Thursday, June 7, 2012

Inspiration or Imitation: Preview Magazine (June 2012) vs. W Magazine (July 2011)

Preview Magazine, June 2012, Anne Curtis

VS

W Magazine, July 2011, Beyonce


58 comments:

  1. Pwedeng inspiration kc di gaanong kamukha. Sa mga men's mag imItationg tunay pati design ng lingerie ginagaya.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hilig naman ng magazines yung gnyan I think sa foreign magazines sila kumukuha ng inspiration/ideas. In fairness dito not so same unlike yung sa ESQUIRE MAGAZINE featuring John Lloyd & iza calzado sobrang pareho ng concept color & pose dun sa angelina jolie & Robert Downey! Wla na bang originality ang mga Philippine magazines???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Napagoogle tuloy ako dahil sa comment mo. In fairness, tumfact ka! Same na same nga yung Jolie at RDJ. Diba si beking kakambal ang EIC ng Esquire Phil.? Naubusan nb sya ng idea? hahaha

      Delete
    2. Tumpaaaak! Napa google din ako dahil sa comment niya :D

      Delete
    3. ang lala na napa-google rin ako ah

      Delete
    4. Bonggels ko dba? haha! At yes si Raymond nga sobrang imitation yung gnwa nila. I wonder kung pasok sa copyright infringement yung gnwa nila....

      Delete
    5. hahaha napa google din ako...my gasss saw RDJ's cover same cover nga with JLC..what's happening with our publication industry?

      Delete
    6. Its not about originality dahlin. Esquire Philippines is the local version of Esquire US. Kasama sa usapan (agreement) nila na ilolocalize ung Esquire and that means they need to get the original feel of the US version. Well of course youll know that if your a reader and gets yun ng market ng Esquire.,..the question is....are you? =) *peace

      Delete
  3. Layo nman ng concept. BDSM yun isa. Circus nman yun isa

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. naconnect mo ba ang suot ni ambisyosa sa stunt nya? spring outfit tapos may pang acrobat-acrobat na post?

      Delete
  4. Dapat magakaron ng PHILIPPINE'S NEXT TOP MODEL para naman hndi laging si Anne Curtis ang kinukuwa ng magazines HAHAHAHAHAHA

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. matagal nangn merong pntm. di lang nagkaron ng sumunod

      Delete
  5. it's not an exact copy so pwedeng inspired by, but still, there's a chance na hindi rin original yung kay beyonce. i don't think na nung 2011 lang may nakaisip mag-photoshoot sa ganyang setup

    ReplyDelete
  6. inspiration, maybe...
    but definitely not imitation...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Actually, the booklet for Beyonce's "4" album has a picture in one of the inside pages of Beyonce in almost the exact same pose as Anne's. So yeah, imitation talaga.

      Delete
  7. inspiration pero mas mahirap pa rin ang posing ni beyonce...

    ReplyDelete
  8. Imitation. MeJo di bagay sa damit ni anne yun lambitin effect.. Trying hard ang dating

    ReplyDelete
  9. From hands to waist-- fierce! Pero Omg Anne's legs look reaaaally short in this pose. Katurn off from the waist down. And as for the imitation/inspiration thing, ok lang yan. Magkaiba naman colors/clothes/poses. Same props used lang. Cool ka lang, FP! Hahaha hahaha.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sorry i like Anne Curtis but this is Purely IMITATION nkklk ah I find it somewhat trashy instead of classy.. Compared to how Beyonce carried herself in that photo.. Hindi mo pwede icompare eh..

    ReplyDelete
  11. IMITATION - eh known naman ang pinoy manggaya , just like fun in the philippines, and as always third world copies the first world

    ReplyDelete
  12. inspiration lang cguro. pero sobrang fierce tlga ni mareng beyonce ditey! ung kay anne, parang keme lang, lambitin lang.

    ReplyDelete
  13. walang originality!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ofcourse imitation. Dyan naman magaling ang pinoy. Ang manggaya sa westerners.

    ReplyDelete
  15. para lang tanga. parang ala class.

    ReplyDelete
  16. sorry pero di ko talaga type si Anne. Parang ang laki laki ng bunganga

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree! Tapos ang hilig pa magred lipstick. Nagmumukha sya lalong cheap.

