish. pareho lang yung kwento... there is no depth of exploration of characters and the storylines... watch Two Wives, sobrang ganda ng kwento... they develop the story and not just focus on one area...

      Delete
    3. Korekness.. The most important part is the script. At kung mag-hit man ng bongga. Wag nang i-extend ng i-extend hanggang mging boring. Hndi ba nila kaya gumawa ulit ng bagong magandang story? Lalo na sa GMA, halatang tinitipid pa. Balewala ang gastos kung maganda nmn talaga kc for sure tatangkilikin ng tao. And lastly, sna dn i-workshop muna na husto ung mga artistang kukunin sa movie or drama series para maging effective ung connection at maintindihan ng audience ng husto yung gustong iparating ng writer and director.

      Delete
    4. The movie was a rip-off. Watched it at SM Cinema and I was very disappointed. Yun main twist nya eh may kakambal sa Lovi Poe and conjoined twins sila tapos namatay yun. Tama ba naman yun? Sobrang parehong-pareho sa concept ng Thai Movie Alone. Mga sis, sorry sa sasabihin ko, pero sobrang bobo ng writers nito. I'm pretty sure anyone of us could have made a better and more original story than the writers of this movie. Gaya-gaya, hindi marunong mag-isip. Kaka-imbyerna. Mas magaling pa magimbento ng nakakatakot na story ang kasambahay namin.

      Delete
  2. I twitted this to your twitter acc. And to krizzy too :) lalang:)

    ReplyDelete
  3. As usual, nanggagaya na naman ang Pinoy.

    ReplyDelete
  4. haha baka pati story kinopya lang din. josskoh!

    ReplyDelete
  5. imitation. pati wind effect ginaya? outfi lang naiba, spaghetti strap kasi ung sa isa

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hindi naman daw, nagdagdag naman daw sila ng pinto sa background at pinalitan ung kulay ng font sa guni-guni :D

    ReplyDelete
  7. lahat na lang ba? kalowka.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I.M.I.T.A.T.I.O.N. Mula sa speech ng isang senador hanggang sa movie poster, wala talagang palalampasin tayong mga pinoy! Ba yan! Lahat na lang!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. isama mo na din jan yung mga designer gowns daw..

      Delete
  9. Imitation,need I say more? This is where Pinoys are very good at. :) we are all guilty :)admit it or not. :)

    Gabriela

    ReplyDelete
  10. After manggaya ng outfit , picture naman ngayon. N k k l k!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Grabe namaan, kapal! Pati hangin kinopya, walang patawad!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Imitation...more fun in the Philippines nga ba?
    Anubayan?!

    Kapi Kat

    ReplyDelete
  13. Napanood ko ung Alone thai movie, maganda ung story nya, may twist ung movie, sana naman di imitation pati movie ng guni guni, may kakabal din ba si lovi sa movie?
    -ai

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yah, napanood ko din ang alone super ganda ng twist sa dulo.na d mo ineexpect. Sna nmn hndi gnaya lang ng guni guni kc mukang maganda na sna sa trailer. Kung ginaya man nila, sna idemanda cla, pati poster gaya gaya.

      Delete
  14. Iniba lang yung background. Binonggacious lang nila itetch. Parang mas feel ko panuorin ang original haha!

    ReplyDelete
  15. akala ko ang mga imitations made in CHINA lang... madami din pala imitations na made in the PHILIPPINES... LOL! :)))))))

    ReplyDelete
  16. Ginagawa ba nila tayong bobo or what? My golly! Sobrang nkakahiya. Buti kung yung mga tao lang behind that ang nkakahiya eh. Tsssshhhhh. Why can't can't we have an entertainment like korea and thailand?

    ReplyDelete
  17. ano ba yan pati movie posters di tayo maka generate ng magandang concept? tsk tsk tsk

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wala ng ginawa ang Pinoy showbiz kung di mang gaya, nakakahiya na nakaka imbyerna, di paganahin ang mga utak!

    ReplyDelete
  19. ano ba yan?? pati ba sa movie posters kailangan manggaya?talented ang pinoy???????????

    ReplyDelete
  20. Mas maganda yung sa Guni-guni.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Baka naman Filipino version lang or similar. Parang "The Ring" na may hollywood version? I dunno~ Sana naman ... otherwise, kahiya if gaya-gaya version na naman tayo. >.<

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In short? Franchise? Na mas pangit na version? Sna nmn kc pag nireremake at least man lng pantayan ang level ng orig kung d kayang higitan. Pero what do you expect sa philippine movie scripts? Always been mediocre.

      Delete
  22. Nakakahiya....copya,copya, copya....

    ReplyDelete
  23. Kalowka ka guni guni pati ba poster ginaya lol..pati din story sa movie ginaya din siguro,Tito sin lang peg

    ReplyDelete
  24. napanuod ko yun trailer.. may pag ka alone nga din yun movie ni lovi..

    ReplyDelete
  25. guni-guni nyo lang daw yan! hahaha

    ReplyDelete
  26. kaya naman pala pabagsak na ang philippine movie industry dahil sa sobrang 2nd rated copy cat....hay naku....nagmumukha tuloy bobo....