      Delete
    2. kala ko nga parang lagpas lagpas lagi yong lipistik nyang pula yon pala malaki lang talaga bibig. hehehe

      Delete
    3. KAYO NA! KAYO NA ANG MAGANDA at SOSYAL! sa inyo na ang LAHAT NANG KORONA! KAYO NA ANG may almost 3mil followers, KAYO NA ang may MOVIE SA HOLYWOOD! KAYO NA TALAGA!
      kung makapanglait naman parang may ibubuga! :)

      Delete
  17. It's not a flattering shot for Anne, not to mention hindi bagay ung damit so I would say imitation kasi if this were "inspiration" then everything would go together - from the clothes to the pose. Eto parang pilit, trying hard na maging edgy but the clothes and makeup are so safe and preppy! Walang sense. Yan ang hirap when mga magbabakarda ang nagtratrabaho sa isang magazine, you have half baked outputs because the people are hired for their personalities and social status instead of skill and talent. And please, enough of Anne. Don't get me wrong, I like Anne - not a fan so I don't watch her shows or movies - but I find her likable enough. Pretty girl but NOT a model.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i couldn't agree more! very well said! clap clap clap! pilit nga and yeah, the styling doesn't coincide with the concept..ayaw mag-connect.

      Delete
    2. I super love Ann and the call me maybe friends kasi sob rang Ganda ng faces nila..pero I agree. First tingin pa Lang I wondered na why her legs look so short eh slender naman xa in real life. The cover pa of this issue, ang sob rang Ganda ng clothes, swear sob rang summer -rainy pastel pero bakit panget ng color ng background etc? Nagging boring.

      Masyado at a sila nagging complacent sa shoot nila and akala nila keri na ng personality ng celebs ang fashion..saying this issue sob rang Ganda pa naman ng girls..

      Delete
  18. Inspiration, kasi same concept, pero hindi naman the same photos. Maganda and classy yung kay Beyonce. I don't like Anne's, kasi medyo "sexual" ang dating ng pose. Sana purely classy na lang.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. totoo gurl! yung kay B, class na class pa rin. yung kay anne, masagwa yung pose talaga. sana ibang pose na lang, utang na loob, preview!

      Delete
    2. True.. D ko rin type pose ni anne dito.

      Delete
  19. parang nakakatawa yata yung pose ni anne. hahaha.. parang up for slaughtering lang =P

    ReplyDelete
  20. lagi na lang.

    kahit sabihin natin na kopya ito. may magdedefend na NOTHING IS ORIGINAL ANYMORE...

    Ewan.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Ann is undoubtedly one of the prettiest faces in the business... But... Sobrang nakakaumay na masyado....overexposure to the highest level... ..Pwede bang iba naman....

    ReplyDelete
  22. Sa Sobrang pagkaoverexpose ni Anne, parang na immune na ako Sa beauty na na kahit saksakan sya ng ganda e wala ng dating ....Lahat na ng anggulo at klase ng damit , may picture sya..Gone na Ang element of surprise nya...

    ReplyDelete
  23. Imitation. Same props, iniba lang ang pose. Dapat ibinitin na lang ng patiwarik para maiba naman.

    ReplyDelete
  24. WALA NA BANG IBANG ARTISTA? SILA'T SILA LANG DIN ANG LAMAN NG MGA MAGS! NAKAKAUMAY.

    ReplyDelete
  25. it's an imitation of the concept. it's just another version of the original. go get your "inspiration" somewhere else, and not from another magazine, picture or similar medium!

    ReplyDelete
  26. please enough of Anne on magazines. sobrang over exposed na siya. ayoko na ngang bumili ng mags na siya cover. sa mga ads sa kalye at malls, puro mukha niya na lang ang nakikita ko.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Girl parihas tau. nakakaumay na grabe. parang sha lang ba artista sa pilipinas?

      Delete
  27. mukha namang inspiration...pero mas kabog ang pose ni Beyonce...fierce

    ReplyDelete
  28. ang sagwa nmn ng pose ni anne d2 parang nakidnap at tinali ng mga rapist!

    ReplyDelete
  29. anne curtis!anne curtis!anne curtis!wala na bang ibang artista sa pinas kundi sya nlng ng sya super nakakasawa na to d point na nakakainis na xa!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. palagi nlng c anne!c anne na walang malay!

      Delete
  30. Sana nilagyan na din ng roleta tapos kunwari aasintahin siya ng knife. Yun, mas original yun

    ReplyDelete
  31. Anne Curtis na nman? wala nabang iba?Jusme nman andaming magagandang babe sa pilipinas.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Awkwaaardd ng pose ni Anne! totally Unflattering.. Dapat palitan na ang Art Director nito.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Preview has a record of copying a lot of fashion editorials/concepts/ideas from different international magazines. Like yung cover si Kris Aquino nung 2007 (Dark Side and theme) eh ginaya lang naman nila yung concept sa isang issue ng Vogue China.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Inspiration siguro. Pero ang masasabi ko lang, nakakatawa ang pose ni Anne. Bakit ba pinagpipilitan ng mga fashion editor na gawing high fashion model si Anne eh hindi naman pang high fashion ang katawan niya? Nagmumuka tuloy siyang awkward at trying hard, kawawa naman. Yung kay Beyonce, OA ang Photoshop ha.

    ReplyDelete
  35. FP.. post mo din yung preview shoot ni georgina wilson and her bf borgy.. they are copied din from some foreign magazine.. vogue i think..

    ReplyDelete