    ReplyDelete
  27. imitation.. sad and pathetic

    ReplyDelete
  28. may nabasa akong article, ang sabi magkaiba raw ang story, parehas lang may twin yung bida..i was able to watch the premiere kagabi sa megamall, ok naman yung movie, hindi ko mai-compare sa iba esp sa thai movie na yan kasi di ko pa yan napanood..
    OT: ang nakakainis lang yung ibang mga fans, ganun ba talaga pag premiere night? ang iingay, puro side comment at nasigaw sa mga eksena, parang mga ngayon lang nakapasok ng sinehan? kailangan sasabihin out loud yung mga saloobin, ganun? :(

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Okay na sna comment mo kuya til sinabi mo d mo pa napapanood ang alone. Pano mo nga naman maiko-compare.

      Delete
    2. tama nd mo pa pala napanood ung thai movie kuya kong maka react ka wagas....the poster and the idea of the thai movie was copied by guni-guni iniba lang ng konti pero ganun parin ung outcome all in all

      Delete
    3. tama nd mo pa pala napanood ung thai movie kaya nd mo masabing ginaya ung concept ng story....nd lang poster ang ginaya pati pa ung idea ng movie ginaya din sana na nga nd nlang guni guni ang title eh gaya gaya nlang

      Delete
  29. it should be GUNIGUNI not GUNI-GUNI(with a hyphen)

    ReplyDelete
  30. What eslse is new? Copy Cat na naman..

    ReplyDelete
  31. imitada! pati yung ideyang doppelganger ng the healing same din sa guni-guni....

    ReplyDelete
  32. When I first saw guniguni's trailer weeks ago,bigla kong naalala yung the alone thai movie.
    and i guess the plot is the same. Evil twin sister being haunted by her dead twin which she killed when they were young pa. I dunno if its gonna be the same with guniguni, i havent watched the movie pa eh.

    ReplyDelete
  33. so hard to find anything original nowadays in the philippines. whatever happened to all those creative juices? somebody please come up with something new!

    ReplyDelete
  34. ayun... yun pala yun na movie.... while watching the trailer may naalala akong asian horror movie na may multong twin din.... Alone pala yun....

    ReplyDelete
  35. oh no! it's hard not to say it's an imitation..at yung trailer, nakaka-insulto ng IQ! we have seen enough such crap..this is a quintessential proof that, in general, filipino producers and directors alike have been lowering the bar for the country's movie industry..

    ReplyDelete
  36. pirated! copycat!

    ReplyDelete
  37. anubayan gayang gaya

    ReplyDelete
  38. grabe naman. sobrang imitation nman yan. hindi ba sila madedemanda nyan ng infringement?

    ReplyDelete
  39. its not GUNIGUNI its GAYA GAYA!

    ReplyDelete
  40. baka naman remake talaga kaya lakas ng loob gayahin

    ReplyDelete
  41. IMITASYON NA NGA PANGIT PA NG PAGKAKAGAWA--'NU BA YAN PARANG NA-TWIST YUNG SHOULDER NI LOVI SMANTALANG SA THAI PERFECTLY DONE---KUNGBAGA SA PRODUKTO IMITATONG MADE IN CHINA--LOW QUAL., LOW CLASS--TSKTSKTSK!!---BE INNOVATOR NMAN SANA MINSAN MGA PINOY--

    ReplyDelete
  42. The movie company must be sued!

    ReplyDelete
  43. so tell me papano uusad ang pelikulang pilipino...haaaaaaaaaaaaaa.... aber........... papano?????

    ReplyDelete
  44. nung first time kong mapanood yung trailer ng guni guni kaagad kong sinabi na aiiiii parang alone lang ahhh.. oh my gawd wala naba talagang ibang maisip na concept? hay naku puro nalang imitation

    ReplyDelete
  45. IMITATION! pati yung peklat sa tagiliran ginaya din nila. ginayan din nila yung concept ng mirrors with the evil reflection. ginaya din nila yung doppelganger with freaky eyes ng The Healing. ano pa ano pa ang ginaya ng movie na eto?

    ReplyDelete
  46. sObrang IMITATION naman to..bakit ba kailangan pang manggaya..?have ur originality naman.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Wala na ba talagang respeto sa intellectual property ang mga pinoy? Yung pag plagiarize ni Sotto dun sa blog content tapos itong si Lovi twice nang involved sa gaya gaya. The dress she wore to an event was also a copy. Pati ba naman poster?

    ReplyDelete
  48. sabi na nga ba eh, kaya pala nung nakita ko yung teaser, parang familiar yung storyline. napanood ko yung alone mga 3 years ago yata. hindi lang pala sa storyline may pagkakahawig ang alone at guni-guni, pati yung poster! kaloka!!! lahat na lang ginaya?! hindi ko pa napapanood yung guni-guni, pero kung pareho lang naman yung storyline sa alone, hindi ko na lang panonoorin. kakaloka!

    ReplyDelete
  49. Nagkataon lang siguro... choz! hahaha!

    ReplyDelete
  50. Lagi nalang inspire mga pilipino hindi pa pedeng sila naman mainspire sa atin tayo naman ang gagayahin kung di naman nageexist yang alone na yan makakagawa ba sila ng ganyang poster hayy

    ReplyDelete
  51. nakakatawa! same concept talaga ng alone thai movie(2007) at ang guni guni, may binago mang kunti, you really cant deny it has the same concept, and yeah almost the same posters! yep i see the difference geeez!.. tsk! tsk!. shame:(

    ReplyDelete
  52. and everyone think that the poster of amorosa is ALL ORIGANL. look at this: http://a8.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/376754_10151874463286988_1820922761_n.jpg

    ReplyDelete
  53. Anubeyen! Gaya gaya! Walang originality, bka naman mas magaling pa akong mgsulat ng horror stories kesa s GMA writers. ;p ;))

    ReplyDelete